Raka Ghirra v. Central Bureau Of Investigation And Another



   

!

 

 
    

  ! "#$!! % ' 

(   "#$ $  %#  )*+"!

, )*-&!. !  * )*.!.

&/  (  0"$%*  %#&  * 1(  

&2!   
**
 3/4!56( ," ! # .(

#7!

&"$%

  *"080
  & !  9%  *""- / :*;* !  .  ; 
363 6 
36    " !( / 88 . 5$%"&   #

. "$%/"$"

&* * ! !  " ! ( 

&  2! <      !&

  "  

& 3 "6  << < !( ((  !& "  # ( *1 < <& ## )* + "!

, /  (!  ((    (, = !  #   !  

:**
*- < " !  

(, 4       & 

##,   ( !

   &      ## ( #,  ##  ,* 9!    = !  ,

#&!*
* >       #    &* %    #  

#, " !  (!&      # 

 ,    

 <# & ( !  (  ,  (   " !

&  # ((#

#      (( ! ,     ##  (#   & !      ((#

< !#    ##   

# &!     # " !*> !#(( !#,     !# ,      " !

   " ! # , !(   #  4(#

#, 

(!&    #

 &#,  #*%

!   ,  # !#   (    

  & &

(#< #< ( #

! <

< < &! & <

   

 # 

*? #(#

&#  !( '()*+,$(-,./+ $).)* ! )).0 0.1*+, 2 .- ),*0"
 3 4  30(5(-.64 
7  !&! - @#.!(" ! &# &   ,! ,(   #,7!

#)&  ( <  (  &  

(# <

     !

 (      !&  , 

& & , !

 # &  , , " !  #<*

##,# &!  

#   ((#

 ,  " ! # <  

!   (!( 

, #,<    !A !# !      &   (

   

&#,(!!

&#&#

   #  ((      " !* / (,      ## < & (  !

&!

#

 # "$%" ! 4 #!

 



!

,(  0"$% ( &    

 

&   (    # # ( !(  ,#<* :*  # !# (( &  # (  0"$%< ##, ((  &(, !   ,  #   (   !    

!  <   (

   , " !  #<

 & 

(#,      #! #,&    ( 



(#   (  ( < *> (  0"$% ! 

#    " ! <   (        # (#   " !  & # ,  ##(#&

#&!     # " !* !##,        (=!

<  

  !  ( 

< =!

# 

&

(# (        ##  * B* >   (  0"$%  !

    #<    &    # &
 
   - @# .!( " !  ()*+, $(-,."+ 8.+* 3+9:0.4  # ( 

&

(#  &&    ! #  * %   !  ()*+, $(-,."+ 8.+* 3+9:0.4- @#/(4" ! 

 ( < )&    (#  

!    !  

 (# < # #, & !(   # =!

&( '$).)* ! 5;.</+ %.),(%.69=,.1"   7 $  * * %   ! !    

 !

 

&(     < & (#  * &  ,  

!    

&&       # #<*? # &   & ()*+,$(-,."+8.+*3+9:0.4# !#!   & & 

 (#   2!  <   

!  & (#

&( 0 < &   < !#       #  /

#3
6 "  ! %

*% ! &! ,# (  0"$%. 
/ "**"* # &(  % &C

 

   " !   

!   !   ( 

   (

 &! 

(#*- <  #&#2!

 % &/& ,   

(# 

!  

 <   (  #  #!  &  * ;* % # (  (! # #  * 8* $ ( 

! < !# (    ( !#, &( 

&  #" !(    !   ((#

    

& 4 #!  

( &    

 (#* 1  ((#

 < !2!#,

  ,   # " ! 

   *8*8*  

<   ( ((    " !,<, ")5 ) *
BB 8<    <(  !  ( * - <  *8*
   " !    

(    (     (  <  # ,      ## ! & #*.!2!#,( 

#  #((#

  #" !  &(,



#   <

< , # ((#

*1 !2! ((#

,( <  &

 , #" !

  
**
<    !  ,( < !#  #  !( 

#&!* *  &       (   (!   ! ##& &  , #



&( 

  &&  & & #*

* 1  # " !    !  !,   #      !&#,#!

  #  <

    ( +  ,   " !* %    ( +     # " !

&#,##

<



!

  (    (  !

# 

* 1    #

 #" ! # ,(  

0

 < !# !

&   

#&! (!(! !  ##,!<   <  #" !  

((#

     * % &  <  ! , &   (  < !#     ( &   ##(# 

#&!<

 #     ,   # " !   (!&   * %

(  !  

 ,#! 

# , (  #!

&

(#< !#  !#, ! + ,  #" !  (  !

&=!

&* * % 

!   !      

  <  ,   " !   (!&   * 1 

 * 3 %#4  /*5;*0
7&


 ?(

&0    D0  ?( # D0