High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/57037/2023dismissed

Sukhdev Kaur v. State Of Punjab

2023-11-23Mr. Justice Rajbir Sehrawat4 pages

"#$%&$'()(%* !!

+$)$*# +!"*,-".+"#/0 12%'"#$&%+#/$3$#(#(%*$+ !

4 !

+"5$+(*#/()"336('"#(%*&(6$1,*1$+7$'#(%*4 %&#/$%1$%& +(8(*"6+%'$1,+$()&%+36"'(*.%*+$'%+1"'%35%&&(*"6+$3%+#1"#$1 !!

**$9,+$ "*1)"6$1$$1

**$9,+$ !

%+ #/$ +$")%*) 8$*#(%*$1 (* #/$ "336('"#(%*0 #/$ )"8$ () "66%:$1"*1#/$1%',8$*#)

**$9,+$ "*1 "+$#";$*%*+$'%+1!

/$3+$)$*#3$#(#(%*/")<$$*&(6$1,*1$+7$'#(%*4%&#/$ %1$%&+(8(*"6+%'$1,+$03+"5(*.&%+.+"*#%&"*#('(3"#%+5=3+$ "++$)#<"(6 #%#/$3$#(#(%*$+(*'")$%!1"#$1!4!

0+$.()#$+$1,*1$+ 7$'#(%*) 0>0>0>40"*1 %&#/$*1("*$*"6%1$0"# %6('$7#"#(%*(2()(%*%! 0?,1/("*"

**$9,+$ !

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

/0 ,+3+$$#A",+1",./#$+%& 8+(;7(*.//")<$$*.+"*#$1'%*'$))(%*%& "*#('(3"#%+5<"(6<5#/()%,+#!$*'$0#/$3$#(#(%*$+/")#%<$#+$"#$1"#3"+ :(#//$+! #/$+:()$"6)%0#/$8"##$+(*2%62$1()03+(8"+(650%&'(2(6(* *"#,+$@:/('//"):+%*.65<$$*'%*2$+#$1(*#%"'+(8(*"6'")$!%+$%2$+0 #/$'%836"(*"*#/")"6+$"15'%83+%8()$1#/$8"##$+C,"#/$6$."

8+(;7(*./!/$3$#(#(%*$+0<$(*.":%8$*01$)$+2$)6$*($*'5&+%8#/$ %,+#"*1*$$1)#%3+%#$'#$1"."(*)#/$+"++$)#!/$3$#(#(%*$+)/"66-%(*#/$ (*2$)#(."#(%*")"*1:/$*'"66$1&%+<5#/$3%6('$! !

%#('$%&8%#(%*! !

+! 7"*1$$3 7(*./0 11(#(%*"6 12%'"#$ $*$+"60 ,*-"< "''$3#)*%#('$%*<$/"6&%&#/$#/$+$)3%*1$*#D7#"#$! +!A"*:"6-$$# 7(*./0 12%'"#$/")3,#(*"33$"+"*'$"*1&(6$1/() (*%,+# #%1"5%*<$/"6&%&#/$'%836"(*"*#! !

#()),<8(##$1<5'%,*)$6&%+#/$7#"#$@<$(*.(*)#+,'#$1<5 7

,+3+$$#7(*./"*1<$(*."))()#$1<5'%,*)$6&%+#/$'%836"(*"*#@#/"##/$ %:*$+%&#/$3+%3$+#5(*C,$)#(%*:")%*$"*)"-)%*%&7/+($:"* /"*10:/%:")"66%##$1#/$)"8$0%*&+$$/%61<")()0<5#/$%2$+*8$*# 1$3"+#8$*#02(1$'%*2$5"*'$1$$11"#$1!!!/$3+$1$'$))%+ (* (*#$+$)#%&#/$3$#(#(%*$+0 ,+"*7(*./:").(2$*#/$)"(13+%3$+#5 %*65#%+$)(1$#/$+$(*&%+)%8$#(8$! %:$2$+0#/$+$"&#$+0#/$%+(.(*"6 %:*$+/"11($10"*1#/$'%836"(*"*#<$(*./()*$3/$:())#";(*./()'6"(8 %2$+#/$)"(13+%3$+#5!7%&"+")#/$3$#(#(%*$+"*1%#/$+6$."6+$3+$)$*#"#(2$) %&,+"*7(*./"+$'%*'$+*$10#/$5/"1*$2$+"'C,(+$1#/$#(#6$%+6$."6+(./# #%#/$3+%3$+#5#/+%,./"*56$."68$"*)%+#/+%,./#/$3+%'$))%&#/$%,+#! $*'$0#/$5/"1*%+(./#%+#(#6$#%#+"*)&$+#/$)"8$(*&"2%,+%&"*5%#/$+ 3$+)%*! ''%+1(*.

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

+"*#$1 '%*'$))(%* %& "*#('(3"#%+5 <"(6 <5 #/() %,+#0 (# () ),<8(##$1<5'%,*)$6&%+#/$7#"#$#/"#)/$()*%##/$)(.*"#%+5#%#/$)"6$ 1$$1$9$',#$1(*&"2%,+%&#/$"<%2$)"(13$+)%*)!&"#"660)/$:")(*2%62$1 (*"*5#+"*)&$+0#/"#()8,'/$"+6($+"*1():(#/(*#/$&"8(65")&+%8%*$?!!

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

*2($:%&#/$&"'#)"*1'(+',8)#"*'$)"2"(6"<6$%*#/$'")$&(6$0 "):$66")0),<8())(%*)8"1$'%,*)$6&%+#/$7#"#$0#/()%,+#1%$)*%#&(*1 (# "33+%3+("#$ #% (*#$+&$+$ (* #/$ 8"##$+ )% ") #% .+"*# '%*'$))(%* %& "*#('(3"#%+5<"(6#%#/$3$#(#(%*$+0"##/())#".$! !

()8())$1! "-<(+7$/+":"# ,1.$ %2$8<$+ 0 8%/"*<(8<+" F/$#/$+)3$";(*.=+$")%*$1 $)=% F/$#/$++$3%+#"<6$ $)=%