High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6556/2018dismissed

Devi Ram v. Balbir And ANR

2020-01-21Mr. Justice Amol Rattan Singh4 pages

#$% %&'(')

%*' #+ ,--%..#$ /%0(1( #.2'0#3#$4%0 %(-3%$(

0%(%$)5 "0"#67#1(4'893*&#$%9 0$4%#--%..#$

:$4'(#--%#.9$4%#--%..#$ -.#'$'

'$4%(1'$';1%($' &4#..%<%($4%613<+%$(#33%&0%%( $4%.%#0%3&10$(2%.=92:=4'&4 4'( (1'$ =#( 3'(+'((%39 '$ 2%'< % (%%8'< # 3%&0%% -%0+#%$ '61&$' 0%($0#''< $4% 0%(-3%$53% %3#$( 0+ 0#'('< '..%<#.

&($01&$'*%0#-#0$'&1.#0-#$4 #3 0+&.('<$4%(#+% $%0%>$%('*%3'(&1((' $4%%*'3%&%.%32:$4%-#0$'%(9 '&.13'<#0%(.1$'-#((%32:$4%0#+ #&4#:#$9$4%.%#0%3$0'#.&10$ &#+%$$4%&&.1('$4#$' #&$$4%(#'30%(.1$'=#($'0%(-%&$

$4%-#((#<%';1%($'21$-%0$#'%3$#3'

%0%$-#((#<%'$4%*'..#<% #3''$'#..:' #&$$4%#0-#&44#3<'*%$=&$0#3'&$0:&%0$' '&#$%(9 %($#$'<$4#$'$=#(#&++-#((#<% 9#3$4%$4%0(#:'<$4#$'$ =#($#&++-#((#<%921$=#(.:#-0'*#$%-#((#<% 4%#0-#&44#*'<2%%(1++%32:$4%$0'#.&10$#3-1$ 13%0$40%#$ -0&%%3'<(#<#'($4'+#(-%0$4%.#= 0'((1'<$= &$0#3'&$0: &%0$'

'&#$%(9 %*%$1#..:9 %*% $4% 0#+ #&4#:#$ =#( '+-.%#3%3#(#%&%((#0:-#0$:$$4%(1'$2:$4#$&10$#3'$=#( 13

$4#$ $4% 0%(.1$' =#( '3%%3 -%0$#''< $ # 3'

%0%$ -#((#<%? #.$<%$4%09 =4%0%#( $4% -#((#<% ' ;1%($' #&$1#..: 2%.<%3 $ 0%(-3%$53% %3#$ 41($4%(1'$=#(3'(+'((%39='$4$4%&1$%0&.#'+ '.%32:

0%(-3%$53% %3#$9(%%8'<#3%&0%% +#3#$0:'61&$'$$4% %

%&$ $4#$ $4% -.#'$'

2% 3'0%&$%3 $ 3%+.'(4 $4% '..%<#. -06%&$'

&($01&$%3$4%=#.. 4'(41(%9#(=#(-06%&$'<$$4% (#'3($0%%$3%&0%%3 4%-0%(%$#--%..#$5-.#'$'

4#*'<#--%#.%3 #<#'($ $4#$ 613<+%$#33%&0%%9$4%.%#0%3 '0($#--%..#$%&10$&#+%$$4%(#+% &&.1('#(4#3$4%$0'#.&10$9#(0%<#03($4%-#((#<%';1%($'2%'< $4%-0'*#$%-0-%0$: 0%(-3%$3% %3#$@21$#(0%<#03(4'(&1$%0 &.#'+9$4%3%&0%%-#((%32:$4%.%#0%3$0'#.&10$'4'( #*10=#(0%*%0(%3 2:4.3'<$4#$#(0%<#03($4%-06%&$'#3$4%*%$'.#$0?='3=-%'<

0+$4%#--%..#$(A41(%$$4%(#'3($0%%$9$4#$=#(#%#(%+%$#0:0'<4$ $=4'&44%=#(%$'$.%3 #--%#.#(+#:4#*%2%% '.%32:$4%0%(-3%$53% %3#$ #<#'($$4#$613<+%$?3%&0%%94#(2%%201<4$$$4%$'&% $4'( &10$( #0 $4'(#--%#.'#:&#(%9#(0%<#03($4%#--%..#$5-.#'$'

94'( <0'%*#&%'($4#$$4%-#((#<%';1%($''($#&++-#((#<% B%#0%3&1(%. 0$4%#--%..#$(12+'$($4#$'*'%= $4%

#&$$4#$%*%'$4%&0((5%>#+'#$' 0%(-3%$94%4#3#3+'$$%3

55 $4#$ $4%-#((#<%=#( 2%'< 1(%3 2:$4%-0%3%&%((0(5'5'$%0%($ $4% #--%..#$5-.#'$'

9'%$4%-%0(( 0+=4+4%4#3-10&4#(%34'(41(%9 $4%-#((#<%=#(2*'1(.:%=4'&4=#(#&++-#((#<%#3$4%0% 0%9 $4%.%#0%3&10$(2%.=4#*%&+%$#=4..:%00%1( '3'< % 10$4%0(12+'$($4#$('&%#-#0$'#.%#(%+%$0'<4$4#(2%% <'*%$$4%#--%..#$9'$=1.3 10$4%0(4=$4#$$4%-%0((=4#0%.'*'< #013$4#$41(%9#%#(%+%$#0:0'<4$ %*%$$4%%>$%$ 1('<$4% -#((#<%9(41.34#*%2%%0%&<'C%32:$4%&10$(2%.= #*'<&('3%0%3$4%+#$$%09'$'($2%$'&%3#<#'$4#$ 1-'+-.%#3+%$2:$4%$0'#.&10$9 $4%0#+ #&4#:#$#(#%&%((#0:

-#0$:9#=0'$$%($#$%+%$=#( '.%32%4#.

$4% #&4#:#$ 0%(-3%$ 4%0%'9=4%0%''$=#(&#$%<0'&#..:($#$%3$4#$' #&$$4%&%0$'

'&#$% '((1%32:$4%#0-#&4#(0%<#03(#-#0$'&1.#0.#%2%'<-12.'&-0-%0$: =4'&4 %*% -#*'< 4#3 2%% <$ 3% #$ $4% %>-%(% $4% 0#+

#&4#:#$9$4#$=#(#=4..:3'

%0%$-#((#<%#3$$4%%';1%($'9 =4'&4#&$1#..:'('$4%=%0(4'- 0%(-3%$53% %3#$ 3&1+%$$4%0$4#$4#$=4'&44#(2%%0%6%&$%32:$4% &10$(2%.=9'%$4%&%0$'

'&#$%('((1%32:$4% #&4#:#$94#*'<2%%.%3 2:=#: %*'3%&%2:$4%#--%..#$9$(4=$4#$ $4%-#((#<%=#(# &++-#((#<%9(%%0%#($'$%0 %0%='$4$4%&&100%$ '3'<

#&$$4#$'((1%#(4#(2%%#00'*%3#$2:$4%.%#0%3&10$(2%.=9='$4 %*%$4%$%($'+: $4%#0-#&42%'<$4#$$4%-#((#<%';1%($'=#( $#-12.'&-#((#<%

5D5 ( 0%<#03( <0#$'< # -#0$'#. %#(%+%$#0: 0'<4$ $ $4% #--%..#$9'$'($2%#<#'$'&%3$4#$(1&4%#(%+%$#0:0'<4$'(.:='$4 0%<#03 $ *%$'.#$' $ 4'(41(%9' $4% 0+ #*%$'.#$0?='3= -%'< 0+$4%#--%..#$41(%$$4%($0%%$9='$4$4%-06%&$'+#3% 2: $4%+ *%0 (1&4 *%$'.#$0 03%0%3 $ 2% -0$%&$%39 ='$4 $4% .=%0 #--%..#$%&10$2*'1(.:' %00'<$4#$'$=#(#%&%((#0:%#(%+%$ 0 -0-%0.'<4$'<?>:<%%$&'$4%0%('3%$'#.#0%# $4%#--%..#$

-(-%&'

'&;1%0:$.%#0%3&1(%.94%*%0: #'0.:3%($ 3%:$4#$$4%0$4#$4%-#((#<%';1%($'9$4%0%#0%$4%0-#((#<%(#.( #*#'.#2.%$#&&%(($4%%$0:<#$%$$4%41(% $4%#--%..#$ 4#$2%'<(92*'1(.:$4%0%'(%#(%+%$ %&%(('$:

#0'('<$4%2#('( =4'&4$4%(#'3-#((#<%9%*%$41<4'$2%.<($ 0%(-3%$9&#2%4%.3$2%#%&%((#0:%#(%+%$$=4'&4$4% #--%..#$'(%$'$.%32:=#: 1(#<%9(#($#&&%((4'(41(% 4#$2%'<(9(%%0%#($'$%0 %0%='$4$4% '3'<(

$4%.%#0%3&10$(2%.=#3&(%;1%$.: '3'<;1%($' .#=$2% 3%&'3%3'$4'(#--%#.9$4% '3'<( #&$#0%#

'0+%39='$4$4%#--%#.

3'(+'((%3

*&<#0< # $ % %!!%&%'(&)%* +%& $ % %!!%)!,% +%&