High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/31351/2018disposed of

Karnail Kaur v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2024-05-21Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary8 pages

#$%& '( )&*+,+'-. / / 0 1$2-$+31$42 ///&%+%+'-&2 5&2,4, 6%$%&'(4-7$8$-)$-'%9&2 ///:&,;'-)&-%, <= >?<@ A < ! BBBBB 2&,&-%. 2/C$3)&D6+-E96')9+FG)D'*$%&('2%9&;&%+%+'-&2/ 2/6H$;$-69'2&IF#GJF4-7$8/ BBBBB

< !

!" # " $" " " %%

" &"" '" ()"

%"%% % % *% % ""#$" "

+ , % -) ,)

!"% . " "" /" # !" !" ""

""!"

" #

$" "" !" ""

/" "

# " )% % " " )"1 23411 56738291

" :

;<=><?@A::

;@BCD:

;DEFD<G<=::

?HI::

;=<=E::

JK::

L<A><B<::

<BM::

J=DEAH:

"" " '$ O"#

" " "" " "" ! "

!" ""

" #! )

# ,P !"

% Q% " ""$

""" R S*% " #"

# # " "#" ! "" "! "" "#" " !/" " ! " " "! ""

" " " " " " "#% )$)

! " "" ""#$" ! " "T) !/"% #"

" "U"" "$" " #"

"" " "" "))"#"

#""" ## !" "! " "" " "" ! " "! "" " !"

" "#!" " )$"

! " ) ""#$" %

V "" ," W" " X% Y%W% O / * ,%%0% ** R -0 *

Z ,

[ % V !" X% \T! ,) &#

" Q , [ \ W , X% ," O "]] ,

Q , *Q %

" "

"" "" )"" " " !

" " "#" ""# # " "" " ""!" " " " ! #

$" "" )" " " " # " "" "$"

" ! )$" ""#$" " " " " "% & " " "" " " # " ""

!/" " ! "#"

# "! " "% % ^ " #"

"" ##"" "! "" "

" + " )" " "" ! " Q Q,%%0% _ `_ ,P QQ "#" Q

" # " $!

# & $! " %! #

& % $ !

% %% %

& % ' (' )$ !& % & !

"! &%

"! *$

& ! %

' + %

# " %

"!' , %

& * & "% $

$ ' - " # %$ ! " $ #' &

& $ % % $ % ' +

. # %%$ # &% &

% *%

% %

%% "# /

& % & "

0 % $ ' #

% $

! ! $! "

%2 ' ,

% %% %

$ # % &2 #3

' 1 # * & & $ " %!

! &

% '

% &2 #3 "

% "

& "

#' +

/! 4% *$

5 6789:55 ;:<=:>?55 @:<A:B5 6>C55 DE:EF55 GH55 @:<9:A:55 IJJKLMN55 DCOCPC55 QRK5 &%

% "

' + $

$ % "

% &2 #3 ' 000 000 000

$ ' 1%%$ # & "#

% %

& %

& ' S'((. ' ' T

/! U #

' ' T (' .'

/# /%

U #' +

" %

#' V .' ,

5 DW<X7E55 D7AY?55 Z>C55 DE:EF55 GH55 @:<9:A:55 :A855 GE?F<>5 M5

[''' + $ $ $ % # %$

% $ 0

S ( T %(' ' T

! ! "# # ! !#

$ %& '

()*+)''

+,''

-).*/''

0''

+12345''

657''

8767''

9/):*4/;/)'

< =>? @@ % A B %&

! ! ! &$

$C & & # E &$FA B < & ! C! # & <

! # !

! $A B ! &$ & ! & !!

$ A % E

! E G=GA > "# ! C &< %

E !

$ %

" $

&C! ! !

!C $ H ! & %& " % I " !

$ ! = ! C"

# $ " &A =

< # & #!A B & ! #

! #

C #! $

A B & !

$< C !

$ C # A B

!! &

C & !

! ! &! # & !

& ! &$ ! A JC # !

$ A< # K L

! ! &$AM A B '

9/NO*1''

8P;/4''

Q/14/''

R57''

S1/13''

+,''

TP)O/U''

/).''

+12345'

V' < "! < W>

# &! #

C ! & & & =

< # & I # & !< AA X" < A Y<

&! ! "

Z! %AABA

!! " # !!$

" % % !

& % '!

! %()* + % $ ,-

% %

! %($ !

% !

!!$ ! " " %%(

! "

(

! % % ' % " !!

"!)* .) /0 123425600 76289:;00 <62;=200 >5?00 <@2@:00 AB00 C2;D28200 28900 A@6:;50 E0 $ " %

$ "# " ' ! %$

" %( '

$ " !%F !

! ($ G# H %% "

$ "% % %

& % '!

! %

! %(I" !

& $ '(

'# $ ,J / "

! %

% K #

L).) $

K $

! %%( % '

% G ( M " !! ! N '

) M % # ' $

" % % %%

& % '! % !%()* O)

! % '

!0 P2;568200 P:>300 >5?00 <@2@:0 AB0QR8S2T02890A@6:;50 U0 $"" '# % V ,) W G# H

! 0 <XA;@500 YR@6A;3@D00 AB0 Z893200 28900 28A@6:;00 >5?00 7:8@;2400 Y9=3835@;2@3>:00 [;3TR8240 O\ $ ) ) L . \ $ ) L) L

!" ## $% & '()"* "' +), )"

)&&!$)"

*! )"

-+&!,

$%! $). ./0.

1/ "*&, +(!-!*

!" *% '(!/"

*%)* * $).

/ *! 2)/&* !2 *% ( .+!"

"* *%)* $).

+(!-!* !" & *%)* 3 4% + (/.)& !2 *% )2!( .) )/*%!( * . -)5 * & )( *% +( " +& !2 "! $!(5 "! +),6 )""!* *( )*

). )" "2& 7 0& +( " +& *! $% % *% ( )( "!

+* !".# 8* %).

" !". .* "*&, & *%)* $% " *%

-+&!,

%).

" $(!"'&,

*% +(!-!* !" 2!( "! 2)/&* !2 % .

/ *! .!- &)+.

!" %)&2 !2 *%

-+&!, ( *% +( " +& !2 "! $!(5 "! +),6 $ && %)9 "! )++& )* !"# 4% ( 2!( *% 1/ .* !" ). *! $% *% ( *% ( )( )",

+* !". *! *% +( " +& !2 "! $!(5 "! +),6 $ && ( +&

" *% )22 (-)* 9 4% .

1/ .* !" $ && )&.! )".$ (

" *% )22 (-)* 9 ). " *% +( .

"* ).

) - **

&, *% ( .+!"

"* "!# $).

+(!-!* !" 2!( "! 2)/&* !2 % .# :. %). )&( ) ,

" +! "*

!/* ( .+!"

"* "!# $).

*% +(!-!* !" ). % . ")- $). !- **

2(!- *% .

" !( *, & .*

/ *! ") (* "

$% % %).

" ) - **

0, *% + * * !"

(

-+&!, (# 4% ( 2!( *% +( " +& !2 "! $!(5 "! +),6 $ && %)9 "! )++& )* !" " *% +( .

"* ).

;!( *% . ( ).!" *% -+/'"

(

. "!* $)(()"* )", "* (2 ( "

#< ;!&&!$ "' *% )0!9

*/- !2 &)$ *% . !/(* " =>?@ ABC

./+() %) '()"*

)(( )(. !2 .)&)(, 2(!- *%

)* !2 ( *(!.+ * 9 +(!-!* !" $% % $).

" /+% & 0,*% D 9 . !"E "%# # 4% ( . "!

", "' *% 2)* *%)* *% + * * !"

( $!(5 "' ). F#F# .*( .. $).

& ' 0& *! !".

(

2!( +(!-!* !" *! *% +!.* !2 */( ( %)9 "'

" +&)

)* .

" !( *, H!# %!$ ( $). !9 (&!!5

".* ) ( I/" !(.J I), G)7- )"

F/5%9 ( K)/( .

" !( *, H!.#

( .+ * 9 &, $ ( +(!-!*

(

# # $# #2# # # # 8* . !"&, !" )!/"* !2 ./0- .. !" !2 ) ( +( .

"*)* !" 0, ( *%)* *% ( .+!"

"*. ( * 2

*% - .*)5 )"

'()"*

+(!-!* !"L MNOPQRL !" "!* !")& 0). . 2(!- *%

)* *%)*!2% (I/" !(.# S# :. . )7 !-)* *% + * * !"

( $). /")0& *! + (2!(-

/* . !2 *% +(!-!*

+!.* !2 */( (

/ *! *% 2)/&* !" *% +)(* !2 *% +)(*- "*# 4%/. *% +( " +& !2 T"! $!(5 "! +),U $!/& "!* )**()*

" *% . +)(* /&)( . */)* !" . "

* . "!* ) (/& !2 *%/-0 *% ( "'

+* !". *! * ). %)

" !0.

0, V!"U0& *% F/+( - !/(* " WB X YB Z[\ ]\^\ _`Bab

F *%)* *%

.( * !" 0).

!" (/-.*)"

. .%!/&

( .

$% " -+& - "* "' *% (/& !2 T"! $!(5 "! +),U .! 2 )"

-+&!,

. /"I/.*&, +* )$), 2(!- $!(5 0, )/*%!( * . *% ,

(9 .)&)(, )"

2 *.#4% ( & 9)"*+)().$% ( !2( ) *%/.c 3# 8* $). 2/(*% ( !"* "

!" *% ( %)&2 *%)* *% "!(-)& (/& . d"! $!(5 "! +),d# V "

) + (.!" )""!* )&&!$

()$ *% "

2 *. !2 ) +!.* *%

/* . !2 $% % %). "!*

.%)('

4! )&&!$ % - *!

! .! . )') ".* *%

& - "*)(, (/& *%)* ) + (.!" . *! +)

" "

$" % & '' ($ ( ''

" ) ")% $' "!

" "%

" ' " $

("( "

$'""' &*'

"! $("

($ '' "

(

% & (

$") " "'

(%"$" "

$ ' %

$ " # #

%"!

'( % "

' &"#

&" ( "'

$ %*%

(%' "($

& '"

) ' &

%"" + ( % , $ , "

$$"'

& '

$ ($

%! "

""! "

( &

%"" % "

($ ( "

( "

%! "

"( - "

./ "

& " $$"'

%''

# # &

!( " " "! +"&%

($ "

'($ 1 ( "! & "

% & ( "

" " $ ) ' %#

& !") &"

"! $

! " &" (

"' % ) ( & $( &%

'"$" 2'"(" $' "!

3)# ( & '

$' "!

'"$" '"(" #

# 1 ($#

" ' ($ ' ' "

'"$" $' "!

'4%" " '"(" $' "!

" &"

''% ) " &"" )"

"&% & ($ ' -

%' '"'%( ' ''

%"" (% & ) " $

)

")"! $"

1 "'

) " 5" &"! '($1# " "

"'"$

%( 1 ")

'"'%( ' % "'

%' ' "

" ( &'( '

+ "!# )#

%' '"'%( ' 1"

"1"& % " ) '

($ "

1 (

'"$" 2'"(" $' "!

% & "

")"! $" "

% ("

'"$" " #

(""

*$ "

$%&"' "

# # % &

! " +"&%

! "# $ %$

& % % !" %

% " %

$ &'#$ (!

% ! ! % % "

% ($

% % " !

) (* &$

! % % % "

% $ %

! ! ," % %

"- #

% %$ % "#(.

, % % $ ! & ! ! # 0#

% % %$ ! 1 % $

2 !%

##%# 0# # # 3 !

% # .

# 4 5

! %%$ ! ! & %

& % 6

" # 0# 7 $ & % % $

% %

" 8 9:;<:=>?88 9>@AB88 9BCDB:E:;F88 9G?H>;88 9>@ABF88 I:AH>;8 JGK:?8L:;?:F8J:>M:NB8OB:@PC?89B:?K:8 8 Q:?NB@:8QC=>8

RSRT8OURVQURWXY8 Z[\]^\Z]Z_8 IVQ`a8 b cdefbgheb ,"- ) i-3 ! ) i-3