Mandeep And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ANR


   



       



  !

"#$%&$'()(*+ )#"',- !  


$#(#(*$) .$)/)

  $)0*&$*#) +

12 


  

3

4   

 !"#  $"% "  & '( )* +

 , - .

'

( ) !"#  $"%"!*" /#"&%





3

4-526  0%% " 1$

!!(# "$
"!"$


"#!2 $$!" 3
"!45$"6 )"$78 *"

  !

!  

  !  (# "  

9   9  

   :  8
2(# : : 8
 !!!

"5) ! "

#( "9

  #;

2 <5 !16%"#!

) )$"&" 1 "$ # - 
"&%"& !

!



2 <5

= !#" $"% "#"! %78+ ) !   #"$%"!*" + 

""$

 # )"%<"$) ) >"1"$. "9 #0

)"+   ""$%# "$

)&  "+1 "

!1+%   !% " !%"!*"  <#!

 # - 
"&%"& !

!



2 <57% )+ 78+" !"1  "$%   +" !1 $

<# 

8 $#"!! %"!*" /%"# <!""+ " ' -

% " !78& -16 !"1 "$ #"&%"&   ?

  $ )  "       %"  $

!  1-  + -  "$  $$   "$ (@ > -;& (%-(% !"$"

#?"&( $-;

  !  (   #"  #"!      

"  

! 

   % "    )  " + $"!  

)
 "$% "*"/ ##! !% !;<<<<"+ # % "*" >A.

 !% "*"  &  !%   -+ + $")! #"$$#% !(# : :

8
+ !!!! )  "8 $ $"&! $ #"&%  ""$  "$

%"/#

!(# ""$
"! %% !

 ##! !%"  >

.

  '+ &"

;&  !.") ! ! &+ 1& !1$"     ;

"

:
 )+$ &!1-


" !"!!

!

 

0& + $ <!$":

1$"


"8 $ #"!!     "+    &

)  "$  %"!  *" /%"# <     1 "

& B!+  '

A %%-(/"( &( )/"@

)9' %

* )!  #;

8 #" !! $"

!#" "  0# + ) !   #"$%"# <+"

)!

 .906

!? &+  

1% " *" !%+" 
"!#" % 1"

!  )""!



C!# "% &

"+ & -@8 ! +" !"

 .90>"1D  

% !% ""'%"# <" #'

")+  &""  2% "

*" 5 ! >A.

 2% "*"5"%<"$1&  >"1

%%

" $ # )% "*"""

! $%! "1+ $"$% "*"/ ##! !% !) %"") %#

#'!

 &% "*" !%+" !"+

!%"") %" "$$ # +"   "# +  & 9- ) & %"# < )"

%"") %#

#'!+ % !%0%"# <+

"& ! " )"&1

'% %"%<"$) ) >"11

"# & "'"+ "1 "$1

'% %+ #+ & !" ) % !% $

! %"# "% "1 )*"

:

"$



 )
"

) %"# < !"

& B!&

)+ % !%+ "#""$%  : 0%"# < # )"

-

)! 78 )" !"% !% !!

!"$



!%"# "% " ""$$+

 %78 

!% " )
"!

#! (% !  "$  "

#  ;

 "  ""'  "    &   0  #"&%

/ %"# <$

)!  

!+ % !% "  !

!    %$"&  &

)  +    &  9-  1

#'&

)  ! 

 )   %"# <+  %"& ") >"1% " !"1

! " 1

'% % !)" %"") %#

#'!+ %"# < 0% " # !#"&%

/%"# <  0%"# <$

)! 78 % "*"/

##! !%

"$

!



 


";

" # ")& !" -" ! & !

$-!

$$ #  '%" "!"+"

!

-?#"&""$ "% !% $"

"+ ) ! 8 $

)! "

%"# < !&"+#"& )1 #'"

 

)$"&;

!++  1"%  ! ,0 "

!% "*"/ ##! !% #! ! !

) %"# < +" !"

"+")& !" -"1"-$ "

! $&

)%"%"

"$%"# < " -"1"- +" !"+&>"

%"") %"$% " !%"# <8 $

)! % !% 1

#'&

)%"# <

!%  ! "% -!& &"$

/""%#

#   %       %"     &  "$   "  %"  + #"!!  !  "  D   

:  % "  *" !%   !

! )     "       )"  & !  "    %"# <     #  %  *   (     &   
"&% <  (#":   #'

 0  &"$(" =

> +

"#"!!! )  "+"

)"

- !  % !% !%"# <  !"

)
  6 " 1 !1-

  #

)
 + #+  )!1-% "*"  >A.

 !% "*"  &  -+ + $"!"1

$")!!"#&  0%% "+ $

! *"&1

$"6 )"$ 78  "    1   "$  #"&%"&   0   "    #"&%   !  $

%"/#

!(# "

 1%!1$"


"

1" :-  )" "

:0# ) 1$ &!1-

""  

0



!

% "  *"" - %"# <1& !1 

"

" "$$")-"$

)
 + # 1& ! 1 $"$

%"# "% "1$" 
" % $"& % !%

)!"  %%"

#!


"$"  #"$ >#

 %"!*" /%"# <"")& !" -1"!- *"+ $ :

-  # - 
"&%"& 2 <5

)!" 1 !

+   ! % !% ##%! &  '

%#"$  # -  !%"# < !

-&&1 +

"#"&& -# # $%"

-"$  & 1 '1-$ "$% !%( )  0  "E1   %< 
"      #   "$  3
   

 

    

 !"#$%$!% &#'

(  "1! "

)<" " $")- !#"% #-+

 %%

   & " 

"$"# -"6 78")"!  & 1

! + #"&%

7"

"+ )"1 "+& !1-"E1 %<
"+



- )!"+1"

!% # % $" "'

)%" " !(# "$
"!  3<<<<< 01"

!% # % + #&)$"&%#!"1>#& - 1&& ! $"

"+ )%"%" " 5(# % %"+"$ )
""%

1"$%"#"$ -#"""#!"$> #0 %" "!""#"$+%"+8" -#")  !% %"++ #   )
"F

50 "# ""$> ""$ )
""6  7  8$"& "%"" #

%"#!

)")"!  &  1 ! 1+"$$! ! & " &  "# ""$> "$"%%""$#"&%"!

"$$# ?

#"&%"!

"$$#%"+"$#" )"!1- %" ""$# "

"$
"!"$


"#! 0

:

%"+"6 !(#  #! $"$$# " #"&%"!



58$"& "% "+ #

%"#!

)"#"&%

 " !16 ! <# "$ > "!(#  )
"&

 +!"$> #+" !> $-<# "$  %"+F 5?

 %"+"$ )
" + ! &1 %  !  "1<# !F2 5"#!"$> #"2

5"

% 1"$%"#"$ -#"F 250!# "+ #"&%

"7 8$"& "%" " !16 !")"! "$$! ! &  !

!

%"

  -"$ # !# #& #"$ ## 

!"<  

1" ""$% # % # 1$"&

!F 2 58<# "$%"+!(# !+

!

)+ 

%  !

% 1 ! )
"& !) !

"  !) -"$"$$# " ! ""$$#

"

)&

!% -""$$## &! % !!

#"

- " %%"%

 -16 !") &"$

-"$ &  !!

%(#"$$#  -% '

)"% 

 1   &% #%""# -0!# ""#"  

##  $"!!"" ) &"$%1

 % )%"$" ""$$#F 2

5 !

 ) !$"& ""$$#& -1#

 + # "+ )"%!"&  &"$

!

%0-  !" !

 #$"" "$  <# "$ %"+"

6  #"#!F 2

5 


 #   "

)  "$$#  + #    $"&  #"&&#

#

&# 

%  %"

  "+  

-

$

"& - %%"%

  "$

$"6 )+%     !!

%F <58#  )
"& -6 #

%"#!

$ +  "$    #"&%"&   1+    !

%     %"

-  "$ 

#" &" !#"  ""$ #

%"#!

)+" "%% !%>!

#F 2<50 - <#% ""% # % " %"%" "2

!2 <5 1"C#""& #"$$# "

)$ #

!#""& +

1 )"$   &%

"+ #

1-"!!"&

"$

&!

%1+% !

% 0 )
"+" !1> !



!#

)"6 +"$$! "

! - '

"

#

"#""& #$ !"& !& "0#"6#"$ #"&%

!"$%"$ #

"#""& #-&+

+ ) 

# :9 & ! 1"% # % + # 1

!!"+  !# ""$ 
"+ "$ +  )
"+ > ! !#

)"

 %%

"$"6 )7 8$"& "%" <# "$  > "0 )
" !!"+"

# #& #C #"$& 1 )"+<# "$ > "!(# "6 78+" !1"# !"$> #"% 1"$%"#"$#"0$   

%%

+ 1#"!

!+  !1 !

&! # " "$
"!"$


"#! 0#"!  

%%

 #

#!$ #! # + # 1 < #! 

% "$ >!)&0 )
" !!" &"!"% + # !1$"

"+!1- %%

 ) )

 % # "$

!"! %  +

-+

)!" 1 #"#!+ #$ 1-"% )1")1 ' ##"8+

  +"$&   )
""1! "

) <" "$")- !#"% #-+

 %%

+ 

+ "  "$"# -"6 78")"!

 & !1 ! + #"&%

? )+  +"$    ) 
"  0  %  #      

"      78  +" !&"  "& -" "

% !

%"

!  " 1+  +"  #" )  %   0  #   "



"  "$  <" " $")- !$ 1 ""$!"#&

""$$ 1 !!"#&"

$$#  $"$ 1$")  "  !!% " "$#"&%

"$ 

!"1 "$ $ 1 !%"+"$

"-8$

78 #"! - !  ! - &%

 ""$$# 1 )" 

"# 

 # )%"1 -"$ "" 

!(#"$$## "1 #"!"1& -% "#

!

%1 &%

"# 



  %"# )   "  # &  8    # #& #     ) 
"  + &  -> ! !#

)"6 78+ # !1) !

!# " : : 

9 ! :2 5"$


"! <<<<<G

 8 +"$$ # !# #& #"$%# ! "

"$!# "% !1-"E1  %<
" # "$
 

  

     !

)#      "   $   #   "  <#  > "!(# "$
"!$"6 )"$78"1 "$ #"&%"&   8# < "!

-> "!(# "$
"! <# ! ##  +" !)  +")

""# - $

% "$ &"# ) - $"&#!"#& $")!+ #   )& 

&% #""E%"

$

' &

)# (# " "$(# "$
"!
"6 -%% " ! & ! 

%!

)& #

" %%

" $ -

" %"!"$ 5 

3

46  )#"',- ! 

* )+,-  .

/ -0 *)& .

/ -0