Gurnam Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS

 
        



   

   



  

 

 


 

  
!"#$%&    '"$%#%

     

 # )   #   % # *+,   -

  .

 

      ) $     

##"

      / 

      ,0 1%

2 34 

 "    ) " #



05    #  6  

 &   .



7  

8     9  # "    



       # 





  :  

#     

  &  #        #    

  .

 %  !

  

 .

   )  #

 )

 & $     #    #   $    # ) # 

  #$ &   ) 



#

    ,

)     ) &         # #"+) 



 .

  )      

 

,0

      $   #  

" ) &

       # #"      )     ; 

    ) 

        )   .

   $ 

   !    $          ) !  

   #" )

 "         .

 -

$ 

 $ )  

  !

   " #" 

    "      #"    )   #"$ 

     .

           

& & #   

#  # $  

#  

& 

 

 " 

-

#

   

- 





 !  #  "#$%&'()* &'+, -. /#/) 01 2'$#3 #'( 0/,)*.4    *0    $   " $      &   

       #  # "     &      

       



 

  

 " 

-

#$%&'()* &'+,5.   1 4 

 !

  :   

# 

    .



-

$ 

 )#  

         

" #$

   )  #)   #     

 

-

#$%&'()* &'+,5.   1 4    #  $ 

 !



 $2  #" 5

-   #  

#      

  ! < (

    ,0   

#)

 

 









 





 !

!

   



  "# !!  "    "  

 

        

  

 



  $           # 

# 

%

#  

  !!  !

      ' 

"  

 "

    !

!! 

( 



    



) *"  !

   # !  

  "  

 

!

 

!

+   ,

-    ,

./ 



"  



  

  1" #   51  .  2" 2 * 6

.( 0 1

 

 

   # 

 2

8  .! 2"# 2 

!

"  4

! ' 

"    "



!#  

 

 

  !! !

" 

' 

"#  



    !

#  

  !  !

  !!   

  !



  

 1" #   51  .  2" 2 * 6

.( %  #    &   ,0 )# ) 

##"    ) !  

     ) 

$   # 

" )          # 

 )

 #"     )     ; ($   ) 

!

  ,0$   )

&          

 )

 #"  



"   .

 -

$



      )    .

         #     ) 







    $ 

#   

#  #  %  " $    

!

 



# & #   #) #  )

" 

-

#$%&'()* &'+,5.   1 4$


   # 

"7#+'&., &'+, ,2*#'# -. /#/) 01 2'$#3 #'( 0/,)*.4  


88  !  #  "709#: *&.,#' 729/# -.
)'/*#: '10*;#/&0'

0;;&..&0' #'( 0/,)*.4 ( #&     

#$&'%()*&'+,5.  1 4

 

#)
-  &    

$2(+;)'/ (#/)(  ! 


 88   ! !


709#: *&.,#' 729/# .
)'/*#: '10*;#/&0'
0;;&..&0' #'( 0/,)*.4# !

!"      4  *"

   ! '

  ,-56

 2   

1  

+# 

 

+ !

 





   51 9

.,,6 



  !

0 4
     !  4

!  

   !!  

'   &.' 



 !

!

!  !!    

  

 

 

 

 

  

 ! 

 

 

"! :

;

1 

 !

 4 

!

  

 

" 







   

!  4

!  

 

!!  

 # 



&.' 

 !  !

! !!    

  

 

 

 

  

$

#  

 " 

!#

 

!   !

 

  



    

  !

1 

 !

 2   ,- ' 1  !

  

4   #  ""

   "  !

! 

 ! '

# 

4   56#   ! '

 

 "

! 

! " 

< "  ! 

     ! 

 !

  



 !

1   ,- ' 1# 



  !

0 4 < 99)#:=5,6 1 

 



     

 4   5,6

! 56  4

  56 

 ""

 

   !

.! '

 

.! '

 

#     #      

 

9   

 

   

   

  ! 

 

 

 *   ! .! '



.! '

 

     # 

 ! 

0 .

  

    ! 

9 

     

  

  !!  



   

 !"  !

 

56 >

  !  

"  



   ! .! '

 

 2 .! '



#      # 

  ,, 

 !



 

#  !   



 !!  

    

 

56 1 ! "  

   

4   5,6 !! !     

 

  

  !



 

 !!



#    !

0 .

   ! '

#      #     !



9 

        

  !!  



   

 !"  !

 

5)6 ' 

   ! .! '

 

.! '

 

#      # "     !  

! 

  

#   !

#      # !! "

!



   " 

 



5+6 '   ! 

" # 

 

 

!

 

<   ( 

!! 

   ! .! '



.! '

 

#      



<

5;6 1  ! 

4   5,6

4   56 !! 

 

    

 !

  9

9

"   !

 

4

 

 !" 

      # 

 

  "

6 

   ! '

#      # !!   "

56 ' 

  #   ! '

#      #  

= 56

<

! 

  *         



!  

    1# ! "= 56  

"  

# 

<

#   !

?

56   "  &  ! .! '

 

.! '

 

#      ? 56  ! "

 





?

56  *"   "

   

!

  "





?

56  " 

    "

 

" 



 

 ! ?

56  

"    !

   !  ! 56  4   5,6   )?

56

<

! 



   ! 

 !

  

?

56 

 !

 1? 5

(   !

5-6   ! '

#      # !! " 

 

  # ! "  "   !#  !  ! 



5, 6   ! '

#      # !!



!  

   



  



   

' 1 

    ! '

   

 "   !

!# 

     ! .! '

 

 #   

!

 #     



    

   5,6  2 

 !

!



<  



 #   



  !   

 

  !!  

    

  

' 1 



 

0 4


.

!

=5,6 >

 ! '

#      #   

 "   !

! 

     ! .! '

 

.! '



#      #  #   

!





  !  



    



    

4  5,6 

!

!



<  



* "! "  

#  !

 !

" 





    ( 

<

  

  

  "  

#  !! ,;



  !   

 

  !!

!  





    

!      ! !!  9

 4  



.

   ! .! '

 

.! '

 

#      # !!  "

!



   " 

  !  

 0 .



  

 

"   

!

!"

! !!

 !

.!

 

.! '

 

#     

56 >

 ! '

#      #   

 "   !

! 

     !

.! '

 

.! '

 

     #  #   

!



  !# !

  !  



    



    

4

  5,6 

!

!



<  



* "! " 

#  !

 !

" 





    ( 

<

  

  

   "  

#  !!



 !    "    ! .! '

 

.! '



#      # 



!

!!

 :

- 1  ( 

"





    !

 

 !  

 !

  ""

#  # 

 

" !!     #  

<

!! 

' 

   "

 #   

 2   

' 1 

#

    !

<

* ' 

  # 

  !

"   





   7

56  56  

"  &.'  !

!#  !



 

 

 7

   " 



!    !!  "  

 #  

9 #  "

  

:



# .(# !

" 



  ! !

  

  ,-56 1 

+  "   <  ( ! 

   # 

<

  

 

"    # !



     

<

 

( "  !

  "  !

   " 



!



!4 9!

 

 "     !

 





     

 

  "

    4  *"   

!

 



,

"           

 &! >  .

    ! !!

"

;

  51 9

.4 -6    





.( 

 " 1 ! &

)+    

 

"" 



   "   "  



# .(# 



   *"

!"     

    

 

"  ! 



# .(# )

  

,, '  # 

# 

!

  &      "   !



    !

 

# .(#   

 

!   

  !

,  &        ! 

  



! "    1 !! 1

 @5!

"    

 ! 

  ,-5,6A 

1 !! 1

 @5!

" 



  ! 

  ,-56A 

1# 

  "    4  *"

  ! " 

  $ B!

2

     $" &    !

 ! 

1  

+ '  #  #    " !!

"

     1 !! 1

 

1 !! 1

 

1  

+  !

!    !!

"   

!!  "   6      

  "   !  

 3

!  !

1  

+

6  4

! 

  

"

!

6 1 

!  "   



    

 !

   !

   

 !

6 '  #    





    

 

"   

" 

  !      !

      

  

  1 

+



#  # 

"   



 

"     

     

 

 3 

    " 

     3 

6 1

    



     

  



,  &  2

  

 .( C $  

 

# & "  



 ! "  

 

 



 ! !


#$%&'()* &'+, . /#/) 01 2'$#3 #'( 0/,)*.4  $2(+;)'/ (#/)( !  ! 




   !

 "7#+'&., &'+, ,2*#'# . /#/) 01 2'$#3 #'( 0/,)*.4   !!

  $2(+;)'/ (#/)(  ! 


 88  ! !

 "709#:

*&.,#' 729/# .
)'/*#: '10*;#/&0'
0;;&..&0' #'( 0/,)*.4#  !!  

  

1 

!"   

:

* %    &   $

 

-    

#     $ !

  )

 

$  $  

)  &  



      $       #  )    )  

 " 

-$ )      #  ##  

    %   #"

 )    (    



   



  )    

 " 

-

#$%&'()* &'+,5.   1 4$ 7#+'&., &'+, ,2*#'#5.   1 4   709#: *&.,#' 729/#5.   1 4    $  &   

      #  

 

#"$  

     

         #  # "     *    

  

"      !

   

  !

 

#   )  

 

 "

-

#$%&'()*&'+,5.  1 4 , .

 #  

- 

 

             )# 

  

  #"$

  ) #)$2  #" "#$%  &'

  ()*+,*- . / 

8

= !

+  > +8 = # > +8