High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/8469/2018dismissed

Bharpur Singh v. Kuldeep Singh And ANR

2019-04-23Mr. Justice Arun Monga17 pages

!"" #$%

% " % "

#$%

!""

% " % " & & '

!"" #$%

% " % " $% &'$ ( $ (

( )"*+%,-

% & '

" % )$#*+%,- . /0 *+%,- " %

111 23 !% " -00 %*

!" #$%

% *

$%#$%

% %

& ' $%

!" #$%

%-%% 5- " 4

-$$% 0

3 - " $

$% " "- - 0 - 4"" "$$ % % 7- %48%

% 6" % #$%

, $

6 $

$%% %

% % "$$ % % 9 $

"$$

" 8 $$8% $%48$ :;< % $ $ "$ - "% " *''**6= >

% -,% "$ - "% 0 7- "$$ %$" %$,% """" " $ % , $

6 $

$%% " - $* - $*8"-$*- " % %"""" " 8?% 7- % " "$%% 9" 7%"& ? $9 " 8" %

% %%7- % "$$ , %

% $

6 $" $%% %

% %% 7- "$ %%* @" % $

9$$ 7- "$ %% 9 9 %8" % "0

0$8 4$0 ? * %" " 0 8 @" "* %

% %% 7- "$ %% %* $

6 $98"0 %%8 %9$$

0" - - $

6 ""% " % $ $

-% % & A %

% "- "$ @" % %

% 7- "$ %% " % " 0" % - % " "$$ % % A A* % 7%

7- % " "$%%"$ $ -% %

& A* $

- 4 " * 5 4 $

9 -""8 7 "" % 0 "

0 + A *4 %

% "%% 0 4$ $

" "

- 0)%

- 4 " *5 4 2&3 ? * " "- - 0 --0 4

$% "A % -""8 4@ % " % " -

--$ -" - "$%

" $"

!!"""""#$

"" " '

()

* % +

"" " &

," " & &

"(" " & &

,"- " '

& ' / '

0 2 3 ' * $

"$%% $" 0 % 8 C - %0

C - 9"

$% 48 $

6 4"" "$$ % % ?$ 9"C- %" " 0 % 8 C - 9" 0 4$ ? "

" 9" $%

A 2A3 ? * $- %% $' 9" $% 0 %0 $ ' $

" 0 % $ " 48 %$

$ 0

C - "

% " 0

- $ """" $

% " %% $ """" $

$"" %$ " %

%" %%9%"

" $ %

$ % "- % $ 8

-$"D"""" 4898 E.$"" %%$%

" " *&*A*A4*A-* %' 3

6 " % " ," " %% %A ""%48,$F% >," *5 4948$- %% $ ' $%48 $

6 0 %0 $ 9" %"0""% 2'3

"$ $- 0 %0 $ 9$% "9 $

" 7" ,0 %0 " ? - 0 "$$% %& 7- %48 %

% , %

% "" 4 " % % "% "$$ 9" 7- % "- $ %0"

&) $"0$" % "09" "$%48%

% $

? $ "$$" """" %

% ?"% "$$ 9" 7- % 4 9 %

% " " %

% 9" " 4$" "% $ -$ 8 "% $ 0"

& ) $" 0$" 9- " - 9" @%

0/ $+>,$0 + 8/+>+6 C4 G4 >,$0 + 8 G>+ - " - 9" 0 % 8 % *$"=9""- -$$8 " % "$$ % % & ,% 9- %

% -$%,"$% $ " $8 4

,$ 0 G>+

% $"= 9" %- , - %

% % % "

-""8 %-0 " " - %

% " 4

" - 0 G>+ ? "$$ % % & 9" 0% "$$ % % >

% % ,$ 0/+>+6 G>+ & " "$$ % % & % * %

% % "$4$ 6 $ @ " 8 " & ? *9" -0 7- % " "$ %% & ,

--%

0" - % " "$$% % ? - 0

$$ 80 9" $" " 4 " % 9 - - % % $" "$$

$"" - - 0 ,$ '

& $% & 48 %

% " %

% % " - 7

" 0 8" %

% -$% -0$89 0" %- % " "$$ % % & >

% $" " 0

C - " %

% * "

0 0 "

8 - " - , $ % 0"

& ) $" 0$" ? "% " 9" $ 0 $8 %"0""% " 9 %9 A 23

8 0 %0 "4 %-$ %48 $ $ 0 %0 " 4%48 0 -

4 $$9% % %0"" " 0% $%

4$$9% 49 %9 B " -" "4"@ , "9-,-0$$% $

")0 %0 $ * $$ - "9 ) 9$%

0 $

$ " ? - 0 %$,8 """" 0 7- "$$"" 49 %9 %$ """" "" 4%%%B 98*" 0

C - "" 49 %9 " """" "" 4%%%?$"%48 $

6 " -""8 - "9%"-$"% $ - "$* 4 "0 -$% 4 - % $$ 3 H % - "$ 48

! " # $$ %&''( )%*% !&+#%#$* (,* *($ $(' -( #% $* " .' #% #$* /)+ &0 *'% $! *1 2(#$' *1 3%(4$ #'5($ 3$0 " %%'

$ 4$ (%6*7 ,'

(%6* ) 8 5+ #% $* )+ ' ($ * 9/ )'' %+ $$ .%* % 8 .

5* ,'* " #2(#$' ) + $(6& #%$* )+ '($*/) + . $ .' #6 #% #$* " 2 #6 #% $* )+ ' ($ * :: ) + ;#' " <$$ .%*= ##4 ',$ ##%#$* )+ '($ *9) + 0" ; 4 #%$* )9+ .& : .,,''

' # " - -

) '+ 9 )-*'+ - * " (21 #%* -( #% #$* ):+ ) *'

+/ - - ##" "' $

:)+) '+9 *;

* #%$*" ;

, # "% ''*$#%$* )+) '+ .(# " ;6( #% #$* )+ ) '+ 6( '2 # " !,,# )+ ) '+ : % *% " -( 660'

)+ ) '+ ) *'

+ % 7 #6 &#% *1*',* #% . $*.1$ &$% "

#%* #6#%#$* 9)99+ ) '+ 9 -

%% " $% 9 8" 4

0"" " 4%48$0 H0 " 07%@" $9 - "* * 0 %0 -

4 "% % " 9"4%48$0 ? $- 0 %0 $ %" 4 - "%% 0 " 4 - "% $- C- $ %%'$ ?0 %0 -

4C- % $ %$8 %$0 I "" $0 @" @8 - "* "0 -

4 % " $0 8 "" ? %- 9 % " $ -

4 % 4 "0

" 4 4% 48 $0 ? 0 %0 - $$9% 9$%$ 4-) % " *9, -"* 08" - $- %- $ 4-) % 0 $- 0 %0 0 % 9 0 %0 "$$9%B -$" $ -,8

"""" 8 " "- - 0 - " -$$8 $ % 8 " -$0 "0 9- 9" 0 % 0 $

" * - ," $%

" 9 0% 4"" $$ 80 -$% 9 %$,8 """" ," $' % 9$$ $8 9 $ """" " "- - 0 - " " ," " 4 0 "$8 - " % 9 ," -

- -$ +- %- AA ? "

8 +- ? 8 """" 9$% $8 $ -, 4C- -

- - $ +- J, * $%

" 9 0% " $

9" """" " 8*" $$"-$%

" 9$% -$% $

0 ")

0 %0 - 8 """" 23 B,- "%% "%-% " $ $%%-" 23 $ " $% 48 $

"- - 0 -* " ,0 0% "- $ "$$% %& 7- %4 9 %

% " % $

" % % $

$- 0 %0 * $ -" - " $%% -" % 4-0 0 4% $

0"$ " $%% ' -" - --% * & % A 7 %%% ,9 $ $

- % % & A B ,9 - $ % $" "

-"* "-- "% - 40% 4"" "% -% "9-9$-4$ - " %--0" -" "-"" B " -"* " "- - 0 - 9" $%9 $0 8" 0 " --$ -" - - $0 " "* 9$$ " 2 3 J,% $8* "$$"% % % 7- % " "$%%9" 7%" & ?" 9" $% A % $-

0 %0 $ 9" $% ' %

" A * -" - "- "$$% % % % 7- % " "$ %% " & % 4-0 0 4% +" $ $ * $

" $%% -" - " $

$ " * & % A 7 %% %

7% 48 98 ""

$ $ - % % & A - $0 " "

0 " --$ -" - * 9$$

" 48 "4"@ $ -" - " ,0 " ? " -" - " % 9-"$%%9" 47- %?$$ %"4"@ - - 7 -

$ , % 9 " - 0 G>+6/+>+*9$% - $-" -

$ " 9 $0 8""+ -$A H0 +- H0 8"" "9 "

" --" - 0" "

9 --$ * 9$$ " G %+ -$A H0 +- * -" - 9"4%48$0 %-$ 8" " 0 %" " - "" % ?" %-$ " , %48+ -$A H0 +- % % 8" " 4 - % 9 " " --"? 0-

47 %%48 $

$ $ - %

% " ? "--"", ,$ 9$$ ," 8 "-" - % " 9$$4 04%+-$% 0 $

+ -$ +- H0 "4 0% + -$A

&+- ?9%D " E"4 %"

%$8"%4 9 9%D"E %D--%EB "4$ 8 "9 " "4%48$0 , * $ $0 9" " " % %

-48 %

% - & H0 +- "0 % 8 % " "% 8 "9 " "9 $0 2&3 ? "% 0 %0 " ,$,

% $ "$$% %& 9-9"0% "$$% % + 8-

-8 "- =- % 4

0"" 0 G>+6/+>+-$%

, 4 % $

0 $

" "- - 0 - 9 $0 8" - 0%0 -

4 % 4 - % "- - 0 - ,9 $%%9 48 . <4$+7

0#$ " ! 2 *' #% #$* :)++ //*9 9"$% -

-8 "- =- % 4

0"" 0 8 -$%

,4 % $

" 9 % $0 " "0 -

4 % 4 - % "- - 0 -?9" "-0%0 "

H-) 0"" -

- " 4"$ 4 %- 4

""% + 0" * 08 ,

- 7- $ 0 $8 0"" " % ? 0"" 0 8" - % -% %- "- - 0 -? "%,99"$" %"%48 . <4$ +7 =$* #% ,#! #% #$* " & 6,'#%$* /)+) '+ " %' C% -""8 4@ %" %(= + 1

!-!,

' & -!, .

!2-!"-!(-!+ &

& & &

-!!3

' 533 6767

2 9

! '

' / '

2 9

8 / ' '

3 '

& ' (-!+ &

-!!

' -2--2

0 2 3 #%* -( #6 " #%* .' #6 )+&0*'%99:* " "$% -$0 " "

0 " --$ -" - * 9$$ " 48 "4"@ $ -" - ",0 " $ H0 8" " " 0 % 7% 0 - % "- % " 7%*

0 % 9

% -% 0 -" "% *1**$( ;( '%* 8 *1*',* " !#0 ! 8 # #% $* )+ * " % 9$ $$9

C-

0 %0 * "0 4"- -$" "$% 4 ) 0 % ?

- " 9- -""8 4 ) - "% 9$ %$

9 $- 0 %0 "00K% " %(= 67 1

;

< 6 7 1

< 6,7

;

' .

= 627 ' ;

= 67 1

< 8 6+78

2A3 J,% $8* $- 0 %0 $ 9" $% ' J, " 9" $% A 5" --$ -" - "48 % % 8" +" $" -$" " $% %9 *1**$( ;( '%* 8 *1*',* 4* )(,+* 0 %0 "$%4 %-$ %"

$$" % $

0 %0 * " 9"4%48$0 +" * $

" 4

" 9 $0

4"" 7 %% % A 9- 9" 7% $ $ -% % & AB 98* 7 %%% 9" $%% 4"" $ $ - 2 3 ,9 $% %9 1 -( (,$ " -( 2( (,$#%$* :)/+) '+/) *'

+* 4- % $%8 ) $- 7 %% -" - - 4 0% 48 ""

$ $ - +%,- J, ,9 $%

" $ $ * %0"" " $%

" -

4 $$9% 4 9 %9 J, " %-0 "

%48 " - 7 87 " 0 7- % " "$%% "-$%

",4 0% ?,0 " 0% $$8"$ 4 8%-0 "

%48 " - 7 87 " 0 7- " "$%% 8 0G $ $- $

$ $ - ""% & A* 9$% "

- "0 8 7 %% % A " 7- % " "$%% - - " -%* " "% 8 0" - & H0 +- "9 " "4%48 $0 B $%

" , - % 8 $$" "- -" - * $ $0 4

07% @" $9 - "-$%4- " % - $%

" %0 $ -% * " 7-" "9 "9 " "9 $0

2'3 5 " "-%% 4,*B % " 0

%%% %A ""%48,$ F% >," *5 ?"," " 4 $$8%,% 0 " %"--%

$8%"0""% 23 ?" ," " "

0 0

% % % A ""% 48 ,$ F% F >," * 5 4* ,% 9- $- $% 48 #$%

%%'$%9 - A 9"%"0""% 2 3 - " "4 $% 44%48$0

* * " ," " 4 $$9% 48 "

"% 0

% % % % A ""%48,$F% >," *5 "@ $8* "," "$$9% 9: 3 ?" ," " "

0 0

% % % & ""% 48 ,$ F% >," * 5 4 ,% 9- $- % % ,9 %% %A ""%48 $ 9" %"0""% 3

" "

0 0

% % % A ""% 48 ,$ F% >," *

5 ? 0

% % " 4 $% "% ," - ,9 " "% % " 4 %"0""% 48 $ ,% 0

% % % % & * * " "$ 4", " 0%

* "," "%"0""% ) $ (*

- +,,--./012 / +,,--0-34 /