Kamla And ORS. v. Kashmir Chand @ Kashmira And ORS.

   

 
   !     

"#$%"% &'

((  


  
  
  

    )* (

+ + !

,++

  !"# $%



 %!"# $ 

''''

+ !

,++-

(

./0    (%

#$



$%  $%  $ 



)*+,--.*/,+0

(% 12 #13  &

 %  $%  $% 



)*+,--.*/,+0

(% !%# 



  $%  $% 



)*+,--.*/,+0$ +.

+, /,/& ,+ ,4 /,/&

3 $

 ## 3

#  $

+ (%   

  %  1

  $   13  %

5

6% $  $  # 7(   0,$/,+-! +& ,4 /,+-!$ $#$8 ,.

++ /,+.!     13      ##      (1! 
 6% $  $  9 (1:71383$

; 

$

!##$ %$9< % :  %###

/ (% % (# 8   +*

 688$% 7!  /!&=>;%! ;

?%"3

#"

36  % $% 7!  @> < %

6 % $% 7 (%

% 

   #   +!  &    = 8% !  #   /   @   $ 

? $3 $#$% #  %+4 ,- /,+-!  8%%$ ?%?%%8    1$ 
13 ?1   ,/?*+44+8%#%1  #% (% 18   "

  13  ?%  ?%%!  %8 !  %  1  

!     "

%  < %#

$% 1$8 % $% 1!1%

8% !#;1   +A?*./@01  "

 %! B B   #

$ 
 %% 1  % "3

#!1#;< %8%  2  %  ## 3!)  &// +4 ,- /,+-     #  /.4!  &,=*   8     8% % #  !

(% ! 

=  $ #

 

#+--

# +=,  $  %     %#  #!  +400  $  

;  #

  $ =!,,!,,,5* 8 !$   % %%  #!

# %

" # ! C  % 8  %  %  

$1%%  ! (1  % $% =/3 D% %3 #

    +,!@/,5*D    /@E   %  #

   $ 

#D

%  $+=D # +5=% $%#

##$

%3

 D "   +@!,,,5*##$$ 

 D

"   #    %    $   =,!,,,5*    %  88   ## 3!  8   #

    %  #   %    $ +.!++!44,5* 13  3238%  -E

    $  %    $ $  $ %

   # B

@

5

%"

$ % 

; 

$% #

8 (1

- F%    

! $%

1  %% (1%    %

 138 3#

##$$

 D  "   3    +@!,,,5*  8  $  

     13

" # 3% 88$% %   $  %  

  (%!  3  $ 

  $  %     $

8 (1

.

  %  %   %!       $      &  > # 

3!1 %% (1%    %33$% % 

%1

  % 1$% # #: $; 1 8 !% 

% %"

1

 ### 8%% 8  "  %

  0!,.,5*8%#%## 8%% 8 813%

C )% !% 

 $ % 

$#

8 (1 % % 

(%    %  #;8   %  #

#3  1 8

  % # #G !   (1!$  % %3 #

$% !% "  8 %

$##  " %% # #G  8% % %  $%

# #% 1% 8 #% ;

8 !% 1 $ % % "

#% $%1 "   # $ H3$ !% #



 % G3### 8% # #G !8%#% $  +,!@/,5* (%% 3    2

 


 
  

 !" # # $ %&'"

 ()"*# + 
## 8%%  $  8   8  13  %

C       ), ( - ./ &  "0/
", 1#+$2-2- $1

3%&'"

 ()"*31 1#+! 

 4  " ,  

5,. -.  "     

3$  2-2  - $  ##  %  &'

"

 ()"*1

!
6 " ,&7 "2""

 , 1$2-2- $%&'"

 ()"*

1+ (% !

% # %!



813% :1



$%   $##$#



(%%# %% %!#  /;% #  @*< %

 $  !!%



%%  

  #  #    /*;%    $  #  #    @*< 

%

 $  ==!,,,5* #%



+,

(%!%

## !;  # % 8$ 813% :1

C

13% )% ;

$#"

# !

"

 1  $  %  #

        13  %     8 13 (1% # 1 81

* Sr.

No.

Head Compensation awarded by Ld.

Tribunal Compensation Awarded by High Court 1.

Income Rs. 10,520/-p.m.

Rs.10,520/-p.m.

Rs. 2,630/- (25% of the income of the deceased) 3.

Deduction towards personal expenses 2.

Future Prospects Rs. 2,630/- (25% of the income of the deceased) Rs. 3,287.50/- ([i.e.1/4thof(Rs10,520 /- + Rs. 2,630/-] Rs. 3,287.50/- ([i.e.1/4thof(Rs10,520 /- + Rs. 2,630/-] Rs.1,18,350/- [i.e.3/4th of (Rs10,520/- + Rs.

2,630/-]) x12] 5.

Multiplier 4.

Total Annual Income Rs.1,26,240/- (Rs.10,520/- x12) 6.

Loss of Dependency Rs. 16,56,900/- (i.e. Rs.1,18,350/- x 14) Rs.16,56,900/- (i.e. Rs.1,18,350/- x 14) 7.

Funeral Expenses Rs. 15000/- Rs.50,000/- 8.

Loss of Estate NIL Rs.20,000/- 9.

Loss of Spousal Consortium Rs.40,000/- Rs.44,000/- 10.

Loss of Parental Consortium NIL Rs.1,32,000/- (Rs.44,000 x 3) 11.

Loss of Filial Consortium to parents i.e.

mother of the deceased NIL Rs.44,000/- 12.

Total Compensation to be Paid Rs. 17,11,900/- Rs.19,46,900/- ++    $  %  

  $%   1   %  %    $



8 (1

-E

 $  $ $ $%

 B% 8  1  4E

"

8$% $8 1% 13

C

13%

8 !  # 

 1 %$$  *#  !1 %%  $ %1 "

% 8 % !%1  %  $-E



+/   %"

   % %  %  2

  #  13  #   $  %

6# 7%!



 %  $ .

@E



+& (%!;

 "

8% $%1 $# $

"  $% "# % $ !% #

 %

6# 7  +4!=-!4,,5* 8% .

@E

 $  $$ $#

%  $ 3

$

%

6

7

+= 

 

%$%  #

 ! 3  6$37#

#

  8!

81 2 % %1 1   %    " (1%

  8

+@ 2"."3&."- 6/.705 8&%$35$'9 72"

/:/.%- /66"/0 $;

/00&:"% :$72 72"

7".8;

$'%$#/7"% 2"."/4&<"(

+ !

,++

 +"67"84".

-