Si Ramesh Kumar No.539/Nnl v. State Of Haryana And Others
!
$#
! "# $ %# !
%
# '#(
% ) *
'## '#(
*
+& !
,,,
%# !&" !
-
(+ +#
#
'
+ .
/#
#
2 3445
3 6'7
.8 (# 0
# +& % #
1
9
:/ 2
3
6'7
8 9+"
#
3
! 2 8&
#
;
< /
(
' 55&
+
'
;
*
:
++9 #
++9
5
6'7
58
;
=+
+
$
53
>9
= /$
. ' :/
2
3
#
(
'
;
/&
9
#
$+ # ="
2
++9
# 0 # #9
"
$+
= = "
+9
$+
$
$
++9
0 #
:/
# ## = =
&
$+
>
33
3
$+ ++#
+
"
0
>#
9( "
/
++9#
:/
$+ =+9#
$
+"
##
9(
"
= = "
> +9
+ '+ 9&
$
#
3 +# =
#
0++
( #
0
="
9+
3 0+
$ = =
&? - #
$$
'7
.
5 -
#$+
#9 0
$## 6 3 8 (# #
3 6'7
.8
++9
5 6'7
58
+ 9(
0
$ &
="
9+
0+
$
= = &
+ #
# #
5 &
#
9
$
9
#9
0++
&
(#
=
#9&
& ( 7 #
#9
$
#
3 "
+#
4
@
# +
=
0
2 3& 5&
9 48
#9 /
=
#
7 #
#9 =
7
&
0++
) #
&
#
#+# 0+ 7 9
#
#9
/ $$
#
+
# +
+#
$
) #9
+#
B
C&
Learned counsel for the petitioner has referred to the summary of allegations (Annexure P-8) and the list of witnesses along with the same to highlight the common witnesses.
-
+
# +
#
=>
#
+
# (
##
0 ( #
+#
.
; #
&
+(
) #9
!" #0
+#
$ ="
+
#
+
/
# ) #9
+ (
' ) #9
$
#+"
+#
#
# =
"9
#9&
$
#&
0
(+( $+
$
) #9
!"
$ # # =+0
B
!
'
=( ) #9 0
# (
) #9 &
$
&
0
+ 0 9(
=(
$ # #
$ / +#
#9
#9
#
+"
=
=9 #
+" /
+#
#9
#9 = # #
+
+
9
#+1 $+"
(
0 (+(
$+
&
#
=+
#9
++
+
- &
++
# &
( ?
++9
=9
# +& = # +
9 =9
(
(+(9 $+
1
#
$+"
" / = +
68&
#
(#
++
( 9
+
9
>
#
$ #
0
9
(
$+
(+(#
/$
+"&
= +
6(8 (
0
# = +
68
68 # 7 (
# +
#9& =
#
9(
#9
+"
#+ "#
= +
6(8 $ ++"
(#
#
#
#$ =9
+"
#+ "#&
(
#&
$
#9&
(
#
##
3
+
+"&
) #9
/#
B$ %& '#
& (# )**+ ,* $ ++"
= (#
!9
#
&
+
1
#
0
(+( $+
-
+( $
# ) #9
$ # #
=+0
B## !
$ % &
#'
(
#)
!
*** *** ***
#+ ,
-
*
%
(
- ". " / 0 - & & .
*** *** ***
..
/
$ 2 2 3 - &
4#5 6
(
%
"
.7 8
8
!
8
*
(
6
8
% 1 . . & &". "/ 0 -(
/
=( # &
( ;
!9
#$#
$$ +
#$
9
#9
#$+
#9
0 ##
#$+
#9
0 ++"
= #
$
$+ +#9# ="
#
(
;
> #
"
#$# 1
=
$ 9#
#9
&
#9 0 $ $#
++
0 ### - # #
# ="
="
>9
= (
0 (
$ # # =(
5
-
/#
B2
3 4 % 5 &(# )**6 66)#
= (#
$
#
#9
( 0
#9
9
#
$#9
"# /
+ = (#
# ) #9
$$
=) (
#9
#$+
#9
9
#
#
#$+
#9&
0
$#
+ # 0
( (
+
=&
0
#9&
0
0
$+"
++9#
(
#&
=+#
=+#
$# /
= (#
&
#
1
+ 9( 9
1
=
#
#
/
# &
- =
+
+
9
#9
#9 0 #
9
#9+"&
- =
"#
#9
++
$$+
#+# #
+ -
# #
##
#
$
#
# #
= (#
- =
!9
##
$+
#$+
#9
( 0
9 -
+( $
# ) #9
)
$ # # =+0
'
-
$ 8 .
.557
-
3 - - %
&
# .
*** *** ***
##
8 - 0 -0 . 1 - & " " 0" 0 " - "
. . " 3:
8
; 8 (
/ < %
%
:
/ < %
*** *** ***
#'
! 8
(
=="
-
'0$ % &7 .73
# )* 6& = (#
#
B#7 !
&
8
% ( (
#'
1 ( /<
2 > ?
< .5#. # /''.
4
% & "
3 - 1 & 1
" & & 3". 8/ 00" -
/
*
"
In the above reproduced judgment, apart from reiterating the fact that it is a matter of settled law that there is no legal bar on conducting the disciplinary proceedings and criminal trial simultaneously, reliance was also placed upon the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in Karnataka SRTC vs. M.G. Vittal Rao, in which it was observed that the ground for seeking stay would be available only in cases involving complex questions of law and facts and where the departmental proceedings were not being unnecessarily delayed. - &
=( # ) #9
0
&
0
#
= ( #
0
#9
0
(#
#9
>$
="
++
7
& 0
$+
(+(#
/
& $+
& = 9
In the present case the issue which is required to be considered is whether the petitioner had sought and taken a bribe amount of Rs.10,000/- initially and thereafter had sought bribe of Rs.2,000/- and as to whether he was caught red-handed while accepting the said bribe of Rs.2,000/- by the Vigilance Team on 09.07.2023 from the complainant Neha Kumari for hushing up the case of her father who was involved in two criminal cases which was being investigated by the petitioner. /
#
& #
"
$+
% ( ) #9 =
0
$+
% (
="
+
# +
$
#
3 =
&
0
3& 5& <
+ 6'7
58
+
++"
=+# '
"
&
$+
(+(#
#
+# =(
% (
$
#
+ 9 rather allegations against the present petitioner are that he had demanded bribe repeatedly from the complainant Neha Kumari and at one stage, had accepted an amount of Rs.10,000/- and thereafter, was caught red-handed while accepting bribe of Rs.2,000/-.
11.
Before parting, it would be relevant to make a note of the judgments of the Hon'ble Division Bench of this Court which are relevant in the present case.
-
( ;
9) 9)*))
+#
B.:2 :1 ' ( " )6* )*)) +#
#
B
/ @ (
/
2 3 - ?
$ > 2
#AAA7/B9A
2 3 -
(
<
(
C
!
/ @
(E
.55) 6
-
/ @
2
*** *** ***
) F (
D / @ G,
/ @
H
"
'
=( ) #9 0
9?
9
0 $+ # =
+
#
9+ #9
&
$$++
=
#9
0
&
=
=+# /
+ = (#
#
& $+
/
+&
=(&
( 9
$+
$
#
3
=
9 (
#&
&
$+ # #0
=( # ) #9
+
$$+"
'
4
-
( ;
B; - 2 .
. & < !1 :1 < <3 3 =3 # >9 , 9)*)# " )+*,)*) +#
#
4
&
D
D
-
D
*
*
.5#A 7# 5# .5.53&##
-
*
2 - I
*** *** ***
6
/ '5A '.5 #.5&$ .5# 3
/ 8
(
D
(
-
3 - #A++
* J( J
( & 8 %
"
/
=( # ) #9
+"
+
#9 ( 9+9
= (#
9
#
(
' 55
(# ="
&
)
"9
#$+
#9 - @ & @
53 +#
# ) #9 ##
#
0 3 /
+(
?
' 0< ( .. & ###
>
+
(0
>
$9 (0
=( # <
# #0
=( # ) #9
( ;
# (
##
#9+"
##
%# !
*+,-.,/)&"
(D%
$ >9 ?
#
E
$
=+
E