High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/57308/2023allowed

Nishan Singh v. State Of Haryana

2024-10-21Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil9 pages

"#$%&%&'

#$#($) "#$%&%&'

* +,-& . -. -- , ****

!"

" !# ./$"

0#("1234 & $%&

' (

)*+ # ,

- (# ,# ./ 01+ %2 03%4 (

*32/

0102 !

%+1+$

1345%+1/

02 !

# & #

" $ 6( %& $0&

7 (#! ./ #

"

(

( 8

!"#

$$ %& % ' ( &

) *

# ( )+ # (,'

++ ( *

( -

# ( '

( (

.

*

/

'

0 ' (,

-

# ( + & .

'

* ( 1 ,

&# ( 0 ( # (, 0# 1,

# ( 1 &

.

.2 &

- 2 - .1 &2 3$$4 5 ( + &., 0 ' ( & & 6 7-

# ( + ('

&# (

' & ' & +.

&. &# ( - 38$$3 & , +

&.

&

&

&# (1 &

+2 ( 8

... % 97 .

10 ' ( & /

'

0 ' ( !'1,

.+

# . 3$$3 ' .1 52

( ++

, 5 ( + &. 0 ' ( :. ( , '

'

9

(

# . 3$$3 ++'

& # (!

# # ( 0# 1,

3 ;+ & '

& '

' 2

& 2 +2<

,

& # ( + '

& , -

# (

& *

. & # (+ +

& '

' ' ' .1

.

+.

&. & & , # (

1

& +.

&. .1 (

++ (&

, & '

# (1 + &

+2 &,' '

(

- ! ++ &

& # (

++ '

# (

,' &

3 * '

' - !,'

2 -

# ( 2

( ,

# ( && +2 + & + (' +

&1

& -

# ( 4*3 . +,# &

( ( 7=#

, '

( & =

=

3 . +

- 3 - &

& 3 (

# ( + ;+ ' 2 (

& + > $*&

( # (,! # ./ ##

: ##

!

# $ 6( 0 )& (! !! ,

# ./ !#

((! ;( #

!#

, !

!

3< 03%4 ,

## 8

( ,

!# $)&

/( . 9 !( , !# *0, #

- , ((! !

, !# (# ( (,!

(

!,

, -#

(#!

(

(

*32/ ! ( $1&

( # (

# #!

%1 %0 03%4 (#( ,

( !# (!

# !

(

# *3 030* ./ 002< *3 030*(

%2)8 #

- 4 - ! #( ,( #

,

./ ! ./ !

*3 030* $4&

= # ( # # ( 0* 030)# , ;, "

( ( #

>## ,

(

,

(

9$ 6( %?0& ;( ! ( (! ! ;( ,

-

, # -

( /,

( !# - --$ ,(## &

! # 7 '

7 ( # (!

#

(

# , '

0%0/ 5"#, ## # , ! # !( 9 @(

;( *% %3 $2&

( (,! ! #

#( (# *%1,

! ( (,!

!# ##,

3* 030*

# !

%3 %3 030* ! #

(

( # # #!1./ #

!#( ./ 0%4

- 5 - 0) %% 03%0 (

*0*5*)%5%)<5%)+51345*325*305%0387 / ,

(

( !#

, (#,# $<&

# ( # (

$+&

/ ./ "

,(## ! ((! : # # #(

!# $%3&

= !# ((! 5 A 5 ##

! , #

8 # #

( 8 ?%++

0 ' ( !'1

.+

,

# . 38$$838 ' + 2

( 52

( ,'

7 ( + &., 0 ' ( :. ( , '

9

(

# . 38$$838 ++'

& # (@!

# (, 0# 1

3 ;+ & '

& '

'2

& 2 +2<

, # ( + (' & 72

# ( *

# (+

& +.

&. ) *

# ('

' 838$$808 + 2.1 .

+.

&.' + ( ( ' & & , # ( 2 ( ( &

,(

1

& .

+ .

&. ..

(

- 6 -

++ (&

, & '

3 ' 2 ( + * & 1 '' + + * 2 + * *

A.+

& % & , # (,'

1 ++& ' + ,

& &2 &

++ '

# (

' &2

, ' ' &

' * ( - -

# ( ( / + +2 ('

,

' &2 *+* , '

, # (' + * 1 ++ ++

:.

( , # (

+ & . + (' + 72

) *

# (.

& -

# (

1

43 # &

?> $%%&

' !#! #! (# (

%4% , # (#! ./ B - ! ((! '

(# #

, (

!

( 8 / + (&2 + &

, &

*

< , ( # # (,

3 ; # & , -

# (,

# (, & (' + '

1 ++

& , % ' * ( +

*+* ' & & (1 *+* &&

% (

, # ( + & ' + '*

&

.2 &2 & +

)7##% * ( &2 &

,

>

- 7 - $%0&

/(# !# *0, #

((! -

!! ,( ! ./ (# ((! $ !#& !# #, # , #

!# #

((! #

' !

! !#

, ((!34 3+ 03%4 ,( !! . 9 !

, 3< 03%4 $%*&

' !#,!

;

# # !!- (

!

5. 9 ((#! ./ # '

, !# . 9 6! $ 6( <& ,

( !# ( ,(## >

#

!# 8 6!

((! ( ((( /( ,

!

. 9 !# !

,

( , ( $%)&

' , , !# (

( 8

,

;

,

- 8 - !!

! !

!

8 #8

$%1&

#

#

, #

( ( 8801+%)80300 #

30 3* 030* # 0% (/ ( #(, !

,# !#

, #- ,( !

!

@(##(

( ( #, #-

#

/ (

(#

(# #,#

( 5 ## ,,# (# # ( #

,# $%4&

' ## ,

# 3* 030*C

!#

,

!

%3 %3 030*(0< D#0

,

6! , (, , (## #

,

, #

! $%2&

" 7 (

!"

# !# $"

%& # ( 0% (/ #(

# 6 ( # # (,# !#

##

- 9 - BC .

& . *

+

.

+ ' ,

+

9

2

+2+ (

. * BC '2, 2, A.

* .

,

+ ( &

+2 .+ ( *

( , 2 + + & &+D C

+2 &2 '

++

+ &. &

+ 2

& + ,'

, ..

8* + + 2 '

'

$%<&

'- # (!

(## # ! #:

!( (#0< D#0 D

,

6!

(#,(# ##-

## !

#( # !# % 0!%3

%0 030)-

! , , (#!( # 0% (/ # E7#(# ;#

F #( ;(

6 (E' $

(

)

! *%"

+

## $%+&

# ##

, (#,#( ,#( , # (5"(

%&%&' # ./$"

0#("123

("1

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No