← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/13730/2018disposed of

Sahdev And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2022-12-07Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal10 pages

 



!

"

 #"

$% &

'

!

& 

( ) **  & + ,,) * *  - &.

&

-* **//00 .1 -



' &

-* **/ !

)

2%3 * $"- !

3 4-

#3  



   



 

  

  1, 5671)

      

$ &   ' $%'( " "

)" 

  #  &    *" (  "

 , - . )" 

/0, &   1

/0, 2(  

. )" % &   ' .%'(  $%    "     #

  



 *" 

 " #  #  "

  -*

*

,0 #,10 

 "

 ,

/0, 

4/ 43 34

 3/ ! . 6  7 * , " )"  "8 * 9 $8    $ !" 7" :

9 "

 -

/0,   "

5 4: 34

- 7"#  .%   7 

4 43 34 ;

" 

.% .%  

" 3/ !  $ 3444444<8   / 9 $%'  4/ 4: 34 ;

" 

$% $%   "   => 8-   

   7  "

   $ 5444444<8   !

-)

9

" 

.%  

"



/

/0,     $%    

8

" $ .%

 !       "" ? 

  "   "    $ :4444<8  )

   .%

 )"

    > " " " 

    



       !   #"    7  "  "    " 

 # "

, @  

   



  .%  !      " 

   )"

:

$%    " "  "8        



       

       ! 

           !  " "   

#       ! 

         

!    !

   "

  

!

 $ % (, /1  /,)

?   >  8

&'

 (  

&  $

&#   (

&  $ )

&*  +,

&-  )  . 

&/  $



&0  1

&2   $

9

&'3  4  ".

&''

 5  ( 3 3 ? "

 "   "       #"    5 ;8 &'

.!8   & 67 &'

     &'# 67 &'2 . !  

&3967 &' . ! :) & . !8   5  &'  &/

 ! :)

5  &0

 !8   5  &2 .!8;

 5  &'3  &'

 !  ! 5  &'#9 &'  ! :) 5  &'*

  

 8 5  &'-

 !8   5  &'/  &'2  ! :) 3 5 @  

  



 > $8

*

"#89 = 

3 , ? "





 "  "     #"    5 ;8 67 $<9$<+ .!  

67 $<.

.!8 & :

 67 $<,

 !8.  =   67 $<6 .!8    ;

        '02

67 $<>9$<1 .!   

: &,1, 08, , !1

@ "   

$%   $%

     => 8A 

$%   

  !" #

# 8

 

&%!(

   =>  4<  " % 7  "    7  B

  C   " 7  "

7 * #" 7" B"  " "   7 * *   7  "

 #  

" # #  " 

 "

5 3 C

  "      #  " *"    

$%     )" 5 5 D  $%

   "

 "  => A    7  "

*"    

$%!&"% " # *"  => A

 #   5 ,  

  

   #

 " "  " # *"   "   #    

  D

;  "  )"  #

     >

        

"

'#

" '() 

    *" +, !--./  

 "8   ? !" @ .    !

       =   "              

   !    A     )!!!

   

  

     ?      "      :

<      "   8     "  )    )    )  ) 

 !      !

"     !    @  "

 

   "    !!

         =         :

  

    

)    )8    @  .        

)  )     )

       

  "

)                   

      !              

  ) ):                )  !

  

7    )        !  

  

   

   )  !     

" ;  )       

    )    :

<               

)      ?

     !    !

              

         ) 

))  "   

      @ .  !

 !

    ) A    !    !

!            "  8  )    )

      )                     !

! 8 )        ) !

 8      

)  " ?

  !

!         A !    )  )8)8  !



  <: ?

  )  8!

  )8  .   !!8 :  !!   !

   

     

 



               

  A  

   )8! )    

))    !         <:     ) * '38

    )    !   !A    :     



)     !        )    !



$ 8"    

 



)8!

))8  !

  !

 8

  A 

  )

8 8 !!

  )            :

   

     B  !  "   

   

 



   

&   

  8            )

@ 88         )               &A !

    <:

  8!  ! !   

   A 

 8           )8  !



: <     )!

8  !  7! ? !

   <:

) 7! "      !

)"

!

   <:   )  ) )            )    8

:   ?       

    )     !  "  )      ! 8   8   ) ! !      <: ) 8

 5 :

 

 #    #   " "   ?  

#  " * "  " #

 "#    #"

 " " # " 

   " 

 #

 "

"  

  " 8   " !   5 - $%

   !   "  " 

          7  "

 $%  )" >  #   D *"    >    

 # "  $%

 > 

5 ;

          "   "

 #"  

 #'8   "8 -3 && # &"!& %'

3 & < - -*

* =,5,

* -0 &

* &

0  >1

, * >1 # 

, * .,007 8

- 4 344/

! ,;4444<8 5;-4444<8 7  "

8 ,

:

)

 535444<8 ;3;

3:-<8 7  "

8 :

,,3 34 4; 344:

B8- ;/:444<8 ,/54;-0<8 7  "

, 8 - ;0

, 4/ 344-  /4444<8 ,3----;<8 7  "

:

8 ;

/03 3/ 4 344/



/4444<8 3//44444<8 7  "

- 8 / 5-4 4, 4- 344;

)

 3:4444<8 ,455555<8 7  "

;

8 ,4;

4; 4- 344;

,34 )

 ,3:444<8 ,/0;- 0<8 7  "

-3 && # &"!& %'

-

$3< -3:

4- 4/ 3440 ! 3-4444<8 -055558 7 * $3<C

5 43 344/

5B8 5

344444<8 ;4530;<8 7 * 5 / ?   > => 8 => 8 0 "

   

 

    7  "

#"        >  #

?  

"     "      ? 









"  "  => $3<%   # 7 -3:

 4- 4/ 3440 &=> $3<( 

, !

:



#  "    7 3  7 /  " 



#   $ 3-4444<8     $ , 4 ;<8  *"   

  

  # 7 34 

5 43 344/ &=> $3<C(     7 - ;

    "  $ ;4554<8  

 #" * 9 $8 5 0 $%

   "  "





; 4 " "

  7  "

  #    "

 ,

/0,  "  !     "



 *   7  "

 )"  #   ?   "  "

" 

$% >







 

<8 #* , &,,) ,

B   "  " 

    

#  " , 3 %)"  

  , 5   "      

&>5@ 

3 4-

#3 8 $"&    !<   C4 <D    ! ) C4 <D

 7 % 7  9 $D8 5;54834 /

 9=6 79 @$

6<

++= @D

$F7 79 @$

$D8383434

?+ $ 79 @+ =$

6<

++= @D

$F7 79 @+ =$

$D8,53-834

+ C?. 9=6?

6<

++= @D

$F7 79 @+ =$

, $D8,53;834

BG

.

$ 79 @+ =$

6<

++= @D

$F7 79 @+ =$

:

$D8,53/834

?+ BG$ 79 @+ =$

6<

++= @D

$F7 79 @+ =$

- $D8,530834

$=

$ 79 @+ =$

6<

++= @D

$F7 79 @+ =$

;

$D8,554834

7@@

?7

6<

++= @D

$F7 79 @+ =$

/ $D8,55

 $ 79 7@+ =$ 6<

++= @D

$F7 79 @+ =$

$D8,,-,834

+ ?79@$?

9=6?

6<

++= @D

$F7 79 @+ =$

$D8,,-:834

.?. $ 79 7@+ =$

6<

++= @D $F7 79 @+ =$

$D8,,--834

7=+ $ 79 7$ 6<

++= @D $F7 79 @+ =$

3 4-

#3  $"&