High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/149/2019dismissed

State Of Punjab v. Jaswinder Pal Singh

2019-03-18Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain,Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill7 pages

"#$%&% '

(")* %%+%%,,- " .

/!(! !0 "1 -' "23 +%%

"# /%%'%/ 0-411 "-4 (")*%

3 ' 3! " ,,- " ("1 '

" &5$6&7 /% %%

/ 2/"

- 8 ,, - 2 "! 3 )(129 " 1 1 &%%$ ,!!

1 *: 3 11 "- '

"! (12 4 / 1;

% . 1 9,(2"

1 )(129 "4 3 / - (/ <( / "(!

3/2 !("1 /'

"!4=>4 =54 =$4 5 "1 '

" &676 7

//(, "4$$% /1 "2 "4

%5%4

9,- "" 9/) ' "23 9 1 " ,,- " ''

/ 1;

/; "2 "2 "!3 "0 3 -- 2 "!33 "312 -!

12 "!3 9,- """13 ! 9 -:9 9* /!%?3 - " 0! , ! 1 '

(/ : /"34 24 (!

1 ,!!, /4 / 1 -/ "2 3 9!

67 1, /!

""1 /1 -/ "23 !6 9,- ""@!71(23 /! 0 1 04 3 0 (-1 !

"1 3 ! 3 -1/ " 9 / - "2 0 3 3 ! 1(23 " / (/" ;

% 3;9

A(/ "1 /9"1

, '"13(4* 33 -1/

"4/ (/"

9 9 / "3 :

/%3 "2 19 3 ! 1(23 / 3;9

A(/ "1 !

" /9"1

, '"13(4 /3"2 "23 /9 /@!"9 93 '3

-*0- ' " //: '3

-4 / 1;

" %5%% (!

1 " 0/ "2-: 2 " 9 /@! "9

3 -1/ " ! "1

, A(/4 03 ! 3 / 9 /@! "9 0! '/*) A(/% (!

"4 03 - "2 , ! 1 '

(/ :/"34 231 1-!

/(,

!*:,/ ,/ "2

1 ,!!, /!% 3 9,- "" 31 * "

1 /

/1 ("1 403 31 !- 13 !%&>4&$4 54&& "1 >&4 0 / 2 ! 1 2 "! 3 1% (!

1 " -!

,(/3!

1 -"1 9 !(/ "2 >= ;"-! "1 9/-! " 3 "9

3 ! 0

'/*) A(/4 03 " 3 (9 "!4 3 "9

, A(/ 0! "

9 " 1 ! 3 !0

%(!

"31-!

,(/3!

13/

,- ! " "9

3 ! "1 -1:% /- /4 " % & 0! 2 ! 1 2 "! 3 1 03 " 3 0! -- 1 '

4 / 1;

%3 9,- ""313"1 / ,

)9*"1 "1

1 ,, /!4 ,/ ,/ 1 *: 3 (!

"% "3 !43 "2 % 1 1 >%5% / 2 ! 1 2 "! 3 9,- ""4 3 ! 0

-8 / A(/ "1 3 / 1(23 /! "1

, A(/ "1 ",/

A(/% (!

6&7 ,!!, /! " 3 "9

3;9

A(/ "1 /9"1

, ' "23403 "3 311 -/ 13 !1(23 /"1

,A(/! 3 ! 0

'/*) A(/% 3 " 31 * "

* /3

3 ! 1(23 /! 9 (" ,- /, / "4 24("1

2 !/ " !%55"1$=403 !" "<( /:

9 3 (" ,- /, / "4 / - 1 3 3 ! 1 2 !/ ""(9* /!, / "

1 * /3

' /, 2/0-4 / ! 1

3/9;

"1 -0 "1 / ' "234 / ! 1

24 / 8 -:% 3 " !

" 3 ! * 3 3 -1/ " 9 / "3 :

/$ ;

,!!, /!% 8 "2 3 /1 - 1 ' ("!

- "1 " 2 "2 3/ (23 3 9,(2"

1 )(129

<( -4 3 ! (/ "1! 3 1 !, 38 "2 B9 "

1 ! 9": ! 5 0 "

!4 3 " 3! - */ "2 3 2( -

3 - 1 / - (/ /9

-- 0 "2

(/ , "!

/9 " "# % ?3 /3 "3!,/ 133 !"

/,/ "4 !- 2-4 // "1,/ /C % ?3 /3 1!0 "1 -' "233!3

9,- "" *: ,/ ,/ "2

1 1 (9 "!

"1 "23 !!

""11(23 /*/ 1C &% ?3 / 3

1 * /3

3 ! 3 -1/ " ,(/, 8-(*- !

(/ :

/ 3 ,(/,

3 "2C % ?3 / 3 1 * "2 2 /"9 " !

/8"

99 1 9 !

"1( *: *(! "2 3 ! , ! " ! ,(*- !

/8" "1 ,(/3!

1 ,/ /: "1 ""

! !

/ -: ("

, (" /: / (/ ! "1

67 3! 99 1 "

,(" !3*- ("1 / '

&676 7

//(, " 4 $$ "1 / 3 " 3! ,/ 1 ! !

"1 !

"*- 1 (*C

/ , " %4 / 38 "2 B9 "

8 1 43 - 1/ - (/3 -133 "31

- !" " ! , / '

//(, " 4 !

! -("3 ,/ 2 "!3 "% 4 "3 *!

!(3 !" "4 3 8 /: ,/

1 "2! 31 *

" 3 -1 * " ?3 - /

/1 "2 ! "1 "2 ("1 / , " %4 0!

("1*:3 - 1/ - (/4319 1-:4- 2 " " / ,/ ! % %3 9,- "" "3 ! 1 "13 1 "3 /! 1 40!, "1 "2%0! (/3

("1 33 ?9/) ' "234 9,- ""431 - 1 1( -- ;

,!!, /6!7 "1 * /3 6!7 *

"8 ! 2 "2

?& A3(!30" ' "23 3 !

B9 " " "3

! 1 3 3 1 31 !

" 3 ! 3 -1/ " */ 1 / 38 "2 ,/ ,/ ;

,!!, /!4 *( 1(/ "2 3 ! / !! B9 " "4 3 ! 1 0 "

!! ! 1 3 3 31 3 /1 * ( 3 !9 9 3 "

23* (/!% 3(!4 3 ! 9 ":

3 ! 0 "

!! 0!

("1 3 /!: 8 1 %

? ") ' "234 31 */ (23 3 /

- "1 ! 1 3 ! , / 3 /

/14 " %5%4 (!

1 " 9 / !3

- - "2 0 3 3 ! 0

'/*) A(/% 3 : 31 2 8 " "

18 '3

- (3 /

6>7 2/1 "23 3"2

'/*) A(/!"1

,A(/ '"13(4 *: //: "2 ( ,(*-

" 3 0!,, /!D"1 "B,/ !!E"1F2/ @%3(!43 ! 9 ":

3 ! 0 "

!! 0!

("1 !(,, / "2 3 !

% ?" -A(9/4

!! !"4

"- !!, /

4 3"1 2/34 ,/ " /

/1 3 ,,- "!

,!!, /!

3;9

A(/ "1 /9"1

, '"13(% /4 0!

("13!, /B3 * !%"1%43 ,!!, /!31"

",,- 1*:3 "% ! / 2/1! 3 -- 2 "!

38 "2 ,(/3!

/: *: -- 2- 9 "!4 8/ (! 0 "

! % % ?> ;;/ ' "234 0/ 4 ?=-) "1 / ' "234 0/ 4 ?529 - ' "234 -< 0/ 4 / 1;

4 ?&/*/ ' "234 0/ "1 ?$3(, "1 /A(/4 0/ -< %4 / 1;

B9 "

1%--3 0 "

!31,/ 1( 13 / "( /

/1% 0!

("133 !

" !! - "* (3 /:4 03 3 3 1 31 , 1 *

3 ; 1 "1 3 /: 03 3 3 " 31 ,(/3!

11(/ "23 3 ;, 1%0!

("13 ?='

. !3-) ' "236"8 ! 2 "2

/731"

1 1* (3 ;,

" "03 31 !,/ !!

! 0! <( / 1 *: 3 9 *: -- 2- 9 "!% ' -- (/3 /4 3 ! 10 "

!!31"

! 1! 030!3 "

B, "1 (/

11(/ "23 3 ;, ?$' / ' "23 " 3 ! / !! B9 " " ! 1 3 3 1 31 ;

!%4=>4G

9 3 ! ,/9

6=7

"!/(

3 (!

"3 9 "3

(2(!4% ?5 8/ ' "234 " 3 ! / !! B9 " " / --: ! 1 3 " 31 * "

1 , /9 !!

9 3 ,/9 " ,(/3!

-"1% 3(!4 0!

("1 3 3 " 31 - 2( - " 3 ,/

1 *: - 1 "2 " "1 - "3 "2 8 1 3 3 (!

1 <( / 1 !,/ " !!

! *: -- 2- 9 "! 1(/ "23 !!

/8 %0! (/3

("133 "31

- " /

/1 3 3 " 31 1 !3 !-: "1( 9,- "" "1 9 -: 9 9* /! "1 9 *: ,/ ,/ "2

1 1 (9 "!

/ !

"1 "2 3 ! * 33 -1/ "*/ 10 33 1(23

9,- ""% ?

"1 3 3 ! 9 ":

0 "

! 1 1 "

18"

" " ": 9""

/ 2( - "3 ,/

"% '" ",/43 /9 / -!, !0 -!

,/ 3 " 31 - --

/: "1 ,/

1 (9 "!4 "!9(3 !4 ! 0 (-1 ,, / 93 9,(2"

1)(129 "4"

1 (9 "/:,/

11 (9 "!40!- 1*

/ - (/%' -- (/3 /43 0 "

/ "( (3 / !31 " /

/1 ,(/3!

-"1 1 ,/ /: *: 3 (!

"4 *( / 3 , /9 !!

" ;

9 3 ,/9 " "1 (/3 / / 38 "2 / !

- "% -- 3

!- 13 - 1/ - (/ /

/13 "1 "2

<( - *: B "1 "23 "*

1 (*%

657

"3 ! "2-:"1("

<( 8 --:40 1 "

"1": , " -- 2- : / "

/9 : " 3 9,(2"

1 )(129

<( -4!

! 0//" "

*:3 ! (/% "!

<( "-:43 ,,- "!

; "2- 8 ,, - !1 !9 !!

1%H 8 ,, - !1 - "

1% !

! " " $%&% 1! ?3 /', ; "2G

1# !G ?3

/*- # !G