High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/51585/2025allowed

Hawal Masih Alias Hewal Masih v. State Of Punjab

2025-09-25Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel6 pages

%&.$/ %(+ %&.$/ %(+ %&.$/ %(+ %&.$/ %(+"$2#$1*$, "$2#$1*$, "$2#$1*$, "$2#$1*$, 8

#$% #$% #$% #$%

! @3$# # %($, , :$,'

* #$%&'() @3$2%(.$(# + + + + ,$$(#+ ,$$(#+ ,$$(#+ ,$$(#+ 6-3" " 6-3" " 6-3" " 6-3" " - - - - ,3; 2 ( ) (8.:%/ #$&% %,#!$2$# # %($,3 ,3

) (.$," (4!", 8.. # % %(

'() *3 <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< - - - -83=-7 83=-7 83=-7 83=-7 " " " "

22 # %(

% $.8'*)$/## #%

)'#$>/$2# %(3$4 #,0 . ,$/#$.#%/

,,0%'#($/$ ,0/%,,$/# %( ( #!$$ .(%#$

2, 0$, ,

'$%&#!$ (2$# # %(3

,$$(# 2$# # %( !

*$$( & $. '(.$, "$/# %( A %& #!$ !

, # 0

, 5"', 5!

(! # 8 =&%,!%,#?""67&%,4, (#%& & ,$4'

#%#!$2$# # %($, (/ $*$ , (4 4 %3 A.

#$.39A3 8 8 ,$4 #$,$. &% %, #!$ %&&$(/$ 2'( !

$ '(.

.$, "$/# %( =78

%& #!$ ,/%# / ,'

'4 (. 0/!%#,%2 / "'*# (/$ $ /#8 =&%, !%,# ?"

" /#678"$/# % %(%&#!$!

, # 0 0 "

(! # 8 =&%,!%,#?"67 7

(. "$/# %( %& #!$ , %( /#8 # % /$ "# # %( %, (4

8 #, /# ',.

2',3

!$4, :

1$(%&#!$ (B'$# %( #!

##!$2$# # %($,

//'$. %& *$ (4 (:% ( 2$,# ( (4 #% " /# (:% : (4

$4$.,$/%:$,0%& 4, 1%&$,% (&,%1/% //'$.8( 1$ 08C'

.$$2 " (4!8 !$( !$

22,$!$(.$.

%(4 #! ! /% //'$.8 ( 1$ 08

) (.$," (4! (. (.$$2" (4!8%(39A3 3(#!$. / %',$%& C'

.$$2" (4!8 (%#!$,/% //'$.8( 1$ 08"

#( 1" (4!

(%1 ( ( #! / $D %( #!$ . / %',$ %& . "

#( 1 " (4!8 %#!$, /% //'$.8 1$ 08 , *!)%# " (4! (. ,(%%, $,$ (%1 ( #$.D &',#!$, %( #!$ . / %',$%&/% //'$.8( 1$ 08 ,(%%,8#!$2$# # %($,

(%1 ( #$. ( #! / ,,$#$.%( A39A3 3 -$ ,($./%'($ &%,#!$2$# # %($,!

#$, #$.#!

##!$2$# # %($, (/'#%.0 (/$ A39A3 3-$ ,($./%'($ !

&',#!$,'*1 ##$.#!

#!$1 (.

#%,02,%: %(%&#!$"/#!

:$(%#*$$(/%12 $. #!8

(.#!'8#!$2,%$/'# %(/ $'&&$,&,%1 (!$,$(#.$&$/#3-$ ,($./%'($ &',#!$, #$, #$.#!

#% $* #% 0#!$2$# # %($, //'$. #!$ . / #$1$(# %& /% //'$.8 ( 1$ 0 ,(%%,3 -$ ,($. /%'($ !

&',#!$, #$, #$.#!

##!$2$# # %($,!

'&&$,$. (/ ,/$, # %(&%,1%,$#!

(9A 1%(#!3!'8,$4'

2, 0$.&%,3 A3 -$ ,($. "# #$ /%'($ !

%22%$. #!$ 2,$$(# 2$# # %( *0

,4' (4#!

##!$

$4 # %(, $. (##!$2$# # %($, ,$$, %' (( #',$

(.8#!'8!$.%$(%#.$$,:$#!$/%(/$ %(%&#!$,$4'

3!$"# #$

/%'($ $$5#%2

/$%(,$/%,./'#%.0/$,# & / #$.

A39 (#!$ %',##%.

08 ! /! # 5$(%(,$/%,.3 3

:$!$ ,./%'($ &%,#!$, :

2 ,# $ (.!

:$4%($#!,%'4! :

$,$/%,.%&#!$/ E3 !$2$# # %($,

,,$#$.%( A39A3 (. (/%(# ('%' /'#%.0 (/$#!$(3!$/'

1 ( # %(%& (:$# 4 # %( (.#!$#,

$1 # (4 #!$,$&,%18 (/ $8%// %(% , $8

# 5$ %(4# 1$3!$2$# # %($,!

*$$( 12 //'$. (#!$ (B'$# %(% 0%(#!$* %& . / #$1$(# %& ,(%%,3 2$, 2,%$/'# %( :$, %(8 #!$,$ (% %#!$,1 #$,

$#%/%(($/##!$2$# # %($, #!#!$/%(#, (.$>/$2# &%,#!$ .. / %',$# #$1$(#3 # 2$,# ($(##%(%#$#!

#'/!. / %',$ # #$1$(#8 (#!$ *$(/$%&/%,,%*%, # :$$: .$(/$!% . 1 #$.$: .$(# ,0 :

'$ (./ ((%#*$% $* &%, 12 # (4#!$2$# # %($,3!$,$

(/$%( #! '('*# (# #$.# #$1$(#, $$, %'.%'*# *%'##!$& ,($ %*)$/# : #0%&#!$ (:$# 4 # %(3 # (%# (. 2'#$#!

##!$2$# # %($,

(%# 2,$$(# ##!$2%#3!$:$, / #0 $ 4!# 4$,$B' ,$.#%*$ ## /!$.#%#!$ . / %',$# #$1$(#1 .$*0#!$/% //'$.

*$&'

0#$#$. ##!$# 1$ %& #,

3 !$ , :

/%(#$(# %( , $. # , 4 :$ , $ #% .$* # $ '$8

! /!!

*$, # %/ ( #$.'2%(.', (4#!$/%',$%&#,

3! %',#.%$ (%# .$$1 # 22,%2, #$ #% .$ :$ .$$2 (#% #!$$ , :

/%(#$(# %(8 # #! # 4$8 $# # 1 0 2,$)'. /$ #!$ #,

3 %#! (4 # (4 * $ !

*$$( *,%'4!# &%,

,. #% (. / #$ #!$ 5$ !%%. %& #!$ 2$# # %($, */%(. (4 &,%1 #!$ 2,%/$%&)'# /$%, (#$,&$, (4 #!#!$2,%$/'# %($: .$(/$3

E33 # #! )'(/#',$8 # %'

. *$ 22% #$ #% ,$&$, #% )'.41$(# $.*0#! %',# ( (!'

:$,'"# #$%&'() (!'

:$,'"# #$%&'() *82 $. ( E9 E9 E9 E9 A

A = + +99A 78 !$,$ (8 &#$, ,$ 0 (4 '2%( #!$, # %.$/ .$(. %&#!$)'.41$(#%&#!$%(6* $"'2,$1$%',# (%& " (4! :$,' "# #$ %& .'8 9 "'2,$1$ %',#

D "1#3 )1'( !

8 *.'

1 . !

(.1 0 F - .%% 2' :$,' "# #$ %& '), #8 ,/%# / %(#,% ',$ '8 A "

9D "# #$ *0 =7 $(4

',' :3

* . !1 . , 1'## G (,368

=7 =, 1 (

7HE D (.; ) 0" (4!:3!$"# #$%& ,0 8*$ , (4"2$/

-$ :$#%22$

=, 37%3=7 EEI 8.$/ .$.%(H393 8!

!$ . #!'+ JE3

$# !$. 2, (/ 2 $ %&

/%(&$ %( .$*0 /% //'$.'(.$,"$/# %(EH%&#!$"/# (!$,$(# 0 :$,0 52 $/$%&$: .$(/$3"'/!# #$1$(#=78*0#!$1$ :$8/ ((%# &%,1 #!$ % $ * &%, #!$ /%(: /# %( %& ( (. : .'

(. 1'# *$ /,'# ( K$. #! '#1%# / '# %( ( /%()'(/# %( #! %#!$, '*# (# :$ $: .$(/$3%,$%:$,8(%,$/%:$,0!

*$$($&&$/#$.&,%1#!$2%$ %(%& #!$2$# # %($,8 !%!

*$$('*$B'$(# 0 12 //'$.% 0 %( #!$ * %& . / #$1$(# %& #!$ /% //'$.3 % $:$,8 ,$4'

2$,# (#% &$ *$,#0%& (. : .'

8%',# ,$%* #%#, 5$ *

(/$*$# $$( &$4'

,. (42$,%(

*$,#0 (.$(', (4#!$ $&&$/# :$ .1 ( #, # %( %& )'# /$

% (:$# 4 # %(3 !$ & (

$: .$(# ,0:

'$ .1 * #0%&#!$. / %',$# #$1$(#1 .$*0 /% //'$. &

#! ( #!$ .%1 ( %& #!$ #,

%',# ,$ #% *$

.)'. / #$..', (4#!$/%',$%&#!$#,

( //%,.

(/$ #!$# !$. 2, (/ 2 $%&

3% $:$,8 .)'. / # (4 2 &%,,$4'

8#! %',# / ((%# ,$1 ( %* : %' #% #!$ / ,/'1# (/$ '(.$, ! /! #!$ 2$# # %($, !

*$$( 4($. %, 12 #$.8 (/ '. (4 #!$ ( #',$ %& #!$

$4 # %(8#!$$: .$(/$ (5 (4#!$2$# # %($,#%#!$%&&$(/$

#!$ 2$/ & /,% ##, *'#$.#%#!$2$# # %($, (#!$/%11 %(%&#!$

$4$. %&&$(/$32, 1 & / $$> 1 ( # %(%&#!$$& /#%, $$(#

#%$(',$ #!

##!$2,%/$%&

(%#1 '$.8 *'$.%,1 . ,$/#$.3L E3 2$,/'#%.0/$,# & / #$.

A39 & $.*0#!$ ,($. #$/%'($ 8#!$2$# # %($,!

,$ .0'&&$,$. (/ ,/$, # %(&%, 2$, %. %& 9A 1%(#! (. 9 .

08 G (%# !% ( #% *$ (:% (0 %#!$, =73

"'&& /$ #% 08 &',#!$, .$#$(# %( %& #!$ 2$# # %($, '(.$,#,

(%#

(#$. (#!$& /# (./ ,/'1# (/$%&#!$/ H3

(: $ %& *%:$8#!$2,$$(#2$# # %(

% $.3$# # %($, %,.$,$.#%*$,$ $.%(,$4'

%(! &',( ! (4*

I',$#0*%(.#% # & /# %(%&#!$-.3/%(/$,($.#,

%',#I'#0 4 #, #$3% $:$,8 .. # %( #% /%(. # %( #!

# 1 0 *$ 12%$. *0 #!$ /%(/$,($. #,

%',#I'#0 4 #, #$8#!$2$# # %($,!

,$1 (*%'(.*0#!$&%

% (4 /%(. # %(+ = 7 !$2$# # %($,!

(%#1 '$#!$ *$,#04, (#$.3 = 7 !$2$# # %($,!

(%## 12$, #! (0$: .$(/$8%,

%, .%/'1$(# ,08.', (4#!$#,

3 = 7 !$2$# # %($,!

(%# *$(#! 1$ &%( (0.

#$*$&%,$ #!$#,

3 = :7 !$ 2$# # %($, !

(%# /%11 # (0 %&&$(/$ $ %(

3 =:7 !$2$# # %($,!

.$2% #! 2 2%,#8 & (08 #!#!$ #,

%',#3 =: 7 !$ 2$# # %($, !

4 :$ ! /$

2!%($ ('1*$, #% #!$

(:$# 4 # (4 && /$,I" %& /%(/$,($. % /$ "# # %(

(.!

(%#/!

(4$! /$

2!%($('1*$, #!%'#2, %, 2$,1 %(%&#!$#,

%',#I

4 #, #$3 =: 7 !$ 2$# # %($, !

(%# ( (0 1 (($, #,0 #% .$

0 #!$ #,

3 =: 7 !$2$# # %($,!

'*1 #8%(#!$& ,# %,5 (4.

0%& $:$,0 1%(#!8 && .

: #8 *$&%,$ #!$ /%(/$,($. #,

%',#8 #% #!$ $&&$/# #!

# !$ !

(%# *$$( (:% /%11 %(%& (0%&&$(/$ &#$,*$ (4,$ $.%(*

( / $ #!$ 2$# # %($, &%'(. #% *$ (:% (0 %&&$(/$ &#$, ! *$ (4 $(

,4$. %( *

( #!$ 2,$$(# 8%(#!$* %&! && .

: #%,%#!$, $8#!$"# #$

#$.#%1%:$8&%,#!

#!8&%,/ (/$

# %(%&! *

! /! 2 8 *'# %& /%',$8 !

*$ , # %/ ( #$. '2%( 1$, ##!$,$%&3 3

(/ $%&*,$ /!%& (0%&#!$ &%,$ ./%(. # %( (.#!%$

! /!1 0*$ 12%$.*0/%(/$,($.#,

%',#I'#0 4 #, #$ . ,$/#$. !$,$ ( *%:$ %, '2%( !% (4

(0 %#!$, '&& / $(# '$8 #$I/%12

(# !

*$ *$,#0 #% 1%:$ / (/$

# %( %& *

%& #!$ 2$# # %($,3

3 ,.$,$. //%,. (4 03 93 %#! (4 .!$,$ ( *%:$!

*$/%(#,'$. ($>2,$ %(%& %2 ( %(%(#!$1$, #%&#!$/ 3 " (/$#!$1 (/ $!

*$$(.$/ .$.82$(. (41 /$

($%'

# %(8 & (08!

%# (.. 2%$.%&&3 ="- "- "- "-7 "$2#$1*$, "$2#$1*$, "$2#$1*$, "$2#$1*$, 8

: , M!$#!$,2$ 5 (4I,$ %($.+ $I% M!$#!$,,$2%,# $+ $I%