← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/56/2019dismissed

Pr Commissioner Of Income Tax (Central), Gurgaon v. M/S Dhg Marketing Pvt.Ltd

2023-05-15Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra3 pages

  

   

   

!"#$#%&'&()* + ,,&''&(#+(%,#!-

#("+!. / 0+1!( 233#..!("

4' 5' !+6#"&(17"8"$ 2 #'3($#("

     

     +#'#(") '+&$9&!':&($#+;!($90/;#(&+;"!($&(1 0('#./ +"9#!33#..!(" +6'9!<9!(/;#(&+$7%!"#/ :&"9+;9!("(0!('!./$7%!"#/ +"9#+#'3($#(" ====

&"0!9+&/ +!.

9#&('"!("!33#!.0($#+;#%"&("9#(%,#!-%"/  /9!'>##(&.#$!1!&('""9#+$#+$!"#$ ? ((#-0+#* 3!''#$><"9#(%,#!-33#..!"#+&>0(!./ 9!($&1!+9/:9#+#><!33#!.

&.#$  ><  "9#  +#7#(0#+#'3($#("  !1!&('"  "9#  +$#+  $!"#$  **@

((#-0+# 3!''#$><"9# ,,&''&(#+(%,#!- 33#!.' */ 0+1!(/9!'>##($&',&''#$

(A/!'#!+%9:!'%($0%"#$!""9#3+#,&'#'"9# +#'3($#("!''#''##""9!""&,#!''#'',#("3#+"!&(&(1""9#<#!+ :!'("3#($&(1 0+&(1"9#%0+'#'#!+%9/(&(%+&,&(!"&(1 ,!"#+&!.:!'0($9#+#!"#+/("&%#0($#+;#%"&(*"9#%":!' &''0#$""9#!''#''##/&(+#'3('#":9&%9/"9#!''#''##&.#$&"'+#"0+( &(%,#$#%.!+&(1B&.C&(%,#8!"#+(/("&%#'0($#+;#%"&(A*  !($ A  !.(1:&"9D0#'"&((!&+#:#+#&''0#$/:9&%9:#+#$0.<+#3.&#$><

 "9#  !''#''##  "#+  %('&$#+&(1  "9#  +#3.&#'  &.#$  ><  "9#  !''#''##/  "9# ''#''&(1 &%#+,!$#!$$&"&(!,0("&(1" 'A%++#'/0($#+;#%"&( ?"9#%"(!%%0("0(#-3.!&(#$%+#$&"'+#.!"&(1"'9!+#%!3&"!. +#%#&7#$  ><  "9#  !''#''##  $0+&(1  "9#  +#.#7!("  3#+&$  (  !33#!./  "9#

,,&''&(#+(%,#!- 33#!.' $#.#"#$"9#'!&$!$$&"&(,!$#>< "9#''#''&(1 &%#+ 11+&#7#$><"9#'!&$+$#+/"9#+#7#(0#&.#$!( !33#!.>#+#"9#+&>0(!. 9#+&>0(!./ !"#+ 9#!+&(1 .#!+(#$%0('#. +"9#3!+"&#'/ $&',&''#$"9#!33#!.&.#$><"9#+#7#(0#><+##++&(1""9#E0$1,#("$!"#$ ??3!''#$><"9#&19 0+"#.9&&( 

 !"# $% & '

 *? @* #.9& ":!'9#.$ "9!"(!$$&"&(%0.$>#,!$#&('0%9%&+%0,'"!(%#' ("9#+D0#'"&(+%('&$#+!"&(>#+#"9#+&>0(!.:!'/ :9#"9#+&("9#!>'#(%#!(<&(%+&,&(!"&(1,!"#+&!.0($$0+&(1"9# '#!+%9/!$$&"&(0($#+;#%"&(*"9#%"%0.$>#,!$#&(%!'# %,3.#"#$!''#'',#(" ("9#3+#'#("%!'#/("&%#,"&(:!'&''0#$(A '&,&.!+&''0#:!'3#($&(1%('&$#+!"&(>#+#"9#(C>.#;03+#,#

0+"  &(  &7&. 33#!.  ?      

!"#  $%% && $'

 $(

 $%'")*'+ "# ,&-.

&"

 / #01##+0 ("9!"%!'#/"9# (C>.#;03+#,# 0+"9!'039#.$"9#7&#:'"!6#(&(# $% & '

(%!'#

'03+!  !($ )*        

!+  ,  - %.

%  *?@  0E!+!" !($9#.$"9!"(!$$&"&(%!( >#  ,!$#  &(  "9#  %!'#    %,3.#"#$  !''#'',#("  &(  "9#  !>'#(%#    !(< &(%+&,&(!"&(1,!"#+&!."9!'>##(0+"9#+>'#+7#$!'0($#+) F* --- --- ---

*

&7 &(%!'#(&(%+&,&(!"&(1,!"#+&!.&'0(#!+"9#$$0+&(1"9#'#!+%9/ "9#  %!(("!''#'' ++#!''#'' "!6&(1&("%('&$#+!"&("9#"9#+ ,!"#+&!.  &(  +#'3#%"    %,3.#"#$  !''#'',#("'50(!>!"#$  !''#'',#("' #!(&(1  "9#+#></  &(  +#'3#%"    %,3.#"#$50(!>!"#$  !''#'',#("'/  ( !$$&"&(%!(>#,!$#><"9# &(!>'#(%#!(<&(%+&,&(!"&(1,!"#+&!.

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

0+"&($& /% 0' )10(%!'# '03+! /(1+0($&',!$#0"" &("#+#+#&("9#&,301(#$E0$1,#("5+$#+/!'"9#'!,#9!'>##(3!''#$>< !33+#%&!"&(1"9#!%"'&("9#+&19"3#+'3#%"&7#'0>'"!("&!.D0#'"&( .!:!+&'#'+%('&$#+!"&(

#'0."!(".</&($&(1(,#+&"'/3+#'#("!33#!.&'$&',&''#$ 

      ;     * !E3 

   )#'5   )#'5