High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/29435/2024disposed of

Union Of India And Others v. Surinder Singh

2024-10-28Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma10 pages

!" #$%$!&'(

!"!" "# $

%

)' *+ ) , , ,- *+ ), , , ,) $# !'( )$ '

"

*

&

+ ) ,

&"#

$,-

.

//// ,- ./ +0 . #

1 &

&

& '

#

2.33.4$ 5.6 & !'

* $7 8- 0! *-- 1

!'

1 #

!

#

-7& #

!* ' ,5 5, !* '& #1 2 #345!1&6 3 % .1 **

$7'3.3.9 1 - # 7 ,- 1 ..3 : - # 7

,-

1 #

**1# !* '!

*#1

!!! "

# $

* $

0! *--

# !

! ! #+# !* '

7 ; ; 1 ...3 * 0

&&*- 1 **1 ,

2.33.4$ 5.6

& , &

!"

##$%&'( &) &)*

( (

'

"

!" &

+ &,

% ( . %&'( &)*

/

*# ## 7

&

5 *

#

1 &

,178$%%$!&%!"9 2 5& 6#!1&% 2"!59 : $$!& 5% $

* - *

&

5

46, <#7 !'

=>!* $&

1

!'

=

!7

, 1

& * * 17

* 0! *-- * -

#

'

2 **'

- : !

7 & # & 2

, !'

=>!* $& -

% &''(

")& * + ,-).

( " "

" !/

0!

!1 2 3 , *

- .30

& # & 2 !

-7

0 ( , 1 (

% ( * % (

& ,0 ( *$'

(

( 2 ,

(

, 3 ( ( ( ( ( 1( 4( '

'

,

, ,

)

((

5 '

( )'

4( ,,

(

(

6

7( ,

( 6 (

, & 7( 89(

7(

( 7(

0 8 9(

1(

( ,

,

( ,

( ( / $ #& # &

, 4& 6-* *'

-

-

- '-* 7 !'

,- * '

* -

* 7

*' #

&&

,

!* #

:

7'& ! #*' & '7 5 & ' &

!'

* '

-* 7

!

-7# #

1 ' <

: !

**1 ! 1

& !

# -

& &

'

&

*#

1 &

- & # & 2

$&

-*

=# 1 <

& -, # & .2'

1

9

, 1 * &&

-- &

<#7 # % &''( 4

4)& * + ,- ) % .( ""

. !,

% 2/

0!

!

1 5! !! "

4 0

, & # & 1

.

(

(

( 0 ,

(, 3 ( (

0'

!

! '

! + +! 6

+!* ! '

! + 089( '

( ,(

( ,

( (

89(

(

( (( + %* '

!7!

* ! '

'

2 3

,'

:

89( ( (

0

(

,178$%%$!&%!"9 2 5& 6#!1&% 2"!59 5 %:!&6 & .

* - *

!7

<#7 &&*- !*

-

7 7!

- -7!

!* 1 * ' &

!* '&

17

&&

-

# 7 ?##46

1**' * < !* - & .. && #7

&* - * -

# @ - <#7 & !'

=>!* $&

393.2 - ;$&6 5,$&49<% &$!&!"&6$ &6

9 5% 1 - $;$2::

2!=!" = # 0

, & # &

,

0 ( $

& 5 0 ( + 4 9 $&; .

(..

00 (

,

(1 1( (

, 0 (

( '''' ''''

2

0 ( '

0 ( < =:

(

(

..

"

(1 1( ( ,

2 (

,

..

>.

; / &" 5 &# %!"9$% !15 .3 #

,!*'- ' * '

7 !'

## 1

!' - ** # - -*# & !'

--

&

# * '

7 ! 7 ?

7 !

!'

,- * ' * -

=1

4

&

!, &-&*

# , - !'

$& - /

0!

!1 23 * )+' . - ,

% 2/

0!

!

1 )+' .5

'

- & *-- -7#

5 & ,5 5, 7 ! 1

!

-

*' &

'

7

*#

&

. @

7 '

&

&

& # & --

, 4& 6 !'

$&

- !* #

-7

##

&

, !* #

##

1* * -# - - - ,5 5,

## % * *'

!'

* '

# -* 7

1*

! *7

!' '&&

,- * ' * -

1* , *'- 7!*#!*-? #

# #

** *

## . 8

7#1

- - 1 - -- ,5 5,

&

1 -# - - - !

7#1

, '- &

!* #

,

&

!'

' !

7

- 7

, - - --

&

&

7 ?# , !'

=>!* $& - * &$!&!"&6$ <% 8;

5>

" &

,

&2$& >= - ..33. 1

-* 7

#

!

-7 1

-- 0

,

& # & --

, 4& 6

4 % * 7( ,(

( ( ( ( (

( , ()

0 % * (

9 ( ; %*6.>6?%#)9*

( @ ? A,

!

& 5

# , ( ,

& 5 # ,

2 , (

2 (1(%

% * ()

>0

3 89(

0 (

.

-

!* #

- 7 ,

&

&

7 ?#

, !'

$&

- * &$!&!"&6$ <% 8;

5/%1:5 0

:

-* * 17

, 4& 6 1

, #

-7 1 ,5 5,

--

!

% * *'

17

#

,5 5,

--

!

-7

-

7

7# 1

&7& : *

&

-* 7 7

1

.2 "-

, 4& 6 !

- 7 &- ..33.

7

,

7 !

0! *--

'

3.0 #

7

, 4& 6 &7& 7 & -

! 7 *'

* ' !

A '

?# &* - =1 1

17 7

,5 5,

&

! **'- !* #

: 7 0

1

!* #

,

&

# , 4& 6!

--7 *' * - - -# - :

& % * *' *

!* #

- 7 ,

&

?#:

&&

#!

#7 , .

1 -

-* * 1 7 4& 67 ?

-* !

& * * 1

!'

& * * 1 7 ,

4& 6 *7 ?

- !

,5 5,

- & * --

*

--

' 7

?

# #

17 7

** -7&*

&

& ,

! * ' * -

$& 2 56 5!"9$% !15 .

7

7

1 &

1

! ,

7 7 0

7&# 7 7 .9 "-

7 - * !

-

**

& # &&*- 46 '

* 46& /, ,- 0 /, ,)0 (

? ,

#

9 9 5%:

3$&4?5 %!& 6 '

%?!

9 9 55 :!5 '

%?!