← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/181/2019dismissed

Baljinder Kaur And ORS v. Kulwant Kaur And ORS

2021-04-30Mr. Justice Manoj Bajaj5 pages

  

        

       

   

  

  

   

   

   !



! 



  

! !   

  "#  $%%#&&$'()*%&$+'(+,,)-  "$.#  ,+&#/  ("+)  #01&$2  #34'/ %%#$&(43"$&&#'0#("#51/06#'($'//#32##/$(#/7 8 9%$))#/+'

+.+&%%#$&4 84,  7:;("#,+2)($%%#&&$(# 412(<"#2#:;("# 51/06#'(  $'/  /#32##  /$(#/  =  7  %$))#/  :;  +.+&  1/0#  *1'+42 +.+)+4'- "$2$2+' +.+&1+(4

=89>  >8 ?

/+)6+))+'0 ("#+2)1+(,42)#%$2$(#%4))#))+4':;<$;4,%$2(+(+4'$&4'0<+("%#26$'#'( +'51'3(+4'<$)1%"#&/

2+#,&;("#,$3()4,("#3$)#$2#("$(("#%&$+'(+,,):2410"($)1+( ,42%$2(+(+4'$'/%#26$'#'(+'51'3(+4'4'("#0241'/("$(("#%24%#2(+#)+' /+)%1(#<#2#4<'#/:;!$'0$&+'0")4'4,+2$+'0"02$'/,$("#24,("# %&$+'(+,,)$'//#,#'/$'()4 (4=$'/,$("#2+'&$<4,/#,#'/$'(4 

,(#2"+)/#$("("#%24%#2(;+'@1#)(+4'/#.4&.#/1%4'"+),412)4') 2+($6+'0"*,$("#24,%&$+'(+,,)- "$2$'+'0"*"1):$'/4,/#,#'/$'( 4   $'/  ,$("#2  4,  /#,#'/$'()  4   (4  =-  $2$'5$'  +'0"  *,$("#2  4, /#,#'/$'()4 A$'/7-$'/ $'+'0":;<$;4,'$(12$&)133#))+4'+'

 #@1$& )"$2#)+ # >=(" )"$2##$3"

 "#)"$2#4, $'  +'0" <$) $&)4 +'"#2+(#/  :;  %&$+'(+,,  4 =  4'  ("#  :$)+)  4,  $  2#0+)(#2#/  +&&  /$(#/   ??8 3342/+'0(4("#%&$+'(+,,)$)("#)1+(%24%#2(;"$)'4(:##' %$2(+(+4'#/("#2#,42#("#;$2#1'$:&#(41(+&+B#+((4+()%4(#'(+$&$'/("# 2#@1#)(6$/#:;("#%&$+'(+,,)(4("#/#,#'/$'(),42%$2(+(+4'4,("#)1+( %24%#2(+#)<$)2#,1)#/<"4,12("#2("2#$(#'#/(4$&+#'$(#("#%24%#2(+#)

2#.+41)&;2+($6+'0"$'/%&$+'(+,,4 ="$/,+&#/$)1+(,42%$2(+(+4':1( /12+'0("#%#'/#'3;4,("#)1+(2+($6+'0""$/#C%+2#/4'  8 $'/$,(#2"+)/#$(" "$2$'+'0"346%246+)#/("#6$((#2<+("("#%&$+'(+,,) $'/$02##/(4%$2(+(+4'("#&$'/ $(#24' "$2$'+'0"$&)4#C%+2#/4'

  9$'/$)$2#)1&(4,("$(("#)1+(<$)/+)6+))#/+'/#,$1&(4'  ?

9 (<$)%2$;#/("$(("#)1+(:#/#32##/

"#)1+(<$)34'(#)(#/:;/#,#'/$'()4 $'/:;,+&+'0 )#%$2$(#<2+((#')($(#6#'():;2$+)+'0,#<%2#&+6+'$2;4:5#3(+4')2#0$2/+'0 

$'/6$+'($+'$:+&+(;4,("#)1+(+'.+#<4,("#:$234'($+'#/+'

2/#2 1&#  $'/("410"4'6#2+()("#2#&$(+4')"+%:#(<##'("# %$2(+#)<$)$/6+((#/:1(+(<$)%&#$/#/("$(("#%$2(+(+4'2#0$2/+'0)"$2#4, ("#%$2(+#)(4("#)1+(<$)/#3+/#/&4'0:$3D$'/#$3"%$2(;+)+')#%$2$(# %4))#))+4'4,("#+22#)%#3(+.#)"$2# (<$)%2$;#/("$(("#)1+(:#/+)6+))#/

"#%&$+'(+,,),+&#/2#%&+3$(+4'(434'(24.#2(("#/#,#'3#)#(1% :;("#/#,#'/$'()$'/$,(#234')+/#2+'0("#%&#$/+'0)("#(2+$& 412(+'$&& ,2$6#/)+C+))1#) "#2#$,(#2("#%$2(+#)&#/("#+22#)%#3(+.##.+/#'3#$'/ $,(#234')+/#2+'0("#)$6#("#(2+$& 412(.+/#51/0#6#'($'//#32##/$(#/ =  7/+)6+))#/("#)1+(  002+#.#/$0$+')(("#51/0#6#'($'//#32##/$(#/=  7

 ("#$%%#&&$'()%2#,#22#/,+2)($%%#$&:#,42#("#//& +)(2+3(1/0# $0$2!4"$&+$'/("#$%%#&&$(# 412($&)4/#3+/#/("#$%%#$&$0$+')(("# $%%#&&$'()("2410"("#+6%10'#/51/0#6#'($'//#32##/$(#/7 9 "# )$+//#32##+)1'/#23"$&&#'0#+'("#%2#)#'(2#01&$2)#34'/$%%#$&

 #$2'#/341')#&,42("#$%%#&&$'()"$)$201#/("$()+'3#("# %$2(+#)  $2#  /#)3#'/$'()  4,  !$'0$&  +'0"  $'/  $,(#2  "+)  /#$("  ("#  )1+( %24%#2(;&#,(:#"+'/:;"+6+)"#&/:;("#654+'(&;$'/$)("#2+0"()4,("# $%%#&&$'()$2#'4( /+)%1(#/("#2#,42#("#)1+(%24%#2(;/#)#2.#) (4:# %$2(+(+4'#/ #$2'#/341')#&"$),12("#2$201#/("$( 412():#&4<"$.# %243##/#/(4$/51/+3$(#("#+))1#)2$+)#/:;("#$%%#&&$'()4'("#:$)+)4, ("#42$&#.+/#'3#$'/'4&43$&3466+))+4'#2<$)$%%4+'(#/:;("# 412((4 +')%#3(  ("#  %24%#2(;  +'  @1#)(+4'

 #$2'#/  341')#&  )1:6+((#/  ("$(  ("# /#%4)+(+4'4, $25$'(+'0"<"4+)'#+0":4124,("#%$2(+#)"$) :##'+0'42#/<"+&#/+)6+))+'0("#3&$+64,("#$%%#&&$'()("#2#,42#("# +6%10'#/51/06#'($'//#32##%$))#/:;("#(2+$& 412(+)'4(:$)#/1%4'

3422#3($%%2#3+$(+4'4,#.+/#'3# 3342/+'0(4"+6("#$%%#&&$(# 412("$) $&)4  ,$+&#/ (4  $%%2#3+$(# ("#  6$(#2+$&  #.+/#'3# 4' 2#342/  $'/  <24'0&; %243##/#/(41%"4&/("#51/06#'($'//#32##%$))#/:;("#(2+$& 412( # )1:6+()("$(("#+6%10'#/51/06#'($'//#32##/$(#/7 9%$))#/:;

("#//& +)(2+3(1/0#$0$2!4"$&+<$22$'()+'(#2,#2#'3#("2410" ("+) #01&$2#34'/%%#$&

,(#2"#$2+'0&#$2'#/341')#&,42("#%$2(+#)("+) 412(,+'/) ("$(("#%$2(+#)$2#3&4)#&;2#&$(#/:#+'0/#)3#'/$'()4,!$'0$&+'0"$'/ ("#2#  +)  '4  34',&+3(  :#(<##'  ("#  %$2(+#)  2#0$2/+'0  ("#+2  2+0"()  +'  ("# %24%#2(+#)+'@1#)(+4'

3$2#,1&%#21)$&4,("#51/06#'(%$))#/:;("# +.+&

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

"#$2016#'(4,&#$2'#/341')#&("$('4&43$&3466+))+4'#2 <$)$%%4+'(#/:;("#(2+$& 412(<"#'("#)1+(<$)%#'/+'0+)<+("41($'; 6#2+( $)("#4'1)(4 %24.#("#3&$+62$+)#/ +'("#)1+( <$) 1%4' ("# %&$+'(+,,)<"4'4(4'&;,$+&#/(4&#$/$';#.+/#'3#4'("+)6$(#2+$&+))1# :1(  $/6+((#/  ("#  /#,#'3#  4,  ("#  /#,#'/$'()   .#'  4("#2<+)#  ("# $%%4+'(6#'(4,&43$&3466+))+4'#23$''4(:#6$/#(434&&#3(("##.+/#'3# ,42$%$2(;

"#4("#2$2016#'(4,("#&#$2'#/341')#&("$(("##.+/#'3#4,  <$)'4(3$2#,1&&;34')+/#2#/:;("# 412():#&4<<"+&#/+)6+))+'0 ("#)1+(4,("#%&$+'(+,,)+)$&)4<+("41()1:)($'3#$)("#%&$+'(+,,)+ #   $'/ ="$.#("#6)#&.#)$/6+((#/("#/#,#'3#4,("#/#,#'/$'()2#&$(+'0 (4%2#.+41)%$2(+(+4'4,("#%24%#2(;$64'0)(("#)"$2#"4&/#2) "1)("+)

412("$)'4"#)+($(+4'+'"4&/+'0("$(("#,+'/+'0)2#(12'#/:;("#(2+$&

412(4'6$(#2+$&+))1#)$'/,12("#21%"#&/:;("#$%%#&&$(# 412($2# :$)#/1%4'%24%#2$%%2#3+$(+4'4,#.+/#'3#$'/6$(#2+$&4'2#342/

"#2#01&$2)#34'/$%%#$&/4#)'4(+'.4&.#$';)1:)($'(+$&

A @1#)(+4'4,&$<$'/34')#@1#'(&;/4#)'4(<$22$'(+'(#2,#2#'3#

+)6+))#/

#'/+'0  !+)3  $%%&+3$(+4'*)-  +,  $';  $2#  $&)4  /+)6+))#/  $) +',213(141)

%2+&  $'+($> 1&$(+   "#("#2 #%42($:&#  #)>4 "#("#2%#$D+'0> #$)4'#/  #)>4