← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25797/2023dismissed

Sahab Singh v. State Of Haryana And Others

2023-11-17Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl16 pages



     

 

 



  

 





 





#$"

  !" #$ %&$ " 

 % & '



( )"* (

+  # ,- .

, /( )"* 



$ 

+ -%

+

(

).(

 

%&$ "'# "



$ -"

,"

) - 23

, 4"



, 

 ,  



5, 

/$, "

"

  

6)7, 8

, 

--

  9 

6)7, 8( *" 1

5, 

 $  :, (

!

/ " 

, 

 , / /,

" 

$" '

 %

!

,



35, -- $"!



, :4# '   

6)7, 8( ,"



* 

,$ )(

 "

-   - 



;, ,( )/ (

 



;

  (

/   /

/ / "

$

",/

7"

1 $(

$

$"

, 4$

-   "(

<, ,%

/$-  -"

!

 <,-"$  (  , &

 (

" # (

  <, ,%

( 

%

<  #"

-( ;

# "(  +

%



/ (

 

$

4

-  

!

 -!



/$- !

-- 3/

/

!



/$-

# ( 3



 ! * / $

-

1 

--1"

, - 4 ,

/$-  

,$( /$-

#9( 3

$

   

$

,

"/ ""



/, #2( 3 1 /$-

$-"

 -!

#9( 3

/$-

 ""

*"3 ,"  /- $

" = 

--

( :4# '

  

 "

 $  ,$ "

-( <, ,%

( *" "

  

6)7, 8 ,$""

$



5, 1  ,"

$,!

,$ " -( ?

"1 (

  <, ,%

" "

 ", / !

-"

!"

7$",-! $, ,  /( 5, 



( $

/ "

, 

--

 6)7, -*-"

 /

$

- "

-( *" "

  

6)7,



98( "

!

)""  @,"

( <, ,%



,

,

,/( ,   

:4#  "(

$ ,"

 

 

,/"

1

$

( , (

 7 /" 4 $

$ /$- 7 /"



,$$

/3$ ,

-, / 

7"

1

$ 4 %

,"

$

-"



?

"

,- 

$

,/"

1 // 1 ( /$- <,-"$ 

4$

,/( 1 4*



=

 4 ,

,/"

/$-  ,$$ ,

,/( 1 *



 (  7 /"

-- / 7 /"

/ &," $ ( /,

(

" $

"-"

1

7 /"3 7 /" ,$$

,/( -

"

,-



$

-"

,$

-"

B   

      (



 !

,$

 - ;

 "#!$$%#&'&

-"

  (   ) *+   ( , &-'%&'& 4

!"



,/( *





 7 /"

-- / 7 /"





9

>

-

"

,- 

$

$ ,"

$ %

" $ / -

" * "/"



 1 " -"

  



; "

 (

-*



  

.,   /1

-"

,$ !

-

"

,- 

$ 

*

, 

/ (

$ "-!

-"

 

" 

"



!

"( 1

$ , "(

1

*-* /$- 5,





$   

.,  

$ ","

-1

B



      

 

   

      

    

          

  

   



              

       

   

    

      

    



  

  



!      

  

      

  

       

      

     



      



  

         

  

     



 

                          



    



     

     

    

                   

         

   

 

     

  





    

) $ ,

* 1



"

*

, /

1 -, 1

*

*

$ 4 -"

 "

/,- ,-!







","

/,- ,-!

4 ,

-"

 "

"

/-

 



 "-5, /$-!

 , 1

*-* /$- 5,

(  ,  ,/ (

"

-

--

-,  >,(

--

" (

/3

--

 

" -( "

/-

 





 , *-*

/$- 5,



5, "

/ 

"

/$-! 

! , - , 68(

  / " *"

/  --"

",

*



-"





%  "

 

$, $ "

1



 , 

 ,

/$-

5,



*-*"

# 4/$ -!(

$

, - , 6*8 *

,-

1 ,"

"

, - , 68

68 " 7( *  /  " "

- (

( , ,

* 

 ,",-!

"- !"

, - , 6*8 $ --!

*"  "

 "

 "$ 

,",-!

"- !"(  *

"( 1

$

( / 

,/"

""

1

2

/-

-!(

4"

B0  12 3/

  

2     /  &''%  $' $ --!

 *"

/ 

"



5, "

"

1

/ 

*-* /$- 5, 1

-* $ 

$ ","

-1

B##  !        

    

  

$      %  &

#'

  



    



    

  

  

          

     

      



    

 

       (  

   

    

#)     

            

 

                 !

    

   



           

   

   

  

*** *** ***

#+  ,  

      

    

 -              

   

        *



  % 

  

   ( 

        

      4     ,5 , 6   ) 4   2 2  5

*** *** ***

..



  

  

 /   



   $ 2      2 3 -    &

4#5 6 

   



  

    

                      (   

               

%  

  

        "

.7 8      

         

  

   8  

     

      

      

    

  

      



     



 

!



  8  

  *

       

   ( 

       

   

     

  



 6 

   8        



     %      +  5  5 2 2,5 ,6  ) 4

* (

* ;

"$"

$$ -

,"

 "$,

(





"$-

1 ,""

/  

"$-

1 --!

"

,$ /$-  -"

"

!

"

* ,

;

%  ","

!

"$" 5,   

/$, "

,(

1 $$"

-- /  1 """

"



" !

!

/ %

 *  1

$ ","

 *



4"

B(   7   8 1  9 2/   &''-   --&/ 

 *"

,-"

$ 



$ , "

* 1

1

/ /",

$"

 !" 4

 *"

$$ 

&*

"$-

- 

"

"  /,

"$-

( 5,

1

$"

,-!

, ",

/ 

/* / *

-

$,/

/ (

1 (

5,

1

 1 /$-!

-- "

//"(

 -"

(

   -"



/$" 4 ,

 *"

( /"

5,

,-

* 

5,

 

"

" 

( > , /

-, 1

- 

1 "

 



)

"

 " -!( > , !"

-- /

$$-  "-"

 "

- $

 "

"/"



"

$( 

" "

 *"

> ,

""

 

, $- 

"$-

/, * 1

/ 



-* $ 

$ ","

-1

'

        

 

  

             

 

   

  

         

 

       -

     $ 8       .

.557 

   -       

  

   

 3   -  -       %     

&  

    #  .

                      

      

      

  

        

       

      

  

     

            

 

 

   





   

*** *** ***

##      

 8   4 )   4) 5 + 4 2 ,    ,  ), )   , 4 ,    5 5  , 7:

                    8        

    

 



 



 

;       8    ( 

 

 

      

          

        

      

 

  

 / < %          

  %         

 

 

         

    

 

  

       

        

  

  

    

    



     



  

        

             

 

   : 

 / < %       

  

      



 

*** *** ***

#'

!      8            

   (   

       

   



 

   

 



  ==" C

B 3)0  1 2: 5:7 

/  &' -(  *"

," 

B#7  !                       

  

 

    &





&  

   

   

  

8  

% (        (            

                     



#'

 

    1  (  /< 

 2 > ?

  <  .5#. # /''.  

 

  

4 

   

 

  



   

 

   

 

                     

   %      2   ,  7  4  + 2 + 

 , 2 2 7,5 ;6  )), 4



/    



    

               



 

   

       

 *      

      





 "

* /(

/







/ 

-"

 -

",

"$-

/,- ,-!(

- 

$- "

,$ ( 3<92  </1  *"

,"



%

* - - -!

 *-*

/$-7 5,



1

1  

,

-!

"- !"



4

-*  *  "  ; 

 (. ,   (

-"

,$

!

-

"

,- 

$ (    

. ,    



"

$

,(

/ 

 (  /



1 "

 * "

1

"

,-



1

*" 1

%$

!

 -- 

7 / 

( 

1

/$- 5,



*-*"

 (  /$- 5,

 

( ,    

1 , 1

5, "

" "

1

$

,   / /$- # ( 3 

$ /

/

, - /-!

1

%

#9( 3

"/ "

 #2( 3

"

1

$

/$-

*"3 ,"

 " 

 ,/ ( 

!

/$- 5,



 + * (  "

  1

,

,  /$- 5,



 4

-*  (

/ " /,

( /,

( , 1(

1 -,"

/$-

"!

7 /"

5,( 1 $

"

$, /$- (

"!

$,

 *" /$-" 4

-* 

,- 

$

!"

7 /  ,/(

1

$

 $

*





// 1

1--

%$

!



 ) $ ,

- 1 6)7, 8( 1

7"



$ %( 1  $  1

,/

- 1 ?

"

,- 

$

",

,

,/ 1 1

'9

, --!

,/

-,  $- "

 + * (   -- 

 "( ,( 

 "

,/

1  )

!

(  /$- 5,

 *-*"

 

" -"

 * + * (  ,"

 $  

$ , " 

- , (

--



 $

% #9( 3

"/ "

#2( 3 /



 

;

 (

-* / %



/

* ;  1

-*





* ;   #& #&'&&

-"

B5*(  *+   3   , &-'

&'&& -"

," 

B

 / @   (  

     

/           

 2  3  -  ?

 $  > 2

#AAA7/B9A 

      

 

   

 2  3  -        

 

   

     

   ( 

 <       

 

    

       (                   

 

   C   

     

             

  !

  

  

 / @ 

    



   

            

           (E         

 .55)  6      

 

       

    

   -

 

    /  @         



    

  

     

    



  2  

*** *** ***

  

) F   (        

    

  

 D  / @ G,   

                       

        /  @       

      

  





 



   

  H 

      

             

  

             "

) $ ,

* 1



3

  $- "

 -

"

 - @,"

,( 

$$-- 



1 /(



,  

 -" 4

 *"

 ,/ (  /$- 5,

 1 *-*"



-(

 *( 

*

  /$-"



$ ,"

 

 ,/"







/"(

,(

$-

"1

* /

$$-!



 

* ;  B= 4  ( 5 5 2 > .+   *+   >  >7      7  <7   / "#!$ #&'&/ ,   &%'$&'& -"

," 

4   

     

      &

        D          

  

  



 D



-

    

 D 

    





  

 

 



    

     

        

 

    *  



   











 

               

  

  *   



   

 



   

   .5#A    7# 5# .5.53&##    

    

         -    

   

   

        

          * 

 



     2 - I    

*** *** ***

6 

          /   '5A  '.5 #.5&$ .5#3  

          /           8    

  (    

         D  

  

(         

    

        

 -       

 3   - #A++      

                    

 *     J(     J



  

(   &  8       %    

       



 

"

* /(

 

-!

-,

 - "

 *"



 "

,"

* 

,$ )( CC

*"

!

, ",

,

,( 

  

&,  

!

"$-

 ? ( ?

C   -"

 "/"

1"

1   

9

<$

*1

*   ,/ 

"1

* /

* ;  ( $ " *

"/"

 " -!

"/"

%&$ "

*+,-.,/ '#   

 ( 

$ %

"

E



$ -

'