Vivek Goel And ANR v. Devender Singh Parmar
!"
#"
"$ "
%&!
#"'"
!"
(
#" )"
$(* +
)" ),
$(* +
)" "
%&!* + (" )" +!$!
-$! * +
"."( /
! & (" " ( 12 2
3!
"( (,' '* ("' 5$ ( ! & 6$&' 2
(( & 4!
12 3 2 ' 7" $4' (" * 3!$ "'& , $ 3!$ $& "&$ "
" 8 $4' & '" " $*
!, 4 4 !3 ( " "( / " 3!
"( """ 3" "" '$ $ (" (" % &"$ ! & " " "5$" 4 & 9(" "( / " ! $* $45$ &* $ ! '($& 12 "
4 &"$ $45$ ! " 5$ 12 "
4 7" ("* $((" ! "&$'* " $( :'
12 " "" '"
)"
;+< 7" "( / * !"
!* (( (" " ( $4' ( ,
12 ! !, 3" "&$ "
" , 5$ ' "5$" 4 $''", '" 7" "( /
" $( 6$&' =!
!
* "&" 8 $4' (" * ! ' ", " , ("& 3 * 3" (" & 9(" !, ! ( " 8 $"!"
$4'
12 * 6$" 2 ' & (,' " /!"
(,' ' "
!" , , ("& & 12 2 "&! , ( >! !" " (" ("$ (("
4
'($& ! "&! , (" " ( '" "
4 ' " !""
>! (" 3!" ' ", $"
, ("& ' & (,' "( / " ((" :' ! ("$ "" )"
;+< " (" %' " '" " !"4 3 ?
>! ( "( / " ("' 5$ &"$ (,' (" , @!
"( """ "* "" (
""" $ & ( 2** . ?
2 @" ' (" 6$" & "( " ?
A"!
(3"
", 4! ("
/
6$" " >!""* "( , 6$" "&$' "* ((" " :'
$& :'
1
2 ?
2 >! 9 "&$' " B3 "* (" ' (" $" $ !'
!"
?
>! 3& ""
!
"
#
$
$
! " # %#
&
' #
$ %#
$
$
!
% &# '
() *+, -
./* $
* 4 010510116 >!$* 3! 3" 3" ("& 6 ("& "$ ( $" "& ,* !, 3" (" & 9("
?
+ (( & 9(" ""* "
, '" ! &! '!
?
>! " "
( ( 3& ""
,
7
8
( , 9 :
1
;
10051010 / , 8 9 :
'
"
,
" 1509101; ( & )
$
"
$
&
'
*
% + $ / "
# ,
" ( & $
$
,
%#
- $
$
% &# '
() *+, -
./* $
* 4 1509101;6 + ("$ 4 !3 $ 46 & "( / "* 9(" 6$" " >!$* "
(" 6$" " >! ! & , & " (( "& ( " "
&
?
>! " "
( ( 3& ""
,
9 :
8 01051011
;
10051011
. /
# $'
$
$
!
&)
"
$ $
0 12 3
# $
%#
&
' #
$ "
1<01101;
8
* 4 9201101;
% &# '
() *+, -
./* $
01236 + ("$ 4 !3 9 "* !3 "* , & ! (("
!, 3" (" & 9("
9?
+ (( & 9("
* "
, ' 3 '! (& 9(" "" 9?
>! 9("
$46 (,& *. 7%+* $"$&"' >! :' "("$ !"4 3
,
%=
>
& ,
% 9 :
1
;
10051011
% 9 :
8 9201101; 4 ?
,
" #
;000%
*= , -
% %#
$
/ $
# $
$
19, 101;
% )&# '
+,
( ) *+, - ,
./* $ 01236 + ("$ 4 :' !3 3! 9 (" ("& 3" * 6$" (,' 3 " " 4 3!"4, 6$" " "* (" ("* ' , "
! & 4" , " * " (( "& ( !$ ! " "
& :' $45$ '* $& :' *
*
1* * 2* * *
*
*
1 !3 6$" " "
9?
12 +"&$' (","
3" !" '"
6$" 2 ' & (,' " D' 12 "("$ !"4 3
,
# - ,
9 :
1
;
10051011
/
$
!
)
! $
"
( & ,
%#
45 $
& / $
!
% ) - +
@
1013
, -
./* $ 01<@6 + ("$ 4 :' !3 (" ! ' ", $"
, ("&* ( " !$ ! " "
& / $!
"&$' " ' (& 12 >!$* " (( "& ( )" "* " "
"&! ,
12 " 3!
' 3 3 B<4 %$("'
6 #
27 8& " 0 "("
(0 9
5 >!$* " "&$' " " $ ! & 3! ' * '" "
4 "6
+ ("$ 12 !3 "
"& ( " 4!
("* " "
' $ '$ *1* . $ "( / " >! !""
9 2 ' & (,' E 2 * 6'
3 (,' '
3 !" , ("& & 12 * !$&!* !, (( & 12 >! 5$ , (""" (( & 6$&' 2 (( & 3!
(( & 12 3" ' +(( +$!",* $"$&"'
'' 2 8 ""* " !( " 43 "( /
($
' ("' ($ " ("
""* '$ *. ("
'!
"* $"!"
$46 "
F "
",
'! +"
& " (* +(( +$!", 4"
$ *11*. !$&!
" "
"
'$ $ " ' 4$ 6' $(! 4"
& ( * ' , ( >! B<4 =!
!
G%$("?
( ("
3 3
B<4 %$("'
6 # G%$("?* !"
", !"& " "
4 ( * 9 !"& "
(& & 3!
"""* " "' $!", 8 ( , 4"
(!" ;" !"&H "(" ' " !"& "
"' !"
9( " "
( ' " ! !& "' 4 * 6' 4 4 " , 4 4 ' & ( !"
", !"& "' " "
!"3 8 "' , ! '( , ' "
4$ $, ( & "5$" 4 6 ("' 5$ (" 6$&' "("$ !"4 3 9; A "
#
>
B "C ) +
8
"
, ,
C
,
8
" ;0 #
>
B "C ) +
, ,
#
"
"
>
" / "
, " " C #
"
,
8 ,
6 2 8 4 * "" ' =!
" %& I$& $ !" 4& " ( 43 3 %& =! ! $"* '$!
*
:
; "(" <= < = 54* " %& I$& ( (("$, "&$ "
" !$ 4 & ! (, "' * !* , (("$, "
" >! !"
( "" !"
" %& I$& 2 :
>
!
"(" 5<= 1: 45 ("
3 3 B<4 %$("'
6 # G%$("?* " , 3
' (,' " "* 6' 3 !& '" "5$" 4 8
3 2 : G%$("?
! 4 ""
3 "& ,* $(! >!$* "&$' " " $ 3" "5$" 4 "' " "5$" 4 $" '" "
4 "6 1 -(&
3 4 "$'* '($& " "* $"$&"'
+(( +$!",* $"$&"'
" " 3!
3 "
4 $(! (" " ( 4& '" * "
4 ' "& ,* '
! ! "
" #$%&$%'()%*+,-./'%*(0-%12 %(/0 #$%&$%''%)0'&*34%2 %(/0