← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRWP/11118/2023dismissed

Mukesh Kumar v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-09-30Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari14 pages



         

   



!

"# $# %

  & '

!

# $# %



    

     (!

 )* (# +  ,* 

  

 

 !"

      

#     #

     $$$$ ,*  - #. /01

% &   '  "!"   (  )     "

**+,**-./  '"

)   

!  01%%*0*23 4 567 (

 

."



#!  

 

8

  ' ( "

  '

"

   +

* 9   .   (

   

 (

 "   ! )   "  '"



 "

 )

 )  2 &

)      " 

   3 9 



7  



 %00

  '       "' ("":

  

)

  

       " 

    ( "

)    '  (  (  &   "

 ;/ <%=6   0-02*000   " 20*,2+=5 ,*0% / . '

)     " .#  = :

  ) # ! )   "!"   0=%0*00* "!"       "   "     " 2+=5  20*  *0%   / . %6+0  '

"   5 + #

#

22 '

&

345'4 '

5'6 4/

7  6 '



5 8 6

8& 6 25 

589

5 8 6

2/&06 9/:8 6

25 

% "20*/ . %6+0 )     

 *000,5 )         * "2+=/ . %6+0 )      0-

*000,5 )      '  2 "*0%/ . %6+0 )      02

5 5 >   

 

( '

 ( 8! 9"   .  ! )    %>01*0%=    . 5856-65895*00* + & "

     '

 

   

   "   )

 !'

*3(7 

  " %*0=*00*3   



?

"*00*@7  "*00*  A   )*0

 "

" *>



" )

  -  !) )) !' "

""     " )  "

   "

         

  '

  (

) <.B 5%->05*0*0 &   '

( "5  (". !   *-0-*0*2 '     "   ""   " "

   '  4     !'

'

' (  .  

          

 

  !" # $%&%'&(



 %) '* %'&+ 6 & "   ""    "   '   "'"" 

  " (

) .C.

 2%=65*0*2 (   .  !     01%0*0*2 " )   "    "

       )

  

 

 ( "  '"  ) "

 '

 

. "

 )

# )

 " "

  )   ( & 

!

    5

" 

" " (

 "

 "  

? @3.

7 . )   "      "

   

( " '")"

 ' (    ". "

 )

 # )

  "   "

       )      ( 

%

 "" )  E 1 &     '

  (  ( 

 . "

 )

# )

   01%0*0*2 %0 ;

  "   ""  !     %0%%*0*2   " )  "

      "  "

     '  ( !

   "  "

    



*3

737 "*00* "

"

 ( "     "    *0 

  "

 "  *> 



"& " "

) !

"    

    +( ++  + (



*   +*





  

%% :

"   ) 3 7 (           "

 "    "

'

      " 2+=5   *0%   / .      ))"  "20*/ .  )           "

  A ( "  "!" "20*/ .    !/ .' "

"   %* & !)  (!( 

"  

" " )  (  . /;/ )"

3 7& !

4

"    5 D%0! )

 "

3(7' !"  "")    "*-327  " !)( "



!   ) .   

( 3

7"!" " '

 

  ""

( "

'F!  " '"!" " '

   "

<

"21> -

G )    

 "2  '"*>3% 7 *-327/   "'" 

)     >

  "'! !' 4.9"

) C !     ( /"   " *0%+327 . 3.

 

7 6*- 3*0%+76..2%2'    ""   " "" "21>/ . " 2,*>3% 7    "

 "

 ( "   " )  

         ;   

  )"  '

  "'"' 

""

  %%/"    !          " '

  !  (    ""  " ) 

   "

"  '.

#!  ' (! B

  (  (  ;    

 )       (  &

.

)' "  ().       "   "     " 21> / . "2 '"*>3% 7  "'   ""

 &

 )" '



 "4 -

>

 "!  &  "  4.9" 

) 3

7/ (   "

*2  ""



2=H2> "'"  I*2

    !"=*-3*7 .

.%1-2'



")J  

 ' 

  "  )     "  '" !  /     "

!   4"   )

 "

") "

 " '""

     !" "

 (  "   ""!  &  !  " =*-3*7 .

. %1-2

      ) "

 %11% 327 . 3.

 

7=-03%11%7=..20=.     " "           "!" ""!  " "

 ( '

   !  & )" !' 4 "2%.

.%1-2

 "2%

   ! 

)  " =*-3*7   . & !  (   ! 



   



    " 2%3%7 .

. %1-2    " '

("  !

" " (  

""! 3 "  " '74"' " " "

       '" "

    ""

 B

"

       "

'

         '  )    !   "   & '

       "

   )

(    "  A ""("  '  " 4  444 444 444 444 444 444 444 444

"

2=/""

 ' A) !B   '    "     "

(

'

            "   '         "  '

 "

 (  "   ""!  " " '  '!  (   !  "     "  

("   "    " '

    2>B ' 

)

'    "



) (     '   "  "

  "  "  " ""! & "'

) )  !'   "    

  ! ( "          

    ()

'

    &

" G "  (  ) .          " 

 ""! /'

"(

 

 ! 

 " )

 "   "   )          "

'

   ""

 B'!  &' "  " '""'

A !'

) )  "2% .

. %1-2 & "  "

   )    "      

    )    " (   " "     " "   " 

 (  " )     ' " 2% .

. %1-2 & "!  '!   (       "   "   "  

    '  "

        "'  ""

 & ("

"     

     A    ))     " B       "   "  ( ' "

  "





 ''"'

"" & )

9"

) 

' (  

' " !) )

' ' !   ))

E 3   7 %2    (    "   ""  '

)   "*00*/ "  A    )   %0 

  "

 "  %= 

  

 " 3"

)  7 '  ))" " 20*/ . +( ++  + (  *  +  +*

%= &    '

 !"    ( 

  " & !) 

) 

 " 

=

  %20**0*= ('

   !

.

.# )



   ('

   !

 )/" #



" 5%= "

 %> :

   "  ' 

)   "  *00* (  " ("!" " ) "       4

")

      "

   ( " 

*3

737  " %+ B 

') . '

" 

 " (   "   "

" %*

0+  %1  

"%>

%0 

 *=   3'  7   *=0+*0*=    "

 '

)  )

"("  ""  %- & "   !(

 ""   3 74

"     "5 + # # / 65'&0/ 



/ 

( #

/:

% K

  ;

 0-02*0000*0=*00%H ;

 *%0=*00%02%0*00* 0* 0+ 01 * .!"  ;

 0=%0*00*%201*00+H ;

 0>02*0%>*=0+*0*= %2 02 00 6/0

%> 2 C!    

 357 ;

 0>02*0020>%%*002 00 0- *1 = /  (  357 ;

 %*%0*0*2 %6%%*002 00 0% 0+ >

!

357 %*+' 02  0* 0> %> '6&/0 + 6 '

%* 0+ %1 +  

3L7 0= 0> 6/0  6 '

<



%

  *+ +

%6 &.  "  !

(  (

 " 

""    "

 



%1 9  !")     

 (

 "    

!  )!

 "

' (  . '

(.  *0 /  ?

@  ( "  :-" ./ &  ) 

  

 

4"

!  #!  

  )!  ( 

 " %61= .!")  ") 

""      

 '  "

   '   4""' 4"!   .

 

" .%1-2 *% /  "

  (/ & /8

#  5

5/-   $ +

%=-   .     5 D") "

"(4""  "   "    

    F4"!   

"  . )) ( F  *  : ///   ! "  ) "

'  -* %+%'"

G" G  G " G   )

   4  

'")    C" " (   '

  ( 

 ( "  =2*,=22 -*,%+% 

'  . !  "

!



'  =2*

 =223 7  

 G  G  ""  <  ( " 

 "(  "        '

& )

!'   F =://! ( " )"



 '

 

  ! ' "

 "

"E  ** & )

   ,   

 '    #!  & 5 

    ( 

  "

  

  "     / "#!  

  "

!

 "

"

  "    )

!      " "  "   '"  "

  '

 "  &  " 

$

    ( #!    "

"

      ","

  "  (  "!"  ( (  . +6/6 / :/ /

# (/4

+5 >4

/

64 - . =1 - +* ""$

"

64 +6/6 / :/ /

# 4&9 +5 > . 0#99/0

# "% ""

 1#

*2 &  .  )  "

+3/85

+4/

4/ /

?

(& (/ 4/

(54 /

# +6/6 ,/ /6/@/ .+1

  .

 . 585 /01 ==-    )

)   "

 #!  4 "' "

  ""  "'

' "!"  )"

 

      '  "!"

&

!

4

" )    5 D+>F

  ) '

 " 9 )'

 3

7   " )

  "

  "!"& )  9 )'



**   A   

 "  ! )3

7'" A  )  .9""#

 #3

7/ '

(    " 4

"   ) I=  )

             "  (

  "

   4   *0 

    

(

 

  



 "  )

 )

   ""

 (  "   .   #

  #!  



3%1+%72.==0' .  

')  "  

! .      :

 ! ) F   /%1>= .+=( ! 

' IK  "  

     (   "  "' (   "

)         /4A'    !

''  "    ' 

 (   #!  "

(  "

    < " !/  

...

 

" 

 " $$$$$ "

          "(  

      '  )  "!" G

I



&.   ( ! I9

 ""    ' "   "M !  )

         "   " >1  

 " "  '      #!       

 

'

 )""&      " ( " '" ( "K            #!     " =0% .

 

"  .

  5 A   <      ( )    " '" "   ( )     "

   "

4  

"

 "

)  &  

 " (  " "

   & A     4"

!  '   !"  

  #!  M    "

       ) 

 #!   "    "=0% .  .

 

"          " B      "A   ) G /         "   .       



 " 

 

 "

 '"   (    

!  " )

)  !

    ( )!          ""  "'  &.     A   " 

  '4"

!   #!   " =0%..

 

"  ">-/ 



.   "

 ""

 ""     )!("  /  

./  ' .  "

  " '  

  "" ( 4 

"

     G      )!      "   (

)

 ( "

  I ;  

*2 )  9 )'

( ! 

' I/

 !K/ 3%16%7%..%0- .9"   . 

       ( !    ! ""

 ""=22 '

 '  "   ' "

     ;  :

< 

3:.!"7! B9H  3*0007 - .. +*+  

)   "   "

  #

    #!  



3%1+%72.==0" 

 " I    I 

          '    )     "!" G

M "!" ))"" 



 

"

 ("  

("     #!    ) (

"  "    "      "!"  ( 

 "

( 

  !/'

( ! )  !

  "     A '    *0 

      ( )  "     (



"

4 "

"

 "

)  

    ' )    " A '     I & )

 "   :

#

  #    )  9 )'

 '

'"  

"

'"

      !  )"

 

 "

 "

)     !  ' "

 '     

 ) ( ((            4"    

     "

)  (  "

 

 E *= /    "

 "    '

 "!"  0=%0*00*(

 )#   " *00*  "

 K      "    '   "   '"

  "

   "

 ("   "  *0

 "

"

*>

' "3'  7& !

4

"

"*00*   5 *3

7 .!" '   "   ( "         "!"' !(     !) "    "

  "5 & "



( " 

 "    *0 

"

 "  *> 



"'

  37

37  '

  *> &.  4  )   (   . /;/ @"

3 7 !'  "

"(

 "        )  

" " /   

)    ". '(    " " *-327    "   (  " ' () "

!"

+6/6 & ;/7

# /075

+5 >4-



  .

+

%"- "!" !! "20* / . *+ &)  . /;/ @"

3 7 ( !  "  

 )" " "21>/ . "2 *>3% 7  "   "

( " " ) 

  '! ' ) ) "

) "

( ! 

 5)

    ) ! #!  /  . 

 "  !)



      ! ) (   '  "  '  "

  )!   "=2* =22 .

 .%1-2(4 "("  ""   ) ""

!

 " "  "

     "   ("" " '

  #!  & !

4

"  )    5 D%+ &   '  '!       "  .  '

3

7" .  "

  '     ")    "

 (         

  )! 20

" '  ! 2+

&  (.  '

3

7(!  "  "

   "'

 (' )

 5)

    ) !(4 "("  

       .   

    "  / )

    ! )(' " ' "

  #!   "=2*  =22.

 .%1-2(4 "("     )  ""

  !

  "  "   '       "

 "    "   ( "" " '

""  #!   %- & '    5 )9"" .  & <  C ! 

9

*0%13*7 . 3.

 

7 %%6 *0%1 3*7 . :F **> 3.

 

 

 <%*0  *0%1"**



*0%17< "

  '

 "!"   "   " 20*  / .  " 



)      

"!" "2-+  21+/ . " )     -

"( "'  ""

    "

   '

 (   !)

 )

"

" ! %+

(!) 2=%& < 

   %162 /    "

 '!       ( "!"   "   " 20* 32 "7  " 20- 3= "7    ( "         " " & A   '       ( )

     "

"   ( "  (    #!    4 "  '   " =2*  =22  .

 . %1-2 B   '  

  

"E *- /"



 #!  4 ")  '  !        "   "

"

  "" ) )

!  " "  "'" ""    " "" *6 & "

 )      "  *00*     " 3 7 "

 ( 

"



'

 ) / (" "  "

"

   " (! *1 & "

( #!  

   )

   ( (  . /    "

      )  ( "      "      "     A    ) *0 



"

 "  *> 

 

 " 3'  7 '"

    ) 

* 

20 & .  

)

 ) .A   (      ( 585  ;

   "    "       

%

  ( "

'



  "

(   ""  ""

  

( " ("     "

 ( .

,

  )

,8 )

""  "   '    "

) 

2%

 ) "

37 

    

"" ) 

.,* 



+9687

64-  %



! B  ),   N,< B   N,<