High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/1662/2023disposed of

Rajvir Singh v. Manoj

2025-07-22Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul4 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()*+, ($- . /0&12&(34 5555566+&%( 766!++( 8!1'*' ("/ 55555!'6"($!( ) ) ) ) 9:252 9:252 9:252 9:252;:

;: 1!'!( ) 154($< ++-$0"% ! #"1 4!66+&%( 5 15 &=& -$0"% ! #"1 4!1!'6"($!( 5 ;:-5 ;:-5 ;:-5 ;:-5 5 4!66+&%( 4'#&+!$ 4!61!'!( 66+&% &"('!!>&(331( "#+!0! "66!+3&(' 4!/*$3<!( "#%?*& +6''!$&(%"<6+&( %'!&(' & * !$*($!12!% &"(

"# 4!!3" &@+!(' 1*<!( '% -

4!1!&(# !11!#!11!$ "'-A% B-C4!1!@, 4!%"<6+&( #&+!$@, 4! 66+&%( C'$&'<&''!$($ 4!%%*'!$C'%?*& !$5 5 4!+&<& !$?*!' &"(1&'&(3#"1%"('&$!1 &"(&( 4!61!'!( 61"%!!$&(3'&'C4! 4!1(66!+3&(' ("1$!1"#%?*& +6''!$&( %"<6+&( %'!*($!12!% &"(

"# 4!% %(@!!( !1 &(!$*($!1 4! 61"0&'" " 2!% &"( D "# 4! 1555 4! &(' (%! "# 4! %"<6+&(( E

5 4! &''*! &' (" +"(3!1 1!' &( !315 ( A7' !+!' &*< A7' !+!' &*< A7' !+!' &*< A7' !+!' &*< &((%&+ 8'5 5 (('!>1( %5 . 2

F) .

&((%&+ 8'5 5 (('!>1( %5 . 2

F) .

&((%&+ 8'5 5 (('!>1( %5 . 2

F) .

&((%&+ 8'5 5 (('!>1( %5 . 2

F) .

1&<&(+

B- 4!"(9@+!2*61!<!"*1 * 4"1& &0!+,4!+$ 4

%"<6+&(( &(61"'!%* &"(*($!12!% &"(

"# 4!% -?*+&#&!' 'A0&% &<B*($!12!% &"( C"# 4!1555-@!&(3 4!6!1'"(C4" '*##!1'#&((%&++"''$*! " 4!$&'4"("*1"#%4!?*!5"('!?*!( +,- '*%4%"<6+&(( &'!( & +!$ "6*1'*!(66!+3&(' %?*& +*($!1 4! 61"0&'" " 2!% &"( D "# 4! 1555- C& 4"* 4! 1!?*&1!<!( "# '!!>&(3'6!%&++!0!*($!12!% &"(

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

( 4!%"( 11,-'3&(' ("1$!1"#%?*& +- 4!2 !- 41"*34 4!*@+&%1"'!%* "1%(61!#!1(66!+!0!(&# 4!%"<6+&(( $"!'(" 61!#!1'*%4(66!+- 4"*34"# %"*1'! '*%4 ( 66!+ &' C& 4 4! +!0! "# 4! %"*1 5 "C!0!1- & &' (" +C,' (!%!''1, #"1 4! 2 ! "1 %"<6+&(( " 61!#!1 ( 66!+5 * C4!( & %"<!' " 0&% &<9'1&34 "61!#!1(66!+- 4!&('&' !(%!"('!!>&(3 '6!%&++!0! "66!+#1"< 4!&34"*1 *($!12!% &"(

F "# 4! 1 C"*+$ @! %"( 11, " C4 4' @!!( &( !($!$ @, 4! 1+&<!( @, &('!1 &"( "# 4! 61"0&'" " 2!% &"( D "# 4!1555 "*1 4+,- 4! 1+&<!( 4' (" <!($!$ 2!% &"( " %&1%*<'%1&@! 4!0&% &<9'1&34 "61!#!1(66!+/*' '& 4'C& 41!31$ "%"<6+&(( "1 4!2 !#&+&(3(66!+5

( 4!" 4!14($- 4!1+&<!( 4'&('!1 !$ 4!61"0&'" " 2!% &"( D '"' "!(0&'3!'*6!1&"11&34 #"1 4!0&% &<

"#("##!(%! "61!#!1(66!+"( 4!31"*($'<!( &"(!$ 4!1!&('%"<61!$ "%"<6+&(( 5 &# 4+,- 4!&(0"+0!<!( "# 4!2 !&(1!'6!% "#("##!(%! *($!12!% &"(

"# 4!% &'%"('6&%*"*'@,& '@'!(%!5 4&'&'@!%*'! 4!%"<6+&( #&+!$*($!1 4 61"0&'&"(&'&( 4!( *1!"#61&0 !%"<6+&( '6!12!% &"(

"# 4! 1555($2!% &"(F "# 4!% @,(!=61!''&( !( &"( &(%"16"1 !' 4!61"0&'&"('"# 4!1555&( 4!< !1"# 1&+"#'*%4$!!<!$"##!(%! 1&!$'%1&<&(+"##!(%!5 4!1!#"1!- 4!%"<6+&(( -C4"&' 4!0&% &<"#$&'4"("*1 "#%4!?*!<*' @!%"(' 1*!$ "@!0&% &<&( !1<'"# 4! 61"0&'" " 2!% &"( D 1!$ C& 4 4! $!#&(& &"( "# 0&% &< *($!12!% &"( C"# 4!1555 ========= 5 ' +1!$, (" !$- 4! 61"0&'" " 2!% &"( D "# 4! 1555C'&('!1 !$&( 4!' * !@"">"(+,C& 4!##!% #1"<

5 5

54!"@/!% ($1!'"(#"1'*%4&('!1 &"(<*' @!1!+&'!$($<*' @!3&0!(& '#*++!##!% "@,%"*1 5( 0&!C"# 4!#"1!'&$$&'%*''&"(-C!4"+$ 4 4!0&% &<"# ("##!(%!4' 4!1&34 "61!#!1(66!+*($!1 4!61"0&'" "2!% &"( D "# 4!1555-&11!'6!% &0!"#C4! 4!14!&' %"<6+&(( "1(" 50!(&# 4!0&% &<"#("##!(%!&' %"<6+&(( - 4! %( ' &++ 61"%!!$ *($!1 4! 61"0&'" " 2!% &"( D ($(!!$(" $0!1 "'*@'!% &"( F"#2!% &"(

"# 4!1555H .5 4*'-C4 #+"C'#1"< 4!@"0!"@'!10 &"('&' 4 4! "(9@+!2*61!<!"*1 -# !1(!=4*' &0!!=<&( &"("# 4!' * "1, #1<!C"1>($61!0&"*'/*$&%&+61"("*(%!<!( '&(%+*$&(3A++&>1/*( A++&>1/*( A++&>1/*( A++&>1/*( ;"$3+&8'52 !"#;1( >" 4!1'B 2D.

;"$3+&8'52 !"#;1( >" 4!1'B 2D.

;"$3+&8'52 !"#;1( >" 4!1'B 2D. -%+1&#&!$ 4 4!1&34 "#66!+%"(#!11!$*6"( 4!A0&% &<B*($!1 4!61"0&'" " 2!% &"( D "# 4!1555&'&($!6!($!( ($'*@' ( &0!&(( *1!-(" %"( 1"++!$ @, 4! 61"%!$*1+ 1!3&' 1 &"( *($!1 2!% &"(

F "# 4! 1555 5 $"6 &(3 613< &% ($ /*' &%!"1&!( !$ 661"%4 ($ 3*&$!$@, 4!61&(%&6+! 4 61"%!$*1+1*+!<*' '!10!($(" "@' 1*% 4!%"*1'!"#/*' &%!- 4&'"*1 $!!<'& 661"61& ! "$&1!% 4 4!

F 61!'!( 66!+ @! 1! !$ ' "(! * 4"1& &0!+, &(' & * !$ *($!1 4! 61"0&'" "2!% &"( D "# 4!1555 D5 ( 0&!C "# 4! * 4"1& &0! 61"("*(%!<!( &( 7'!+!' &*<&((%&+9'%'! '*61 7'!+!' &*<&((%&+9'%'! '*61 7'!+!' &*<&((%&+9'%'! '*61 7'!+!' &*<&((%&+9'%'! '*61($ 4!0&!C >!(@, 4&'"*1 +'"&(2 6+2&(34052 !"#*(/@(15

$&'6"'!$"##"( 5 D5 .- 4!61!'!( 66+&% &"(&'$&'6"'!$"#C& 4 $&1!% &"( 4 4!+!1(!$2!''&"('*$3!%"(%!1(!$'4++ 1! 4!61!'!( 66!+'(66!+#&+!$*($!1 4!61"0&'" "2!% &"( D "# 4!1555 ($''&3( 4!'<! "(661"61& !"*1 #"1$&'6"'+"(<!1& '-&( %%"1$(%!C& 4+C5

5 4!%"(%!1(!$66!++ !"*1 '4++61"%!!$ "$!%&$! 4! 66!+!=6!$& &"*'+,-C& 4"* @!&(3&<6!$!$@,(,$!+,&(#&+&(3 4! 66!+- &( 0&!C "# 4! +!3+ 6"'& &"( ("C %+1&#&!$ @, 4! "(9@+! 6!="*1 5

5 4!!3&' 1,&'$&1!% !$ " 1('<& 4&'"1$!1+"(3C& 4 %"6, "# 4! %"<6+! ! 66!1 @""> ($ 1! *1( 4! 1&+ "*1 1!%"1$- &#1!%!&0!$- " 4!+!1(!$2!''&"('*$3!5 5

&'6"'!$"#%%"1$&(3+,5 *+, *+, *+, *+, ($ ($ ($ ($---- .

;: *(!! I4! 4!1'6!>&(371!'"(!$ ) !'7" I4! 4!11!6"1 @+! ) !'7"