← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/82/2019dismissed

Nandu (Deceased) Thru Lrs v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2021-12-13Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal7 pages



    

1. XOBJR-154-2021(O&M) in & and 

!"#$"$"

NANDU (DECEASED) THROUGH LRS $$%% &&'  ( )*) STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR.

$$

)% '

')

2. XOBJR-13-2021(O&M) in/and RFA-83-2019   RAM KARAN AND OTHERS $$%% &&')  ( )*) STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR.

$$

)% '

')

3. XOBJR-153-2021(O&M) in/and RFA-84-2019   GURDYAL SINGH (DECEASED) THROUGH LRS $$%% &&'  ( )*) STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR.

$$

)% '

')

4. XOBJR-157-2021(O&M) in/and RFA-85-2019   SHIV KUMAR AND OTHERS $$%% &&')  ( )*) STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR.

$$

)% '

')

5. XOBJR-149-2021(O&M) in/and RFA-448-2020   SUCHA RAM AND OTHERS $$%% &&')  ( )*) STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR.

$$

)% '

')

-2-  ! +, $ -,.-

,  

        

 

        !   "

# $    ! ,.-

,/ & $  % 

 

  %     %   

 

  % 

 & $ '  &   %

 %    

     () 

 * +    (),- .       / (),- 01



 #    #     



# %  

  

 #   



    

  2  #      () 

 (),-   # 

 



   



    #  * +  



   



 



  %   +   &

    

   $   .1  #3  

  () 

 (),-    

   % 

 

    #  

   

      

 

 +   #



 



   



6 

  &  .#1 

    #3  

  () 

 (),-     

 



% 

 



 



   

 

  

 

    (4.41 

 (),-  $

    

  .#1



    

      (4   #      

 



% 

 



 

()





(),-

#







-3-   

6 

$

!6#



&



 % 

3            

 

 +   #   

   

    

% 

  2

     &



     

 % 

 



 

% 



         

   $

 

 %   

!      

        

    

   #     3   





   





  



   

  

     

   

    

 

 

     

  

 

 

     7  +    /   * +  

             '  & 5       

 *    (,9:     

%   

 ;0 $ 

  # 5 



'<3-4=34=4(   / 

!   " * '  0    :( =) 4=4(

    %   

%  #   &   &    3

-4-      

   !"  #  $  % & '( &&$)( 

%( *

+##

, -$(-$ 

($& . ( (,&

$( / # 

& (

) !

-

 & 

&/($ & (

$ & $$ 

   ,$ -(& $ (  $(( 0/ # 

,$ $( & /

1 ("$

&/(0$"! !/ & &2$ &1 &$ $ !

 $(( ((

$&0 ),$ -(& ( &3    " (  ($& (, $

 -(

 $ &  0$  $0 

(!$1 $(&$ ,$ $($ (& /

( "&

$ 0/ # 

 &  "!$(-$  &$ ($&& - $( (

$) 1 $(&$ 

 4 )$- 

(  !$$!(,  -  - &  0 5 "/  

!

( "

-$&& -0/ 0&'$#

$0& 6$"(  7)/ $0 

$"$ &1 $(&$ $(

/   &  0  0 & 

 & "$ -  "

$-$$ $((8&

5$(  $ (  1 $(&$    "(  -$ $  $"$ (

$ ((!$1 $(&$ &- 

1 $(&$ 

(  $0 $(&!&

    5$(  

  $   (  $ "( (4 ( 0)$ (& /$(

(

(  (&$ "( (5$(

$)( $

-$   1 $(&$ ,  &  -    $0  &$)($ (1 $(&$  " (



 ($ & (

( & $( &$ (  &  -$    $0   

 ,$  (-$ 

(/$ 0



$0 (( "(1 $(&$ $"

,  " (  0  ( $( $&     &$ ( . $($  

  $ (  . $$  ($($ 

"

)$  $(( 0()&0/ 9$)/# $$: ((-19(

1) %%/

&6;<*

+%4  *9#+=-)1 $(&$ $($)

  0/    

 9$"  &  (  1 $(&$   $(  /  $)  !

   $ (!$ $& "( $&$  $ $( $)(!$$! ( "(" ( 0 "!$&-$ ,$ &

 &$(

1 $(&$ 

$ /0

 "!$& -$  1 $(&$ & (

$( 4 !!$ $("&-$$(

-$ $ $", # 

-$

) !

-

"8 4 &

-5- "$ $"$ (

$( -!

-,$ $(  # 

-$)

&$& -     !!$   !( &  0/  $" $( $(

-$ $ $",&( $( $(

&$ ($&& -$ 7)       $(  - /  "&  0/  # 

      -$  ( $  ) 

"$    )$&$ / 

    0 ( )/1 $(&$ 

       &!&(      ! !  0$"& & ,& $(

! !, $(

1 $(&$ $

 

 -( $ $( & /

(

 (

/   &$ ( $&  & -  $  )0 "!$&-$ ,&$ $(

&0& "( $( /$$ (  -$$ $(& !



$( )$& 4 $( /)$&  -$  $)(  1 $(&$ 

    &,



,      ( 

 (8  $ ( . (   -   $  (  1 $(&$  

  $   4&$&$ . ( 

1 $(&$ $ (

  & 0/ # 



, $( $/

 $(

!!>$ $( / &$($ " /& /

( $( /$ (  -$$ $(& !

 &$& $(  )$& & ! !    &$

! )$($ (

  & -$  $  $(  "&  ?  $(    0($  & !$"$/  & /  -$   $0    !

(($0/  ) $&  ?    (,  

, 1 $(&$ 

&$&-   -("&0/ !$ &!($0&0/

! )$(

( 0( *+

 

 ,&$ $ $&( $ -(( "&, &$

(- @  0(.  /,  $             

 

  !

 !!"

!



!

 #$$%$&#&  !"# &

$  



<$"$  ,  , !!$0  ! )$($ (

  

-$ 5 &( !$ &

$"$ ,0$) 8&$ 0/

# 

 0/ -$&$&$  & ?) &$( (($ $($!, -$$(5  &( &3 ?$

"8!!$ $-$ $ $(! )$&& & *+?! )$(

( 0( *+!($0( $"$ -$ $  -$    ($&  $  - &  0 5$(&0/ $"  &$(( $( $&

-6-

-  4  % &  '( &&$  )   

%( ;*

+##

=, $(#

-(  &  !



 &$&  $     & "&0/ # 



 0/ &    !$ & 

 $"$ , -           0$&   && "$ "!( ,

  !!$ 

  &  -(0&0/$"$ A?$( # && # 

$(. $& & 

"8  

 $"

 $ &$ (,"/,*$+ -$

!!$ 0/$ ( &!( -

(

!

& -&>*$$+ 



01 ( 8



!

$ -&> &*$$$+ $"-$ $-$ !!$ ( 0"&4!!

0  $

 ( &$ (( &$ (!&

0

 $&,  $  &    !

- 

 "8     & $($ "($0&0/

&$ ($&& - $& (  &$ $( &$ &$$"$ 

0

&$ ! )$( ?# 

 (( (

/  $ /4  !!$ $( 

"&-$ $ $", # 

-$

)

  !

- 

 "8     4  & 

"$ $"$  $( -!

-, # 

  -$  ) 

 &$&  -   !!$ !( &0/ $" $( $(

-$ $ $"&(!$ / &$ ($& & - & 7)$ $( - /"&0/ # 

, -$ )

& "$ )$&$ /

 0 ( )/1 $(&$ 

       &!&(  !

    ! !  0$"& & 4  $(

! ! $( 1 $(&$ $    

        4  -(,



,& $ $( & /

( (

/ &$ ($&& -$      $ &$       $ 

$"$ ,)0 "!$&-$ & !!$   $(  

$"0&  4  $(  

&0&  "  ( $( /$  $ (  -$$ $(& !



$( )$& 4 (

! &

& "$ "!( &$ $ $( $"0&,$ $(

& !



 ("4 $( /)$&  -$$)(1 $(&$ 

?

,      ( 

 (8  $ ( . ( - $ (1 $(&$ 

  $

4 $(0/ !($0&!$ &0/ ! )$(

( 0( *+

 

 &$ $ $&( $

-7- -(

( "&, - &&$

(-  &$/,$ -(&

($ -("&0/ $"$ , -(1 ( $&$ ($

(- @  %



 



     '  &  

 %    

  

% 

     () 

 (),-  #   * +  

 2



"!

' 

    &    $ #





   

 +     

     

# 

    () 

 (),-  



   

       %   &  + 

        

2      '  &        

  %   

%  # 

%

 

  &  %  3#   

 

  '%  <   

 # 

    

  % 



 

    

 "#/" ,.-

, /    >  %? 

@?7 > # 

@?7