High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/54/2019dismissed

The Commissioner Of Income Tax (Exemptions), Chandigarh v. M/S Shri Panchayati Gaushala Society, Rohtak (Pan-Aaets0228g)

2020-01-20Mr. Justice Ajay Tewari,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan7 pages

!"# $$ % &'( )*+,$(* - ! " # ! "$" %&'&()

% &(&'*+,-."&(/%"),(0/(12('&- %)*&,33&--,() .(/0/+"0 *& %&4&(2& *,' /-&0 )*/' ,33&,- ,1,/(') )*& %0&% 0,)&0

53,''&06+)*&(78&,933&--,)&%/62(,-. &: &-*/;

% '*%). )*&%/62(,- <*& ,33&,- )*&%&'3(0&()='7/&)+;*&%&/(, )&% %& &%%&0),' )*&'7/&)+ <:,',--:&0,(088/''/(&% (78&,9 ;9&83)/('<;

%'*%). )*& <:,'0/%&7)&0)1%,(),33%4,-))*& %&'3(0&()='7/&)+2(0&%"&7)/(5 )*&(78&,97). > ;

% '*%). )*&7) <--:/(1'26'),()/,-?2&')/(' -,:*,4&6&&(7-,/8&0 @;/< #*&)*&%()*& ,7)',(07/%728'),(7&' )*&7,'&.)*& ( 6-&:,'7%%&7)/(0/'%&1,%0/(1)*& ,7))*,))*& 8,/(&83*,'/' )*&,33-/7,()'7/&)+:,'1&(&%,)/(1)*& /(78&,(0,77282-,)/(1'2%3-2'&'/('*,3& 'A ;//<#*&)*&%()*& ,7)',(07/%728'),(7&' )*&7,'&.)*&

( 6-&:,'7%%&7)/(0/'%&1,%0/(1)*& ,7))*,))*& 8,B% &83*,'/' )*& '7/&)+ ,33&,%&0 ) 6& ,77282-,)/( ,''&)/()*& %8 ',(0&,%(/(1 /()&%&')()*&',8&%,)*&%)*,(2)/-/C,)/()*&',8& % &93,('/(A ;///<#*&)*&%()*& ,7)',(07/%728'),(7&' )*&7,'&,(0/( -,:.)*&( 6-&:,'7%%&7)/1(%/(1)*& ,7))*,) )*&'7/&)+0/4&%)&0 %8/)'6B&7)',(01)/(4-4&0/( 788&%7/,-,7)/4/)+A ;/4<#*&)*&%()*& ,7)',(07/%728'),(7&' )*&7,'&)*& *,'&%%&0/(3-,7/(1%&-/,(7&()*& ,7) )*& ,''&''&&*,4/(1

%&1/')%,)/(,(06+/1(%/(1)*& '),)2)%+7(0/)/()*,)

%&1/')%,)/(/'8&%&-+,3%&= 7(0/)/( % &()/)/&' ) 6& &-/1/6-& % ,33%4,- 2D'5 ;<,(0)*,))*&3%7&02%&/(4-4&'&9,8/(,)/(

)*&%&,-32%3'&,'-,/00:(6+)*&( 6-& &-*//1* 2%)/()*&7,'& D'E/%)/*,(0,%,:,)/*,%/),6-& %2')4' /%&7)% (78&,9;9&83)/(<,(0)*&%' ;

< ;

&-*/F

A ;4<#*&)*&%()*& ,7)',(07/%728'),(7&' )*&7,'&.)*& %0&% )*&33&--,)&%/62(,-/'7()%,%+))*&&4/0&(7& ,(0 8,)&%/,- ( )*& %&7%0 )*& 7,'& ,(0 )*&%& %&.

3&%4&%'&AG &-&4,() ,7)' ,%& )*,) )*& '7/&)+ :,' &'),6-/'*&0 (

> >:/)*)*& --:/(1,/8',(06B&7)'

@ H&&3,(03%)&7)2'&-&'',(0-07:',(07,))-&I)

F H&&3,(08,/(),/(8/-H7:',(02'& 2-62--'I)32%7*,'& 7:',(062--'/(%0&%),218&())*&(78& ,2'*,-, )8&&))*&&93&('&',(08,H&)*&,2'*,-,'2'),/(,6-&I) 3%)&7))*&6%&&0 7,))-&I)'&--)*&'2%3-2'8/-H/ ,(+ ;, )&% &&0/(17,-4&'</(%0&%)8&&)0,+)0,+&93&('&'I )8,H&,%%,(1&8&()' % 00&%,(0'*&-)&%' %H&&3/(1 )*&7,))-&,(0,77%0/(1-+8,H&,%%,(1&8&()' %32%7*,'&I )8,H&,%%,(1&8&()' %72-)/4,)/( %,1%/72-)2%,--,(0'

,4,/-,6-& :/)* ,2'*,-, ) 7--&7) 2(0' % )*& ,64& 6B&7)'. ,(0 ) 7()%-D'23&%4/'& /(4&')8&() ,(0 &93&(0/)2%&G *&'7/&)+/'02-+%&1/')&%&02(0&%"&7)/(

)*&7) (,33-/7,)/(:,'8,0&( >

> %,33%4,-2(0&%"&7)/(5

)*&7)*&%&B&7)&0)*&',8&4/0&%0&%0,)&0 >

J8,/(-+( )*&1%2(0)*,))*&'7/&)+:,'1&(&%,)/(17&%),/(/(78&,(0,',%&'2-). )*&,82() ':,'6&/(1&(*,(7&04&%)*&+&,%*&7(7-2'/(:,' )*,))*&'7/&)+*,00/4&%)&0 %8)*&6B&7) '&%4/(1-0./--,(0-,8& 7:',(01)/(4-4&0/(788&%7/,-,7)/4/)/&' (,(,33&,-3%& &%%&06+)*&'7/&)+.)*&%/62(,-(

,--:&0)*&,33&,-*-0/(1)*,))*&%&:,'()*/(1(%&7%0)'26'),()/,)& )*,))*& 2(0':&%&2)/-/'&06+)*&'7/&)+&-'&:*&%&,(0() %/)',/8',(0 6B&7)'):,',-'7('/0&%&0)*,)%&1/')%,)/(2(0&%"&7)/(

)*& 7):,'7()/(2/(1*&%0&% )*&:,''&),'/0&,(0/):,'0/%&7)&0 )1%,()%&1/')%,)/(2(0&%"&7)/(5 )*&7) 11%/&4&0 )*&%0&% )*&%/62(,-.)*&3%&'&(),33&,-/'

/-&0

!&,%(&072('&- %)*&%&4&(2&,%12&0)*,))*&%/62(,-&%%&0 /(,--:/(1)*&,33&,-./('3/)& )*& ,7))*,))*&%&:,''26'),()/,-,82() /()*& ' )*&'7/&)+,(0/):,'/(4-4&0/(788&%7/,-,7)/4/)/&'*& 7*,--&(1&3'&0/')*,))*&%/62(,-&%%&0/(*-0/(1)*,)%&1/')%,)/(2(0&% "&7)/(

)*&7):,'/)'&- &(21* %,33%4,-2(0&%"&7)/(5 )*&7) "&7)/(

;

<,(0"&7)/(5 ;<;4/< )*&7);

%)*& %&-&4,(),''&''8&()+&,%<%&,0,'2(0&%=

) , # K;

< *& %/(7/3,- 88/''/(&%%88/''/(&%.(%&7&/3) ,(,33-/7,)/(

%%&1/')%,)/( ,)%2')%/(')/)2)/(8,0&2(0&%7-,2'&;,< %7-,2'&;,,<%7-,2'&;,6< '26='&7)/(;

< '&7)/(

.'*,--K ;,<7,-- %'27*0728&()'%/( %8,)/( %8)*&)%2')% /(')/)2)/(,'*&)*/(H'(&7&'',%+/(%0&%)',)/' +*/8'&-

,62))*&1&(2/(&(&'' ,7)/4/)/&' )*&)%2')%/(')/)2)/( ,(08,+,-'8,H&'27*/(?2/%/&','*&8,+0&&8(&7&'',%+ /()*/'6&*,- I,(0 ;6<, )&%',)/'

+/(1*/8'&- ,62))*&6B&7)' )*&)%2')% /(')/)2)/(,(0)*&1&(2/(&(&'' /)',7)/4/)/&'.*&IK ;/<'*,--3,'',(%0&%/(:%/)/(1%&1/')&%/(1)*&)%2')% /(')/)2)/(I ;//<'*,--./ *&/'()'',)/'

/&0.3,'',(%0&%/(:%/)/(1 %& 2'/(1)%&1/')&%)*&)%2')%/(')/)2)/(.,(0,73+

'27*%0&%'*,--6&'&()))*&,33-/7,() (2 + !

%!,

," 3$," (7832)/(1 )*&)),-/(78& ,(,''&''&&.)*&%&'*,--6&0&027)&0./( ,77%0,(7& :/)* ,(0 '26B&7) ) )*& 3%4/'/(' )*/'

"&7)/(= LLLLLL ;<*/'"&7)/(,33-/&')0(,)/('),(+/(')/)2)/(%

2(0%& &%%&0)/('26=7-,2'&;/4< 7-,2'&;,< '26= '&7)/(;

<.(-+/ /)/'&'),6-/'*&0/((0/, %,7*,%/),6-& 32%3'&,(0/ /) 2- /--')*& --:/(17(0/)/('.(,8&-+ LLLLLL ;4/</(%&-,)/()0(,)/('8,0&, )&%)*&F ')0,+ ,%7*

.)*&/(')/)2)/(% 2(0/' %)*&)/8&6&/(1,33%4&0 6+)*&88/''/(&%/(,77%0,(7&:/)*)*&%2-&'@8,0&/( )*/'6&*,- G "&7)/(

)*&7)3%4/0&'7(0/)/(' %,33-/7,6/-/)+

"&7)/('

,(0

)*&7)"&7)/(

)*&7)3%4/0&' % 3%7&02%& %&1/')%,)/( %,4,/-/(1)*&6&(& /)'2(0&%"&7)/(

)*& 7)(0&%"&7)/(

;

<;,< )*&7))*&%/(7/3,-88/''/(&%% )*&88/''/(&%/(%0&%)',)/'

+*/8'&- ,62))*&1&(2/(&(&'' )*& ,7)/4/)/&' )*& )%2') % /(')/)2)/( 7,( 7,-- % '27* 0728&() % /( %8,)/(,'*&0&&8'(&7&'',%+ ',)/'

/&0,62)1&(2/(&(&'' 6B&7).

*&3,''&')*&%0&%%&1/')&%/(1)*&)%2')%/(')/)2)/(.)*&%:/'&%&B&7)')*& ,33-/7,)/( (0&%"&7)/(5 )*&7)%&71(/)/(/'1/4&())%2')% /(')/)2)/( %)*&32%3'&)*,),''&''&&1/4/(10(,)/(')'27*/(')/)2)/( 6&78&'&()/)-&0)7-,/80&027)/( )*&,82()0(,)&0"26='&7)/(

> "&7)/( 5 )*&7) ')/32-,)&' )*&7(0/)/(' %,33-/7,)/(

"&7)/(5 )*&7)))*&0(,)/('8,0&),(+/(')/)2)/(% 2(0 %& &%%&0)/('267-,2'&;/4< -,2'&;,< "26"&7)/(;

< *&7()&()/('%,/'&06+)*&,33&--,()=%&4&(2&-,7H8&%/) %8)*&,4&%8&() )*&'7/&)+6& %&)*&./):,'&4/0&())*,)2)

)),-F 7:'.(-+

=F 7:':&%&8/-H/(1*&026)%,/'&06+)*& :,',')*:

=F 7:'72-03%027&8/-H:%)* >. .>F D=*&',/0 026):,'6,'&-&'',')*&:,'':,+&06+)*& /12%& )*& /12%&/'

%21*-+:%H&02)))*&0,/-+,82(),(0/ ,(,4&%,1&3%/7&3&%-/)%& 8/-H/'),H&(,' D=.)*&3%027)/(:2-078&)

-/)%&' 8/-H, 0,+ *&6B&7)/()*,))*&,82()/( '*,0&(*,(7&0:/--() &(*,(7&)*&7,'& )*&%&4&(2&*&%&/'()&4&(,(/), &4/0&(7&) &'),6-/'*)*,))*&,82():,'()6&/(12)/-/'&0 %)*&,/8',(06B&7)'

)*&'7/&)+62) %'8&)*&%32%3'&*&,82()(-+1/4&',3%)&7)/( ))*&'7/&)+ %0,/-+(&&0'./ )*&77,'/(',%/'&')*,))*&%&/''7,%7/)+ 2(0',')*&'7/&)+*,',-8')F 7:')),H&7,%&,(0) &&0) 7,(()6&%2-&02))*,)'27*,72'*/(8,+6&%&?2/%&07('/0&%/(1)*& (,)2%& )*&:%H0(&6+)*&'7/&)+ *& 7()&()/( )*,) )*& '7/&)+ *,0 0/4&%)&0 /)'&- /() 788&%7/,-,7)/4/)/&'/'6&-/&0 %8)*&%,)/ 8/-H/(1,(0((=8/-H/(1 7:'2) F 7:'.(-+

)F 7:':&%&8/-H+/&-0/(1*&%,)/ :2-06&F F*&',/0%,)//',3/()&%,1,/('))*&3-&, %&4&(2&*&%& 7,(()6&,(+6B&7)/(/ ,'7/&)+:*/-&,7*/&4/(1/)',/8',(06B&7)'/' ,6-&)1&(&%,)&'8& 2(0'')*,)/)'0,/-+&93&('&'7,(6&8&) /)':( *&%&/'(?2/66-&()*&3%3'/)/()*,)%&1/')%,)/(2(0&%

J "&7)/(

)*&7)/)'&- :2-0()6&&(21* %,33%4,-2(0&% "&7)/(5 )*&7)*&%/62(,-*,'(-+7('/0&%&0)*,),/8',(0 6B&7)' )*&'7/&)+*,4&6&&( 2(01&(2/(&:*/-&1%,()/(1%&1/')%,)/( 2(0&%"&7)/(

)*&7),(0 %1%,()/(1,33%4,-2(0&%"&7)/( )*&7).)*&%&,'('*,4&6&&(%&7%0&0,(0)*&0&(/,- ,33%4,- ()'2'),/(&0!&,%(&072('&- %)*&%&4&(2&*,'(&/)*&%6&&(,6-&) '*:)*,))*&4/&:),H&(6+)*&%/62(,-/'&%%(&2'(%,(+8,)&%/,-( %&7%0 /' '*:( ) *-0 )*,) )*& %0&% )*& %/62(,- /' -&1,--+ 2('2'),/(,6-& '26'),()/,-?2&')/( -,:,%/'&' *&,33&,-/'0/'8/''&0

.(/0/+!

045-!

06+06+

8H #*&)*&%'3&,H/(1D%&,'(&0

&'D #*&)*&%%&3%),6-&

&'D