Ruby Chauhan v. National Institute Of Technology
!" # $% &
&
'( $) !$%$*%+ , %(
& &
- . -
/
0 - /& .
/
.-
!!!!
/
.-
& 2!'34 " # $$% & ' # #
( ")"*$*$+ , -".
, /0
(
$+"$$*$$ , -% 0 /1 0 ( $
( 1 2'$**)
(
( # ( ( 1 / '$*")
/
(
( /
/1 &(( 0
(
( 1/ (&( 3# # +
( 2$"4$*")
5"
# 1 %***4)***4- / (((6 / 0 0 ( 1 ( 1
&7 $5%$%$*")/ &
# ( & "8"$$*")
( 1
(
# 9 $*$$ 0 0 (
(254$*$$ (
#6'
0 #/
1 &7 $*8.)$*$$ / &
# ( &
( ( 6 # #
(
( # ( (( $+"$$*$$
0
( 1 ( 1 # #
( /( . ( 1 0 0
& /101&7 ::+ $*$+ &7 "".*$*$+ & (
"5*"$*$+ ":*"$*$+
1
//1
0 '0 ( 0 #
(
- -
1 (
# ; <1 /1 1 ( / (
=/ 9 $*$$0 / / 610 0'
# $+"$$*$$ 8
>9$*$+
# ( 2")4$*$+ (
; -' ?- "$ # (2"54$*$+
; -'' ?-"* 0 #
0
(0 /( 01
"5 0"+0
; -'' ?-"* 8
; -' ?-"$ ## ; -''
?-"*
(# #
( (((6 %
( $"*:$*$+ "$ ; <1 (&( 3# &7 $"555$*$+ / &
# 1 ( 0 (/
$:*:$*$+0 / 1
1
0
( (
"5*"$*$+
/1 & &7 2::+$*$+ )
$:*:$*$+
/1 & &7 $"555$*$+ 0
&7 $+$.)$*$+/ & (
0 25 % / ( ; 0 "$ 0 #
1 &7 $+$.) $*$+ ( /
( ")"*$*$+'
( 0
(
( / 1 0 1 ( "8** "*@, ,( 0 /(,((8))** (
#
( # /
( 1
(
/1 ( 1 5 &
(")""$*$+ /1 ( """$$*$+ , # /
# : /( (1 0
# (2"54$*$+ 1 0 # 10
/
(
/
( 1 /1 ( 1
/1 0 (1 ( 1
# #/ 0 ( (
/0A ; BA=;9 (# 6
/1 # ( A=;0 "%+ # / / (
(1 /
(/ #
6 6 ( / /
#
0 #
# "* /( 0 (&( 3# #A=;
#
# / /% ( / 1
# -/1 0 0 ## 0 / ( 0 ## 0 /
3 ##
40 #/
##0 1 /0 1 "" ' #( / 0/
"$ ( ## (
6 # (0
- $*") /
(/ 0$+*"$*$+ $+"$$*$$
((
(
; -'' ?-"* / ' ( 0
( /
( /1 ")"*$*$+ 0
/ 0
(/
(
(
?-"* 0#
/
(
(
( 0 1
(
?-"* /
1(
( ( / "+ < ( # #( /
0#6 /1 & C
7
(
(
?-"* (/
7 (1 D
7 0 ##0
/ (
". E9/ (& 5
/ ( 1 / /1 ( 1 ( 1 / /1 ( 1 "8
# /1 2 ' #1 3 $**) B$**)
9 5$**) # : ,
B 9$.
( 1 $% ( /0 . +(6$% '+76%8 '( % (6(*(
96 6($!
!
"" "
# " $
"
% &" "
" ' #
"
"
"
(((( (((( (((( (((( !
" "" '( "
) )" ) '
"
'*
+ ' ""
" , "" *
( "
( "
-
) '
(((( (((( (((( ((((
# $"%
. /
" "" "
0 !
+ ' ' #
"
"
%
1
"
$ "
""
+
2
" (
3 < ( #/6 ' B 9 1
( ( 0 0
/ ( /1& ; ( A (1 ( 0
/ / "% ' , 0 /1 /- $
$%$**)& ; (/12 $+*.$**: ( B < 2 ' #19 B< & ; ( ( 2' /1 $"*)$*") ".*%$*$+& B< 9 B 9 /- B /- 9'< 2' #1 0
0 / (((6
4
4
$$ <
((/ $+
:
( $. # (
(( 1 $5
( , $$ $+ $. $5 /0 4 &! '('
!)'*+ *( ), -,-.,/ *( ), )!((0
1( "
""
'
5*
!
%"
0 ) ' )" ) '
'
' '
, '
'
"
+
-
)
1 0 ' '
' , ' 7# " " '
7# " " ' 8 '
' ' , '6
'
'
' ) '
"
+ -
!%"
2 % 0 9 ' )" 9 9 '
'
'1
' 1( 1 ' : 1 ' 6
' 6
'
0
;
'
" '
'
' <"'
' )
1 "
+ !
" !*'+)-,+)
"
) 9 " "
)
)" )
" !
"
. / %
8 "" "" ' ""
. / "
"" 2
. "
"
"
6 0 9 ) " )"
0 1
'
/ + =
. " "
"
5*
.
( ) )" ) "
5
) )" ) *.
!
>? *6 % + (" '
+ *6 2 ("
*6 = 0 )"
"
*6 (((( (((( (((( (((( @
"
' + '
. '
$ A
" "
" " ( ' "
"
?
' +
" # "" "
"
# # "
' ""
" ! 3'
%4" %" 5 6!" %%4
%%7 8,+,/!&),/- !+9 *+9')'*+ *( ,/ '
,*(,/-!+,+),-&*:,, "
5*
C " '
"" "
"
"
"
"" ' '
C " '
"
(
" '
*
"
5
""
" ( " "
" " ( ; !*'+)-,+) *+ *+)/!
)
?
' +
" "" "
"" "
" ( = !
C " ' + ""
"
"
"
""
" " ( % % 8 #
"" .
"'+ /
. '
$
" +
") < ( # < ( (
(#
( ( / 0
( A 0 #1#
(1(
(( (,((8 1 /
, #+1 / <
(
(/ &(( #& ( .
(/
(# / /( /1 &(( "5 & ; ( (< ( 2' <1 ( $*"" ( /
/ /12'<1 ( $*"+A=; 4
2' F $*"+ ++ (# A=; *.*%$*". $
$*"+ ,
B19 .
(B 4 9/ # ""
/ / <1 ( ( 0
( 1 ( 11 / ;
. ,/1 + #
1 , $*"+
/0 < 9
0
3 '
? (((( (((( (((( (((( 9 = 1!
" 0 8
'
""
'
( " ( (((( (((( (((( (((( .
1( 14 "
))
$
"
? ": ; , 0 $*"+ 0 / /1A ; 2'C /<1 (# (C 1 # 1 , # 0
1 ( 11 /0 !%
> 4>
>," > 1>
> !% %)"4( 14
'
"
"
"
"
#
"
" ""
C ' '
'
"
'
*
' " ""
* ' "
"
'
"
$
"" C '
"
"
+/
/ " ) "" "
' ""
"
(((( (((( (((( (((( ( 14
"
' +
' "
"
4
3 "
' ( " '
1( "
) % %
) 2 '
'
"
;
(((( (((( (((( (((( <)"4( 14
4 "
3
"
&/E /
" "
"
'
' BF=(
6 > 1
;
GHBI # / H=;
J
> >
"
( C (" 3 $* , ' "8*"$*". 1E (E# 3 2' / ((( 6 , 1 ,/ 1 , , /0 6 K
1("
? ?,? & 18 1.0?,/L & (
9 > 4. % % !
%"
8%4 , 1 ?1
/12 ,@
* , 1 A " !%% 1 9 1 A " !
+*%
/ HBBB;*MBF
*
"
) ? ? "
. : !
+*%
/
-FBBB;*
)
"
"
" "
. :
"
"
. : "
- ) # $" ? $+*5$*"+ , '' 19
"8*"$*". 2 ( 1 ( $+*5$*"+ , ( /0 <+" % ( 14
+ 1'
)
146+')7 + 9 >4. % , 1?1
%/12 %!
%"
8%4 ,@
"
= A-+"8%**-
"
? +:"**0; %***4- ( ""
)
(" " "
+ +*% =HBB*%A BB
/ / HBBB;* "
* "
) C
' BI
0 ' (
"
$
" !=I
(
" + / "
" ) (" '
"
/ F'BBB;* "
$$ # $., ' $*"" (10' (/ ( 0 / 0 # (1/
0;%***4-1 0/1 + 1 , //1( 1 1 ((
&(( # $. /0 G!2
"
))
)
" *
" '
6
/ 9HBBBBB
" ' (
.
' C "
' N )" " ) '
(" "
#
$ $ " '
""
)
" ' ""
)#
'
"
$ .89'
( (" ?
"" )' "
""
"
8 ' "
)
" ' "" " "
+*%
! * "
6
0 '
8' ' "
(
H 3," 1 %5 # (# $*"+ ( / (((6 ; ( $*"" 0 #
(
( 00 $*"+
# 1 $+ < ( ; / # 01
0 # / /1( 0 # /
$*"" / 0 $*"+
(
/( 6
( B( 119 $.
$*") / 6
/101 ; 0 /1
$"*)$*") / /1 01 B39 <
$+ < 0 ( ( /- .
I $+ /0 42
. ' "
"
"
:
. / +
=
$
""
( ) '"
"
O1>
. #
""
( )
' 5*
) )" ) *.
!
>? *6 %
(" '
+ *6 2
(" *6 =
0 )"
8
" )" )
*63 3," 1 %5 $8
/- .
$+ &((, / / ( 0/1& ; ( /- $+
6 ( I
( ( /
B39 &((( # ((
( ( & ( .(/ , B39 /0
%1B, G !%=
J ?1
% " % %
" !
%"
.!& $&
68%'(6$%1 ';
'%# '%# +'# ,6+ !'# ';
%(6'3 <*'36)6+'(6$% %(6'3 =*6! , %( *,*3'(6"
%(6'3 ! #6( $6%(
"
$
+
.
"
=
1 A -+ 0 ; 1
%*** 2'?
2'?
$
=
1 A -+ 0 ;
1
)*** = 1 , #
' ' 1 "* +
1 A -+0; 1
5***0(((
1
+**** 1 , 1 # , ( '
( ?/ ' 1 $* + 6!" %%7 <67
"
"
. '( " "
(" -
/ * ""
'
"
, * B ( F . . ' " , *
6 ( F . . " "
"
"
'
. ' " 3 3," 1 %5 $8"
2' ( B39
/101 ".*%$*$+( ( / ( &( 2$ 2" $ ( &(2$ 2" $ /0
1+ 4 '/ * ""
, * B 6 ( F . . " "
"
"" . / .
'
3 1 " 4 '/ * ""
, *
6 ( F . . " "
"
"" . / .
'
3 $% < ( # $**) <
( $*"" ( $*"+ #
0#
( $**)1 (1(#2' #1
'1 $**:, 0 /1 $**); ( <
< ( 1; ( ( $*"" 0(/ / /1$*"+ # #0 0 / (
0 6
( #
$*")6 ( I
( ( 0 / /101 #
A1 $*") ( ( ; (
B39
$) ; (( < /1 $"*)$*") B39 /#6 ( I
( ( (/
2" $ / ( /1 ".*%$*$+ 2" $
(
0 ; 1 %***4- )***4-,
B
9 0 /1,
B 9 $5 (1
(
0; 1 %***4- )***4-/ ( # 4 (/
, (
( / ' /1 ; 1 %***4- )***4- ?"*I""
1
&
/ #(
( 1((/ /( / (
/ 6
6 ( 0 ( 4 /- $5 A 0
( (1
( , #81 ' A (1
1
/ 1 (
/ , #+1 /- "*
$+ A 0 (
(
# 0 # ( # ( &
( / "$ ( /- $+ 0
/ /1 A (1 -
&(( < /- I "* $+ $5<
( /0 G !*'+)-,+) @ 7 "
' +
. '
$
?
'
+
" # "" "
"
# # "
' ""
" ! ,,, ,,, ,,, ,,, ; !*'+)-,+) *+ *+)/!
)
?
'
+
" "" "
"" "
" ( = !
C " ' +
"" "
"
"
""
" " ( % % 8 #
"" .
"'+ /
. '
$
" +
H $:
/- $+ /
&(( #
/ / /1 ( /1
( # /- I $+
$5(
( / (1/( /1A # &(('
( ( A
A (1
/ ' $**) (/ # ( #
(
( B / /( /1 &((0 8((/
#((/ ' +*
$.$**)
( /( /1A 0 0
<
/ 1
( /
, (
( # /( (/ # #(/ ,
B 9 ( $ B39<
/ ' # / 0$**) < ( 0$*"+
0; 0 1
(B / 9, ( 1 B39#/ (
-"* ""
(1/
/1A # -((, ( '#
( / (/ 2
(
/ /
2 B39 1
/# # (0 1
(1/ # (?-"*?- ""0 (
B 9 ( /?"*I""
# 1
(/ +" # $., ' $*""
(B 9 0'0
( # (/0/# # 0 #
( '
( 1B 9 # /( (# $*"+ (
(((6 # ,
B19 /1 $
'(
1 / +$
( # #( (
( ?"*I""
/( /1 1 &(('
( ?"*I""
01
(
#
( # (1 (
( - ( 1 / #
0$*"+ - (( $+ "* $5 < '0# (
/1
(
?-"*I""
(( /1 1 &(( 0#
'
( ( /1 - &(( 0 0# 0 / B 9 ++ & A 4> C D % * 2E"92 %* >6#7
( ( 1/ & / ( #
( ( 1 / # , ( ( #
/1
( / & # J ( 1
0( "*1 ( #( , #( (& E"92 "
/0 42%
'
$ "
"
. . '
"
"
2 # "
$
2
H .
'
"
" '
.
'
""
"" "
$ "'
""
"" '
""
'
""
'
' " "
" ("
""
" "
#
"" '
" '
'
"" "
" "
" " " "
" "" '
$
0 .
!!H . '
"
'
'"
3," 1 %5 2A
"
#
" #
"" .
' ' "
#
" "
"6 '
"
" "" "
"
" ' "" "
"
#" ""
7 ""
'
# "
.
'
"
"
""
2 H . 3 3," 1 %5 +. #( K ; ( ( # J 1 (1( 1 0 ( "*1 /1$**%0 # J +8 0,
/1& A E"92
67 / /1 (& / 6 #( 5*
1& A %294 % %* >6;7
& ( / 1( ( 1 (
( ( / - #(
(
# /
( ( 1 / /
( ( 00# / / 1 +% 1 (#
/#
/ / / ( '
0
( / / (
( ( 1/
0 -/1# 1 ( (
(( 1 /
:
# 1 E #
(# # / / /
(
?"*I""
/ ( # /
(
?"*I""
/( (/ (
( / / +) '0 /
# /1
#(
(
?"*I""
(/ #( 1 / 0
0 # +5 (
#0 /
# # 1 ( 11
/
# /0 /
# # &=&-""5-$*$. #0
1 ( /( ( #0 ( 1 6 /# 5 # 0 1E 1 #1
# # ## 0 , 1 $)*$$*$.
( /0 4%
" " " $ )"
"
"
""
'
"
"
$
2
)
" $ " B@
"# "609)"
' # / D
..6
"
" $ " B@
"# "609)"
=
0 ' ." 1
" 5*
8 )
6
8
";
" .
;
" 8
)"
$ / 8
" $
"
;"
)
6
$ #
' $ # / 8
$ H2
BH / 8
#*"
9 ;.
;
" ; / 8
);6
" "
8 (
(*9;%3 +:
# # #
& 1E 0 ( ( 1( $*"$$**" 1E 0 ""*+$**+ 1E
# 5 # 0 , ((
$*"$$**" ""*+$**+ /0 - (( !
#'( # & &
4!
)
@ P B "#
9
"
&%% 0
6 > ?%B*2;!BBB*
!B ) '!BB '
6
8 # * / 1
E 9
1 E
(((( (((( (((( (((( %
' "
8 # /1
9
) ' .9 )"
'
&/.' .
1 "
7
.
AA=
"
" "
.9 ""
6 ;)"
&/. # +
' /
8 # / 1
9
#
((( ((( ((( (((
"" " 6
09) 9
;
;
"'
"
) ;.9 9!BBBB "
"
9 BBB "
.9
)"
"
("
9
;
"$ "
1
?1 4
% ( 4 ( @4 +1;+
;6 1$
9@BBB" 9ABBB" 61;6
;6++ 1$
9A=BB" 9 BBBB" 3," 1 %5 .* < ( 1 6
1E
#5 0 # 0 ##0
### 1 1 E
1# 1 1 # ( 10
1 (# /
#
###
( /
/0
# #( ." '0 /
# &
(
(
?"*I""
(/ ( /
#(1 / /1 # 1
# #
1 #
/1 1 .$ / ( /
(
#1 (
' /1 (
(
0 /
##
4 4( 1/ (
6
0"8 1 ( 1 #( # 1 .+ A #0 #('0
(/ (# / & ( 1
( # /1
3 1 1 1 / #' 1
#J/ ##
( (
# (
( # /
( ( 1 -/ /
.-
*"*8$*$.
7
#4 L 42 9" L;?