High Court of Punjab and HaryanaVATAP/18/2019dismissed

M/S Siddhartha Bronze Products (P) Ltd., Gurgaon v. State Of Haryana And Others

2020-01-20Mr. Justice Ajay Tewari,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan9 pages

!"#$% & ''(( ) * + ,' ! " # ! "" $%&%'(

$)*+,-'+.($+/0,1)(% $(.%)22%33)'(

&)'+&.)%&.)4)$+)/ %25(60,1)(%%'%$)3/)$6)') --*.*/%$. .%)22%33)'(.)& +3%0(4)22%)3&7%)$+'-&

)'08

5'0%$"%1(+'9: (.%)$6)'))35%00%0);1(/

9< $&.$(/ (.%1( = $)&&%&&>%'(6%)$&

@)'0

A& &+>+3)$+&&5%+&+',3,%0/7(.(.%)22%)3&)$%7%+'-0%1+0%0761>>' $0%$$(.%&)B% 1',%'+%'1%/ )1(& $>

.),% 7%%'()B%'334+'-&57&()'(+)3C5%&(+'& 3)4.),%7%%'13)+>%0 D<)= #.%(.%$ +' (.% )1(& )'0 1+$15>&()'1%& (.% 1)&%/ "()(5($6 '(+1% +' $> ?

+&&5%0 +' (.% ')>%

5*)$)( +& '( +33%-)3 )'0 >)B%& (.% )&&%&&>%'( 7)0 )7+'+(+/4.%'(.%*5$+&0+1(+' (.%)&&%&&+'-)5(.$+(6 +&1'

+'%0((.%75'0)$+%& (.%"()(%'36E

<7= #.%(.%$+'(.% )1(&)'01+$15>&()'1%& (.%1)&%(.% $%)&&%&&>%'()'01'&%C5%'(+)32%')32$1%%0+'-&)$%'( 7)$$%0763+>+()(+'E <1= #.%(.%$+'(.% )1(&)'01+$15>&()'1%& (.%1)&%/(.% 2$1%%0+'- $3%,6 2%')3(64+(.5(&()(5($6'(+1%+'

$>)$%3%-)32$1%%0+'-&E <0= #.%(.%$+'(.% )1(&)'01+$15>&()'1%& (.%1)&%/4.%'

(.%$%1$0+&&%+F%076(.%%'($)3;1+&%5(.$+(+%&)'0 '015>%'(),)+3)73%%')73+'-(.%)22%33)'((0+&13&% +(&&)3%75((.%(5$',%$+&2)$( )3)'1%".%%(/(.% (5$',%$)>5'(&(&522$%&&%0(5$',%$)'0&57*%1(( 2%')3)1(+'E <%= #.%(.%$+'(.% )1(&)'01+$15>&()'1%& (.%1)&%/4.%'

(.%(5$',%$4.+1.+&2)$( 7B& )115'(75(1530 '( $% 3%1(%0 +' (.% $%(5$'& 7%1)5&% $%1$0 +'

2&&%&&+' (.%%'($)3;1+&%5(.$+(+%&/2%')3(61)'

7% +>2&%0 $ &522$%&&+' (5$',%$ 4.%' (.% 2$1%%0+'-&)$%(.$5-.7)'B%$&)'0756%$/),)+3%0)'0 7()+'%0+'25(();1$%0+(+'(.%"()(%+(&%3 EG .% )1(&)$%(.)((.%)22%33)'(+&)573+1!+>+(%01>2)'6 )'04)&$%-+&(%$%05'0%$(.%1()&)3&5'0%$(.%%'($)3")3%&);1(/ @:.%0%)3%$4)&%'-)-%0+'''?

%$$5&>%()3&.),+'-+(&&)3%

+1% +'5$-)'.%C5)$(%$36$%(5$'&4%$% +3%0+'(4C5)$(%$36$%(5$'&/'+3 (5$',%$4)&0%13)$%0.%)&&%&&>%'(5'0%$"%1(+' @<9= (.%1(4)&

+')3+&%0' 9

'(.%(5$',%$0+&13&%0+'(.%$%(5$'& --$+%,%0 (.%)&&%&&>%'($0%$/)22%)34)& +3%0.% &(

9 22%33)(%5(.$+(6$%>)'0%0(.%>)((%$7)1B((.%&&%&&+'-

+1%$ $

$%&.)&&%&&>%'(76-$)'(+'-'%>$%22$(5'+(6 7%+'-.%)$0.% $%>)'04)&-+,%'%

%1((,+0%$0%$0)(%08

.%0%2)$(>%'( $%1%+,%0+'

$>)(+' $>&>%2%$&'(.)((.%)22%33)'(.)01'051(%0 &)3%&+' '0 )'09$0 C5)$(%$ (.%&)+0)&&%&&>%'(6%)$((.%(5'%

@/9A/:

/ A9H?)'0 @/ /A /:8@H?$%&2%1(+,%36/(.% (); $(.%&)>%.)& 7%%'1.)$-%075('+3$%(5$'&4%$% +3%0(+1% $$%?)&&%&&>%'(5'0%$ "%1(+' A (.%1(4)&+&&5%0)'00%>)'0 9 /8A/

@H?4)&1$%)(%0( 4)&7&%$,%0+'(.%$0%$(.)()1(+' $2%')3(65'0%$"%1(+'9 (.%1( 4+337%()B%'&%2)$)(%36.%$0%$ $%?)&&%&&>%'(4)&)11%2(%076(.% )22%33)'()'0')22%)34)& +3%0(+1%0)(%0@8

4)&+&&5%0 $ 2%')3)1(+''%)22%)$%0'7%.)3 (.%)22%33)'()'0,+0%$0%$ 0)(%0 @

/2%')3(6 / /8@/

@H?4)&+>2&%05'0%$"%1(+'9

(.%1(.%)22%)3 +3%07% $%(.% &(22%33)(%5(.$+(64)&0+&>+&&%0 '

9 5$(.%$ )22%)3 +3%0 7% $% (.% )$6)') ); $+75')3/ .)'0+-)$.< $&.$(/ (.%$+75')3 =)3&>%((.%&)>% )(%--$+%,%0

(.%$0%$0)(%0 8@

2)&&%076(.%$+75')3/(.%2$%&%'()22%)3+& +3%0 #.+3%)$-5+'-(.%)22%)3/(.%'36+&&5%)00$%&&%0+&4+(. $%-)$0(+>2&+(+')'0&5&()+'+'- 2%')3(6%&2%1+)3364.%'(.%(5$',%$ 1530'(7%B%2(5( 7B& )115'( .%2+'?2+'(%0C5%&(+'(7%1'&+0%$%0+&D4.%(.%$+'(.%

)1(&)'01+$15>&()'1%& (.%1)&%(.%2%')3(6 $&522$%&&+' (5$',%$ 1)'7%&5&()+'%04.%'(.%(5$',%$4)&$% 3%1(%0+'(.%7B& )115'(EG ',+%4 (.%0+&15&&+'>)0%+'(.%3)(%$2)$( (.%*50->%'(/ (.%C5%&(+'+&)'&4%$%0)-)+'&((.%)22%33)'(

8 "%1(+'& @< =(<9=)'09 (.%1()$%$%2$051%07%34 D 01 & (

< = .% $%(5$'& 5$'+&.%0 76 ) 0%)3%$ &.)33 7% 0536 )1B'43%0-%0 +' (.% >)''%$ 2$%&1$+7%0/ )'0 4.%$% )33 (.% $%(5$'&$%3)(+'-()')&&%&&>%'(6%)$.),%7%%' +3%0)'0)$% 1>23%(%+'>)(%$+)32)$(+153)$&/(.%0%)3%$&.)33/&57*%1(((.% 2$,+&+'& &57?&%1(+'< =/7%0%%>%0(.),%7%%')&&%&&%0

$(.)(6%)$ (.)(4.%$%(.%$%(5$'&)$%'(1>23%(%+'>)(%$+)3 2)$(+153)$&/(.%0%)3%$&.)337%-+,%')'22$(5'+(6(1>23%(% (.%> < = "57*%1(((.%$53%&4.+1.(.%"()(%,%$'>%'(>)6

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

@ $%(5$'$%3)(+'-((.%)&&%&&>%'(2%$+0$/(.%)1(5)30)(%4.%' )'6$%(5$'$%3)(+'-((.%)&&%&&>%'(2%$+0.)&7%%' +3%03)&(/ 4.+1.%,%$+&3)(%$ <9='(.%0)6&2%1+ +%0+'(.%'(+1%$)&&') (%$4)$0&)& >)6 7%/ (.% )&&%&&+'- )5(.$+(6 &.)33/ ) (%$ .%)$+'- &51.

%,+0%'1%)&(.%0%)3%$>)62$051%)'0&51.(.%$%,+0%'1%)& +(>)6$%C5+$%'&2%1+ +%02+'(&/)&&%&&(.%)>5'( ();05%

$>.+> (.)('$0%$5'0%$(.+&&57?&%1(+'&.)337%2)&&%0 ) (%$(.%%;2+$6 (.$%%6%)$& $>(.%13&% (.%6%)$( 4.+1.(.%)&&%&&>%'($%3)(%& ;;;;;; 3( 1

) %)3%$ .)& >)+'()+'%0 )3&% $ +'1$$%1( )115'(& $ 015>%'(&4+(.),+%4(&522$%&&+'-.+&&)3%&/25$1.)&%&/ +>2$(&+'("()(%/%;2$(&5( "()(%/$&(1B&/ -0&/$ .)&1'1%)3%0)'62)$(+153)$&+'$%&2%1((.%$% $.)& 5$'+&.%0 ($2$051%07% $%)'6)5(.$+(65'0%$(.+&1($(.%$53%& >)0%(.%$%5'0%$)'6)115'(/$%(5$'/015>%'($+' $>)(+'

4.+1. +& )3&% $ +'1$$%1( +' )'6>)(%$+)3 2)$(+153)$/ &51. )5(.$+(6 >)6/ ) (%$ )

$0+'- &51. 0%)3%$ ) $%)&')73% 22$(5'+(6 7%+'-.%)$0/0+$%1(.+>(2)6764)6 2%')3(6/ +')00+(+'((.%();(4.+1..%+&)&&%&&%0$+&3+)73%(7% )&&%&&%0/)&5>(.$+1%(.%)>5'( ();4.+1.4530.),% 7%%' ),+0%0 .)0 &51. )115'(/ $%(5$'/ 015>%'( $

: +'

$>)(+'/)&(.%1)&%>)67%/7%%')11%2(%0)&($5%)'0 1$$%1(G !%)$'%015'&%3 $(.%)22%33)'()$-5%0(.)((.%-0&+'

C5%&(+'4%$%$%1%+,%0764)6 &(1B($)'& %$)-)+'&( $> $> 5*)$)()'0&()(5($6 $>&"?9 4%$%+&&5%0.%-0&4%$%&30(

H&+'0)3"()+'3%&&"(%%3&!(0 $4.+1."?9 $>&4%$%+&&5%0)'0 %,%'?81%$(+ +1)(%&4%$%-+,%'76(.%)22%33)'(&(.)((.%25$1.)&%$1)' 13)+>+'25(();1$%0+(.%1'(%'(+'+&(.)((.%&)3%&1530'(7%B%2(5( 7B& )115'()'0(.%$%4)&'C5%&(+' &522$%&&+'(+& 5$(.%$ )$-5%0(.)( $)>+$)(.4.4)&)5(.$+&%0( +3%(.%$%(5$'&/23)6%0 >+&1.+% )'00+0'(0+&13&%(.%(5$',%$ (4C5)$(%$&+'(.%$%(5$'&/ .%'1% ' 1)&% $ 2%')3(6 5'0%$ "%1(+' 9 (.% 1( +& >)0% 5( $-5>%'(+&75(($%&&%076&()(+'-(.)((.%$%4)&'>)3) +0%+'(%'(+'

1'1%)3>%'( &)3%&+'(.%C5)$(%$36$%(5$'& .% 1'(%'(+'& >)0% )$% '( 4%33?

5'0%0 ' $0%$ ( )22$%1+)(%(.%%

%1( '(&.4+'-(.%&)3%&+'(4C5)$(%$36$%(5$'&/ &1.%>% (.%1(4+(.$%-)$0()&&%&&>%'('%%0&(7%-'%+'( $>"%1(+' @< = (.%1(/+(+&%,+0%'((.)(+(+&'(+')33 (.% 1)&%& (.)( )&&%&&>%'( +& $)>%0 .% $%(5$' +3%0 4.+1. +& 0536 )1B'43%0-%0&57*%1(((.%2$,+&+'& &57?&%1(+'< = "%1(+' @

(.%1(+&0%%>%0(.),%7%%')&&%&&%0 $(.%6%)$'1)&%(.%$%(5$'

+3%0 +& +'1>23%(% )& 2%$ (.% 2$,+&/ )' 22$(5'+(6 +& 2$,+0%0 ( 1>23%(%(.%&)>%&2%$&57?&%1(+'< = "%1(+' @ (.%1(/(.% ,%$'>%'(.)&( $)>%$53%& $&%3%1(+' 1)&%& $&1$5(+'6(+&'36 +'(.%&%3%1(%01)&%& (.)(2$%&1$+7%0'(+1%+&+&&5%0((.%)&&%&&%%( 2$051%$(1)5&%(7%2$051%0)'6%,+0%'1%(&522$((.%$%(5$'&

+3%0 %)'+'-(.%$%76/+'1)&%(.%$%(5$' (.%)&&%&&%%0%&'( )33 4+(.+'(.%&1$5(+'61$+(%$+)/ +3+'- (.%$%(5$'45307%1'&+0%$%0)& 0%%>%0)&&%&&>%'( '(.%2$%&%'(1)&%/+'&2+(% (.% )1((.)((.%)&&%&&>%'(4)&

+')3+&%05'0%$"%1(+' @<9= (.%1(/(.%(5$',%$)&&.4'+'(.% $%(5$'&4)&)&&%&&%0.%)22%33)'( +3%0)')22%)3)'0(.% >)((%$4)& $%>)'0%07)1B%,%'(.%$%) (%$(.%&522$%&&%0(5$',%$4)&'%,%$7$5-.( ((.%'(+1% (.%&&%&&+'-

+1%$/$)(.%$(.%$%(5$'& +3%04%$%2$%&&%0 52'.% )1(&0+&30-%(.%)$-5>%'($)+&%0 (4)&)&)$%&53( +'

$>)(+'-+,%'76)2%$&'1''%1(%0 4+(.(.%75&+'%&&(.)((.%&)3%&>)0%76(.%)22%33)'(+' '0)'09$0C5)$(%$ &)4(.%3+-.( 0)6(45307%2%$(+'%'(('(%)((.+&&()-%(.)(+(+&'( 0+&25(%076(.%)22%33)'((.)(();4)&05361.)$-%0 $>(.%25$1.)&%$75( '(0%2&+(%0 "%1(+'9 (.%1(%',+&)-%&+>2&+(+' 2%')3(64.%$%) $%(5$' 5$'+&.%0+& )3&%$+'1$$%1(+')'6>)(%$+)32)$(+153)$'(.%1)&% +'.)'0/(.%)22%33)'(.)0&511%&& 5336&522$%&&%0(.%(5$',%$'('36+'

(.%$%(5$'&75()3&+'2$1%%0+'-&5'0%$"%1(+' @<9= (.%1()'0(.% ();1.)$-%04)&+33%-)336$%()+'%076(.%)22%33)'('&51.%,%'(/%,%'+

(.%($)'&)1(+'4)&0+&13&%0+'(.%7B& )115'(+( 4+337% ' 7%'% +( $%,%$/"%1(+'9 (.%1(+&4$0%0+')>)''%$(.)(+( )223+%&'('36(>)+'()+'+'- )3&%$+'1$$%1()115'(75()3&( +3+'- +'1$$%1($ )3&%$%(5$'&/4.+1.(.%)22%33)'(0+0+'(.%2$%&%'(1)&% .%1'(%'(+' (.%)22%33)'((.)(>+&1.+% 4)&1>>+((%076 )5(.$+&%0$%2$%&%'()(+,%?

$)>+$)(..)&$+-.(367%%'$%*%1(%076(.% $+75')376&()(+'-(.)('7%'% +(1530.),%7%%'0%$+,%076 $)>

+$)(.76&522$%&&+'-(.%&)3%&+'C5%&(+')'0 +3+'- )3&%$%(5$'&.% &),+'- ();/+ )'6/4)&((.%)22%33)'( .%$%+&)'(.%$)&2%1( (.%>)((%$.%)22%33)'(+&)2573+1 3+>+(%01>2)'6(+& .)$0(7%3+%,%(.)('%)5(.$+&%0$%2$%&%'()(+,%

+3%0(.%$%(5$'4+(.5((.%&)>%7%+'-,%$+ +%0,%'+ $(.%&)B%

)$-5>%'(/(.%$%4)&)>+&()B%/(.%&)>%4)&75'0(7%.+-.3+-.(%005$+'- (.%)&&%&&>%'(2$1%%0+'-& ((.+&&()-%/4%>)60%)34+(.(.%)5(.$+(+%&$%3+%052'76 3%)$'%015'&%3 $(.%)22%33)'(%3+)'1%' 4 -( () 1( $!

" 556 70%&'(%'.)'1% (.%1)&% (.%)22%33)'('(.)(1)&%/(.%)22%33)'(4)&)&&%&&%0(();' (.%&)3% 4%(-$+'0%$&/(.%23%) (.%)22%33)'((.)(.%4)&&%33+'-+(&2)$(& '36/&)>%4)&$%*%1(%0'(.&%&%( )1(&+(4)&.%30(.)(+(4)&'() 1)&% $3%,6 2%')3(6)&(.%&)3%&4%$%&.4'75((.%13)+> &)3%2)$(& +'&(%)04%(-$+'0%$4)&$%*%1(%0 ' 1 & 8 5 ) 5/$

55!9" 7:/+(4)&.%30(.)(75$0%'3+%&'(.% $%,%'5%(%&()73+&.(.)((.%0+&25(%0)>5'($%2$%&%'(&+'1>%)'0(.% )&&%&&%%.)&1'&1+5&361'1%)3%0(.%2)$(+153)$& +'1>%$0%3+7%$)(%36

5$'+&.%0+')115$)(%2)$(+153)$&.%*50->%'(+& '.%32.%1'051(

(.%)22%33)'(+&%,+0%'( $>(.% )1((.)((.%();1.)$-%076(.%)22%33)'( 4)&$%()+'%0/'+3$%(5$'& $(4C5)$(%$&4%$% +3%0/(.%(5$',%$4)&'( 0+&13&%0%,%'+'(.%15$&% )&&%&&>%'()'0+(4)&'36'(.%7)&+& ) 1>23)+'($%1%+,%0(.)(&522$%&&%0(5$',%$15307%();%0 '* (#) ;

$ 6!

"55 7/(.%"52$%>%5$(.%30(.)(2%')3(61)''(7%+>2&%0>%$%36'

)+35$%(1)$$65(&()(5($673+-)(+'(+&) C5)&+?1$+>+')32$1%%0+'- )'05'3%&&(.%2)$(6.)&)1(%00%3+7%$)(%36+'0% +)'1% 3)4$-5+3(6

1'051(1'(5>)1+5&$0+&.'%&(/(.%2%')3(6&.530'(7%+>2&%0.% 1'051( (.%)22%33)'(+'(.%2$%&%'(1)&%+&0+&15&&%0)7,%('36(.% (5$',%$4)&&522$%&&%075((.%)22%33)'(4)&7%'% +((%076$%()+'+'-(.% ();1.)$-%0 $>(.%25$1.)&%$ .% &5&()+'+'- 2%')3(6 76 (.% $+75')3 4)$$)'(& ' +'(%$ %$%'1% .%)22%)3&)$%0+&>+&&%0 !--*.*/%"

!.<-=,/"

.>%-.>%-

>B #.%(.%$&2%)B+'-H$%)&'%0

%&H #.%(.%$$%2$()73%

%&H