Gurraj Singh And Another v. State Of Punjab And Others



  
        
   

 

 !

 "# " 

 ! $!% !& "# " 



 

           

     

  
&  '( "

)
 )  )

 

    ! "#$!%&'($#)

 #'

(*# %&'($# +(!,(

-.#'/# #!% , /&'($##.%  #0 11111 )  )



"

"

 /'(- !2#
(&#/

&$('&!3( 0/ '   (+  $(  456  (+  !  !##/#  # #-  #-!#  #!#%  5758% !#+0 +&#9 :%!,,(!#0+.&0/! ,(  +(  ;

#!  (+     (5<7  &#&  =5575>%  &  $( 4?5@%6?@%5A?5@%=?8@%=7%5=A%586%85=B $(586#&85=#&&& .#(C(+!!##/# /#/# #!#%5758%(.$ #(#.( % $   # #?

(!#.@ 5

 
!..!+#$D  +(D$(&#!#!#0('
D(& $#D(0 (!#D(+!# '"+(+ #!

* D# "##&0/!#0('
#D&$(D,.##!#(<5575>%!

5
!#&'&!,!"#D./#&, !#D#%"!(.'&!(  (5>8% $(
58%  "  /  $.#'  *!##%  $  (!#.  $$(&  ( $(D,.##!,!"!#&, $!#&#(!,.(%,.( (86 #& #!2 !( #&!"## $( $(! ,("!$!!#& #.#&/#$!&(+( &#(.'.$$(& ($(D,.##(65575> !D( !#.( "!!,!"#&!"+ !#!#!#& ((! #0('
D(&,.(%"!!$( $("#,(  8

"#+ !#.. &0/!$(D,.##!###0( 777 % 6
= -(",($#D!#&#&!

. +.!/#0 (!D% "!!/"#+(D#&#$%+(..("&0/###$- ,(!D"!! !.,  (+  0$-0# $$(&  (  $(D,.##  (  (+  !  #0('
D(& ##.#"##D&"!#,#&#&(!"!$-,$(D,.## "!!%!,!"#&!,!"E"+&( #"#/+(D!,(( #'!D.'%!/" ( &&0/!#0('
#D&##.##&# ## . "#.# $!& ,( !D$$(& ( $(D,.##!#0('
D(&## .%!!#& ++&

(!!#&#&.+#D"!! !.,(+!#,(0 $ > !$(D,.##+ !#&!#!&#'( ( #"#/ +(D!,((#'!.++(D!$.

$!(+##.#%!+..&("#& !#+%!##.## &!,!"%!"+#&!.#0( "(- (!,(!$(D,.##+ ! 0D&!#!/!#&$#D&+(!., #&  !#+%  ##.#  +.&  +(D  !  ,(  $$(&  (  $(D,.##% !#+%!"# (#&D&!!(,#.0/#+&(+!,!"#& !#!#D(+!,(%"!(!#&.# $!&##$- ,(!D"  #

8
 !((+ $!#  !$#/ #,#&#& $!#  !$#/ !!#, (0 $ 4

!$#(+!,($ (!#'"(+#0('
D(& #D+(D#. (+!$#"#.(& &#&!' #(#- , A !,,(!#0+.&0/!,(# #"!(D !##.. #(!#!/" D#.+.$ 

(! ,((+$(D,.##"!!!.,(+,#&#&!#,& &(0 $ <

#& 6

  !#  0  $(&&  (  0!#.+  (+  !  ,(  !#  ! ,(#($%"!(!#'($(DD&#/(++$$$(& ( .#&$( .+(!,(+#$($&%###&0/! $(D,.##%!#&'#-,.#$#&!#"!#((, F! ,((,#"#/"!!.#&&,(,/%#+#.$#!#0,.#&

,(!,("!!!.,(+$(D,.## !#0+ !$(&& 0/.#&$( .+(!,(!#+#$!,$(+.#&%"!! $( $(0/!,!"(+$(D,.##"#0 #&0.( &(! ,(%#&!#(!0#(+(D+( &&($ D#&'.(,#D./ H# "# '.(,'I&E!#&#-&$.#D('!#0('
D(& ,$(+.#&0/!(" #,.( (86$$(& (.#&$( .+( !,(!#0('
D(&&'.(,!#& ((!2!#! +( &! # (+,( (5(&($ D,( $&(!#'0  &0/!,(##$(+(  .$$+#'( (+#0('
#D&&'.(,!.#&$( .+(!,(!#+ !$(&& !#"!!,($#D(-("#0( !#0('
D(&+( /% !/DD&#./+.&#$(D,.#0+(!,(.$#&##$(; $(+

>
#0('
D(& %! #&(+G H# "# '.(,'I&E

&$#.$ (&/ =

#&&((#0('%!.#&$( .+(!,(!# #.($(&&!#"! #&(#0('
D(&,$(+.#&'#$'.  !#0+.&0/!,( (5%#&!#0('
D(&$'. % !.#&3( !# &#

$((&%0 &,

$((& ,#&  0/  !  .#&  3(   !  ,!"  (+  $(D,.##  &  (  # $( $(! ,(,.#&$( .+(!,("! #&( #0('
D(&'(.#((+(&(+!3( %!,(!##.#&/0 D('&0+(!3(  7 J!.0#-  ,(!#0('
D(&+#$#&$$ D#$ (+!$#%!.#&$( .+(!,(!## &!#!  ;

(!#0.(& &(!0#(+(
2%+#.#&D# #/ ( &%#&!#(

/%"!#('%"#'+.$&0/!,(

,(!,((+$(D,.###&!#$('#$"!,(.$(++$#.# +#.$#!#0,.#&# #!D/$.#D !#!#0('
D(&  (! 0 ##0 (+,($(+.#"%!.#&$( .+(! ,(!#  &+(!2$(+2#
(&#/

&$('&! 3( #&;

#!(+  
 %!.#& #$( .!#$(&&!#!  !;

(!#0.(& &#!#$(+$(D,.##%"!(!#& ++& 

!$&%#&!#!D(/(+$(D,.## D!# '

"! #&(

/ ++&0/!#& ./ ,,(&#&$((0(#&0/! D&$#.'&$ !##.(0$(&&0/.#& #$( .!#' +!$(((+,(;

#!+#$!#!/#("(+!#0('
#&

4
,$(+.#&%"!$( $("#0 #&%(!##(&,#&0/ 3'.3( "#+#'( (+!,(%'!&&(D#!#! ,(!#& (# !(+.$

(!,((+!# '%! $(D,.##$$(& (.#& #$( .'+!#&(+,( "! #&('(.#((+

$((&,#&0/!3( #$$,&( 0 (+#$'#.

%!,(!#& ((.$$(+.$

/( !,((+$(D,.##J!.$.#D !#!($(,+(2$(+ 2#
(&#/

&$(!#$#%!#0$(&&0/.#& #$( .!#!,,(&'(&(+D#&&'&D#. 5 !$(&!#0, &$#+ ../ 8 $#+ ., #.(+$(&!("!#!,$#!(. ( &#-0/!,(!#!/#("(+!,(,/%"!! $( $("#0 #&0/ !,!"(+$(D,.##% #&!# '(.#((+(&,#&0/!3( !$(D,.###&!,!"" #  $( $(  ('  !  #0('
D(&  ,(,/  (  !  #-  (+ # D%'+!#0('
D(&#&(+!,(#-(0  %#, #.(+ !("!##.. #(# #!,(#"!  #&($#  (+

/"!!!.,(+!#,& &"#,((!0(&/(+ $(D,.##!#0('
D(&#.. #(0 .#&(#! $#% !0/!.&!#!&, "! #&(("!,(+!,.(;

(!# (! (&("!!$(DD((+#.. &(++$%#&D/(,(! (&,#&0/!3( !3'. "! #&(

$(!#( 0# (!,$# > J! #&(,##D+(;

#! (+ !.'#.#" !#0.#&&("0/! (E0. ,D3( (+ &#!$#(+

A

*+ ,-+

!.

+ / $%/$   /"

(/"

"

)/+/ .

+*+ + */ + +!

/*

!  ,!

,2,!+3 44+3

"55 .

 #1!#,$0&! &. "!! $#0;

#!&!,$,.#!#
@(.$!#!# (/ !#&& / &!.'#,('( (+!3(&(+3D#.($& $(#&3!#,K (+ !3(&(' #(#$( F#0.(++$L @3( "( .&(!"##/' #((!$( F#0. (++$L @ (./$#"!($( F#0.(++$((++$(+#/ -&&$.(&!++(D#(,(!#!3( "..

(,D#' #(( ((L '@  !  ,("  (+  ;

#!  !( .&  0  2$&  ,# ./  "!

$$ D,$(%#!#0(0'&%!G#(+#$# ?((0$(+ &"!!+(D#(!$(2(+&#! ,#./@L '@ J!.2#D # H$(D,.#%;

#! (+"!$!( !% !$( $#(D0#- ,(#;

/#(!.#0./(    (  (!"  (+  !  #.. #(  D#&    !  H$(D,.#L '@ 3D#.,($& ( !((0$ .&#!#.# L '@ M #! (+#$(D,.#H !( .&0#2$,(#!!## (&#/ .L '@&#./%!$( #0#&+(D  , !

&$((+ !,(.$%$!"(( #(+! #(,#"(,$+$ ,!(+#$'#&(( !((#&('!(! ,!L 2@ !+ $((+!

&$#/#&!,(.$#$(D,.D#/% (('.#,, L

<
2@ #'2$,(#.$#"!(
+$"( .& . D$## (+

$%!3( #&!

&$#.,($!( .&( +#!# (+' #((+(++$L 2@ 2#(&#/#&!,("(+!3( &(($(+# #0#/

&$((!3( (#$#$$(& ("!D( $#,$L 2@ !++(D#(,((#$/$.(,#&#"!$!D  &$.(  #..  +#$  #&  &#.  .#  (  !  (++$  ,(& !+(%"!!' #(0/!,(.$,( %! $( !( .&( ((!D(+!#.. #(!  (.$D 0,D&($(D,.!' #( "( .&0 ,D# (,(( $!$($.

(0#&(!#F/+#$!#! $(D,.#H   &(  (  &'  (  0  ' #&  (  !#   #D( (#0 (+,($(+.#"+' #(%+! ' #  (++$  +&  !#  !    (   0#$    ! #,,.$#(D#&0/!$(D,.##%!' # (++$D#/ +.##,,(,#,(H DD#/0+(!.#& # # "!$!D#/0$(&&0/!.#& # ##$$(&#$ "!!-(",($& L 2@!,(" & $(>6533'/"&%0 $(+D (+"&,(";

!$( (0D($# (  $## (( #&D(&. & /(!$( L 2'@ ("'%#!#DD%!$( %+!-+% #&0 !#&(!,##D(+;

#! #&!.+
#D,(&0/ .#"%D(,#$ .#./!,##D.#&&("0/!3(  !$#(+*#, #&!# #I#.%!#!

&$(( ;

#!! H$(D,.#L 2'@J!#,#/+(;

#! ! D#&0/!#.. &#$$ & #&!$( "!2$ !,(" & $(>65 33%(./!#($(&"!!!#.. #(!  &$.($(DD((+#$( F#0.(++$((!$( 

6
(;

&($(&(D"!!((!D(+! #.. #(D#-( #$( F#0.(++$#&!$( !#( ,D!' # # $/H,(.$(' #!#.. #( ! L 2'@!#+(#&,##D"( .&0#,,.$#0.#&H(!#+(#& #,$#;

&(0$(&&0/!  !3( "!. ,# #D(&#;

#! ,(2$(+ ,(" & $(>6533#&H( &$.55A(+! 3( (  (+  &#  ("'%  #  D  (&  (+  #/  (+ ' #(&  !,&$/(+!;

#! ,($#0 ,#&"!$$ D,$( $!#D(&!( .&( ;

  (  0  ,#&  ( ./%  $# #../  #&H(  D$!#$#../

(D#../%"!!' #(,( #&!+#$# !#F/#&!'&$HD##.(0+(!  !3( % !  !3( !( .&#.++(D,# !D(& (+((#(9($($',(0#&(,&:#&! #$$ &!( .&0. #&(#,,./+(#$,#(/0#. & $(>86330+(!$(D,$( !  !3(  !#..(#&# $!(

+&,# !(&(+(( ##&H(9($($',:!&  !' #(( ..  !  ' #(    $(D,.&  #&H(  ..  !  +#. ,(H$!# !    +.&  &  $(  <8  33%  "!. &D H&,( (+!;

#! ,( & $(>65 33#&H( &$.55A(+!3( ((+ &#L 2'@'#$#"!!  !3( ,D#+#$(+!(,( !##2$,(#.$#D#&( +( #(+D#/(+ + !' #(%#+$(& !0(#&,##D"!. 2$ !,(" & $(>6533#&H( & $.55A(+!3( ((+ &#+&(!#0('%!

 !3( !#( '0+#("!/ $!#D(& "##&#&H(;

&(0,#&(!#$#&D(# !#,,.$#((+D&0/!3( #&!! !+( D$#

=
$(&"!#"#" !&"!!  !3( "!.,#  $!#D(&L 2'@J!'#D(&,#&0/!  !3( (+9( $($',(0#&(,&:"!!#+(#&,##D%!

 !3( D $.#+/"!#&(D#0/9($($',( 0#&(,&:#!D9($($',(0#&(,&:$#0 #&(0(('# #&H(0(#&"!$!$#0D &((& #&H(D#,,.& 4

!$#(+G
  

  61 
     !

(E0. ,D3( (+ &##+'" .#   D0  (+  $#  (  !  ;

(  (+  ;

#!  (+     !#  ,$0&  !

&."!! $#0;

#!&!,$,.#L
@ J!!#.. #(D#&! +(D#(,((! $(D,.#%'+!/##-#!+#$'#. #&#$$,& !/&((,D#
+#$$( #/(++$(D#-(  #$## #!#$$ & @ J!!#.. #(! +(D#(,(#&(! D##.%  +  #/%  #$$(D,#/  !     &(  (  &$.(  # $( F#0.(++$%

+/ #' #(0/,(.$(++$

& $(4A?@(+!3(&2$, &#(&(+#

# #"!!, '"(+ $(44?5@(+!3(& @J!! $(('&#.. #(D#&! ($(D,.# #&!'&$$(..$& ,,((+!#D&((&$.( !$(DD((+#/(++$#&D#-( #$## #! #$$ & '@ J!%!#.. #(! &(($( #$( F#0. (++$  0   $(   (./  #  (
$( F#0.  (++$%  ( ' #(,D&0/#,(.$(++$"!( #(&(+#

# ##$(D,.#&& $(44?5@(+!3(&

7
'@ J!!#.. #(D#&! ($(D,.##(#0 & #&!./D,(0#0.(!0#(+"!$!(, &,( $#'#$!#

$($.

(!#! ++$ ( &+( ,($& # #!#$$ & '@ J!  !    #  2,  . #.  0#   #+&    #/  (+  ! ,('( (+ ! 3(& (  ! $($& $  ? &"!$!  # $D#.,($&  &@(! (#&$( #$ (+!,($& #&H("!!#,$+$,('(! 3(&(!$($&$%,('& ++$#$( &+(! '#$(+!# '&,#/ '@ J!#$D#.,($& D#+./#&&"!D#.#+& #&H( "!  !  ,($&   D#.$( ./  & "!  #

.(D('+("#- ' #$(!#$$ &#&"!# '"(,!D& (,'##&,(#.  &  A D.#./  ! $# (+ 
 !   " # 

 
  $ %&'()
*1! (E0. ,D3( (+ &#!# .& !#  ,(.$  ' #(  !( .&  0  #..("&  (  ,($&  .  2$,(#.

$$ D#$"##'($$(& ( (E0. ,D3( (+

&#  !   !  3(   !( .&  (  +  "!  !  ' #(  "! #.. #( &$.($( F#0.(++$ <

!$#(++, -   

-
./0  &'()
*& 1! (E0. ,D3( (+ &#!# .&!#

&$( (+;

#! (+ !( .&02$&,# ./!G#(+#$#E , (E0. ,D3( (+ &##.. #( ($(D,.#D 0 #-#+#$'#.

#&#$$,&!/(#"!!!/&$.( #$( F#0.(++$ 6

!$#(++1 % 

(  $ 
    # &'

()
*21! (E0. ,D3( (+ &#!.&!#!3( !( .&(


$(& $#D
#.#!# (+;

#! #&!#;

#! (+ !( .&0 #2$,(#&2$&,# ./#(+#$# ! (E0.

,D3( (+ &#!#+ !!.&!#3( $#(D0#- ,(# ;

/  #  (  !  .#0./  (     (+  #.. #(  D#&    !  H$(D,.# =

!. !(+#0('
D(&,$,.(+.#"0/#/$!(+ D# #(!+#$ #.D#2(+!$#&((.#&(#$($. (%!# +. (+ !$###0 (+,($(+.#"!

%D/(,(% !($(,+(2$(+2#
(&#/

&$((+!3( ! D, &(& 57 #;

.(#0('
D(&(0'#(%!0/!.&!# !,,(&'(&(+D#&&'&D#.!#D !0/&D&#$$(& 

7)  )

8  "# " 

 J!!,#- H#(&  N J!!,(#0. 

(