← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/58313/2023dismissed

M/S Zee Laboratories Ltd And ORS v. Union Of India

2024-02-22Mr. Justice Harpreet Singh Brar10 pages



        



   

   





 



!

" $

% &

()

*

()

 + -)

*



'

.

/ 0+'

+#





  ! !

"#$#%&



* 3

('

0   

+* "-$

 !' 

&&

#+) &





0  

4) 7

0

)



 

      #+ % 2%2

% 2%2

()



9

%

:

;2 )

,3, <

7

&

)

#0 (

&



&

() * ()

 + -)

* $

%(,-2* +'

&&

 

)

&

,3, < 

0&=









#0 %

:

#0;2 * :



;

 ;

+

 ) 3

# 

&





+

#0

&



  

)) (

#0* = +



(

#0*

&

&#

+

  ( 0 $ )

# )

#

7

 

+'*

>

&

0&+ 7  +

# 

#0

4



0&+

++

30+&

%

0)

 0)

+'*

) ?

 88 0

#  

0

@&' 3&+

# 

#0*

 =

 A B0 3) +*

() &

(,-*

C

?

* *

+'

#0

&

!

 B0 ,) * &



 (

?

A

+)

=

0&+

#++ 

/0>



& 

&



0&+

()

 #

7

4

@* &

!

 B0  3++

0&+

+'

)

()

!

 B0  /

/0 >3



&'

/0 >

>3

!

 B0 * &



 (

?

A

0&+

%,,3?($  2

0

3 +'

 ) ()



'* 9* ) 

0&+

%,,3?($  2

+

E<

F 'G

0

3 +'





) ,((6  

  /0 

0&+



#0

+



&

'

30+&

?

++

30+&

# >

+0

 HG 8

&'

+

!

 B0 * &



 (

?

A

% 2

+4 #0



#0

 -



#0

# 

 '*

&'



0&+

&&+

6=

#0

)



%2

%2

=

#0  



0

3 +'

> -



A





##

(,-*

C ?



+)

 3 '* .0 

# ) &

#0

#0;

+ '*

&&&

&

00  .

0&)

,3, < 

 

!

 





#+

@&'

+# +#

)*

0 #)*+,-#%*.&#+/&) 0  "12%$3#+&."4

56!7 /

()

&&

0

= 

0&



0&+

#+

$!





&

##

 9 %3 @

>2 #+

( & ()  ++ %$2* (,-* ?

* 

'

.

/ 0+'

+#



0

@ 

)+

'

 + 0&

0

$$$

# 

)+

 3

&&

0

) 3 +

>* >

8



$

0

@ 

#

"

+)

$$$

$!

=+ 

&=

#+

+ +'

) 0



##

5

$

+

=

 +'

#+

/ ++'*

#

0

4

 

   *

) 

" $

0&+

++

30&+&

%  0)2*

+)

+

 '&



&0 +'

'&

*

 =

()

+'



&

0&+

0

3 +'

 ) ()





'* )

+# 

&



+'



  .=

&

#0



8

)

0

3 +'

 *

+'

&&+



> 

+)

0&+

* 

  #0

 

+

  '

0

3 +'

&& 

0

3 +'



  =

#



 

# ++'

)

/



()

+'

&&



< #

/ < 3    (

 



+)

') 

(

,3, <  

) ++'

&

##

&



# 

 *

00

 )+

#+)

,3, <

#

##0

83?

#

< ,- 3 9 ,83? 

8 

 A



!8!  !!

 .

)







 

&

()

&&

0 - *

&

 (



0&+

++%

0)2

30+&

%0)2

)

 88

# )

@&'

3&+

 

)0

) 0&

#+





0





##

 9 %3 @

>2 &

+

+'

 *

&&+

7

0

#0

 3

&&

0

+

%

+

83

()



+

9 

< #

/ < 3    (

 

+'

&&

() * (,-

,



?

* .0 

)0

)

@ 

#

3 +

>* >

8



#++=  

 

                       

    ! " #$  %        "#      

6

& '' (# %  # # '  ## ")*  # " + ' ##  ,'   ' ##  (# #      #

-. '     *       # "+ 

#  %  #

/0%  ##  '  "& %#  # /1 234 #    #   &* "

#$  + 

" 

  +5 /

0 +

#



@ 0





 *

0&



C

+)

&

 /

)

&& 

0

3 +'



) ,((6  

 *

%2

%2



 

 .= 

 

# ++'





)0

)

@&'

+# +#

 *



0

3 +'



) ++'

= && 





++=

+)



&+

A)0

=

.;

,&

9,:.  !-*&/  (9*%#  /,"-,+#1&*+,9$  &) %)  ,%.&/#"  0  !&,&#  .;



,)/<, ",)#$/ 45   4"*-*%,956*

4)

) 5

?, *

#++=)

  %'  

 ##(   ## #   '      #    &2  #      #     "          0'( # #'

7  ))2  /  

  ###  #( " ## #      "     ##"#    #  "   

 %  )21%  ))3#      " #  

((( ((( (((

8 "'7 7 !,   $ # , #"   

!" #  #$

%%&'

()*)'*+ #(,-&.'

%%&(/**010'  #  #9 :

 ; /  !  #    ""  #  <     ! #  =  "       #   # # # '  ;  -        ## "  #    =  

# $  ; -  #' #    " # ; / :

% # !      ## % ' # # ## ## #   = !    #    >" # -&1( # '(  ?#"#     " #" #  #  ""# "# @ "<  #  $  ; - #' 

)0

##

,3, <

#

 % 2

# ++'



# 

)C

##

00



#++=  0

*23 

.   #   #( 

7

 % 

 "

#       #'"      "   #  #  A

  ""#A

# "#   '      

&  ' ##=56 

*56 ##   56 #5 6*6



-." #  ##  

   "   #  #       '         '   "   /

83?

#

< ,- 3 9 ,83? 

8 

 A

++=

'

##

+

 / ++'*

 



;

+

=

.;

,&

=,&+/#$*-*&#)0$  >*),4 5!66

+

&=



 

@

0) &

7

$

+'

0

&

7

@ 0)





#

7

0& 0

= 8

=

.;

,&

,&/*$/ ,>1%%*?"*$/%,%8$ !&,&#4.0& .;5 !%9*%#!'

4)

) 5

.

'*



 $  "     ;   "       "   #      C "  #"  

  "'  '   " # 

  ## # #$  

      #'""  

 

# % '#  # "  ;# #  "           =         " 

  '$  #"   # #

     "      D     #' # 

  ## ### "      ! >



&

   ) 

&&+

% 2*

'*

&

#

4 !5   .

4)

 I

<

 I

<