← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/52461/2019dismissed

Inderjit Singh v. State Of Punjab

2023-04-27Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil12 pages

  

      

  !"#"$%&''(  

    

  

   %  )*+'

, +, ++ * ****  

 



  



 !

 

  "

 #

!

  , $-

./-0"12 ' $

&

 

  '()

""

&

*

   +,+-)+$- .

/ ,0 

1  2 343 1 2

5   1

#

1    +6+()+$7 .

/ )0 1

8

5+$   $)+9)+$7 .

/ $0   

  ,-.)0.0

)$

))

  )$(

'99

'7$

$)+3

6('

'() "

  ),

4

1

 

1 %& 8

: 

5    /  

 41

11  ;

 1 .11  

 4&0 

 41

"8 <

5 :1

  /4  4 

  



1 

4

8   

/   = 

 41

11  ;  1



4 "8 <

5 :1   /4  4 

   

1  

- 2 - )

   1  1 *  1

3  

41 11 

) 41 41#



   41

 > 6

  

 



11 4 





:!

%8



   %

%

 *# 

 

%8  

   

  3

4   "

4  

% %    

 

   # 1

 

& % % 1

 

4

1       4

1

      

  3



# )+$6 )+$'

1# 

1  

  



4

1 11  

4

1    

  1

1

#

 #   1

  3

41

 ;

4

1

&

 



     

4     

   4

4    11 1

  

4

1

 #

4

1

 4

1



 1  

   

  



 '

? 

 4  1# 



  * 1  

441 *  #

 

 !

 @

& * 4

   % % 11

  4 5$$)(3

66= = :!= %8 :  )(+')+$7

%8 A* 

  

- 3 -  1#    

 1

 

 



441 *  #     

 1  #



  4 

 1     1

4

1



*   1   

44



          & A

" 1  

& 1 * 1 8 5 $,,

  $$+)+$6 ?= )$=)-

$-(, 

 1

:  % %

 



  * 

%1

" )66)+$7 



  3

1

   & A " 1

4

    

#

 4     



  

$-(,



  ! 4

5   5B

B 66=" 9$=(,=

') 97=(7   6

 4

$-(7



 

5:

$-(,



&

 

   1

4   /

  4

     ')



     

1

4 

1  4 11   4 

1# 

1

   &

   4 

       

 

$-(,

,



 1  

!=

@

4 



:!

%8

 

  

+-+9)+$7

4 

1 # * 1



2 

4 :



    

- 4 - 9

< 1

4 

11# 41 

 

&



1  

44      

 1 A    !11 #







4    

4  

 

 =  4 

4

1=1

  

 

 4

    

  11 &  #   

 41#

 C1    # D"EF  )++

"

4

7

    1

E4

:  

;

  

  

 C1 8

 

 

1 1

2   1

4   1



   

4



4 9+++  / A   

1 4 1#

2   1

41  

1

    

/

/  



4

1 41#=1 "

41 < #

G

 = 

4 

4

1=1

 





#  1 1 1    





 

   5 

:   4



   

(

< 1 4 

41   

 1 8 5+$   $)+9)+$7 



 

    1 1

11 

- 5 -  #

 



8

41 =4

 1#    



8



  * 

4 

B

  

     1 # 41 1



* 1

 3  



4 =41

11 

* 1

  

"   41 1 .

/

9

4 

" 



1



 $++

8=

   

 

6, 8=

 

-

< 1 4 

   

%8

 1=    



 8 5+$  

$)+9)$+$7

4= = #

;4 ""%

 

   

    ))+9)+$7

"2

 1 14

 ""%   1 1#

 #

   

#= %8

 

1

*   

11   # 11 



4&   

 

$+

4   1    +6+()+$7 

1    / 

 41

11  ;

 1

 

1 "

    +,+-)+$-

4

 1    +6+()+$7

 

   

1

1

   +,+-)+$- 

11 

1  3

- 6 -     



         



            

    !   

      

"   #

     

 !"   

  

   #     $  

#   %%

#

    %

   %   

           



 

 

 %%

# # 

! # !   %               

"     

 !  %      

  

                  %               

 &  %!



 "       %   

      # ! 

  ! '       !( &(# $))*    +  &     ,      #    '   "    

"    - .    

            "      /)))  # 0     #    !  % %

  #

  +   &   "  #

" - .  $1





   

        * 2  

  0    0 #            

!   

   * 

  3!" '"  #

       

        

        

 



 &  %!



   

 ! 

            

!   

   * 

 3!" '            

! * 

 3!"'  "

 $1) $1)$)2$1 &%4   5"2%  * 4 #    %

  * !  " & 

  "   &

#   %   " 4  * 

  +0  " 3 6 "    3!  

" ' 7 "     " &       " 

   

!   * 

 3!"'  

    

!         $1)   $1)$)2   0   # 4 0 4 

# 

- 7 -         !&%&

 &

        $1)"         

 #

   "*4"&                 $1)"    

   * 

 3!"'#     ! 

       $1) 8   



     



             

    ! 

   

" #

 

   

 !"   

 

       #        " !



         % 

      

   

 ,     ! 

    

               # 

        &%4          # #

  "    

    

            

  "     "                ! !#  

 ! !"  

 

           " #   

 

  , 

 9

      6:

       



   

 

     #  

  #   ! #      

        

  !  ! 

"      # "        #     



  "     6  

    

   * 

 3!" 

#     0

    !    

#      



  "    

  

   ! #   #    

 

#      

        " !    0  

  

 

  , 

9

       6:     *   



 3!" # &     0               ;<  *"    

                      

 



- 8 - /   

 0        0 #     "

  

! * 

 3!"'#              $1) #

"    

   * 

  3!" ' #      ! 

      $1)"  

  0

         * 

  3! '"    

 6   $)=$)5 

  , 

9

       6:"            "    * 

  3!" '   0      

  "   



      

    

 * 

 3!"' #

                 

   * 

 3!"'#

         

   0      

 * 

  3!" '" !   

                 $1) 94 0  4:   

 * 

 3!"'  

                      4  !           

 

 3   * 

  +0   #

      #        %#

     %>  "   

        

       

   * 

  3    

 

3 #

   #    %  #

     %>  #

       #

         

"               4  ! =   



              %"#  ! #       "           &% 4            



 &  %!



          "    

   #  

 "    

    0         0  * 

 3!'" 

   

              

    !   

      

"   #

     

 !"   

  

   #    

- 9 - 5  **? #

  !             $$)=$)5  ! *

 * -

 7  "7

"       "

  !       !   6  

   

   

    !  

      6

 

@ %#   

    !"      

 "    **?    # # 

# 6 

   

 

 @  %# #     

   ! #    "  

 

           " !  @  

  

 %%

 

    

    @   A   $11" %

 3  " -    !  $))="       #    

 

@ %# B      #     

     

 "  

       

             0   

  

  , 

    

  *   



3!9* 3:" #&  "

 0                  *C $$



 4 

1

 

1

"

41 <#  11 

 4 1 

1 "

41 < #

 11 4 =1  



/

  4

"

41 < #



%8=    

#

1

<="

41

E/4

   

  



 1 

4  $)

< 1

1 

1  1   



 " 1  B 5  "41 " 5$9'+

)+$+  )6+$)+$6

5 1  

  .!

5"% :1 0

"1   59,6 )++9  6+$)++7

1 C4  5 

- 10 - " 1 

"41   5 $7$ )++(  )7+6)++(

:      11  

   & C&

)+$,.$0 :".

5 0 )')

4



   "41

     56'--+3 )++)  $$+7)++6

 &

1  C 

   "1  53))++)

)+$).BH0  $-$$)+$'

4



  

"41

1 5)(63: )++7  6++6)+$$ $6

1#

1

    )'+,)+))



11 

  

 "

41 E/4 

8

 < #

5 

 1

1

 1   

1  # &

/ 

 41=3  4  

"8 <

5 :1 

  

1   

   

1 3  

41 

   

" 

41  

 1 #

$'

<

  1

 

   

 41

"

41 E/4 A



 4 AI1

4 "

  

       

        "

:    4

" !

"  

#"$ %

   &%#'( )  $,



 1 1

 





 1 $9

1 



1#  

  

1

 

 

&

"  3

- 11 -  

  #    

41

4



 # 4

  )-6

" "41 

4



  /  41  

*  .0

/ "

1

# * 

3   =341

 11     

5  : 

#  

 

4  

 4#

 

 4 

/ 41# / 1 4 

 

 

 1 

$7

   



1 1   !

 *  9 :"+*  9 :)

,-*  9 :

1 

1



 1   

11

 

 



 / 

/ 1 4 

   / 4  

 11#      4

1 1 

41 3  

$(

" 11#  1



1  &

  11 

) 41 

4

3  

1#   1#

1   

  

1   

5

  

   

" 





  #  4 1

$-



   # 



      41

 

4

 1 1# 1#  

- 12 - )+

8 4

 1



1#   4

1

  # 3  





1 





 

1

 <

  # 4  #

  



 41   

  #    *  #

 1# 

 



 4  

 41

41 1# )$

:4

)7+')+)6 ??



3, $-

./-0"14

/-0

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No