High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4981/2018dismissed

Jagtar Singh v. Gurdhyan Singh

2019-01-22Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary12 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

()* + +++

!" #

$$$$$ +++,

% " &'

&( )(&* + , - . /

# " () (1 )(&'

+ . "+ # + + # " (* )(&& + % +

% + #

" (* )(&&4 +# + 5 # # # . #" "+ " )( (((6% 5# #"+#

# &7 (((6% "4 " + #+ " 4 (7 5# " #4 +# (* )(&& "&7 (((6% " #" 0+

8 (7 )(&)

44 # + 9 # " +

)2 (((6%+#.0 :7:''2(;

+0 3 < +2( (((6%

" "4 "

4 # # +

5# #6 # # "

4 (2

< 4 + # " +# # +

= #

. # " #

" + #

" " # 5# # # "

# > " 5# # # # + #

- " + 4 ?

"< (7 ." #

# "

# #"+ ,% &

@ +# " (* )(&& 4 +

" + )2 (((6%A )

5 & # " A8 ;

@ " " ,A8.

A8.

@ ++" # % "

81 &-/,,A8.

B , " # " # (* )(&&+

""" + 4 # #

" + #

% # "+ . "+ " () (1 )(&'

+ +

" +

,+# +

% B

&*- /

- C

C/ "

# "

+ + 5 #

# 5 "+ " D4 %) #

#" &( )(&) + " #

" +" C + C# C4

" . =

, .#/ !01!&232!04!'/!.&.%5!6 %'/!6, %7%68 +# C @ C C C

C@ C

" = C+ ", 2%09:'!'!5/#!/4;+0&.&0 !:!'2!'!, <

<+ " # + >+ + 5 +"

= %

"4 " (* )(&& B

" = , !>30 %':2.&!/290%395!0%?!/294!6!!'/"2#0&, - %7%6 8, #+ + #

# # "+ , ?

+# +

" "%#4 B ,+# # +

+ +% 9 (7 " "+ # # # )(

, + " 5 "

+ "

+ - " +

+> " (* )(&&/ B " " = C+ ", !6 30%&2'!!'/!'"2#0.& 2!:@!'!&/#!/!'/"2#0&

< %7%68- , + # 5 " (* )(&&#4 " #

< " &E ?

" # 5

+ # "

" + , +# + , > + % +"

B # " + +" + , +#

B +"

+ % # = 7 #

% F?

# + # # " # " " 4 +" 4 "

5 +" # 4 ." (;

)(&)# 46 4 + # &( < # " 8 " 4

C+ " + " > #" &( )(&) B +" <

" +> "

" &'

&( )(&* + > ?

C "+ # # " + = "

# )(&' "

" () (1 &(&'

+" "

" + ,+#+

5 ,+ "

" (;

)(&)D4 %)")2 (((6% ,

D4 &

+ + 0 3 < " D4 %; D4 %7 D4 %2 (7 4 + + +%

9 4 D4 %*

D4 %&(

"< + +% 9

# # +% @% &%.

8 030

@%)% !" "

#+ " D " 0 &;&(7 @%;%

4 " (* )(&& " &7 (((6% @%2%

4 "

" &7 (((6% 5 %

# " 4 " (* )(&& &7 (((6% " " (* )(&& &7 (((6%+ " 5 + # " #

" + * # " + % F?

+ # #

" " # > " 5 # " " " " ?

# # # 4

> 4 5# %

# +% 9 # #

4 5 "<+ +% 9 D4 .%& # + 5 # #< # " # .@%&+ , " # # " (* )(&&# "

&7 (((6% . " +% 9 (7 + # "" +

" (* )(&&

=# %4" = + " # + < " &E 3 , +#

+ " %4"

" 4 " (* )(&& &7 (((6% " D4 " (* )(&&# " +

< + + "

" +

+ #

" #

+ " "

(;

)(&) " " )2 (((6%# + + # "%# 4 " (;

)(&)# % ?

"" +#

&( )(&) # #<"(7 )(&) 44 ?

" #

(;

46 +

(7 5 #

4 ." (;

# # "

+ C # C "

C C #

C@ C

+ # 4 " + + 5 # # 4 # "" &( +" " , !5395!0?!5395!0.&90%'/#0395!0/

!'/ !'"2#0

+ 8 < 5 .#/ !01!&2 32!04!'/!*& 9A0!, #

+ +

5 "

4 "" " 4 # ?

#" &( )(&) "

" # # < + < " (* )(&&

" +

# " # 4 +

> + ?

" " # " " # # # < # #

+" " = C+ ", 3!''!'

/#!/4;+0&!'/"2#0&.&. !'/90!':!5/#!/4;+0&!'/ "2#0&, %7%6 - # %

# "

D #+ &

% + > #"

+ > ##

3 "

" # "

0 " +

! # " + "

" &'

&( )(&* () (1 )(&' + , - . / 0 . "+

> "#

B+++C

9/:# &12!'

@ < 6 H60

@ + H60