Surmukh Singh v. Financial Commissioner (Appeals) Punjab
!
"
# "
"$%& )&*+,+'-
..
/012034 ......
&%+%+'-&1 6&1,0,
88&$7,9 0-:$;
'%4&1,
......
&,8'-)&-%, <!= .
/ / !
1&,&-% 1.
./.
!$+-,9 )>'*$%& ('1 $887+*$-%8&%+%+'-&1.
1.
+12$7:+% "+?$-$9 /&-+'1 " 0-:$;.
. . / !
.
=
.
4+, +, $- $887+*$%+'- (+7&) 0-)&1 /&*%+'- ('1 87$*+-5 '- *&1%$+- )'*02&-%,
.
'1 1&$,'-, 2&-%+'-&) $887+*$%+'-9 +, $77'?&) *&1%$+- )'*02&-%,
$1& %$3&- '- 1&*'1) ,0;:&*% $77 :0,% &@*&8%+'-,.
887+*$%+'- +, $**'1)+-57A )+,8',&) '(.
.
1$A&1 +-,%$-% (+7&) 0-)&1 1%+*7& '-,%+%0%+'- -)+$9 +-%&1 $7+$9 +, ('1 +,,0$-*&
-$%01& *&1%+'1$1+ ('1 ,&%%+-5 $,+)&
..
9 "+,%1+*%
08-$5$1
,4'1% <'77&*%'1<B
.
9
08-$5$1 "+>+,+'-9
08-$5$1
,4'1% <"+>+,+'-$7 '22+,,+'-&1< .
9
88&$7,9 0-:$;
,4'1% < '22+,,+'-&1<.
.
!1+&(7A9
/012034 /+-54 $88'+-%&) >+77$5& /$+(7$8019 &4,+7 "+,%1+*%
08-$5$1.
% $88&$1, %4$% )01+-5 4&$1+-5 '-& )+,80%&) 20%$%+'- '.
>+77$5& /$+(7$8019 +% ('0-) /0;
$5+,%1$%&9
08-$5$1 %4$% *$8$*+%A 4$) ?1'-57A $%%&,%&) 301,+-$2$
%$;7& /$0)$5$1 ?4&1&+- -$2& '-& ,'-,9 -$2&7A9 '2+%%&).
,$+) 2$%%&1 ;1'054% -'%+*& ?4'
+,,0&) ,4'?
*$0,& -'%+*& $(%&1 $(('1)+-5 )0& '88'1%0-+%A 4&$1+-5 >+)&
..
9 )+,2+,,&) (1'2 =$2;$1)$1.
.
&&7+-5 $551+&>&) $5$+-,% '77&*%'1<, '1)&19 81&(&11&) $- $88&$7 ;&('1& 4'?&>&19 )+,2+,,&)9 >+)& .
.
. /%+77 $551+&>&)9 81&(&11&) 1&>+,+'-
;&('1&
$7,'
)+,2+,,&)9 >+)& .
.
.
- $('1&2&-%+'-&) *+1*02,%$-*&,9 (+7&) +-,%$-% ;&('1& %4+, '01% ,&&3+-5 1&7+&( ,9 -'%+*&) 4&1&+-$;'>&.
.
&$1).
.
>+)&-%7A9 /$0)$5$1 4$) %?'
,'-,9 -$2&7A9 $-)4+1 4'?&>&19 $*%+-5 4$) $%%&,%&) ?1'-5 %$;7&
301,+-$2$ /41+ /$0)$5$1 ?4&1&+- $-)4+1 ,4'?- '-7A ,'- /$0)$5$1 /+-54.
. '-,+)&1+-5 2$%%&19 '77&*%'1 $(%&1 $(('1)+-5 )0& '88'1%0-+%A 4&$1+-5 )+,2+,,&) 4+2 (1'2 (01%4&1 $((+12&) '22+,,+'-&1.
>&-
>+)& +%, .
9 084&7) )+,2+,,$7 (1'2 =$2;)$1)$19 ';,&1>+-5 0-)&1
!"#$"$"
% &'&
( '& ( ) ) )
(
*"*$"$+ ( ,
-
.
/ -
' )(
0 ) / 1 0 )
$2 $$"$$
3434 5'
/ -
)
/ )
*"*$"$+ ( ' ' , - 6
) 2" $"$$(
) ) ( , )
) 7 )
) )
) )
) 8
9
$"!$"$2 )
/ 0 /
"! $$"$$ ) 0 / ) )
/
9 :
;
.
'-,+)&1+-5 $('1&2&-%+'-&) ($*%, *+1*02,%$-*&,9 $2 *'-,+)&1&) '8+-+'- %4$% (01%4&1 084&7) ?&77
)'&, -'% *$77 ('1 $-A +-%&1(&1&-*&.
=$2;$1)$19 1&C0+1&) &-,01&
*'11&*% >&1+(+*$%+'- D01,+-$2$
%$;7&($2+7A %1&& 1&7$%+-5 7&5$7 4&+1, )&*&$,&)/$0)$5$1 /+-54.
'2+,,+'- '-& ,'-9 20%$%+'- 81'*&&)+-5, +, -'% 2+-'1 7$8,&.
'((+*& +, ;$,&) '- %10,% *'-(+)&-*& >+77$5& *'220-+%A.
8&1,'- ?4',& *'-)0*% *1&$%&, )'0;% '1 ,0,8+*+'- *$--'% *'22$-) -&*&,,$1A 1&,8&*% 1&5$1) 1&,+)&-%,.
+%4'0% ,0*4 *'-(+)&-*&9 *$--'% &((&*%+>&7A )+,*4$15& )0%+&, $%%$*4&) =$2;$1)$1.
.
- %4+, >+&?
2$%%&19
)'
-'% (+-) $-A 2&1+% %4+, +, $**'1)+-57A )+,2+,,&).
.
&-)+-5 $887+*$%+'-
,9 +( $-A9 ,4$77 $7,'
,%$-) *7',&).
/ !
"
..
,:3, 4&%4&1 ,8&$3+-51&$,'-&)
#&,
'
4&%4&1 1&8'1%$;7& #&,
'