High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/51975/2025allowed

Tony Kumar @ Chuha v. State Of Haryana

2025-09-19Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel5 pages

!&' !&' !&' !&'

( 5'2-*- ) ( 5'2-*- ) ( 5'2-*- ) ( 5'2-*- ) %'1&' 3'" %'1&' 3'" %'1&' 3'" %'1&' 3'" /

# $$!

F6'&-&- '"

9'"**

%&!&' ( !"

F6'*1 5'

) ) ) ) "'*'

"'*'

&) =+ 6 % % =+ 6 % % =+ 6 % % =+ 6 % % + + + + "6 %!

5''1 %- ,$ !&&!

/ 592 2!&' (" &$' 1'&-&- '"6 "6 ''1!.

!" "':!4/ !"

!6 >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> + + + +/ 6 ?+@ / 6 ?+@ / 6 ?+@ / 6 ?+@ % % % % "'*'

& 1'&-&- $!* 3''

(-4'5

5'" %'2&- <B0 ( $!"!&-

!,!"-. %"!

!.*$! %!

$-&!/

0 ?(" *$"& A

%%=@ (" ,"!

& ( "',4!" 3!-4 & &$' 1'&-&- '"

" - 2!*' 3'!"- , 6 B 5 5!&'5 <6 6

0/ "',-*&'"'5 ("

(('

2'* 1

-*$!34'

5'" %'2&- * 0

"'!5 :-&$ 0< C

( &$'

5-!

!4 5'/ BD ?(" *$"& A =@/ !& 4-2'

' %&!&- %!5!" !,!5$"-/ -*&"-2& !

!, !"6

$' ,"!9! '

( &$' !44',!&- * !,!- *& &$' 1'&-&- '" -* &$!& '

!7!4 $!5 * 4'

-8'5 ! 49' !""-!,' :-& &$ %.$:- 5'" %- ,$ 3& 4!&'"

5'9'41'5 !

-44-2-& "'4!&- *$-1 :-&$

!" # $$! ?1'&-&- '" $'"'- @/ / :$ :!* ! 24 *' ("-'

5 ( "

!" #

,-6

0/ !7!4/ !4 , , :-&$ &$' 1'& &-&- '" !

5 "

!" # ,-/ 2 *1-"'5 & '4- - !&'

%.$:- 5'" % ,$6

'E'2&- ( &$' 2 *1-"

"!2 / 5"- , &$'

-,$& - &'"9'

, ,

<6 6

0/ !& !" )

!6 6/ "

!" # ,- !

5 &$' 1'&-&- '"

& & !7!4=* "'*-5'

2'/ :$'"'/ :-&$ $'" !**-*&!

2'/ &$'

"5'"'5 %.$:- 5'" %- ,$ 3 *&"!

,4!&- , $- :-&$ ! "1'6 & &$' &- ' ( &$' - 2-5'

&/ "

!" # ,- "'*&"!- '5 %.$:- 5'" %- ,$/ :$-4' &$' 1'&-&- '" !

!7!4 144'5 &$' "1' & 'E'2&' &$' !2&6 %3*'G' &4 / - "5'" & -*4'!5 &$'

14-2' !

5 ,-9' &$' !11'!"!

2' ( *-2-5'/ &$' !22*'5 $!

,'5 %.$:- 5'"

,$ :-&$ ! A$

-= !

5 '9'

2& -& $!4(:!

& (!3"-2!&' '9-5'

2'6 +'!"

'5 2 *'4 (" &$' 1'&-&- '" $!* -&'"!&'5 &$!& &$' 1'&-&- '" -* 2*&5 *- 2'

D6 6

06 +'!"

'5 2 *'4 $!* !",'5 &$!& &$' 1'&-&- '" $!* 3''

(!4*'4 - 14-2!&'5 - & &$' - G'*&- 6 +'!"

'5 2 *'4 $!* -&'"!&'5 &$!& &$' 2!*' - $!

5 -* & ' ( &$' '

' :-& '** !22 &/ 3& &$!& ( 2-"2 *&!

&-!4 '9-5'

2'6 +'!"

'5 2 *'4 $!* -&'"!&'5 &$!& &$' 1'&-&- '" $!* 3''

1"- !"-4 - 14-2!&'5 - & &$' - G'*&- &$' 3!*-* ( **1-2- +'!"

'5 2 *'4 $!* ("&$'" -&'"!&'5 &$!& &$' 1'&-&- '" $!* *(('"'5 2!"2'"!&- ( "' &$!

'!"*/ !

5 &$' &"-!4 -* 1"2"!*&- !&- ,6 $*/ "',4!" 3!-4 -* 1"!

'5 ("6 <6 +'!"

'5 %&!&' 2 *'4 $!* 11*'5 &$' 1"'*'

& 1'&-&- !",- , &$!& &$' !44',!&- * "!-*'5 !,!- *& &$' 1'&-&- '" !"' *'"-* -

!&"' !

5/ $'

2'/ $' ,$& & & 3' 'E&'

5'5 2 2'**- ( "',4!" 3!-46 +'!"

'5 %&!&' 2 *'4 *''.* & 14!2' "'2"5 &$' 2*&5 2'"&-(-2!&' 5!&'5 B6

- &$' "& &5!

/ :$-2$ -* &!.'

"'2"56 6

$!9' $'!"5 2 *'4 (" &$' "-9!4 1!"&-'* !

5 $!9' , ' &$",$ &$' !9!-4!34' "'2"5* ( &$' 2!*'6 D6 $' 1'&-&- '" :!* !""'*&'5

D6 6

0/ :$'"'- !(&'"

9'*&-,!&- :!* 2!""-'5 & !

5 &$' 2$!44!

$!* 3''

1"'*'

&'5

6 B6

&!4 1"*'2&- :-& '**'* $!9' 3''

2-&'5/ & ( :$-2$/

$!9'

3''

(44 'E! - '5 &-44 5!&'6 & -* &$*/ - 53-&!34' &$!& 2 24*- ( &$' &"-!4

:-44 &!.' 4 , &- '6 $' "-9!4 2 &'

&- * "!-*'5 !& !" ,-9' "-*' & 5'3!&!34'

-**'*/ :$-2$ *$!44 3' "!&-2- !&'5 1 5"- , &$' 2"*' ( &"-!46 $-* "& 5'* & 5'' -& !11"1"-!&' & 5'49' 5''1 - & &$'*' "-9!4 2 &'

&- */ !& &$-* *&!,'/ 4'*& -& !

1"'75-2' &$' &"-!46 &$- , &!

,-34' $!* 3''

3",$& (":!"5 & - 5-2!&' &$' 4-.'4-$5 ( &$' 1'&-&- '" !3*2 5- , (" &$' 1"2'** ( 7*&-2' " - &'"('"- , :-&$ &$' 1"*'2&- '9-5'

2'6 D66 & &$-* 7 2&"'/ -& :45 3' !11*-&' & "'('" $'"'- ! 75, '

& ( &$' =34' %1"' ' "& - !9'5 4!

!3- %$!-.$ 9*6 %&!&' ( !9'5 4!

!3- %$!-.$ 9*6 %&!&' ( !$!"!*$&"! !

5 !

&$'"*/

<?0@ ?"- - !4@ << !$!"!*$&"! !

5 !

&$'"*/

<?0@ ?"- - !4@ << !$!"!*$&"! !

5 !

&$'"*/

<?0@ ?"- - !4@ << !$!"!*$&"! !

5 !

&$'"*/

<?0@ ?"- - !4@ <</ :$-2$ "'!5* &$*) HB6 "- - !4* !"'

& 3"

& 3& !5'6 $' $ !

1&'

&-!4 -

'9'"

' -* ,5 !

5 */ '9'" :"-&' (( !

2"- - !4 !* 3'

"'5' 1&- 6 $-* $ !

-*& ( 5! '

&!4 -* (&'

-**'5 :$'

5'!4- , :-&$ 5'4G'

&*/ 79'

-4' !

5 !54&6

5''5/ '9'"

*!- & $!* ! 1!*& !

5 '9'"

'" ! (&"'6 I$'

! 2"- ' -* 2 -&&'5/ ! 9!"-'& ( (!2&"* -* "'*1 *-34' (" !.- , &$' (('

5'" 2 -& &$' 2"- '6 $*' (!2&"* !

3' *2-!4 !

5 '2 -2/ !

3'/ &$' "'*4& ( 9!4' '"*- " 1!"'

&!4

',4'2&J !

3'/ 3'2!*' ( &$' *&"'** ( 2-"2 *&!

2'*/ " &$'

-('*&!&- ( &' 1&!&- * - ! -4-' ( !((4'

2' 2 &"!*&'5 :-&$ 5-,'

2' " &$'" 1"-9!&- *6 6

( &$' %&!&' " !

1"*'2&- , !,'

245- , &$' 2"& 2 '5 $!* :$'"':-&$!4 & 1"9-5' " 1"&'2& &$' ( 5! '

&!4 "-,$& ( !

!22*'5 & $!9' ! *1''5 &"-!4 !* '

*$"- '5 5'" "&-24'

( &$'

*&-&&- &$'

&$' %&!&' " !

&$'" 1"*'2&- , !,'

*$45 & 11*' &$' 14'! (" 3!-4 &$' ," 5 &$!& &$' 2"- ' 2 -&&'5 -* *'"-*6 "&-24'

( &$' *&-&&- !114-'* -""'*1'2&-9' ( &$'

!&"' ( &$'

2"- '6

I' !

$!*&'

& !55 &$!& &$' !11'44!

& -* *&-44 !

!22*'5J & !

2 9-2&6 $' 9'"!"2$- , 1*&4!&' ( 2"- - !4 7"-*1"5'

2' &$!& !22*'5 -* 1"'* '5 & 3' -

&-4 1"9'

,-4& 2!

& 3'

3"*$'5 !*-5' 4-,$&4 / $:*'9'" *&"- ,'

& &$' 1'

!4 4!: !

3'6

6 I' !"' 2 92'5 &$!& &$' !

'" - :$-2$ &$' 1"*'2&- , !,'

!* :'44 !* &$' "& $!9' 1"2''5'5/ &$' "-,$& ( &$' !22*'5 & $!9' ! *1''5 &"-!4 245 3' *!-5 & $!9' 3''

("- ,'5 &$'"'3 9-4!&- , "&-24'

( &$' *&-&&- 6K D6 * 1'" 2*&5 2'"&-(-2!&' 5!&'5 B6

(-4'5 3 &$' 4'!"

'5 %&!&' 2 *'4/ &$' 1'&-&- '" $!* !4"'!5 *(('"'5 - 2!"2'"!&- (" ! 1'"-5 (

'!"*/ 0 &$* !

0 5!

*6 "&$'"/ !* 1'" &$' *!-5 2*&5 2'"&-(-2!&'/

&$' 1'&-&- '" -* *&!&'5 & 3' - 949'5 - &$'" ?*@6 :'9'"/ &$-* (!2& 2!

& 3' ! ," 5 *((-2-'

& 3 -&*'4(/ & 5'24- ' &$' 2 2'**- ( "',4!" 3!-4 & &$' 1'&-&- '" - &$' - G'*&- :$'

! 2!*' -* !5' & (" ,"!

& ( "',4!" 3!-4 G! &$' - G'*&- "!&-2- !&- , 1 &$'

(!2&*;2-"2 *&!

2'* ( &$' *!-5 6 '4-!

2' - &$-* "',!"5 2!

3' 14!2'5 1

&$' 75, '

& ( &$' =34' %1"' ' "& - !4!

! $56 -" !*$!5- !4!

! $56 -" !*$!596 %&!&' ( 66 !

5 !

&$'"/

?@ ?"- - !4@ B 96 %&!&' ( 66 !

5 !

&$'"/

?@ ?"- - !4@ B 96 %&!&' ( 66 !

5 !

&$'"/

?@ ?"- - !4@ B 96 %&!&' ( 66 !

5 !

&$'"/

?@ ?"- - !4@ BDJ ! -9-*- '

2$ 75, '

& ( &$' =34' !42&&! -,$ "& - 2!*' ( %"-5$!" !* 96 %&!&'/ %"-5$!" !* 96 %&!&'/ %"-5$!" !* 96 %&!&'/ %"-5$!" !* 96 %&!&'/ B ?

@ ?"- - !4@ < B ?

@ ?"- - !4@ < C 75, '

&* ( &$-* "& - 60BB

&-&4'5 !* .$-4'*$ %- ,$ 96 %&!&' ( !"

.$-4'*$ %- ,$ 96 %&!&' ( !"

!/ 5'2-5'5

/ !

!4"!7 96 !4"!7 96 !4"!7 96 !4"!7 96 %&!&' ( !"

!/ B ?0@ ?"- - !4@ 6 %&!&' ( !"

!/ B ?0@ ?"- - !4@ 6 %((-2' & *!

/ ("&$'" 5'&'

&- ( &$' 1'&-&- '" !* !

5'"&"-!4 -*

& :!""!

&'5 - &$' (!2&* !

5 2-"2 *&!

2'* ( &$' 2!*'6 6

9-': ( !39'/ &$' 1"'*'

& 1'&-&- -* !44:'56 '&-&- '" -* "5'"'5 & 3' "'4'!*'5 "',4!" 3!-4 $-* ("

-*$- , 3!-4;*"'& 3 5* & &$'

*!&-*(!2&- ( &$' +56 '5 ;& !,-*&"!&'6 :'9'"/ - !55-&-

& 2 5-&- * &$!& !

3' - 1*'5 3 &$' 2 '5 ;& !,-*&"!&'/ &$'

1'&-&- '" *$!44 "' !- 3 5 3 &$' (44:- , 2 5-&- *) ?-@ $' 1'&-&- '" *$!44 & -**' &$' 4-3'"& ,"!

&'56 ?--@ $' 1'&-&- '" *$!44 & &! 1'" :-&$ !

'9-5'

2'/ "!4 "

52 '

&!"

/ 5"- , &$' &"-!46 ?---@ $' 1'&-&- '" *$!44 & !3*'

& $- *'4(

5!&' 3'("'

&$' &"-!46 ?-9@ $' 1'&-&- '" *$!44 & 2 -& !

(('

2' :$-4' 3!-46 ?9@ $' 1'&-&- '" *$!44 5'1*-& $-* 1!**1"&/ -( !

/ :-&$ &$'

&"-!4 "&6 ?9-@ $' 1'&-&- '" *$!44 ,-9' $-* 2'441$ '

3'" & &$'

9'*&-,!&- , ((-2'";% ( 2 '5 4-2' %&!&- *$!44 & 2$!

,' $-* 2'441$ '

3'" :-&$& 1"-"

1'" -**- ( &$' ; & !,-*&"!&'6 ?9--@ $' 1'&-&- '" *$!44 & -

'" &"

& 5'4!

&$' &"-!46

2!*' ( 3"'!2$ ( !

( &$' !("'*!-5 2 5-&- * !

5 &$*'

:$-2$ !

3' - 1*'5 3 2 '5 ; & !,-*&"!&' !* 5-"'2&'5 $'"'- !39' " 1 *$:- , !

&$'" *((-2-'

& 2!*'/ &$' %&!&';2 14!- *$!44 3' !& 4-3'"& & 9' 2!

2'44!&- ( 3!-4 ( &$' 1'&-&- '"6 "5'"'5 !22"5- ,4

&$- , *!-5 $'"'- !39' *$!44 3' 2 *&"'5 !* !

'E1"'**- ( 1- - &$' '"-&* ( &$' 2!*'6 6 2' &$' !- 2!*' $!* 3''

5'2-5'5/ 1'

5- , -*2'44!

'* !114-2!&- / -( !

/ *$!44 !4* *&!

5* 5-*1*'5 ((6 ?% + % + % + % +@ %'1&' 3'" %'1&' 3'" %'1&' 3'" %'1&' 3'" /

!$!9-"

I$'&$'" *1'!.- ,;"'!* '5) '*;

I$'&$'" "'1"&!34') '*;