← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2704/2018dismissed

Har Narain v. Sahib Ram And ORS

2024-04-26Mrs. Justice Ritu Tagore10 pages

 

      





   

 

       

  





 !

"  # #

   

 

! "#$  % & 

! & '&% & 

()

   

$  (

*  &     

       +) +, -+(./

(1

 # 2 & #3/3  & 1%  %      #4#  ##4     

          2 --5 -+(6 #     &

 

-

7 

# /  ( #  #21  

()/  #  #2 4  1

 



 & #     &%#    8   

       

  .    (.  /          1%               (9#4#4

  # % #

 : %&    #   #   ##   %4   # &  &  ### 4

       (9:

# #  &4 

; #     8   % 

  

  #

## #    #   %

 # /

,1

7 

# /  (1          

       %   #     4 

 /

61  &  

 

  4&  %#  #2

   &  

4&%  -< +5 -+(5

   

#%  4 

  #  #2/

<1

,

=  # 

# /  (1  &

   

5( +5 -+(6/

-1%     # # /

51



  #      # 4&%#  #2&   ##4

 &  #   = #  #

%

2 ##     4 

   67    %(9<5    # % 4       #0    #  4   # 

7 

# /  (1 0   # #  

#      &   %   ## ; 

 #       %4   ## #> 

   ## %# 

##     #

#   

             /

1%  ##

  ?##

 (6 +5 -+(6% 

> 4#

#   % &   #   

4&%  &  

### 

7 

#    +) +, -+(.

/

(1 4## 

 #   #4 # #   * 

       

%  #   

#     8  #

    #

&'& ()*& "*+*',) -.

./0*(* 12+&3 #&3,,($  %4

*-*5 46  #23*(),3 1&23 &()

(7'/,3 -.

#&+,,3

/&'*&$  4

*-*5  % &  #  

#

#       #   

<

  %# 

# /

()1

  # &#  4



       7 

#  & 4

 4   #  



   %   ;        

   

      %           ##

               #  @%   

  #   8

             #       7 

# 

&    0   #   # 

4

  # * #2 7 

#   6 7    (9<5  & 4 

            #      #   2   * 

  



%# 

# *3+ 1&23& &5

*./&(

&..

-.

*3+ &'/3&

&..

'+&

&+$

/+,)&8&) &() '/,3.$

2(9&8 &() &3:&(&  7 

#     

 8   

    # ##



   

% &   

 =

     %# 

# 

&9 1*./73, &(),:

-.

#'&', 7;

  &() '/,3.$ 6

*-*5  %

)

=&# 

#   &  >4  &##

 

.

=  /

()1  # & #  #    8   /

,1 

 /  

.(.1    4

& -< +5 -+(5/

<1%

    

#  = # 

   4  #   5( +5 -+(6

4

/

0   -1%  4   4          &       # /

7 * #2   %##4

/

-1    &    +) +, -+(./

(1

=              %

  # &     # 

*    /    (1         %    #  

##4 

*      0       /

()1# 4   # 

:



    # 4 

  

   67    (9<5:

 # * # 2  #  

   &  #         &    %  4 # ##4   

 (+   # >   

#       &#



     /

0   -1  4  

    4   

      #    67    %(9<5%4&%

4

   &  

  ( = *3+ 1&23& &5

*./&(

&.. <&., .2=3&  8  4   #

   67    %(9<5

   & 4 # 4 

#0

# *



2  4 #  #   #     '

125.7<+2( *..& -.

773 7/&++&)$

6%

55&/8&)  4  4  &

      

    

                    !      "   #   #   $          

   

       "=4  &

      %         %   ((

=   

    8  #        &     

  (



    # %

##     

4

 % # 

 # 4 

   67   

(9<54 #%  8     (    

(-

4

 ##  #  * #  2  #    

     /

  (   )1%

&  A     ?#   # 

   %  # #   # ##4



  8   *

  0  A   

 ?      44 2%4  0 

   # #4   #  

(5

$

 

   % 

  &

9# . #922%4 



B   

             



     

 

       

   

 

  

   

  

 

 

  

   

 



    

   

   

       

      

   

 

 

            



 

       

 

  





 

          

           !

  

       

  

 

 



  

   

 

       

"

 #     

 

  

 $ 

 

C



(,

*   /

  (    )1%     

/

-1 # 

#4          -< +5 -+(5 &     

#   =  # 4  /    

  .    ((1             #

% > 4

#    =4 #

#4 4 24   #  #  % #    %#

> 4

#  %##   #



=



/

-1% #  #  & 

(6

*#  #2%

 & 

       #4    

#0      #   %  &  8  %##4

   

@# ;   %#  #2#     

/

()1 *



 2%   #    #  2            8    

%  

    &  &##     

(<    @%   #&  & 

     

 % 4#&  &   

9#9%22 &  4  

4##  # 

 #.%4 

> 

#  

   / 1%   #

 

  

   

 * / 

6

.(51%   # /

51% #

4  2  # #   

 4  4 ## 4&%    # # =

&4  4  % #&4 4   > ; # 2 @% 4#  &     *  

   4 ##

      =      %

#>   /

()1 

##



      

#   %

 # # %   # ; >##4    #    #

%  ;## %  ## 4 #      & ##%#4 #>  

#



 

 

= 

%

  & 

   > 4

#   %   

#           =   &       

  &%  

0  

 # # &       

  2  *   0  #  # 2    

 8    ##    

()

@%  4   #  2 

    %& &#  %

   # &    ## 4   #  %

 & 4  # D &   %#  4 ##4    # #  

   

   8    #    %4#

 

  8    = %##  #2

 #  8   # 0 8    &     (.

@

 & &% 

  ###    %4   0 & #8   

  #--)2

     2 * #4#     &  % # & 

  

(9 @

% 2    &

%   % %

    # %   

+, +9 -+(.  2%  &  -+

      %  ## 

/ 1%  %# 

 #

 



   

     &23&- #737'

Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No