Birendra Singh Chauhan And ORS v. Food Corporation Of India And ORS
!"#$ "%&'&#( ))
* *
*
+
,* ,- *
.
* *
*
- / 0-)*- *0 ! " #$%&'(& )
" *
+
, *
---- - *0 1)23 4 ( $ " .
%(
/ * 0 * "
+0 "" #$1&(2)1)#$1&'(&1) #$123)41)
0 * ""$ / . 0 . "#$1&(2)1) *
&63 # 7 /* *
)8)3)(()3)')2) )2)')9:
1 14 .0
% " 0
0*
* 9 ; # 7
* ('3(9
<;#7 * ('3(=5
/* * (())(2()) )())9:
13148 .0 . > 4 >
1;#7 * 0 777 "
0 5 0 )"
* 8)0 #"" "
. " 0 5
/ "
* 9 ;#7 * ('3( 5
* 1" " ". "
?
0 ? 1" " )8)3) (()) >*
.
!"#$%&$'&%()*+ ,
+-./01 2 34 55 5+34 + & 6! 7 3!
8 . - .&&&%%&$*&5$59 :6+& 76 ;2 - . $9 + . ..
- &<
8=, +. 2 34
55 5+ 34 %(*% 2!6&> 6+=5*&$$95:%:5$59= =%=>!6 # %%&$*#5$59&
8=, +
6 . 8 - #
& 6!7 3!
8 .
- 1
8=, +&< 8
."
.0 0 " 0 .
" "
)')3)(
.0
. .* #""5
. > *
#"" #""5
" 0 "
5 "0 " 80 * "
* *
()9 "
0 . "
* *80 . 0 " 0 . "
*
*80 . * 0 "
0
. 7 < 0* = <:= < *=
.
" 0 5 "0"
0 . "
"> " 0 .
.> " "5
" (4 # 7 &
." 0 #"" 5 #""
0 " 0 "5 #"" " 0 "
0 0 " "
0
" / 5 .0
#"" 5 #"" :"
#"" "" > 5
"
0 .
"
0 " * /*
.
.>
" (( # 7
. .
*"
*
()9
. "
0 . " . " . " . 01 "1
5
. " 6
. * "
05 "
*
()9
* .
*"
* 3 7 * " . .
2 + *
. * 9 ; # 7
* ('3( *
)')3)(
.
5+ + + 6. -
- 2 - --2 .
?-. # +4 -4@442 2 ;= - - 2 9A- A$-B +4- -=2-B
+ 42. - - . -2 -
-2.=
- 2/ 8- 2-
# 022 - - . --- . 1 -C.& + - C.. .
. &
A& -.A$:AA-
9$-2 - 8=4434
+ %(*%&7 D 2-;- - 2. /
2 -
2.:= -& )& - - - A$:AA- 9$- 2 - = -
&.2 = =
.
A2 28 /.-. -=
- - 55 5+&7 2. - /2 A$:AA- 9$ -;-2 -& *& 72.- .. - 8/2.
& 4
- 8 2
- 2 2
2 & E&
!
&
7 . 2.
.
.# $$&%"
-"56"3'#$"7&"8#55&!!""
2#6"9"%&9"96:;;#&(!&(< =!>#3&!:
@
5B:
C? 5 D# 6
*? 5 D 6
42 !: 8 2 + -=4 2
>:
- : . 2--- -& "
7 .
.# $$&%"
-"56"3'#$"7&"8#55&!!""
2#6"9"%&9"96:;;#&(!&(< =!>#3&!:
@
B "". "" C? "
6 "". ""
*? 6 "". "" 7
/
# $ # # #% & - 8434
%(*%+& (& '
!4 2 - .
4
+ 2.
& 7
. 2 -2. .
- 2
- 2.& %$& " ( () #
!7 .- 2.
. /
.#= + - . - & + -4 2 & 7 - -:
& + 6 -- 2 -2 . .-
&.2 4 . 2 - .
+
2. &7 -. - 28 2-. 4 2 -& 4+ 6 -- 2 2 A-. A- 2 -& 7 .2 . - -&4 -.2 A- 2
-/
. - & + 72 - 2.&78 ?2 ?2 2.
&7 - -
2 & - ./ -/ . - - - &4. 4
2 - 2
- 2.
& 2
/
-/ &E '
/ * 9
* "
* ; "
* A "
0"0. 1" 0
. 5
1;#7 / 0
0
)')3)( "
*
1" " . . 5
1" " 5
. "
"
0
. 1" ".
"/
. 0 .
0
. 0 . 0 0 .
5
.
"
. >
. * () 7$*#+,'-. /01 2/
/- . . :
. * * " * 0 (4
. 0BA 0 .
BA 0 .
" ?.*
. " .
" $
. 0 "
A . * * (4 ,
+ *
/* . *& 6.
;
-. ; %'#. ; F 7 &4. - &
1 .
8
&6 = . 2 2 & ;-- . -
. &
..- 1- &0& - 2& 7 6 %(*'+ ' 9 - 2 2.
;- &4 ;- . B.
. . & - ;
.22 %'<&
%'/ ;- & 7 . -. - ;- = 2 %'/ - 5% . -. %'&4 1<- 2B. . ; 5% . & ((
"# >
*" "
0 " *" " " " *
#
" *
(( 9 # "
"
0 ". *
"7 " 0
" /
""
"
0 . "
0 "
" 5
*
" "
/* 1
" " * ".
.. " . .
.>
" F
"
* *"
@ .
/* *
0 *
* "
* 9 ;#7 * ('3( ( .> "
0 " "
" 0
* 0 .
0 "
"# 1*3+, (# % .
01 2 . * . " *"
0 "5 : >
*" 7. - .
- . -
# +22 2
-/ & +!- - 9%% & +3 - . - 22 &
2+ -2 /2. & 2+ 2
/ & 2+7 - 2 ;-.
& 2+4 .2 2 2 & 2+ - 2 &< 7 4#( "$ 5 4 4#( "$1 2++ *
"# "
0 " "
() # 7 "
0 " A 05
. "
0 7 6$(1# + 1"## .
01 2
"# .
"
0 " . 0"
" .
*. 0.A :
. .0# ( "
.0 #""
#"" *
*
* #"" #"" 7 #""
#"".
"
0 # :" "? 0 #
0 #"" #"" .
#"" / "
0
* "" * * *
. #"" " " 0 5 #
0 "0 " *0
.0
.> #"" 7 / .1 >
*" #
.
#"" .0
. "
* *80
. (4 ** " * " 0 "
0 . 0 /5 # /
*0 0 0 "" A "
0
.0
" 0 "
0 . 1" 0 .:"
.
F
(())
" 9* A 0 /
" 9* > 0 9* .0
"
0 5 0 . . .0 #"" "
0 . "> 6" " " ;
" *
#"
0 /
7 * 1
"
.. 0
. 1 .0#"
0 (8 7 * #
9 *
()
)')3)( . "
* 80 * 1" " .
0 0:" ; " > * #
9 9
*
() )')3)( * " * 9 ?
0"
0
. *
* * 80 . 0 9 ?
0"
0
. *
. "
*
* *80 * . 0 9 7 "
0 . *
. * 0 0
80 .
. 9 7 "
0 . "
* 8 0 * 01 "1
"0./ 5 .
. " " . " 9 #"" "
# "
0 .0
" 0 .0 " 1 ""
" / 9 7 #""
* . "
. .0 #"" (& ,
*+
"# 1 #+ #&.70 1
" "
0 " 1" 0 " 5 .>
.
*
"
.
A 0 . " 5 : >
*" ,- 22 2. - 2 2 &72 2- 7&.2. .
2 & - / - -
.
-& " -.2 2
2 8 - -
2 22 ;2 ; 2 &4 2 . - & - & -&< . . " .0
"#
.
A >
*"%)#8+ 19#$#.
0 17
(3 ; "
.
*#"" *6 *#""
#"" # *#""
/ "
#
7! *
() )')3)(7 . *
" . .0 )')3)(
.0;#7
* 0 . "
0
" 7
" "
0
*80 . .0 *#"" .0 #""5
* #
9 #
9 *
() )')3)( .
1
"
*80 * " "7
" . "
"
0 5
* #
9 9 *
()
2/ " 0 ;#7
+
(2
. "
2- *0 ()
$
/*6 G 6% G:6