High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1518/2018dismissed

Hardeep Singh v. Malkiat Singh & ORS

2019-03-11Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary8 pages

! "#

""$$ % & $'# " ! "#

### (

)$* +&, -

""$$ ...

### $ ""$ * $ *0 ""$$ 1 "$

$$##2&#, 3

"*0 4-$5&#5& -, 6$$2&#,

7"*0 $ 5&#, ""$$1"$

*,6 $ * "$*060

- " "- $6" $ &&- '6$# 6 $6 $

$$#$0 ,*0

$#6 &$ &$9! "#

- &$'# 9 #"

# $, & 6

6 & ""

*#&" ,$*$* # :"$

" 0

, 600 "- ,6"

$&&" &$&

&"- '6$# 6 $6 $$&# 6 # $

*,6

0*060 - "!6"0#0

0 " 0(

*,-

, 6 $$; $

$& ,2& #

# " &$ " & "

, " , *$0 $$#$$0

, ,/ &6 "$

9 - 2&#, 7

&*, <& , 6 " &$ * - "*& &" ,

" &$"$

$ 0" 7

,2&

$& *,6

0*060 - "6 <&$

,2&$9! "# - &$'# 9: , 5& 0

"$"" -$5&#5 -, $#6 &$ ($

9 &,*,"

6',,$$#$0, *0

& #

$0 & #" ,2&/ ,6& #*0

9&$($

6$ 7

*0 &$ &6 *0 /

"$$$0$$ " '6$# ;#$ $#&#6 ,6 &,*,"

'6 &""

# ,

,/ &,*,"

6""*0

&$,6 - , ="$(&2*

,*00""$6 $*0 3# 2&#, 7

6 "$

"& "" : , &$ ##*0

-$ 6$0 ,2&6 " $$#,8

, '6$# / "$

$$# - & &$ 6 6 ,$ ,0& , - 6 6 6 ,

$,6 $ 0 ,2& 7

,6,-$& $0 *0

,6*#&" ,! "

&6 #$0 $ 6 -&" *& 0""

06 #=" -

$-"" 6*= (?(?

&2) 6$=,;-

6 $*0 >

> @ $4& # - &, $& "$ - " $0*&6" ""$$1"$

$ # & 6- " 0<&:6 * - "$

6&*$ 6& &,6 ,

66 #$0 &,*, '*0

,/ "$

6 &$0 $,&6 #$0,""$ $*0

6 $ ,*0 $ 5&#, - 2&#, 3

7## -

""$

* $ @ ""$$- ,$0 #& ""$$ "

- ,$ *" 0"&

, 600 & &<&! "- 0" $- 6 - ,,* $ ""$$ $ & 8

*0 ""$$9&$ "

$ &

6 &""

& ""$$ *#&" , , * * 2&"

-# ""$$

, # "$#( & 6 >4(46

,$## -"

2& ""$$@ $ &" 2&#, !9*$&"

,4& %&'()*+,-&.)/ 0.1-&0+23/# (40&(-( 5+&+(',)+0../+*2.)0&(

73 44 8 &+.',+'*)++*2.)0&(40&(-()+()'%-,+&+&+'* '*)++*2.)0&(

>344 : - $,$ 0$$ 0

7 6 #=" & &$ $0 - *

1""$$: &"

0 ""$*$$62&#, 3

"*0 4-$5&#5& -, 6$$2&#, 3

7"*0 $ 5&#

, *& $*0 ""$$*

&# & : - $ ""$$ -#

&# $6 *$ :, & ""$$9 <& $0 # & - " 0 <& " $&

&"&& & '#$

6 " 0: , 7

,2&6#

$0*&

&*" "

0<& 6$$# & &# *0 ""$$/ !9*$&"

,4& -&-26+&++)'3 40&(-(&+, +*7)+/+.5'11+80'&.)+1++*2+*.)0&9 ::;

$ " - " "

0 ' - " ,& 6 ": * -

A ;-

&*- " ' $

& - " ,& 6 "$0 "

$# ""$$""$$

0 & - " $B C ""$$9-6$*0 >

> # 6 6- $$#*0

$0*&

1""$$ &* " *$0' , $0 # & * - ,$0 & # *0 $ &$ ""$$ # &$$0*, 2&#, 4& 8'*20&

%+-&40&(-(-&3+7)+*%+-&+*2.)0&(< < '4'1: 00.'*8)2070+(02&0=&0(0*.023/)'(# (5+&>)+%+-&+*2.)0&( 40&(-( +*?00.'*8)+*2.)0&(@ '4'19 2&#, !9*$ &"

, 4& %&'()*+,-&.)/"( &"

""$*$ &, %&'()*+,-&.)/"(&"

6, 6"

$#*6 " #

, & $*0! 0:0# $,* 6 &"

0 -#"& ,

,+$0& ,:0 : 6$& $#6' , 6 ,*0 !9*$&"

,4& !# 4&

'# &,/ " * - #

0#- 6&$* $&, D& , , $0 *& - * "

#=" *# & # & "$

9 $0

6$# "

-,$ $0 # & *0$ ""$$ "

,*0 & *$6 -$ ""$$ "&$ &, /

1""$$6- 06$$$- - 0

*$& 0"

2& *& ,&E

,# & &# $- 6&$ $0*-*$ -

, " &

"*0 & *$6/ , &$* ,$0 # &*&6 $

&&*$

, , $

"&$ &, 6&$, $0$6# ,!6- *- "&$ &, : * # & , ,

# - *0 ""$$ -

,*#&" , $ & 2&# ,:

" # $0* -*0* & *$6 - 6& &,, 8

6 6 #$0 "$$0 6 &$ "" #* $ " 0& $$0"

&,* "

# , 4& / & - ,*0 ""$$ 06 '*0 ,# &$ '0" # # , =" $# "

, * - -*

$0 , &'#$ * - " ,*$ / <&$@ ""$$&*$"&0 <& $6,& $&*$<& $66 -$-

""$ ) $ & *$6 - &

# # ""$$ 6 $, "

- 6 6

@ ""$$&*$"&0 $$#$0 ,0 - 0,"&#2&#,

"*0 4-$5&#5& -, 6$$2&#, 3

7 "*0 $ 5&#, $$ 0

*0 ""$ #&, * $0 > 0 E $# ""$ +"#-6 , *, <& $0 E $# ""$ * , ""$ #$0" #$0 ""$,6 #'(+'11

-280

"'#B

FB ?

" *$