High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/60734/2022dismissed

Gurjant Singh v. State Of Haryana And Others

2023-05-08Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil16 pages

!"#"

! $!% !&"'"

**** !"# $% %&' ()%*" $ +"' %,%% * -./ ()!* $+,-. " " ! 3 %"+ * " % 11 4544 06 72 % 8, 9'%$ %%+%%:&&%"%$$

% 15 4544' )% 44; % <5 5< 4541 ) <4<=-/4=<57=/5>=451=<- 9' + % &) % 9,' %$ % %+%

"* %&'"*%)*")%%"% 44; % <5 5< 4541 :% + ) <4<=-/4=<57=/5>=451=<- 9' % " %) * %! = %!" # $% ?%$8%' +% + @ % 8,"$% :" '%$&,'%@%% !% * (+%8,

% " ')"%&&% )17<04299:%

%+% %%$ +" % %@ # $%' :"% " A @% +"% "8" %':* 8) 0<2 "%*' )$ &%% %! %

% % B1 % *& %

&)% ) <1C 99 * $$+ " % " 8" % % %

%& %))

:(' " % %

&)% :%

- 2 -

$ ( % <5 5454406 -2 "9 174<* 4544 *& 8, " )$ &%% )"%&&++ " % <5 54544

+ 8* " 9 :" ) * $ "% 8 <1 4544% "%$ +*51 454< 0-2 "$%$'" :%% ( $$ % 4544' %&&+ &, " +%8 * DA(+%E ) 17<0;2 " :% ) 8* 9'%$ %%+%':"( $ + % 11 454406 72$% " @ )%&) ,&&4< )) +&,'"%%( "%"% $$ % 15 4544% "$ + % 11 454406 72$% +" @ )%&) ,%&&+%&'% %%8 *

)*&%:% % )""%$%&%8&83 %" 8+)%, &%:

0/2 ) * $ :% 4< 4544 % " )% :% *6 * 47 4544 * "%+ 8* " %)% F)" % $""% +),"%8"+"&+" 8,") &*&+ *")%8*"%)%F)"'"&'"9 ) "%") &*" %% ) "%$$ 0>2 ?% ) &*" "%) "%:%&, %*" +"(+%:")":%(* "&(&* "%"

%&+ :" " 8" % :% * ) ( " %

&)% )<1C99:% $ :")":%(,$ )" "!:& +*" &)% " "*%)'" &)'% &&+%&$%% *6% ) %'"%% "

- 3 -

("$&, %+ "% DA(+%E ) & 8 ) ) :" $*$"9 ):% )%&&+ " @ "

" DA(+%E :% ) ) " * )%&*&)'$8%&%( % " (+% :% %* ) # !"% % " ' # !"% "% )

) ) DA(+%E (

% 5> 4544 %*" $%&*"%

&)% )<1C 99 * $$+ " <5 5- "*' " ) *

&**DA(+%E%8%,% &&+%& 0;2 ?% ) &*" * ") "%(* DA(+%E D* " (+%E ) 17;0<2 8 ) ) ':%) $8 " &)% "*:% %* " +% + )"* "( )"%+%':""%&&) 8" " %& ) 17<042 99 % "

&$%, )17<0;2%:"""+ * $+"% " %)) "% )$$ %, **) )" ) :% *&&: 8," '% )"'"$ + %) %&,&&+%& " , * &%:

&%) "% 8 &%) " ) @ +$ * "

E8&

0C2

* "%( "%") 8&: %

&,$ "*%)*")%% )% %&&, % "$ + %, $% )"'"%*" (&%(*)&41*" 9 * % %( "% " %) * DA(+%E +*)% % "% 8 6) %+&,' 6) %& )% %

- 4 - %)"( " * @ ) ) "% " +" % )% * D* " (+%E' % ( * ' "% 8 " ) *

%,*" &)! $*"9 ) D* " (+%E % *&

&$%, )"%+A"' :")" "% 8 % " " )% &%)"%8 &%) !

"#"

$ % &

( )*

)+, "'" '" &)"%(% *"(+% "$%:")"%+%"&%:&% :8," E8&

$ 9 %)%%*@ +$"& "%%* 8$*%& ' " &)"%+"D* "E(+% )1740;28 * *"(+%A(+% G* 02-

%./ / 0-

)++1

,)+'02

"%./ /02

3,H

* "")*&% ) &*" "%:"%* +**%)"%8%)" *%( *"%)) ' )"% * +: & ) %

%+%" ) % "% " & &% &, " % $8&, * " ( ) :")"

+ " * + * *%) ) 8, % )$ ) % %

( &%:* & %& &%) &%) " @ +$ * E8& %@%"% +"9 (% '!

./ /0

+51 ?% % ) & 8$"% "$ + % 8," 9'%$ %%+%@ '&+%&% (%& % "%$8% "$%%&*%):")") &$% * "(+%*"$% % % )"'"%)*" @ * %+"

- 5 -

* "%( "%" "%8 )*)%&&,%$ " ' :""%8%8 %8)!8&:""% *")$ &%%':")" "(%& %*"8 , 01<2

%(+"% &% ) &*" %% ++" +" ") '"9 *") "%"$"

% "%$&%8&8 $

01-2 "*%& )17<99" :%

5> 5/ 45418,

' 9,%$ %%+%:"% "%" '%$ %%+% (*)%*"(+%'* "

% %8"* %%$ +"'%)% % )"", : )"%&&%

8)$ 3 %&&, $ % "% )"%&&% %

%+% %%$ +"':"*%"*" % :%* (&( " % )) ) B"%' " %+% :"$ )*)%8 "%(8$% 8,"%$(,)$ &%%'"%8 * 8) "*%& &%:"%8%% :"% )+$%%&'" "%8* ) (" % <5 54544( :")""%

&)% )<1C99*& 8," )$ &%% %,+ * $$+ * " % % %

%& %)) '"%8 :' )*)%,+ '$ )"&" *)*(% )%&%:'&**" *$8+ $$

01/2

$"%( % 54 5C 4541*"

) %& * &)' $8%&% (' $8%&% 9% ' " (+% * " )% :% %* *$ ) %$ % %+% ) # !"% % " # !"% ( % 15C 4541 ) %

*) )+D(+%E*")% 45;

4544'

- 6 - ")$ &%% %,% "%)) ' %%$ +"% %@# $% )%$ % ":(' ) & 8 ) 8*"

%* * %&& " $$8 * "

' % *"

% "

+"' ' ' "%"%8% :% ) % (+% 14544'$$8*"%)) %,)& +" )%$

8* "

% "%*' (*)% 8, "

' "

:% * (&(

" &(% " %

&)% * $% *& 8," &) ) % A

!" #"

$ "

% &' (' "

&! ))*!

+ , - ' , - ( .

$ "/ 0 / !%/ $ / !$

0 01>2 %& * " %8( %

&)% *& 8, " &) !+ @ )%&$% *" : & ":"%" )%&* &)' $8%&% (' $8%&% 9% ' %* " )% * (+%*$)%$ %%+%)# !"%% " * # !"%'%

:%) *) )+D* " (+%E*")% " &)% "%:&&:""+" * "(+%*"$%"8%*( ):")":% "D$ E8," &)% "%%$ %%+%% "%:%" %:",")%:%%* **%% D(+%E"

:")":%) 8, '# !"%

- 7 - " *$ ) * " "% " &) % ")%DA(+%ED* "(+%E"$%')"

"%8* 8)'"%& )17< 99)%,8* "':")"% % A ),* /0 00 !/ !0 !%/ $ / ! 1)2 3" "

+ $ 12 12

$ 4

- 5

6 2 7 12

7 1 2 $ 8 $

7 12$ "

$7 12$ 7 12$ $

$ $ 7 12$ $ )9# 12

$ " 1:2; )< $

- "

- 8 - 1=2 ;" $

- 6 $ -

1<2; $ )9#

$ 4

$ 6 2 "

7 12

6 )*) $ > $ 1*2

8 4

- 8

192 ; "

" 6 1<2 1 2! "

6 12 $ 4

$ "

$ 4

" 7 "6 12 1*2

- 9 -

$ 6 12 0 01;2 "&+&% "% %$8+ &, "6 D"+ ")"%&&8 $ )& * "(+% )* % **) %* % ) 17<042 "% 8 *:% " %+%E':")"":"%(%**&+*% 8*") * )$ @ )' " (+%+ **) )% && ) ) * " (+%% :" )"(+%'"**))"%+*%

&)%+* "( )'%& ) $%,'""%&&*:% " %+%' % * " +% + )" ( ) "

)8 *$ ": '"(+%+%+),)$ *& %

&$%, $%, $* )17<0;2% "%$"%&&8% ) %*" $%, % "%$

(*&%:"%&&%

&,:""9 %&:" )" 01C2

%(+ % "% )%, "+"&+" "% " * " (+%E :" " (+%+ **) 8% * " %&

) $%,( )%*"*%& "%8*& 8*"9 $* )17<0;2 " :( :""6) ( ) ) %*" ( (+%'"*'8 % )8 %%D* "(+%E8 )"(+%) * " %& % ) $%, ( ) " & * * " (+% 8+ " *%) 8* " 9 ( * ", %

)( %% 83 %+" $%,(+% " 83 (+%$%%

&$" $%,(+% ) ) 8,"$ : &)**)8,:%,*

&$%, :")": & %!% %% %)&*" $%, F "

- 10 - )%&, $% "% * " (+% : & : ' )&, $ & &,' " **) * %& (+% ) ) 8, " (+%+ %+), :('"&% %+%"%@ ) )D*"E D (E(+%%"%)%'""%8% * * "9 ""(+%+%+),"%+%"%%, : ) )D*"(+%E':")"

" )"$* 9 " )%'* "(+%"%8 8," % D*" (+%E G* -

./ / 0 -

)++1

,)+H 6 /

8 / % ./ / 0 94

/ :+ .

**;' " E8&

$ 9 :"& *+ "

(* )17<*"9 '8( "%" &)"%" : ) )* "(+%$* )17<0;2*"9 8 %& "% ( " %& 9 )% ) * " (+% )% )*"(+%'(:"" "%8*&

* ""& "% A

$" "

? "

> $ * : +

@ "

A "

( "

$" $ $ 0 " (: %! 6 /

8 / :% %

!% <

1 3.

3)*':" " E8&

$9 "& "%(%*)$ &*(+%

- 11 - 8A) 042 * ) 17< * " 9 ' " &) "% +" * " (+% 8A) 0;2 8 D*" (+%E DA (+% E )'"*'68:%(+%% * "(+% :%* ""& "%"(+%+%+),% =% ) 6) " @ ) )* "$ &, $ * "

(*"9 ") 8 %" +"9 ( "%(%," : )-;499":% "%"

A)+I%) @ ) $% $ 8 6) :" " * )*"9

!$ ./ / (

'& )+,+ . / ),+)' " J8&

$ 9 "& "% * " (+%8," &): & 88% (:""%+% "% %! )+I%) * " **) % " +" * " &) * " (+%6"% % " &))%6) )"%+"%* %)%,:"*"*$%)$&+"

!$=)% %& $% *) - !$ > - ?

'& )+53 8 )1 :" " (, 9 )& "% ) "% " :%

( 1;C; 9 )8+ " ) 8 *&&: 8, "

&)':"'%*" 8$*% )17<0129$%& ) 9 % %*"%+%"% %!)+I%)*"**)' "*"*%))%$&+":")"3 * "(+% ") ' ":('%&) "%6 ( "8+" &)*$ &% )"+ %(+%"*"*%))$+&+"%*" 8$ * " ) 17<012 %* " %+% "% %!)+I%)*"**) " *"?%:9$$"

- 12 - +% :%%)) +&,$% % *%&&," ("*$* ) 17<0;2 :% )

" %

" % ))$ "% " * " (+% 8, " &) : & )" " ) + 8* " ) :%8( 8%&&,*(,+% 8%)):"%("

&)"% '"*%& )" )"+% * " %) : & %&:%, $% :" %+% " :% * 8 % **)%*+ % %+%%,6)( %8 * :*" &) $%!* "(+% 04<2

! <

!/ 1 3 .

5)* " E8&

$ 9 % " $ $8&, * "& + D*" (+%E % 3 ()%&&, "& "% D* " (+%E$%,8 $8&8 D*"(+%E$ $8& " 'D*"(+%E(%+ )%8 $

* " 6 &% % &%8% ": K K$%L M'LM' L

M %& * ) 17<0;2' $%!+ )&% "% D* "(+%E $8&8 DA(+%E "8

E8&

$9 %&8( "%"&%: $% %%!+ * D 4

E * D* " (+%E 8 )%,+ % D* " (+%E ( %* *&+ * )"%+ " % % ,+"*" &)% DA(+%E:" $

04-2 +% " 8$*&% ) &*" "%" &)"%((A%)" " *"%&) % % )"" % * " "% & (&% * )& 41 * " 9 * %'"8(%$% 8, E8&

- 13 - .

6 ! .

./ / # 0 (

) .

)' 8! $

" 69 "& "%(, **" & 8$% 8+"+ &,&%:%8 ,% %8(&%: " % *& )"), ") %%)) " :")"N B% )% )) )@ ) % *% (+% "(+%8) ) %$%% %: %@ 8%&%)8:)IJ+" )&1C% 41% 6 %(

:* &)$%!(+% * ""&

; "

- "

" "

$" $ " 0 04/2 " ) *

' % &% 8, "

' %& : & %& )$ " ) * " % " 8%) + * %

&)% *

& % )$%& %& "% " * *%) " & "%( 8 8, % )$ ) % *$ ))%% %* +**%)"%8%)" *%( *"%)) 8 "% "%&& 8 % 8% " %& % )() * " %)) * %

** )**) &%)"%8 &%) (% '!

0 %2 :"&&, $ &%)

)% %&&, ) "% " & )"* +**%)"%8 *%( *"

'$A:""$%&& 8*"%&)

- 14 - F '" * $$+*" %& +8*" 9 9A174<A4544 04>2

" )%' %* * %&& " $$8 * " %&

' % *"

% " +"' ' ' "%"%8% :% ) % (+%14544'$$8*"%))

%, )& + " )%$ 8* "

% "%*'

(*)%8,"

'" :%* (&( % % )" ",:%

+&,' 8) "%"$%':")" :% %& (+% 8, " (+%+ %+), % $8%&% :% %* # !"% % %

:% 8 )

%+"8,'" &)**)%&$+""%(8)) " $ D*%)E :")" : %& D$ E 8, " (+%+ %+), % $8%&% :")" & + * D* " (+%E 8, "

" *%) )$ &+" :")" : & &% ) & %+ 6) & %+ )%

'%(+%" "% + 8%%&@ )%)$%&)% %$$ %"%%( +* " &%,8+)% ))& + ")$%& ) + )% )&%$ ))' % % $% * +"' % " %& && + "% ( %&,' " &) $%)", ,A 8 8+"*%)")*") % 8+"%) %&) & 8! " ' $+&,' 6) *& ) ( " (+%+%+),%$8%&%% % ))

)*)%8 * @ ,"%8$% %+%" **)$%! $% *%) %"%+ $$"$ :('"%%$%*%& **%&% @ )%%8 "+ &% "9 *%*$)$$+

- 15 - $*")% (":')"%&&&++'"

: & 8%&8, ("))8,&% +( )'* %,' :")" $+" "%( 8 %! D) %E 8, " %& (+%+%+),%$8%&% 04;2

"&+"*"%8( ) '"9 *$(: "%02" A &)% "%:&&:""+" D* "(+%E'%*"*%& "%8*& 8*"9 $* )17<0;2'"8%** "%& ) $%,( ) % " :( :""6) (O02D* "(+%E"%&& 8 ) % * " ( (+%' "*' 8 % )8 %%D* "(+%E8 )"(+% ) * " %& % ) $%, ( )O 02 " +" * "

&) * D* " (+%E 6"% % : & 88% (:""%+%"% %!)+I%)*"**)% ')% 6) )"%+"'%*%')%,:"*"*$%)$ &+"O 0(2 " &%: $% % %!+ * $ *$ " %+%*D* "(+%E'% 0(2" 8$ % D* "(+%E: & 8

&$%,"%& 04C2 "%%*A% % (:*"&%:&% :8, " E8&

$9 '* %8('"9 * %, + '$ )"&(%& '3 %"" % 11 454406 72 % $ % 15 4544 44; % <5 5< 4541

- 16 -

) <4<=-/4=<57=/5>=451=<- 9' + % &) % 9,' %$ %%+% 0<52 )) +&,'" $

) 5;

5/ 454< C /()!* $+,-0

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No