← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/4941/2018dismissed

Pawan Bishnoi v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2022-06-02Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri12 pages



    

!"#

"$"% !"#&   

   ' ( ( 



 

)#  *)  (((+  *)  (',((

   

    "



    "#       $% &&&&&&& ',((

- '

 ("

 

)



*+*,-*+.



) #0(+.*1-(-*+1

2  







-1*.-*+3(#0(+3,(-*+3  !

/  /

 

" 

)  !

  

  '

 

(       "

   

 

   $ "

 

 / 4$5 

!

 

 -,*.-*+6 4  (+5 /

 

!8" !"

4  2#95'



" 

!

"

/



+:*3-*+1 4 (+,5  )) ) 

  

!

  /  " )    

 

 

 !(<(!

= 1

-3. 

 )

"

   

 



 !

 / 

(" 

 

[2] -  "

         /

  

   # 

 $ 4% (63   !

(1-5!

 

-,*.-*+6 4  (+5 

$ 

 >

     %    '

 

  



% "

/

" ( 

   " +?*3-*+6

      !  "

 " 

 

   #  )  *3*:-*+6=



 



 -1-"

  /



# )

 

!  "

  "  

"

 /    

  4 (- (65



 '

 

!

  "

-**:-*+6 6

 " 

/

"

//

#0= -13,3 -*+6  )) @ ) 

/

;     

 /



#

) *3++-*+6  1  0  )

#0= -13,3 -*+6 +1++-*+6 

  )  ! 

( AB!

) 

"  " !    #  

    

 

  B7  /

"  @ )  

"

  " " 

  )

B7

C ,  

 )

"







 !

 -.++-*+6 4  (.5 '

 

 (

[3] A'

 ""

)/  

D 

  

"

"  /

#



)

-?++-*+6 "

  

! )   / 

"

" )

    " 

"

 

;  )

/; @ /

;

 )

 )!

 /

    ! ) "    "      



  

  

#

/

)





     / "

)  B7

 "



 !





)

"

" 



 )

B7 #

 /

"

 )



"

 ;  !  

 

;

; 

   C ?  D"

   

4#5



/ -.++-*+64 (35 !

 

  "

 

 

   

)    

*1+--*+6'

 



( A=E'D#B ,."! // "/."# 0"!.!0/

 12 20  033 !  /2 43 /./.

504."0/." +* 



/  D  DD4

  # $5

!



 

  

  "  !"

*3(= !(-*+6 -*   

 

 /  !   ) )

 

/ /    )

#

 

 / 1  $

  -*+6 / *,**  6* " 

"

#

   F") !  "    )  @/ 

 

 

 1* 

 

  

 ;   !

 

 



[4] ,*

" /

 ! !

  C . 

 

  



 = + 

 





 *-+--*+6 4 (:5 3  

   "

     " 

   / ) #0 = -*1?.  -*+6

 2

 ! "    

  

 

 '

  

 )

"



 )#0= -*1?3 -*+6

2 ! !

  

 

  

!

+6*.-*+1  "  

( A

)

 

  

 



  

 

 

!

 

) 

"

 

 / 

"

 

'

   "



 

!



)

" 

  



= "

/   "

 

 8  "

  

 

! 

!



      

"

 '

"



 

 

C : D"

"

   !

!

 / 



?-"

 

 

/

  )   

!

 

 '



 +:*3-*+1  # 



 "

/(

   -3? "

   3*  $ 4  (+,5  " 

  "   

 

 



[5] +* D / 



/

= +4   5 / !

-:++-*+? 

)?*

!8'% /  



= - ++   )  /)

 !

*?*,-*+?  " "

/

% 

 $ 

>

  !

#0= -*6:6

 -*+,

  !# $#   

  

%

"

 

 

 $ 

/   '!

   G  % '



 

 = ,1 ,, ,?

 D  ""/!



  !  )

) "

//)!" ;

; D

!



= +        = ,6 

 "

 616,*  46--H-+,5 

= - = 1:

"

611,* 46--H--,5

1** '



  /#



4

5 *1*:-*+1

"



!"

/



 +-   

 

 

 )  

 "

/  

 

 "

    ; / 

 



"

 



"

  %  = 13    "

611?. '



"



 

"

!

"



!

 !!(!

 +6 

 

 !

+1*:-*+?/

 "

/  #

'

  !   



7

  /

!  ;    D   DD 

[6] !

@8

 

"

""

)/



 

    (+ 

  !   "   

" 

 +1  

  

" 

 / )

 !  

  +, 

) )

"

 $  ;   

  )  )  

 /  -*+6 

0   )!



#

"

!





")!  " "

 "

"

"

" ; /"

"  "  

 +? 

  "  

)  !

 

  

 "  )

(#0(+3,(-*+3 

/

(  ()

 

 

 )   '

 

 



!

-1*.-*+3  )   

) ! 

 +.  !

  

  

    

   "

 !



 

 +3

  

  "

) !

+1*6-*+?   !

 

 ; = .1  D 

$

  

  

 

$ 



    

  

    "

 

 

#

   " #   G

  



+6*--*+?  /

; 





" /



 = +: ?? .1D    

0  

[7]  

 



   !

"

 !



D  



 "



G # 

;

!



  +:  "

 



  





 

 ) )  ( 

       "

  "

D  



"



 !  

  !"" 

% "

/ !"" 



"   

  

 #  "  " 

 



2 B7 9  "   



2B7 

9D   





0   !

 / " 

 -.++-*+6 4  (35 

#

)    B7     / 

 

; 

!

 / 

  "  !

 

"







"  "    

) /

"

 -* 



 "  "



  

 

  D   

 ) / 

 )

      )





/ -*+6  )#  

"" "

   !

 7#    

       -6 7(89:- "  

 

   

 



     

  6 7:(9-

[8]  ! '

 ! 

  

    

( A8E     / 

 / 





// 

)



) ( !  

D 

 

/ 





"

 '

  



!



/  "  

 "

 



 

 "

!

  !)

"

/ ;      "

  ;/ 

)  

) 

   "



 "

"  " 

/  ' #    /      I 7"

   ) ;  8D 

 





"

#

 "  !



"





 "



 '  "

 

 ! 

/   

 " / 

 "

 

/  

!



 " "

      "

 / 0 



 "

 



    )        

)

 

  ;/ ) 

 ""

/ "

"

    '

 ) 

 

 ) 



"

" "

 "

 



 ) 

     /

 "

   !

""

/  "

 

  

  

 '

        ""



; "

" 

 "

   

  

   ) /  

 

"

 

)





  I 

[9] !





J

  



J

/)

  "

  !

  

J   

/  )

"



'  "

/ 





/

/K ! ) " 

"

 / "

  )   

'

 ) "

  "

 C -+ D!     

"#  $ #  67&(:9-

 7# "

)

 ;  

       



@         

" "   "



" 

  !



 )



 

    

 ) 

#  "

        

/ 

/ '

   " 

>) # )

 (

  )

G !

 

/ 

( AD!

   

 

 >)  #

 ;      

   "/ 

   



"

D

 " "/  )

!

      

 "

  ) 

  

 

+ /D 

" "

>) #  )

 

  )

G >  

      /"  #

/  

"   



 

"   "

  !

 

 >)  #  

 " "

 



>) # C --    

/  

   

  #  %  &              67  (8  



(

[10] A: 

 

  "     !

/    

 ) 

7  "

"

D/  

 ;  /

  

 !

     

  '

/   

 "    / "

"/  "  "  ))    )  "

   ) 

 '

 "" ) 

/  

 

"

 

/

"   ) '

; "

) 

/

 

 " 

 ) "

 

" "   C -6 0   ") !/  "

  

    

 "

 

  

 "

"  )

   

   %  &6 87(8-

  

( ;'

     

 

"

/



/    "

   ))  " 

/        ) ;

/  )'

"

 "  )    " 

    "

 "  ))



/   D&# '  ( ) L&# '  ( !*$#  4+:3651##6*:M 

/

 4+5

 J 4-5 !

) ) /

J 465 

"  

7"

 

;      )

 "  ;  8  

   "   "

"



   )

  / 

 

/  



 B7



[11] 

      !

    -?(

#

"

!

/

  

 "

,; 

-;   /  " )

D "  

 "



7   !    " 



 "

7   "

"

 N  

"



/  

/ )

"



"



"

" ) 

 

)

)!

 / 

 

 

 "

"  

 " 

 

C -1

 

     "

"

 

 !

/"



 " 

%      !   

      67 ( 8&-     ")

 " ! 

 "  --?

   #   

 "

    

)

)



 /  -, DG= +:,? -*+-

%     '     (  !      

"

+?*+-*+6     ")  "

   "#  $ #    %     

 "



  "    "    4%   5

   

!



)

")

"    

" "   )

  

7

0 

  

  ! 

 "  -?  "

  

 "

 

"  

 "



  "   #0 = -,1-*  -*-+



 % !   %

"

*1*--*-- )  "  ,

"       !  ""

[12]

 

 

) 

/ 

   

 

 " ) !   #  ) 

! /



7 

/   

 D

   "    

 

 / # 

"

 )!

 /

 0

 ;    / )  !



 (

B7

J  

 " "" "

 " 

!



7 

/

"

 -.    

/

 

/ !

 " 

   !

  "    )

 (+

 !

+1*:-*+? /

 "

/ #'

   /

""

"



 !



 "

" 



"



 !

""

 -3 D !

  "     







/

)



 

/ /  

!

  ""

)/ 



  ) /

  

  6((+7 6',((

7       $"

- )  

 )@ 

 O @=

   O @=