High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/35992/2019dismissed

Rajpal Singh v. State Of Haryana And Others

2022-02-03The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli11 pages

CWP No. 35992-2019 1

!"##$%&%'(

!)*!+,%'-. #"%"%'#/ 0#/&1& ,"!"#!/2!'!!'3".#/& #&*'3#'"&

/#&#'"(4 /)!2.!'-!&536$!"#5/".#*#"%"%'#/ /'71/%""!+533+36$!"##'#/!+5!/2!'!8%". /,!1/!9.!-5&&%&"!'"36$!"##'#/!+!/2!'!5 /".#/#&*'3#'"&

.# !/#&!%3 */#&#'$# %& 9#%'- /#$/3#3 "./1-. 6%3# $'#/#'$%'- &%'$# ".# */$##3%'-&!/#9#%'-$'31$"#3%'6%/"1!+1/" ::::::

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

CWP No. 35992-2019 2 !" .!'3 92 ".# '?9+# ,1*/#=# 1/" '3%! "#/ &##%'- 6!/%1& %'"#/*/#"!"%'&5 ".# $'"/6#/&2 #/1*"#3 8!& %'!++2 &#" !" /#&" 92 ! '&"%"1"%'#'$.".#'?9+#,1*/#=#1/"'3%!%'$!&#

!".# *#'1+"%=!"#*!/!".#)13-=#'"%&/#*/31$#3.#/#%'9#+8(4 BC# $ %&%& ' $

$ $ () $ *

+ $ $ ( ' + ' '' $$ , * + $ ) *

%&%+&$ $ (

$-! $ + ( . ' /0 %& + '

+ /0 /0 . $ 1 * %&$ $ ( 2

$ $ $

$ ) $ + 2

+ ') + 2)

) $

+ ) + 2

., 3 3 $ %& $ $ ( $

. 1 $ 4

%& + ' 5 $ *

+$% '& $ $ $

1 $ $-!

' $

$ ( + * ($ 1 $-! +$ $

) ( $ +* 64 $

% &

$ 1 *$4 '

5 $ *$$ )

$ ( + 7 '7 $ $ $ 1 $ $-! 8 +

(%&$ $ -! ) 1 %& 4 4 $

CWP No. 35992-2019 3

.+ *

* (%&'' $

'* $ $ *

) 1

* %& $ $ ( " . %&$ $ (

+ $ %& $ %&%+& 9 . $ 2* $ -!

%&+'* $1 : ;'+ 2* "$ $-! )

%&$ $ () +

2 %& - . $ %& * $ $ *

+ $ 2

$$ +$ $ ( $) *$ 1 * ' . $ + $ + + ,

%& $ $ ( * ' $ 1 * $

* $ 1

* * $$ $ $ () ) 4+ *

' 1 * $ $ 2*

* $ $

$ 1 0 .!"".#&1=!'3&19&"!'$#".#%'"#/*/#"!"%',#$"%'<

".#$" 92".#'?9+#,1*/#=#1/"'3%!%&".!"".#%/&" !'3 /#=&" $'3%"%' " &##7 +!*&%'- %& ".!" 9". ".# $'"%'-#'$%#& */6%3#3%#!91"".#*.2&%$!+*&&#&&%'!'3".#*!2=#'"$=*#'&!"%' !/# " 9# 1+%++#35 =#!'%'- ".#/#925 % #%".#/ ".# $'3%"%'& %& '" &!"%&%#35 ".#/# 81+3 ' +!*&%'- & !/ !& ".# 9+%-!"%' " =!7# ".# *!2=#'"%'+%#1".#+!'3!$;1%/#3%&$'$#/'#35%".!&9##'$+!/%%#3".!" &1$. 9+%-!"%' " *!2 %& $=*+#"# 92 "#'3#/%'- ".# $=*#'&!"%' 8.%$. 81+3=#!'".!"".#$=*#'&!"%'!=1'"8!&=!3#!6!%+!9+#"".#+!'3

CWP No. 35992-2019 4 8'#/!'3%.#.!&'"!$$#*"#3".#&!=#5%"8%++'"9#!6!%+!9+#/".# +!'3 8'#/ " $+!%= ".!" ".# $=*#'&!"%' .!& '" 9##' *!%3 ,%=%+!/+25 8/3D3#*&%"E.!&9##'%'"#/*/#"#3"=#!'3#*&%"%'-8%".".#>/".# "/#!&1/2/".#/##/#'$#$1/"/!8%'-*!'$.'=!.!&9##'$'&%3#/#3 "9#!6!+%3*/"!7%'-*.2&%$!+*&&#&&%'!'3'$#".#+!'3&"!'3& 6#&"#3%'".#,"!"#5".#/#%&'3%6#&"%'-*/6%3#31'3#/,#$"%'< ".# $" .#'?9+#,1*/#=#1/"'3%!.!&1/".#/$+!/%%#3".!" ".#*#/%3/8.%$.!'2%'"#/%=/3#/8!&%'*#/!"%'58%++9##F$+13#3 8.%+#$=*1"%'-".#-!**#/%3%6#2#!/&,%=%+!/+25%".!&9##'$+!/%%#3 ".!",#$"%'< ".#$" 3#&'"-%6#/%&#"'#8$!1&# !$"%'";1#&"%'+#-!

+%"2$'$+13#3*/$##3%'-&+!'3!$;1%&%"%'!&%" !**+%#& " '+2 ".&# $!&#& 8.#/#%' ".# */$##3%'-& 8#/# *#'3%'- ' ".# 3!"##'/$#=#'"$" < !6%'-*#/1&#3".#)13-=#'"*!&&#392".#'?9+#,1*/#=# 1/"'3%!%''3/##6#+*=#'"1"./%"2 &1*/! !'3".#*/%'$%*+#& +!%338'5'8 8#*/$##3""#&" ".# !$"1!+ =!"/%F".#$!&#%'.!'3 *+#!3#39#/# 1& ' " ".# !/# /#*/31$#3 +!%338' */%'$%*+#& 92 ".# '?9+#,1*/#=#1/"'3%! &*#/".#$!&#*1"/".92".#*#"%"%'#/5.#.!&$'&"/1$"#3! !$"/2 91%+3%'- ' ".# +!'3 %' ;1#&"%' $=*/%&#3 %' G.!&/!

4 !'3<<H H@ 4 %# %-.! %&8!&%"1!"#3%' ".#/#6#'1##&"!"#0%++!-#!/!'&!/5#.&%+!'3%&"/%$" !'%*!".# &!%3+!'3%&%'".#$'"%'11&*&&#&&%'".#*#"%"%'#/&%'$#".#"%=# %"& *1/$.!&# .# &!%3 +!'3 8!& !$;1%/#3 92 ".# ,"!"# !/2!'! 6%3# '"%%$!"%'&3!"#3 I!'3 %&&1#31'3#/,#$"%'<!'3 ,#$"%'@".#>!'3$;1%&%"%'$"5 I</#&*#$"%6#+2A++8#392!8!/3 3!"#3 / ".# *19+%$ *1/*&# '!=#+2 / ".# 3#6#+*=#'"

CWP No. 35992-2019 5

#&%3#'"%!+ !'3 ==#/$%!+ ,#$"/ 4 J !'%*!" " %& ".# $!&# ".# *#"%"%'#/".!"#6#'!"#/*!&&%'-".#!8!/3'#%".#/".#*&&#&&%'".# +!'38!&"!7#''/$=*#'&!"%'8!&*!%3".%=92".#!1"./%"%#&!'3!& &1$.".#!$;1%&%"%'*/$##3%'-&.!6#+!*&#3%'6%#8,#$"%'< ".# $" @

#/ $'"/!5 / '71/ %""!+5 +#!/'#3 33%"%'!+ 36$!"# !**#!/%'- / ".# /#&*'3#'"4".# ,"!"# !/2!'! &19=%"& ".!" ".# $'"#'"%'".#*#"%"%'#/".!".#%&%'*.2&%$!+*&&#&&%'".#+!'3%& !9&+1"#+2!++!$%1&%'6%#8".#+!8+!%338'92".#'?9+#,1*/#=# 1/" '3%! %' '3/# #6#+*=#'" 1"./%"2 &1*/! 8.#/#%' ".# /#$/3%'-/!*!"4/)'!=$.!.!&9##'$'&"/1#3!&!6!+%3=3#"!7%'- *&&#&&%'!'3!&&1$.#6#'%'".#$!&#!".!'35".#*&&#&&%'".#+!'3 8!&"!7#'6%3# !*!"JJ3!"#3 !'31/".#/=1"!"%'

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

CWP No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

#3 !'3 1"!"%' ' IJ< 3!"#3 8!& 31+2&!'$"%'#3%'!61/9#'#%$%!/23#*!/"=#'".#'?9+#,1*/#=# 1/"'3%!%''3/##6#+*=#'"1"./%"2 ,1*/! .!&$!"#-/%$!++2 .#+3".!"".#/#$/3%'-*!'$.'=!%&".#6!+%3=3#"!7%'-*&&#&&%' ".#+!'3!'3!=1'"&""!7%'-*.2&%$!+*&&#&&%'".#+!'3 '$# ".# *&&#&&%' ".# +!'3 %& "!7#'5 %" 6#&"& %' ".# ,"!"# /## /= !++ #'$1=9/!'$#& !'3 !'2 *#/&' 8. /#"!%'& ".# *&&#&&%' ".# +!'3 ".#/#!"#/ %& ! "/#&*!&&#/ .# /##/#'$# %' ".%& /#-!/3 %& =!3# " ".# ++8%'-*!/!-/!*.&/=".

! "

#$ %& !

( "

$% * +) ,

( "- "

" ! "

$%."

)

/ ."

CWP No. 35992-2019 7 ! )

" &

)

) )

" 0 & ."

! !

$ $ ) ' '

$ -! )+ 2* $ .2* $ ( ' 2* $

= 1 ' $ 2* )

2* $ ; * 2 $ ' ' 1) =

+ $ $' + 1&

& )

" ") )

.1&5 8# !/# ".# $'&%3#/#3 *%'%' ".!" ".# *.2&%$!+ *&&#&&%'".#+!'3%';1#&"%'&"!'3&31+2"!7#'!'3".1&5".#*+#!9#%'- /!%&#3 92 ".# *#"%"%'#/ 9#%'- %' *.2&%$!+ *&&#&&%' ".# +!'3 %' ;1#&"%'%&8.++2=%&4$'$#%6#3!'3%&+%!9+#"9#/#)#$"#3 / '* '0* '"&1%'( #*!&(#1&-(*)&0* '$#(+!(,-' *!&(2# *'(+'0'+&0(&*

.#/#&*'3#'"&.!6#$!"#-/%$!++2*+#!3#3%'".#/#*+2".!"".# !=1'"$=*#'&!"%'/".##'"%/#!8!/3#3+!'38!&=!3#!6!%+!9+#" !++".#+!'38'#/&'".%&/#-!/3/%""!+.!&!&&#/"#3".!"%'6%#8".# #F*&%"%' %' '3/# #6#+*=#'" 1"./%"2 &1*/! ".# 9+%-!"%' ".# ,"!"#"*!2".#$=*#'&!"%'%&3%&$.!/-#3%".#!=1'"$=*#'&!"%'

CWP No. 35992-2019 8 %&"#'3#/#38.%$..!&9##'%'"#/*/#"#3"=#!'".!"".#!=1'"8!&=!3# !6!%+!9+#"".#+!'38'#/&!&9&#/6#3%' !/!8.%$.%&/#*/31$#3 .#/#%'9#+8(4 2*+ & !

' (

+ $ %

3 3

" 4

>' ) $ + ' ' +*$ + * 2 + $ $

2* - "

" )

+ ++$! "

5 "

)

" ) "

+ %

)

) " )

+) !

* * +

6 "

7 8 "

) " ,

+ $%)

>' ) ' *

) + ( )

6 "

7 8 " )

+ 9 !) ."

1 5 .# !/#&"!"#3 !$"& $+#!/+2 /#6#!+& ".!" ".# !=1'" $=*#'&!"%' 8!& 31+2 "#'3#/#3 & =1$. & ".# =!)/%"2 ".# $=*#'&!"%'!=1'"&"!'3&3%&91/&#3!'3".1&5".#,"!"#.!&3%&$.!/-#3%"& 9+%-!"%'"8!/3&=!7%'-".#$=*#'&!"%'/".#+!'3!$;1%/#3!'3".1& ".# *+#! 9#%'- /!%&#3 92 ".# *#"%"%'#/ ".!" ".#2 .!6# '" 9##' *!%3 ".# $=*#'&!"%'!=1'"%&/#)#$"#3

CWP No. 35992-2019 9 &('&)* '"&(*!(3'("!' # 3!4'(-(+'0 '"*!&(56 &) "*&)5789#0')-$)!$$'+:

.# '?9+# ,1*/#=# 1/" '3%! %' '3/# #6#+*=#'" 1"./%"2 &1*/! .!&$+#!/+29&#/6#3".!"/3##=#3+!*&%'-!$;1%&%"%' */$##3%'-&1'3#/,#$"%'< ".#$" 59".".#$'3%"%'&%# *!2=#'"$=*#'&!"%'!'3"!7%'-*&&#&&%'=1&"'"9#1+%++#3%# %#%".#/".#$'3%"%'%&1+%++#35".#+!*&%'-$!''".!**#'.#'?9+# ,1*/#=#1/"'3%!.!&9&#/6#3".!"8/3D/E$$1//%'-%',#$"%'<

".#$" =1&"9#/#!3!&D!'3H'/E #+#6!'"*!/!&/=".# )13-=#'"!/#/#*/31$#3.#/#%'9#+8(4 2 - 8 " 5

$%) !

&")

)

* +

" & ) "

( ") '

( "

( ' ( ,,,, ,,,, ,,,, ,,,,

* - :; 7 & <

- =##)8

> 8 "

) ,

(

"" " - !

@ '$ +% - !

)

" - ")3 3 3 33 3- =, 4

3 3

$ %!

) " ! ! 3- ) 3& ,

(

) 6-&9673 ) !

" 3 )3 3

-) )

) ! !

)

! !

- " " ,

7 )*** $ %-) !)

)

& !

3 3 ! !

" !

" " !

& "

" -

CWP No. 35992-2019 10 "

"" " " !

" ,7 )***5 $ 0% & ."

@ - "

A- " &"

($ " % .) $ $ 1 * ') %&$+ + 2) ) 2)

) 1 *

'".#$!&#%'.!'3!&/#+#$"#3/=".#/#*+2%+#35%"%&#6%3#'" ".!"!"#/".#!8!/38!&!''1'$#3' 5".#*.2&%$!+*&&#&&%' 8!&"!7#'92/#$/3%'-".# !*!"'JJ3!"#3 8.#/#!"#/".# =1"!"%'8!&&!'$"%'#3%'!61/".#9#'#%$%!/23#*!/"=#'"&!/!& ".#$=*#'&!"%'*!/"%&$'$#/'#35%"&"!'3&31+2&"!"#3%'".#/#*+2".!"".# !=1'"8!&31+2"#'3#/#3!'38!&=!3#!6!%+!9+#"".#*#"%"%'#/'6%#8 ".#/#59".".#$'"%'-#'$%#&!&*/6%3#3%',#$"%'< ".#$" !/#'"1+%++#3 0

'(*!#$!*&)* '$#(+!(,-' *!&(

/'71/%""!+'".#&"/#'-".".#!$"&/#$/3#3%'".# /#*+2&19=%"&".!"".#+!'3%';1#&"%'!&!$;1%/#3/".#*19+%$*1/*&# '!=#+2 ,#$"/ " J !'%*!" !'3 .!& 9##' *+!''#3 !& *#/ ".# 3#6#+*=#'"*+!'".#&#$"/31+2!**/6#392".#$=*#"#'"!1"./%"2 .#+!'3%&".#/#/#5'#$#&&!/2/!$.%#6%'-".#*19+%$*1/*&##.!6# $'&%3#/#3 ".%& *!/" !/-1=#'"& /!%&#3 92 ".# /#&*'3#'"& !'3 !/# %' $=*+#"#!-/##=#'"8%".".#&!=#!&%"%&!'#&&#'"%!+!$"/"9#7#*"%' =%'38.%+#3#!+%'-8%".".#$!&#!/%&#'1"".#!$;1%&%"%'".#+!'3

CWP No. 35992-2019 11

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

0,G ,

>> /!6%'3#/ .#".#/&*#!7%'-H/#!&'#3 #&H .#".#//#*/"!9+# #&H