High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/837/2018dismissed

Haryana Vidyut Parsaran Nigam Ltd And ORS v. Darshan Singh And ORS

2022-07-19Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri8 pages

!""#$%&''

% (

' )')')* (

' )+,))

! "

# $

%" & ')')-$".-/-0!- 1' 2-0

' " ( *

( ,-.,,.#/

'0 ),#.-,),.#,1 + 2

! ! .3#.,.#, 45 )#$6 !

! !" "

! ,3.8,.##45 )-62 9 ("

"2!" "

: ! """ #8#.,.#, 1 + ! 2

2" ( ( 2 ( 2 #33:

#33& ,.

! ! ( ! ( ( ;

;5! " !2 ! *

( '0 )##:-/),.#,

,,.$,.#$ <

)##,-),.#$ 2

#8.8,.#$ "

4'6:#:.-=,.#$2

.8.#,.#& ! 2 ! *

'0 )3/,&),.#&

.#.,,.#/ < ! 2

> )#:#-),.#/#,.8,.,, 1 ! 2 2

( " ' ("

! (

"! "!

( (

1 2

2 ( (2

-3

#45 -5#67#!$!$8 -3#645-5!#$

.$./#33& ; --? ( '

( @

#$.,#33& ; --? ( ??

.$./#33& ; --? ( + (

2 ./.&#33:

; --? ( ??

1 ! ,3.8,.## 45 )-6 2! 2

( 2A

2A "

#. #..$,..-

!2! ( ( .:./,.##45 )86 B<5! 2 !" ( !,.3" '

"< 2

-"% %

4% ! 6 "! &,:):%) 8.=,.-/ ,/ + #38. 1% "

( !" !% '

( " " #.)$),..-( % ' =2A ! ! !

=2A) ! = 2 ( ( A

2" ""!

1 " ! % ' % =2A = !=! !

= 2A)! = 2 ( ( 7 " "

" "2! 6 1 =2A ! 2A"

#.)$),..-

! " '

"1(

1 "!

(A !

( ! 6 1 =2A

!( 9 "! "

= 6 1 !! ( "

(

( ; ;5! ( = ( "! ( !

( !

6 1 2A ! !

9 (

! ! ! (

6 1 ( 7

" 6 !"

! "! !

(( " !! 6 !

( " ( ! %

" 2 65 ! 2( (2 , "

"! ( ( 7

! C

* 2 2 2 .#.3#33&.#.8#33- .#.,#33- (

(" ' !! (! ! ! .&.:,.#&45 )#-6 2! "

'0 )##:-/),.#, 4% ' > 6 ! 5' <

" " ! 2 (!( < ! A

((

! !(

2! !2

2 < '0 )#:&,3)#333

! ./#,,...( ! @!2 2 " 9 ( 7 2 2A" "

: 2A*

" (2 *( !

(! ; ;5!2 "

" ! 2 (!( *

(2A 2 ! 4 !

6 ! #,#3/# 2

02 #,#3/#

"2 !!

"2A ( 9 *

"2 !!

< ! " "2A *("2 !!

5 2 9 !

(! ! 2 "

"2 !!

( A 2 2A ! 2 !!

"2 !!

2 ( 2 "! ( (2"

! (( 9 9 ( 2 " "2A *

" (2 *(< 2 '0 #.88$"#333 ! $,,...( @!" ' 2 ""! !2

( !

! ( ! ( 2 2 !

5!2 "

" ! <

#/ *( (! 2 *( " " 2A *

" <" " 2A *

" *( ( 2 *( 2 2 2

;

"2 !

2 *( 2A !

( "!

5 )- 9 "

""!

!" "(

"2 !42 65

)8 9 <! ( 2! !

2 ! 42 6 5! 2A

<" 2A !

( "!

(

"2 !42 62

(

"2 ! " C 1 * ( 4'6#/&8=,.#/ ,3.#,.#/< ( ! %' > 4 6

2 ! "" " ( ; 2$ 2A

!#&

"2 (*!

2 A

2A *

! " B< " !

( ' "" " ;1'!

!A ( " ' A! < "" ( #&

2 #&

" 2A < ( 9 "2A 1 (*!

2A "

"! 4<<<6"

! ,38,.## 2! ( ( )

/-,..8 "

(" ! "

(

(" !" % C ? 2 !

2 2 4 6 2 2

2 ( !

2 22A !#33&)#338 ( ; ;5! !

! ! " 2 ": ! * ( 5' 0 " ( ! (

2 ! 2 2 ( 2 #33:)#33& * ( (" 7 ! ! .&.:,.#&45 )#-6 <

"! '0 )#833/)#333

! ,,./,.., * 4 6 2 2 2 ( "! 2!

! " (*!

(! !

2!!

" "! ! ! " "

2 2 ( 2 !#3/8)#338 (2A2

(A < !!!

! 2" !

(( ! 2 ! ( %' > 4 6 !!

;

;5! 2 " <

! ( !

: ! 2 )2

2 !

(" <

( ! )#&8.),.#8

! ,&./,.#8!

&....=)2 0 " 2 2 A 2 "!

( "

#,&..=)!2!

( 2 ", " ,-.,,.#/ (! 2 2 ')')*

<0=&1 +,))

0 A=

D = 0 (

D =