High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCOCP/4118/2019disposed of

Sheetal Munjal v. A. Sreenivas, Ias, Director And Another

2019-12-11Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan3 pages

! "# ! "#" $%&%'(

$)*(+'+,-./+(% $(0%1%(*(*'%$

$"+'-%%1" +'',"%'*$ ,+$2+'+ !$%%&'&()!*'+, 34'/0 1%(*(*'&5+& *6%-&%%7*'8+-*$%/(*'(/'&*-%$ (0%/6+*) (0%1%(*(*'%$&9*'(0%5$*(1%(*(*'&: $(0%*$+-;4&()%'(4'-%$ (0%6*/2 -;4&()%'(<(*/%-+(%- =>

+'-

!%+$'%- /4'&%6 $(0%1%(*(*'%$&+((0%(*)% +$84)%'(& (0%5$*(1%(*(*'& &43)*((%-(0+((0%1%(*(*'%$&0+-)+-%$%1$%&%'(+(*'&50*/0+$%62*'8 4'-%/*-%- 0%5$*(1%(*(*'&5%$%-*&1&%- '

-*$%/(*'8(0% $%&1'-%'(&(-%/*-%(0%$%1$%&%'(+(*'&321+&&*'8+&1%+7*'8$-%$+ (%$ 1$.*-*'8+'11$(4'*(2 0%+$*'8(5+& 4$(0%$$-%$%-(0+(* -%/*&*'

*&'((+7%'5*(0*'(0%&(*146+(%-(*)%,*(5*66%'(+*6*'(*)1&*(*' /&(& ?,

<@0%/'-*(*' *)1&*(*' /&(&5+&'62+&1$%.%'(*', &(0+((0%1%(*(*'%$&-'(0+.%(+.+*6$%)%-*%& $/)16*+'/% (0%

$-%$ 0%1$%&%'(1%(*(*'*& *6%-16%+-*'8(0+('%%- 460+&'(3%%'

-'%32(0%$%&1'-%'(&

*-+.*(-+(%-

$"$%%'*.++&,", *$%/($, *80%$-4/+(*',+$2+'+ *6%-*'4$(*&(+7%''$%/$-,/120+'-%- .%$(6%+$'%-/4'&%6 $(0%1%(*(*'%$ A*(0(0%$%162,1436*/'(*/% -+(%-

+'-$-%$-+(%-

+$%+''%B%- !%+$'%-/4'&%6 $(0%"(+(%&43)*(&(0+(321+&&*'8(0%$-%$ -+(%-

,-*$%/(*'& (0*&4$(0+.%3%%'/)16*%-5*(0+'-(0% $-%$5+&1+&&%-+ (%$1$.*-*'8+'11$(4'*(2 0%+$*'8% 4$(0%$ &43)*(&(0+((0%$%*&-%6+2 +11$B*)+(%62'%5%%7*'1+&&*'8(0%$-%$ $(0%-%6+2,4'/'-*(*'+6+1682*&(%'-%$%-+'-*(*&%B16+*'%-(0+((0% $-%$5+&(3%1+&&%-41(=

+&(0%+-)*&&*'1$/%&&5+&.%$ '=

(*&&43)*((%-(0+(-%6+2//4$$%--4%((0%'4)3%$

/+'-*-+(%&+'-1$/%-4$%*'.6.%- !%+$'%-/4'&%6 $(0%1%(*(*'%$&43)*(&(0+((0%/6+*) (0% 1%(*(*'%$*&5$'862$%;%/(%-(*&+$84%-(0+(*(*&+/+&% -*&/$*)*'+(*'

+&&)% (0%%)162%%&0+.%3%%' +-;4&(%-50%$%+&(0%/6+*) (0% 1%(*(*'%$*&$%;%/(%-% 4$(0%$&43)*(&(0+((0480(0%1%(*(*'%$+11%+$%- *'14$&4+'/%((0%1436*/'(*/%+'- *66%-(0%1$ $)+34(5+&'(8*.%'

1+(*%'(0%+$*'8 0%&+*-+&1%/(/+''(3%8'%*'(*'(0%1$%&%'(/'(%)1( 1$/%%-*'8&0%-*$%/(*' (0%5$*(/4$(5+&'625*(0$%8+$-((0% $%1$%&%'(+(*' ( 3% -%/*-%- 0%$% *& &43&(+'(*+6 /)16*+'/% (0% -*$%/(*' (0*&4$(,*'&4/0/*$/4)&(+'/%&,'/+&%*&)+-%4( $

4$(0%$14'*(*.%$-%$

= 0%/'(%)1(1%(*(*'*&-*&1&%- 5%.%$,(0%1%(*(*'%$ &0+663%+(6*3%$(2(+.+*6$%)%-*%&*'+//$-+'/%5*(06+5+8+*'&((0%$-%$ -+(%-

+!$%%&'&()!, '-)%

)7 A0%(0%$&1%+7*'8<$%+&'%-

%&< A0%(0%$$%1$(+36%

%&<