High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/29747/2024dismissed

Union Of India And Others v. No 1084654 Ex Naik Ramesh Singh And Another

2024-12-17Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma8 pages

!"#$%%$

! &!' !"%$%$

( ) ) ! *" +,* $ ))

) -

+,* )$ )) ) * "#$%&'() "*+,*++-$&+-"(.%/,0"-/%10$/*%1 20"3+%4%3,3,0/%"*5 "-6,7-&(-1.&608-3%20""%*40/&%/30 )

) -

+"0$#+3+%,/*3-/3:",34%3,3,0/.3+%4%3,3,0/%"*+%"%,/

/,0/02/&,-.4"-(*20"3+%*%33,/#-*,&%023+%0"&%"&-3%&

;

<//%=$"% >. -* 4-**%& '( 3+% 1%-"/%& "?%& 0"8%* ",'$/-1 80/8%"/%&.:+%"%'(*3+%81-,?02"%*40/&%/30 20"3+%#"-/302 *%"6,8%%1%?%/3023+%&,*-',1,3(4%/*,0/20"3+%*%"6,8%"%/&%"%&'( +,?,/%2%/8%%8$",3(0"4*<>+-*'%%/-110:%&.'(80/&0/,/# 3+%*+0"32-1102 ?0/3+*-/& &-(*2"0?3+%"%@$,*,3%

(%-"*02 @$-1,2(,/#*%"6,8%20"%-"/,/#*%"6,8%4%/*,0/,/3+%

/'0&/1/'23 &!

%*40/&%/30 :-*%/"011%&,/3+%/&,-/"?(<+% "?0$"%&0"4*>0/; -/&:-*&,*8+-"#%&3+%"%2"0?0/ ;

%*40/&%/3 0 :-* #"-/3%& "%3,",/# 4%/*,0/. -* -&?,**,'1% 30 +,? -* 4%" 3+% %/*,0/ %#$1-3,0/* +%"%-23%". "%*40/&%/30 :-*"%%/"011%&,/30%2%/8%%8$",3(0"4*<

*%"6,8%> 0/ 880"&,/# 30 3+% 4"%6-1%/3 401,8(. $40/ -33-,/,/#3+%-#%02*$4%"-//$-3,0/."%*40/&%/30 :-*&,*8+-"#%& 2"0?*%"6,8%,/3+%0/;

-23%""%/&%",/#-*%"6,8%02 (%-"* ?0/3+*-/& &-(*.:+,8+:-**+0"3'( ?0/3+*-/&

&-(*.*0-*30?-A%3+%*01&,%"%/-'1%&3080?41%3%3+%@$-1,2(,/#3%"? 02

(%-"*.20"3+%4$"40*%02#"-/302*%"6,8%4%/*,0/.3+$*20"3+% *%80/&*%"6,8%"%/&%"%&'(+,?,/3+% ; %*40/&%/3 0 :-* &%/,%& *%"6,8% 4%/*,0/ '( 3+% 80?4%3%/3-$3+0",3(20"+,*/0380?41%3,/#3+%"%@$,*,3%@$-1,2(,/# 4%",0&20"%-"/,/#*%"6,8%4%/*,0/,/3+% %%1,/#-##",%6%&."%*40/&%/30 2,1%&.'%20"%3+% 1%-"/%& "?%& 0"8%* ",'$/-1 80/8%"/%&. :+%"%'(* +% 8-*3 - 8+-11%/#%303+%-20"%*-,&"%B%83,0/0"&%"+%*-,&.'%8-?% -110:%&6,&%0"&%"&-3%&

;+%04%"-3,6%4-"3023+%*-,& 0"&%",*%=3"-83%&+%"%,/-23%") ==== ================================

%%1,/#-##",%6%&2"0?3+%-20"%*-,&0"&%"-*4-**%&$40/ 3+%<*$4"->.'(3+%1%-"/%&"?%&0"8%*",'$/-180/8%"/%&.3+% 4%3,3,0/%" /,0/02/&,-+-*2,1%&3+%"%-#-,/*33+%,/*3-/3:",34%3,3,0/ '%20"%3+,*0$"3

;

)&456

6 !

7081/ !' &!

17 0890606 !

$ +%1%-"/%&80$/*%120"3+%4%3,3,0/%"**$'?,3*.3+-33+% 1%-"/%&",'$/-1+-*2-,1%&3080/*,&%"3+-3,/3%"?*02%#$1-3,0/ 0 023+%%/*,0/%#$1-3,0/*20"3+%"?(. -/&%#$1-3,0/ 0023+%%/*,0/%#$1-3,0/*20"3+%"?(. .3+$*0/1(3+% 0?4%3%/3$3+0",3(:-*%?40:%"%&3080/&0/%3+%&%2,8,%/8(,/3+% "%/&,3,0/02@$-1,2(,/#*%"6,8%.3+$*'(3+%*01&,%"20"+,*'%80?,/# %/3,31%&30*%%A3+%%/&0:?%/3024%/*,0/30+,?+%*-,&%#$1-3,0/* -"%%=3"-83%&+%"%,/-23%" <!

CD. > #$% &'

()

( )

#+ ()

CD. > ++ ,

./ ( )

0 (

)

#% (

)

1 0"%06%".3+%,/,*3"(02%2%/8%6,&%01,8(1%33%"0 < >5

55<%/501> &-3%& . ,/*%"3%&81-$*%<,6> ,/ 3+%

%#$1-3,0/0023+%%/*,0/%#$1-3,0/20"3+%"?(. +% "%1%6-/34-"3:+%"%02.,*%=3"-83%&+%"%,/-23%" 4%"$*-1023+%-20"%-?%/&?%/3:0$1&?-A%,381%-"3+-3 "%1,%2 @$- 80/&0/-3,0/ 02 &%2,8,%/8( ,/ "%/&,3,0/ 02 3+% -440*,3% @$-1,2(,/#*%"6,8%.,*30'%-880"&%&0/?%",3.*0-*30%/*$"%3+-3-/ -"?(4%"*0//%1,*%1,#,'1%20"-31%-*30/%*%"6,8%4%/*,0/! "

+%1%-"/%&80$/*%120"3+%4%3,3,0/%"*2$"3+%"*$'?,3*.3+-3 3+%B$&#?%/3023+%1%-"/%&"?%&0"8%*",'$/-1.",/8,4-17%/8+. %:%1+,."%/&%"%&,/8-*%3,31%&-* # $ %&

:-*/0380""%83"-3+%":-*80/3"-"(301-:-/&2-83*. 3+%"%20"%./0"%1,-/8%0$#+330+-6%'%%/41-8%&0/3+%*-,&B$&#?%/3 +%"%1%6-/34-"-#"-4+*.-*088$",/3+%6%"&,83<*$4"->-"%%=3"-83%& +%"%,/-23%" $,

$+4+$4#

. () 5

678 *

9:6 #+4 $44#

;++; *

9:6

$44$4#1<

) 7

) 8

< ) 6=

6 >?

@?A4$4#B 41##$4#B 2,

< ) 8 2,

9 (:6)

< '''' ''''

C 3

. ( ) D A ()

( )

6 7 8 #+

8 8

8; E

7 8

6 7 8 E

8 6 ;

= GE

6 : , ( ) !

‟ ( )

! " *

(

( ) ()

$($) 2,

$441,

#+4 $44#

; #$7 7

;( )

+ "

,-. -/ " 0

/1-/ -/2 (

) ;

( )

8 8

6 F ( )D A()

;+1

!7 !' 7086 & 0$

,/8%3+%%=40*3$1-3,0/*?-&%,/4-"-#"-4+0 023+% B$&#?%/3"%/&%"%&'(3+% 0/E'1%4%=0$"3,/8-*%3,31%&-* !6 ! 7 !6//!! 08 ( $)& ! )6!38 / 5/ ."%40"3%&,/ -/32 ,-,. 4-"-#"-4+ :+%"%02 '%80?%* %=3"-83%& +%"%,/-23%".06%"80?%*3+%&,*-'1,/#%22%83*.,2-/(.02*$4"-%=8%43,0/ 0<,6>.-*'%8-?%,/*%"3%&6,&%401,8(51%33%"&-3%& .3+$*.

,/3%/&%&30:0"A-*-/0'*3-81%"-3+%"-#-,/*33+%*01&,%"81-,?,/#"%1,%2 0280/&0/-3,0/,/3+%"%@$,*,3%*+0"32-1102*%"6,8% #$

' #$

= E

8 ,

$+H

#I %

$44#

+%"%20"%.3+%B$&,8,-16%"&,83<*$4"->.&0%*"%/&%"/%#-3%& 3+%*$4"--"#$?%/3"-,*%&'(3+%80$/*%120"3+%4%3,3,0/%"*.3+-33+% %?40:%"?%/33080/&0/%3+%"%@$,*,3%*+0"32-11.'%80?%**01,3-",1( 6%*3%&,/3+%0?4%3%/3$3+0",3(.%*4%8,-11(:+%/3+%+%"%,/-'06% $/&%"1,/%&4-"-#"-4+*.-*088$",/3+%6%"&,83?-&%,/)& ! )6!38

/ 5/ + '/ .-11$&%&30,/3+%6%"&,83?-&%,/+-?- -$"E*8-*%.&0 ,/6%*3B$",*&,83,0/,/3+%",30$"3.303+"0$#+B$&,8,-1,/3%"6%/3,0/. 3+$*?-A%3+%%*40$*%&80/&0/-3,0/

0/*%@$%/31(.3+%8$?$1-3,6%%22%83023+%-$3+0",3-3,6% B$&,8,-14"0/0$/8%?%/3-*8-"",%&,/3+%-'06%%=3"-83%&4-"-#"-4+. ?-&% ,/ )

" 3+$* 80?41%3%1( 80$/3%"6-,1*'03+3+%*$4"--"#$?%/3*"-,*%&'%20"%3+,*0$"3.'(3+% 80$/*%120"3+%4%3,3,0/%"*.3+$*20"&%/(,/#303+%"%*40/&%/3.3+% '%/%2,3023+%*%"6,8%4%/*,0/20"+,**%"6,/#,/3+%.?%"%1(0/3+% #"0$/&3+-3+%+-*/0380?41%3%&3+%@$-1,2(,/#4%",0&02*%"6,8%. '%*,&%*0/3+%2$"3+%"21,?*(#"0$/&.3+-30/1(3+%80?4%3%/3-$3+0",3( ,*-$3+0",F%&3080/&0/%3+%*-,&*+0"32-11

; 0/%3+%1%**. ,/ 3%"?* 02 3+% &%81-"-3,0/ ?-&% ,/ 3+% +%"%,/-'06% $/&%"1,/%& 4-"-. -* 8-"",%& ,/ 3+% 6%"&,83 <*$4"->. 3+% 81-,?*02&$-12-?,1(4%/*,0/,/-&&,3,0/303+%2,"*32-?,1(4%/*,0/.,2 "%@$,"%&.:0$1&'%"%*3",83%&2"0? .-*%/6,*-#%&'(3+% ,/,*3"(02%2%/8%C%33%"&-3%& ;

6!/1 7086 & 0$

/-23%"?-3+.3+,*0$"32,/&*/0?%",3,/3+%:",34%3,3,0/ -/&:,3+0'*%"6-3,0/*-'06%.3+%*-?%,*&,*?,**%&

+%,?4$#/%&0"&%".-*4-**%&'(3+%1%-"/%&",'$/-1 80/8%"/%&.,*?-,/3-,/%&-/&-22,"?%&

,*40*%&02-10/#:,3+-114%/&,/#-441,8-3,0/<*>.,2-/( :)

) -

;

:) ) *;

%$%$ /B-1 808 9/26!3< / ! "

< 808 9 0/41 "