High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/29769/2024dismissed

Union Of India And ORS v. No 13819956 Ex Lance Nk Banta Ram And Another

2024-12-17Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma8 pages

!"#$%&&%

!"!'"( !"#&%&% ) * *

!"# $ +# ,-+ % **

* .

,-+ *% ** * + %&'()*+, #%-./-..0').0%+1%02(3'2-(3 4%5.(6(5/5/2(%-7 #%*./802+'.0%801)9:05(4% %(-62)(25 ;;;;

* .

.%'&.5.(/2-5025<%/56(5/5/215.(6(5/5/2(%-.(%(/2 2/242)/016%0+-4%5.(-(55/2&0-/)(45.(%)(%)05()

=22(>'%( ?1 0- 60--() *+ 5.( 3(0%2() %8() %:(- %/*'203 :2:(%2()1<.(%(*+-5.(:30/84%(-62)(25 4%5.(&%0254 -(%9/:((3(8(2545.()/-0*/3/5+6(2-/24%5.(-(%9/:(%(2)(%()*+ ./8/2(4(2:((:'%/5+%6-=?.0-*((2033<()1*+:2)2/2& 5.(-.%540334 825.- )0+-4%85.(%(@'/-/5(

+(0%-4 @'03/4+/2&-(%9/:(4%(0%2/2&-(%9/:(6(2-/2/25.(

0(1'020(34 !'"

(-62)(25 <0-(2%33()/25.(2)/02%8+=.( %6-4A ?2 02)<0-)/-:.0%&()5.(%(4%82

(-62)(25 <0- &%025() %(5/%/2& 6(2-/21 00)8/--/*3( 5 ./8 0- 6(% 5.( (2-/2 (&'305/2- .(%(045(%1 %(-62)(25 <0-%((2%33()/25(4(2:((:'%/5+%6-=

-(%9/:(? 2

::%)/2& 5 5.( 6%(903(25 63/:+1 '62 0550/2/2&5.(0&(4-'6(%022'05/21%(-62)(25 <0-)/-:.0%&() 4%8-(%9/:(/25.(2

045(%%(2)(%/2&0-(%9/:(4

+(0%-1 825.-02))0+-1<./:.<0--.%5*+ 825.-02)

)0+-1-0-580B(5.(-3)/(%(20*3()5:863(5(5.(@'03/4+/2&5(%8 4

+(0%-14%5.(6'%6-(4&%0254-(%9/:(6(2-/215.'-4%5.( -(:2)-(%9/:(%(2)(%()*+./8/25.(

(-62)(25 <0- )(2/() -(%9/:( 6(2-/2 *+ 5.( :86(5(250'5.%/5+4%./-25:863(5/2&5.(%(@'/-/5(@'03/4+/2& 6(%/)4%(0%2/2&-(%9/:(6(2-/2/25.(

((3/2&0&&%/(9()1%(-62)(25 4/3()1*(4%(5.( 3(0%2() %8() %:(- %/*'203 :2:(%2()1 <.(%(*+- .( :0-5 0 :.033(2&(55.(04%(-0/)%(C(:5/2%)(%.(-0/)1*(:08( 033<()9/)(%)(%)05()

.(6(%05/9(60%545.(-0/) %)(%/-(>5%0:5().(%(/2045(%, >>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

! "#

"#$

&&&&&&&'

((3/2&0&&%/(9()4%85.(04%(-0/)%)(%0-60--()'62 5.(=-'6%0?1*+5.(3(0%2()%8()%:(-%/*'203:2:(%2()15.( 6(5/5/2(%2/242)/0.0-4/3()5.(%(0&0/2-55.(/2-5025<%/56(5/5/2 *(4%(5./-'%5 *'567

7!"

!819 2 "

(!'"

28!

19 :

1717!"

% .(3(0%2():'2-(34%5.(6(5/5/2(%--'*8/5-15.055.( 3(0%2()%/*'203.0-40/3()5:2-/)(%5.05/25(%8-4(&'305/2 45.((2-/2(&'305/2-4%5.(%8+1 02)(&'305/2

45.((2-/2(&'305/2-4%5.(%8+1 15.'-23+5.( 86(5(25'5.%/5+<0-(86<(%()5:2)2(5.()(4/:/(2:+/25.( %(2)/5/24@'03/4+/2&-(%9/:(15.'-*+5.(-3)/(%4%./-*(:8/2& (25/53()5-((B5.((2)<8(2546(2-/25./8.(-0/)(&'305/20%((>5%0:5().(%(/2045(% =A #D1 ?

()*& +,

- .

/ -.

(12 -.

=A #D1 ?

22&

()

45 .

/ 6

7& #%(9(%15.(#/2/-5%+4(4(2:(9/)(3/:+3(55(%

= ?7

77=(273? )05() 1 /2-(%5():30'-(=/9? /2 5.( (&'305/2

45.((2-/2(&'305/24%5.(%8+1 .( %(3(902560%5<.(%(41/-(>5%0:5().(%(/2045(% "$# $

$ &$

6(%'-0345.(04%(08(2)8(25<'3)80B(/5:3(0%5.05 %(3/(4 @'0 :2)205/2 4 )(4/:/(2:+ /2 %(2)/5/2 4 5.( 066-/5( @'03/4+/2&-(%9/:(1/-5*(0::%)()28(%/51-0-5(2-'%(5.0502 0%8+6(%-22(3/-(3/&/*3(4%053(0-52(-(%9/:(6(2-/2

$ .(3(0%2():'2-(34%5.(6(5/5/2(%-4'%5.(%-'*8/5-15.05 5.(C')&8(2545.(3(0%2()%8()%:(-%/*'2031%/2:/603"(2:.1 (<(3./1%(2)(%()/2:0-(5/53()0-

<0-25:%%(:5%05.(%<0-:25%0%+530<02)40:5-1 5.(%(4%(12%(3/02:('&.55.09(*((2630:()25.(-0/)C')&8(25 .(%(3(902560%0&%06.-10-::'%/25.(9(%)/:5=-'6%0?0%((>5%0:5() .(%(/2045(% )&

8 !

)2&92&)9(#

4 - .

:;< 0 =

> ?

: (2&9#&)99(

@ 22

= @

> ?

)9&91&)9(7A .

;

A .

! : B

C&=D &19

)9(E 97&((&)9(E =8

A .

< =8

> -?

A ,,,, ,,,, 2#& =

4 . F

D & - .

. /

: ; <

< @ G H;

: ; < G HG <

: @ IG ? ;

? 0

: ?

& -

.& &

&&- $ ‟

!"#

/ & $

-. -.

' =

;

)-).

= 8 =)997&

(2&9#&)99(

@ ()

;

@ -

& "

& # $

%012%13%& $&4 &

3513%136"#

. @

! : &

&- .F

D &-. @ 27 & "8

!8197 !'

/2:(5.((>6-5'305/2-80)(/260%0&%06. 45.( C')&8(25%(2)(%()*+5.($2E*3(6(>'%5/2:0-(5/53()0- "7!"!8 " 700" "!19

) %*'

*7"49 1%(6%5()/2"%137#6

' 0101 60%0&%06. <.(%(4 *(:8(- (>5%0:5() .(%(/2045(%19(%:8(-5.()/-0*3/2&(44(:5-1/402+14-'6%0(>:(65/2 =/9?10-*(:08(/2-(%5()9/)(63/:+73(55(%)05() 15.'-1 /25(2)()5<%B0-02*-50:3(%05.(%0&0/2-55.(-3)/(%:30/8/2&%(3/(4 4:2)205/2/25.(%(@'/-/5(-.%540334-(%9/:(

()&

()

G <

)2J (K#*

(2=

)99( ,

.(%(4%(15.(C')/:/039(%)/:5=-'6%0?1)(-%(2)(%2(&05() 5.(-'6%00%&'8(25%0/-()*+5.(:'2-(34%5.(6(5/5/2(%-15.055.( (86<(%8(255:2)2(5.(%(@'/-/5(-.%540331*(:8(--3/50%/3+ 9(-5()/25.(86(5(25'5.%/5+1(-6(:/033+<.(25.(.(%(/20*9( '2)(%3/2()60%0&%06.-10-::'%/25.(9(%)/:580)(/2*'

*7"49

, (0

1033')()5/25.(9(%)/:580)(/2.080!0'%E-:0-(1) /29(-5C'%/-)/:5/2/25.(%/5'%5155.%'&.C')/:/03/25(%9(25/21 5.'-80B(5.((-6'-():2)205/2

2-(@'(253+15.(:'8'305/9((44(:545.(0'5.%/505/9( C')/:/036%2'2:(8(250-:0%%/()/25.(0*9((>5%0:5()60%0&%06.1 80)( /2 ! "# 5.'- :863(5(3+ :'25(%90/3-*5.5.(-'6%00%&'8(25-%0/-()*(4%(5./-'%51*+5.( :'2-(34%5.(6(5/5/2(%-15.'-4%)(2+/2&55.(%(-62)(2515.( *(2(4/545.(-(%9/:(6(2-/24%./--(%9/2&/25.(18(%(3+25.( &%'2)5.05.(.0-25:863(5()5.(@'03/4+/2&6(%/)4-(%9/:(1

*(-/)(-25.(4'%5.(%43/8-+&%'2)15.0523+5.(:86(5(250'5.%/5+ /-0'5.%/F()5:2)2(5.(-0/)-.%54033

2(5.(3(--1 /2 5(%8- 4 5.( )(:30%05/2 80)( /2 5.( .(%(/20*9( '2)(%3/2() 60%01 0- :0%%/() /2 5.( 9(%)/:5 =-'6%0?1 5.( :30/8-4)'03408/3+6(2-/2/20))/5/255.(4/%-5408/3+6(2-/21/4 %(@'/%()1<'3)*(%(-5%/:5()4%8 10-(29/-0&()*+5.( #/2/-5%+4(4(2:( (55(%)05()

7"02

!8197 !'

2045(%805.15./-'%54/2)-28(%/5/25.(<%/56(5/5/2 02)</5.*-(%905/2-0*9(15.(-08(/-)/-8/--()

.(/86'&2()%)(%10-60--()*+5.(3(0%2()%/*'203 :2:(%2()1/-80/250/2()02)044/%8()

/-6-()4032&</5.0336(2)/2&0663/:05/2=-?1/402+ ;*

* .

< ;* * +< &%&% 2C03 .(5.(%-6(0B/2&7%(0-2() , D(-7 .(5.(%%(6%50*3( , D(-7