High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-AD/12/2023dismissed

A v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-05-1416 pages

!" #$%$!&'

( '

! !! ))) *+ ,,,-. *+ ,++ /01 234 "

# $ %& $' "

&( ) $'* &

)))) ++ 5

+ (!'

(%( !,

, -$('(%- !') (.

/%(!'!($(0 0(0('!6,

!"1&7 3$1/8$,$&09:;;< /$8$& =(

1&(%)#(# #( 2)#% '3)( 4 ,

((!!(!5)#/6!+ '7) 1&(& (!!(!! 89 &( %! 0 (' & !!8-'')!%

7 (&0 '3)( ' # ) '( :

;& 0 ! !8:-'')! ), ! 0!'3)( ' #)

'(:<

;&('!6;8444 =) '(!

: ;& #(! ('( &(

! !')( $ !(& '%(-$('(%- !') (.

%$'%(/. 91#(! !!8-'')!#(#

( !8-'')!

( $( ) !0% !> )4>?''7&0 ! 0!

#(# % )'?! )!& !!-'')! 7 ( ( ' '')! (### %) , % ) (!( ! '7/1 '')! 7, (! 7( , %'%%( ) 7( ('!! % '%( #0(

)!,0('( &(& 0$ &, (

($& '')! ,,,0( ('0( !!(!'

. ' (' ,( !(#) !!%,7 ! !!) 7'(#(! '')!+ &! 0! !!) (@ '% %(! % 0 ! %

' (#

(' !&! 0! , '')! 0)$(

$(%(# )(> ,!(! %(/. 91& % 6;/. 41) '(:<

;0! #(! 4 = ;$!(#( 0! ')' , A !, B( (# ($!(#(& )# !( /. 1 ' '')

' 0!

!%! 0(!!! 0 > 49=& !% !') (. /. 41 ) '( 4 0! #

') '(:

;0!( (! '!>49='%(- !') (.0!%(' # .%( (* !(&(&$("A/. :1#(!0,! $('(% #0( !(!!%!0 $ ;$!(#(#>

, ' '' 6A.%((><=& !!(!), ;!' (,#(# ')' ($!(#( '!

(#($!(#(&'')! (0! )(''' (#

' ) '( :

; 0! & 0 !

' )

'(: ;0!( '! '')! 7), ! 0 2(( ($!(#( 0

!>=&'')!

7), ! !)

(!'!) !%!/. 49 4=1 () !) !((!'!) !%!& #% ' ' '')

'&$(% '(%%!/. 41> !% &'')! 70!%(' # .%(* !(& (& $( "A /. 1& 0 ( ' '' ( (#0!!)##!($ !0!(', (#!.) ( ') ! !% '')! 7 0! '' !(! !%!#0( ,!%0! $ ;$!(#(# >

(' 6A .%(( * %(' .%(( '')!), ! 0!!#')'%!0 ! 6 !(''('A,

&" ),& !(! $(#

'($ 6A ! /.C .D1&

A((7 /E 441& 0 ')' %(' # .%(( $('(%- !') (. ( !!(,(( !.)( ') !', ))6A /.D1 !'%(#($! '')! 7(%' 0(

%!0,!!(! $('(%'') (# %(' # .%((

'%( ($!(#(& ( !$(!# ) '(4 : /1 0! !( ) #(!

!!8:-'')!

7), ! : 6((#

'!& ! 8 '')! 7 0!' # ! ' ( '%%(!!(

')(! ,

' ) '( : ;&0 ! !8:-'')!), ! 0!

' # ! ' ( '%%(!!(

')(! ,)

'(:<

;&0 (' #)( '(% ( + !),!( (! '!& !')( ! .%( E / !') (.1( !%&! ( '! %( /. 91!'( (' ! '')! (0!!($$ !'%%( ) !!

.%((

E 4/ !') (.10!

!('() '(:4=

!)%%(# (!(('')!0!%$, !')(& 0 (' 0!0&$( :94 (0!!)%%!

(('')! ' (#0( ' '')! 7), ! < > 4444& !)%%(# ' '')! (&

!!8-'')! 7 (0 ' # !

' ( '%%(!!(

')(! ,) '( :

;&0 ! !8:-'')!), ! 0!' # ! ' ( '%%(!!(

')(! ,) '(:<

;& 0 (' #)( '(% ( +!),!((!'!& !')( !.%(E 4 ;

5#,( (# &E A !,B( /;$!(#(#>

(' 1& E :/$('(%- !') (.1&E A !,%B)! (7&E < (B(& 5)('("#(! ;!!!&(&E ;!'

%! B)% &E 7 / )!, $('(%1&E 9;(

(# &E =!,"2B)% &E 4 ; (,#(# /;$!(#(#>

(' 1&E 44

A((7/"('>

(' 1E 4

# $ /"('>

(' 1 + & 6A /.C1

( /.D1 0 ( $(' #($(# ) E!

( ' & 6A& " ),& (%( % ;!' -> )( B)% &,(#)'!!

& !')($('0!'!, ),(' !')

'!) !')( $('& !%!

!!8-'')!!$(!#) '(:4: 0

&0 ( ('

(%((#% (-$('0 ) %& ,) $( #(!$#(! % ('' !(%('( '')! ( .( ('(&'%(#0( )#, 0! !( (!

/ %1 0 ($$()

'($((! 8(# ,) ! # '($(# !( ( %(& /'')! (1 ' 7'7 % )(% ' (' &!') ,!&'%( $#(! ,(#!%!(#(! (%(' ((( '(#!) '(!4 -4<4#(! (%A #(!')!!(0( # !!(!&'%( #($$ (%( !'! !#(!&,)) (#($!(#(&!( #(!0 ) ! / (10!' (', (' 9 ; ' $('& ! 8-'')!

7 !

.%( (!% 4B%! 0( % &0

($/.

1'((#'$ !( $('(%& % & ,

'')! 7 !'

( !('$ !((!.

9 ,$ !( 0(!! ( (' /.

=1 ) '( <

< $(' ' ,$!(0(!!& $(#! # !/.

<1& (( ( % ! ! ! 7 ( !( # !+ & '$('0!'! = > '(( $('& + ( ) '3)(

!!8-'')! ' #!) '(!:<

;&$(2)#% '3)( 4 4 E $ ')! !0!

')!'

((' .%( $('$(,

44 A ')! -$('(%- !') (. ' (%)# 2)#% , + ( ) (!

('& $ ! !% !,!!0 ((# (#!'(( ('

')% %('$('A + () ! ( '( 0! ( #(! ( 6;!% ''%( 0!% (!& 0$ &)')!( '')!0( ('&'(0!7 '%(0 $('(% ' (# ) ((!& '( 0! ((( ! !)' & ( & '')

( #(! ( 6; !,0.( '')!0

( $

( !$ !( '%( 0! !),!3)%( ('(( !% '%(A + ( ) 0 ( (#)!''%(/.

1 !0 # ( ' ('

$ !(0! !, $('(% !% '& ,$!(')%0!$ '

- !') (. (' %(!)! !(#) !,(,7 A + ( ) 0 # !') (.(!! (#0(!!'%

> (# !0('!!) '(: ;$! !(% $('(%(!!)

('(, (# % #)( '')!6) & + () !0 # () '(#!) '(!

4 -4<4 + (! !),!(# (%,0

'')

' %(' #.%(( $('(%&( (!!' (& + () !0 # %?,!' (2) (! !

$('(%?!! 0( "A&# ) '3)( # !/.

<10 !0 # (), + () ! !%0 $ ((! '! ' !( # ! ( '')

'(3)!(+ )!& !!8 -'')! $,0 # '3)( ' #!$#(! % (,,)(! !% !!)' &(%)# 2)#%(!(,,!!((!% ,0 4 A ')! 0 ( !) (# ')!

!') (. ! ( ,$!('(! (!, - !') (. 4: E ( $(#) # '(! ')!

(!& ( (! ,! $ $( (%)# 2)#% 4& !!8-'')! $,'3)( ' #!

$#(! %! !')( !%(! , (!),!((!

#(!#(! '')!;(!,$()! #(!'3)((! '!( !(# (

% !'% (

+ & !' ) &0 ((#0( !

#(!'3)(&(!!+ )# (!%, # ) $ ! '(!( ,! $(' ) 0 ('

? '3)((!,!&# '3)(,! !)%(

('' '')!& (! ! # , '3)( +

) & 0 ( '!( (# #(! '3)(& ! '!( 0 '%(#!),!( !! $ !(# '3)(+ ) ' $ ! '3)( ( $(07, + () (!,

)!( ') $,7, ) '%2) (!('((!

7#(!0!'! '

(%(2) (! )'" ,')! ) & '(( $)( $('&(!

('(7(

$(0&(

'0( 2)#% '3)( (!2)!( (;

$(07, + () (!!!(, $(0& $ ( 0 $(0! 3) ,'& ( !) ( (

', ) ( 2)#% + ( ) '3)(+ ) 0( $!0 (!

$ !( ( '(!(&( '')!(! '

$('

& ) ?!( ' (! (# ((!,!

)!) !(#;

'3)((!, $ !&

) %)!.%((!')!! # )!#($, + () '3)( '')!%)!#($'# !!$ ) ((#!+ )!&0 ('!( (# #(!'3)(&#

) ! )(

0 $(07, + () (!) !, $ !+ (!

'& ('', ' )(#! + =$.18 /,9 /8 &2!9 /% $! ,1@ /$& &2 &

&2 8 83/ &# /5;?;, '1&$%9 @@ &2!9 /% $!, !".

5 ;

&+'<< ,1@/ 8 !1/

; 4 ?, ) % ) ( == @@ /% $! , !"

5 ' ,1@/ 8 !1/(&0 ((#0( ,$ !(#)((! !!)%% (@ ('(!!)

# $ % &

! ( %

& )

( %

& * !

( % & *

" ( %& *

" ( % & * " !

+ 4< B(#($(0,$!(! !(( 0 0 ( (# !( ( (!% &(','$(

!')( !) ( $ !!8-

'')! $'%%(

')(! ,) '(!:<

;#(! $('(%- !') (.E( (!#!(((%(& 0 $'!( $(07, + () (!!!(, $(0(! 3)( (

', (!) & )!& + () ! (# '3)( !!8-'')! ' #!$#(! %+

($!('')!(& !! )% !) /(1

%( & E 7 & )!, $('(%- !') (.&0! ! (% ('(&! (!

!% !0( ( % ! $('

(# !% $('(%- !') (.& ! ' , ' ' (@ ! ! (# 0(!! ,')! $ !( (!

' ('

$(' +!(% $('(% (! !)

('( $ '')!( %!

, (

% ( !) ' 0 (' (! $(, ! $ !( , $('(%- !') (.& '')! (### %) '')! 7! 0 7( , '%%( )

('!! 0) $ ('( & 0)(%(

)!,!(% $('(%(!(3) $ #(!!! %$'%(/.

1, (# : '((# !%('(E 7 !! '

, (! ' (!0( %$'%( /.

1 ('( 0 ( '(# ) !(

'%(& '(#!) '(!4 -4<4 0 ((( #(! '')! E 4 ; (,# (# /;$!(#(#>

(' 1 !'# (' ! '%( /.

10!(3)( (, (%&,) #(! (! (0 ), !!(') (#(3)(

&'')! % ( 7! ,)!(# %( %%, !

'%(& )!& '(#!) '(!4 -4<4 0 (((#(! % , )! !(%

E 4 ; (,#(# $! ((('%( /.

10!%$, '%( !('%(0! )'(0 ((#, '%(

0; ((('%(/.

1&$('(% !'# ('

# 0 ! 0! (#0 ! ($ ?!

)!& 0 )! (&! 0!( ' , 0 )#! !% (! ,( )70

)#! ) (!( )!& #$ ,(#! %(%! %!$!

) ,$!('%(/.

10!(3)( (,

; (,#(# /E 41 (! ,& #(!

$, $('(%0 ), !!(') (# ') ! (3)(

&'')! ( 7! (# (# 0( ' ( $ %& ; (,#(# ((('(#(! %) '(!4 -4<4 (!2)') &((! $() '%( 9 /. 91&0 (' #(! (

(!6;&0 ($('(% !# )4>?''7&0 ! 0!#(# % )' ?! )!& 0 , '')! (& ! 0(!!'')! ( 7!(# & '')! (### %) &) (!( , '')! 7, (! 7(

, '%%( ) +

$ ('!! 0)'%( & 0)(%( )!, , )! ((( '%(/.

1 $! % '')! ( 0!(!'! (&0 ! ') (0!70 $('(%# , %#$,(#!

%(%! %!$!) + (! #(( '%(/.

1 '')! (### %) '')! 7, (! 7(

! 0! '(, 7(!( , 0 ! 0! , %,

% &#( 0! ) ( ((('%(/.

1 , '')! $ $('(% ('!! 0) '%( & 0)(%( )!,;(!

(%( ( ( ((('%( /.

1 ( '%(9 /. 91& (! ' '')!), ! 0( #(! ) !'

$('(%0 ! 0!$(# ! (! ' #(!

'('7$(0 $('(%0!$(# ! !($(0! !%(( ;0(,)

'%( E :/ !') (.-$('(%10 ( 0(!!

,. !'# (' ! (

( '%(/. 91 ( !% )

'( 4 ! $ %( %

'')!), ! ('(% !'# (' ! '')! ), ! () !'

F$ '('7 $(

!%( $( ( $

; (! $(0 % & ' ('

$ !(! $, , $('(%( ((('%( /.

1'%(9 /. 91&0 (' #(! ( (!6;&(!%)' !#(!

0 $, $('(%#(!'')! ( )70 )#! ! ( !(!'& )!& !!(,((

( )'( ') &.## )# $ !( ', )) /((1

(# '

.%(( $('(% /E :1& # ! /.

<1 0 !! ( ! $(' ,

'')! E : /$('(%1 0 '

0( # !

<1! )# ! (( (! ! ( ! # !&,)! '((

'')! 7( !( # ! '# (' ! ! $

7'')! 7 0$ &) (# '

.%((& ! '# (' ! '')! 7

' ,#! $(# 0!$(!((# %!0(

0 $( ! !)' ! 70 (% , % E :

/$('(%1(((

% !( # !

<1!'( (' ! !( ! '%%( 0 #') ( (% + )# E :/$('(%1(((

% !( # !/.

<1&,)0 )!,/E

7 10!'

0( # !& '# ('

(( ( (!0( '')! 7( ! # !

<1 # !/.

<1 $('(% '')! 7 ! .

0 , %', ! )##(#&7(!!(#' !%( ( &'')!

70! $()! 70$('(%!( ( ((('%(/.

1&! ( $ (!%

!!,!70 &0 !( !),!3)'%( 9 /. 91& ! $ (! % !

7!!(,(( '!!) (! ( $('(% '')! 7', ))!( # !

<1&, % ! )##(#7(!!(# ' # ! /.

<1 !) ,,(( '$ !( !(' (! (,0 $('(%'')! 7,'%),(')( $( '')! (&$('(% %, ( 7(

'')!('%(9 /. 91; (!$(0 % &'') ' ('

$ !(!

(

, $('(%& !(%('( !!8- '')!( '%%(!!( #

'&(!0$( /(((1 + )# # '')

' 7 ' & 0$ &$('(%0!%(' # .%( 49=!!)' '!( ,# (

,)0% !&!!(,(( '( (2)

!'') #!.)!!)( (! 0$ &( (!'!&E :/$('(%10 ( 0(!!

,. !'# (' ! ! ! )## !$ !

% ')' ! '')!) (# !(

!(!'&! !)!((2) (! , !& ! %), 7# ,#!! 7 %

%' !(2) (!('(%/E :1 !'# ('

! ! ( $ ')% %(' % ('; (!$(0 % &'$('(% (%7$(, %(' &( %! 0 (' & ! 0! (2) (!!)!(, ) (# ') !

#'')

'& (!'( ')%!'!' ( ' !)' (2)

0! $ !)!( , & )!& !')($ !( !,), ) /($1 6A /.D1 !'%(#($! ( !%(!(!!) '(%84 /!(!1 !) ' (%84 /!0,1 $('(%(!%' (#0(

( ,!% '')! 7/!) '

< (%8:1 4

!!3),$!( ((#!&0 (( + () 0 ( '((# ( $('((! (# !'($& ! (# 0(# !!&((!)! ) ) !(

!(% $('(% 0( )

, (0 (' !.(! & !')(

%()!)''!!

) $#(!#(!'')! !!+ )!& '! (

'( (%)#2)#%(!%)+ $(0 + () (! ,

( %(!%(( 4 ;$(0 ,$& !&,(#, % (& (!(!%(!! 49 (#('(/!1&( &!!!(!!

,1/ %9B /9 A1/ + =$ / 120 120 '

( '

E !7(#- ! D!-8 E , D!-8