High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/29768/2024dismissed

Union Of India And Others v. No 3385755n Ex Nk Parsan Singh

2024-12-17Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma8 pages

!"#$%&''&

"#"(#) !"#$'&'& * + +

!! ,$ -., & ++

+ /

-., +& ++ + , "#$%&'() *"+,-+,,.$&,."(/%0-1".0%2 31"4,%5%4-4-10%"+6 *"7-01&$8.".$+,.2/&91:.4%.0& *"*.$+.2/&91:.4%31""%+510&%041 ;;;;

+ /

,"1$#,4,%-0+4.04<"-45%4-4-10/4,%5%4-4-10%"+,%"%-0 0-10130&-./5".(+31"4,%+%44-0#.+-&%134,%1"&%"&.4%&

=00%>$"% ?/ .+ 5.++%& '( 4,% 2%."0%& "8%& 1":%+ "-'$0.2 :10:%"0%&/<,%"%'(+4,%:2.-813"%+510&%041 31"4,%#".0413 +%"9-:%%2%8%04134,%&-+.'-2-4(5%0+-1031"4,%+%"9-:%"%0&%"%&'( ,-8-0%3%0:%%:$"-4(1"5+=?,.+'%%0.221<%&/'(:10&10-0# 4,%+,1"43.2213

&.(+3"184,%"%@$-+-4%

(%."+13@$.2-3(-0#+%"9-:% 31"%."0-0#+%"9-:%5%0+-10-04,%

1)2(131)45"(#!

%+510&%041 <.+%0"122%&-04,%0&-.0"8(=,% -A, %#-8%04? 10

.0& <.+ &-+:,."#%& 4,%"%3"18 10

%+510&%04 1 <.+ #".04%& "%4-"-0# 5%0+-10/ .+ .&8-++-'2% 41 ,-8 .+ 5%" 4,% %0+-10 %#$2.4-10+ ,%"%.34%"/

"%+510&%041 <.+"%%0"122%&-041%3%0:%%:$"-4(1"5+= +%"9-:%? 10

::1"&-0# 41 4,% 5"%9.2%04 512-:(/ $510 .44.-0-0#4,%.#%13+$5%".00$.4-10/"%+510&%041 <.+&-+:,."#%& 3"18+%"9-:%-04,%10

.34%""%0&%"-0#.+%"9-:%13

(%."+/

8104,+.0& &.(+/<,-:,<.++,1"4'(

&.(+/+1.+41 8.A%4,%+12&-%"%0.'2%&41:1852%4%4,%@$.2-3(-0#4%"813

(%."+/ 31"4,%5$"51+%13#".0413+%"9-:%5%0+-10/4,$+31"4,%+%:10&+%"9-:% "%0&%"%&'(,-8-04,%

%+510&%04 1 <.+ &%0-%& +%"9-:% 5%0+-10 '( 4,% :185%4%04.$4,1"-4(31",-+014:1852%4-0#4,%"%@$-+-4%@$.2-3(-0# 5%"-1&31"%."0-0#+%"9-:%5%0+-10-04,%

%%2-0#.##"-%9%&/"%+510&%041 3-2%&/'%31"%4,% 2%."0%& "8%& 1":%+ "-'$0.2 :10:%"0%&/ <,%"%'(+ ,% :.+4 . :,.22%0#%414,%.31"%+.-&"%B%:4-101"&%",%+.-&/'%:.8% .221<%&9-&%1"&%"&.4%&

,%15%".4-9%5."4134,%+.-& 1"&%"-+%>4".:4%&,%"%-0.34%") >>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

# $%

%%2-0#.##"-%9%&3"184,%.31"%+.-&1"&%".+5.++%&$510 4,%=+$5".?/'(4,%2%."0%&"8%&1":%+"-'$0.2:10:%"0%&/4,%

5%4-4-10%"0-10130&-.,.+3-2%&4,%"%.#.-0+44,%-0+4.04<"-45%4-4-10 '%31"%4,-+1$"4 +(678

8"# "92:

3 1# !)"(#

39"2:

;

2828"#

& ,%2%."0%&:1$0+%231"4,%5%4-4-10%"++$'8-4+/4,.44,% 2%."0%&"-'$0.2,.+3.-2%&41:10+-&%"4,.4-04%"8+13%#$2.4-10 1 134,%%0+-10%#$2.4-10+31"4,%"8(/ .0&%#$2.4-10 1

134,%%0+-10%#$2.4-10+31"4,%"8(/

/4,$+102(4,% 185%4%04$4,1"-4(<.+%851<%"%&41:10&10%4,%&%3-:-%0:(-04,% "%0&-4-1013@$.2-3(-0#+%"9-:%/4,$+'(4,%+12&-%"31",-+'%:18-0# %04-42%&41+%%A4,%%0&1<8%04135%0+-1041,-8,%+.-&%#$2.4-10+ ."%%>4".:4%&,%"%-0.34%" = C*D/ ?

'() *+

# #

'-.

') # # # + & = C*D/

.. / # 0 # '( #

+ 12

# ,

4 *1"%19%"/4,%*-0-+4"(13%3%0:%9-&%12-:(2%44%"1

= ?6

66=%0612? &.4%&

/ -0+%"4%&:2.$+%=-9? -0 4,% %#$2.4-101

134,%%0+-10%#$2.4-1031"4,%"8(/

,% "%2%9.045."4<,%"%13/-+%>4".:4%&,%"%-0.34%"

5%"$+.2134,%.31"%.8%0&8%04<1$2&8.A%-4:2%."4,.4 "%2-%3 @$. :10&10.4-10 13 &%3-:-%0:( -0 "%0&-4-10 13 4,% .551+-4% @$.2-3(-0#+%"9-:%/-+41'%.::1"&%&108%"-4/+1.+41%0+$"%4,.4.0 ."8(5%"+100%2-+%2-#-'2%31".42%.+410%+%"9-:%5%0+-10

,%2%."0%&:1$0+%231"4,%5%4-4-10%"+3$"4,%"+$'8-4+/4,.4 4,%B$&#8%04134,%2%."0%&"8%&1":%+"-'$0.2/"-0:-5.2E%0:,/ %<%2,-/"%0&%"%&-0:.+%4-42%&.+ ! "# $% <.+014:1""%:4".4,%"<.+:104"."(412.<.0&3.:4+/ 4,%"%31"%/01"%2-.0:%1$#,441,.9%'%%052.:%&104,%+.-&B$&#8%04 ,%"%2%9.045.".#".5,+/.+1::$"-04,%9%"&-:4=+$5".?."%%>4".:4%& ,%"%-0.34%" (/ "

# # 5

6 (.7.(7'$ 1

9: !,

; <9 '.7$(77' =.. = ,

# ;<9

(77-(7'4>

#> : # # # > 9?

6 9 @ A BAC-7(7'D74''(7'D# 5/ > : 5/ # ;

<9 > ++++ ++++ .$

# #!

E 6 !

F C

#9 : '.

# : : # /#

:= # G # : , # 9 : #

G # G : 9 = ?#HG < < ,

# # 6 9 < /

& ' (

) ( (

## # /#

& # ( (5/# (774/

#'.7$(77' = '( = # *

+,-,. / .0,.,.1

= #

# : : # /# 6 9

F C =.4 # #9

"92:8 "(2&

-0:%4,%%>51+4$2.4-10+8.&%-05.".#".5,1 134,% B$&#8%04"%0&%"%&'(4,%!10F'2%5%>1$"4-0:.+%4-42%&.+ #8"#"9 #!811#!#"2:

* &+( #!

+8#5: 171/"%51"4%&-0,.21 +,+/ 5.".#".5, <,%"%13 '%:18%+ %>4".:4%& ,%"%-0.34%"/19%":18%+4,%&-+.'2-0#%33%:4+/-3.0(/13+$5".%>:%54-10 1=-9?/.+'%:.8%-0+%"4%&9-&%512-:(62%44%"&.4%&

/4,$+/ -04%0&%&41<1"A.+.01'+4.:2%".4,%".#.-0+44,%+12&-%":2.-8-0#"%2-%3 13:10&10.4-10-04,%"%@$-+-4%+,1"43.2213+%"9-:% '(

# + '( # +#

G : /#

# # # /# G

(.I 'J$) '.

(77' + # //# #

,%"%31"%/4,%B$&-:-.29%"&-:4=+$5".?/&1%+"%0&%"0%#.4%& 4,%+$5".."#$8%04".-+%&'(4,%:1$0+%231"4,%5%4-4-10%"+/4,.44,% %851<%"8%0441:10&10%4,%"%@$-+-4%+,1"43.22/'%:18%++12-4."-2( 9%+4%&-04,%185%4%04$4,1"-4(/%+5%:-.22(<,%04,%,%"%-0.'19% $0&%"2-0%&5.".#".5,+/.+1::$"-04,%9%"&-:48.&%-0+( #!

+8#5:

171- )1

/.22$&%&41-04,%9%"&-:48.&%-0,.8..$"F+:.+%/&1 -09%+4B$"-+&-:4-10-04,%"-41$"4/414,"1$#,B$&-:-.2-04%"9%04-10/ 4,$+8.A%4,%%+51$+%&:10&10.4-10

10+%@$%042(/4,%:$8$2.4-9%%33%:4134,%.$4,1"-4.4-9% B$&-:-.25"101$0:%8%04.+:.""-%&-04,%.'19%%>4".:4%&5.".#".5,/ 8.&% -0 ' ( 4,$+ :1852%4%2( :1$04%"9.-2+'14,4,%+$5".."#$8%04+".-+%&'%31"%4,-+1$"4/'(4,% :1$0+%231"4,%5%4-4-10%"+/4,$+31"&%0(-0#414,%"%+510&%04/4,% '%0%3-4134,%+%"9-:%5%0+-1031",-++%"9-0#-04,%/8%"%2(104,% #"1$0&4,.4,%,.+014:1852%4%&4,%@$.2-3(-0#5%"-1&13+%"9-:%/

'%+-&%+104,%3$"4,%"32-8+(#"1$0&/4,.4102(4,%:185%4%04.$4,1"-4( -+.$4,1"-G%&41:10&10%4,%+.-&+,1"43.22

10%4,%2%++/ -0 4%"8+ 13 4,% &%:2.".4-10 8.&% -0 4,% ,%"%-0.'19% $0&%"2-0%& 5."./ .+ :.""-%& -0 4,% 9%"&-:4 =+$5".?/ 4,% :2.-8+13&$.23.8-2(5%0+-10-0.&&-4-10414,%3-"+43.8-2(5%0+-10/-3 "%@$-"%&/<1$2&'%"%+4"-:4%&3"18

/.+%09-+.#%&'(4,% *-0-+4"(13%3%0:%C%44%"&.4%&

8#13 !

"92:8 "(2&

0.34%"8.4,/4,-+1$"43-0&+018%"-4-04,%<"-45%4-4-10 .0&<-4,1'+%"9.4-10+.'19%/4,%+.8%-+&-+8-++%&

,%-85$#0%&1"&%"/.+5.++%&'(4,%2%."0%&"-'$0.2 :10:%"0%&/-+8.-04.-0%&.0&.33-"8%&

-+51+%&13.210#<-4,.225%0&-0#.552-:.4-10=+?/-3.0( <+

+ /

= <+ + ,= '&'&

0B.2 :

;

148#5> "# !

;"2163