Mahender v. Kamaljeet



    









  








 

 

  
!

 "

# 
 
 
 


!" # $
% &"'
(

"


 
$ 

)

 
*
 
" 
!
!

 
"
 
 

!$
+$

  
# 

&# 


 )) ,- -,).'

!$
 
 
+
 



 !
 
+

/

-

    
 
 



+ "
(#

"

&# 

)) - -,).

 
#  &
0
 
)1  '

 

"
 '
&






 


12
3"'

+
4

(
!$
 

#
"

  


5 #


#


-6
3"

+
 

 
# $
!$
  
 

"
 

+ 


&# 
 
 
+ 4 &


4 

"


+
 4

), )- -,).

"
  
 &+ "
+ 

'
! 



  
&  




"&

+ 

"
 

%!

& '
"77
!
 
 
 #

4
"

 "
  
#3
"

 
!
" %!

& '
"77

"
  
5 
"
 
(
 #
 &
"


4
!
"
 

$
 $
"


&
 
 )8 ,1 -,)2
+
 


"
 

4 

"
&# 



!


( 


 
  
"
 

  

 "
4  
 
 ( &

-6
3"

 
# $ 
"
&# 
#
"
  



"
"

!"

+ 
+ "
 
 
"
 

 5'
"
&# 
+

&
4

"
4

!# &

+ 



 

( &


"

 '
"

 $


#
&# 
 )) - -,).

#

'
#    
 
 
9

!(
# 


 

" &
"
# !  $

 
&


" #

.

% 
 
+

(  '
 
+
/
# + &



)

:""
"
&# 

))"
;!$'
-,).
+

#
!+
"
  
 
 
 
"
 #
 4 

&  



+
), )- -,).<
9 -

:""
"
  
+
+$
$
 
+  &

# "



&# 
"&"
"
 <
9

:""
"
  

  




   # 

$
<
9 .

:""
"
 
 

"
 
#

# !< 9 

:""
"
  
" 




 
"
 
 < 9  =

:""
"
  
" 
#
+ "

"

!
" /<
9 

:""

"
!
$
!$
!"

+

     &
+ "
"
 
&# 

)) ,- -,).
"

!
4<
9 

 

  



(
4  
>4

)?'



:

)
 !

 
"


 

  $

3 "
/" 
> :-?
"

+ '
(

4 

" &# 
!+
"
  
$# 


-6
3"

 # $
!$
"
  

 
 
"
   



!$
"
#& 
+ 

 #
> :

1?

3 "
> :

.?
 + 


"
&# 

"
(

  
    
 '
  

#3
"

 
!
%!
& 
>4

-?'
"

 ( 
>4
1?'

#! 
# 
>4 .
@
4 2?


&
 
>4 =?A
+"
 


:)
 
4# 
"

!"

+

:-



"

( 


"
(  

=

 
+

+" 


&





 )
 1'
"
&# 

)) ,- -,).

!
& 
 

( 

 

/

5 $'
  
+
"
  

   # 

"
&# 



+
 

(

"  
&


"


B


 .

0
+




!$
"

/

5 $'
"
 
+

 
"
 
+



 

4


+ "


 

-
# "

#
"

 

&

7&# 
 


;  

 
!$
"
 
+ #


( 
7&# 


)) ), -,--



!$
   
  
&'
"77'

 # &
"



"
 
/
!+'
 &

  &


 &
 


 




"
 C 
&
"
!"
" /
!+
(3
"
# 

"
&# 
)) ,- -,).

>4
)?
+

#

'
#    
4 

 

 

" #'
+ "
#
 
  

&!
"
$

"
D"

+

"
 '
+ "
+"#
"
     
"
!

 

! &
 


 5
 '
$
 

##  &
"


B

"

"
    
 

(
"



#


-6
3"

'
+ "
" #

! 3
# 

" (  
+

!$
"
    

 ! "
" ( !  $

"
 "
+ "
" #
;"'
 

$# 


-6
3"

'

#
"
6,E

"
&

# '


 "'
&&
##

 
+ "
 '
+"
"
 $
 
"
4  



 
 ( &

 $
$# 
" 

"
 



!#  "
#

 

"

+ 

+ 
   
 $

"$
+
# $
3 +

"
 
+

 

),








"
 




"
 
"
!# 
"
" /
!+
 
 

 
"
    
"
 


(
"



"
 
"



"
 



" $


#

"
 

"

 ( " "
 


"

# $
##!

$
 

"
#
 (
#
"



 
"   $

 

"

&

B

"
!#  "
/
!+
 
 


"
"
    
"
 
 ! "
!$
! &
 $
# $
(  
"
"
+
$


+  &

&
"


4
 




"


  
/
!+

! $'
( 
 "


!

 


 

  
  
!
#

)) B
"(
"
 




"
 
 
"(
 "
'


"
( +
"
"


 
# 

"

!#

#
!$
"
 




"


 
!+

 

"

(  

"
  
 
"

+ 

( 
#



!
"
 
"
4
" &# 
>4 )?

+ "

3 +&
 
 

&


&


"

 
#  &
0
3 
)1
#'
 

" &# 
>4

)?




 


12
3"


"
&# 
 
 (

-6
3"

 
# $
# "
  '
 
 
#
   
  # 

#&

4

)

"

& "

 

"
+ 

"(
 (


#
"
# $
(  

&#  " 
 

 
"
  # 
 

"
+ 

!$ ! &
 $
#

(

 $
 # 

! ( "#

 
 

#"
"
# 

 &
+ 



 

 $
 # $
+ "
" #

"$
! &
!   $
 
"

 

&# 

'


!!
& 



!
"  (

:

-

"
 !

 
+ 



&&  
+
& (

" #

"

$
   
+ "
"
  
  &
+ 


& $
 
!
"
4 
 &# 
4

)
 
 ( &

-6
3"

!$
"
 #
"

 
# $

  $
 
"
" #
  
"
  

"
 

" 
+ 



" &
 
 

&
"
&# 




'
"
 

 
"#!
#3

  
"
+ 

"
  
+" #
(  
"

!

 
"
 

"
  

9
"
 $'
"
 
 

! &


 $ (  

 # 



#
 
 #
"
&# 



4

)

#



#   

;  $'
+


"
#
!


( &
# 

 


   

!
"
 !
 
& 
(  

!$
"
   ( &

4  
 
#

$# 
  
# $
" 
B
 
 '
5 ( &

 



 
&# 
4

)
"
#$
! 
"

( '
 &

 (


" 
"
! & 

 &#  (








B
"
#
!"'
 

 $ &
"
4 
 &# 
>4

)?
 4
!"

"


# 
'
#    
4 

 
 

" #



!$
"

!"

+'
+"
+
"( &
!

 

+ "
"  
+

$

2
3"


  '

"
4

!
 + 



 
 
"
3 &
( &

"

!      '
&
"
&# 
4
+

" +" (
3
"


'
#   



4 

 
 '
# 
(
"
#
!$ 
 ! !
 3

 # 
"&
+('


& 
(  

"

&

(  


(  

"+
"




4 


&# 

 $

 
"'
"

!"

+
>:-?

+
+ "
" #

&&  
+
& (

"
+ 


   "

"


4  '
"

!"

+ +
+ "
" #

+ "
"
  
/" 
>:

-
?
"
!"

+ 
 
 

 
"
"
+
# $ &
"

"


4  
;"'
 
 !"

+

"
 

:

-
" 
"

"
($

 
 
3
!$
"


(




"


"
 
"
"

!"

+
+
 !


 5
+ "
 
+

$

2
3"


   

"
 '
"
+ 3

!#

+ 



 '




(

 "
 
 
/"

:

-'
!"

"(
# 
"
"$
"(


 $

& &
"
!



;"'
"


4 

 

 



!$
 $
# $
(  
D"'
 


+ 

"(
# 
"
"$
#

# 

"
 



& &
"
&
4  
!$
4


 

##  &
"


&

(





4
"
!
# 

 
>:)?'
"
(  

!

 
"

"
&# 
>4
)?
+
& 4'
+"
"
+
"($
 3

%
#"


&&  
+
& (

:

-'
"
 !
"
 
+
 
"

 

 5'
+"
&# 


+
4 " 
# 
"
# 
"
"
"
& 

"

  

4
"
&#  "

#

! 

"
"
+ 
+
!
4 

"
&# 

" + 4 


(






% 
 
"
 
"
4  '


+ 
! &$

"
  

 ! "

  &# 

#
+ "
" #

"



4 
 &# 


"


4 



;" #'

"

"
!
3
!$
"
 

 $

&&  
"
!
& (

"
  
"
"
"

   # $

#3
"
$#

 $
"

!
3
 " &
"
  

"
  '
"
  
+
5 
 ! "

 

# 

3


"
  
 #

"
 
'
+" "
" 
!
3


4

)



 
"
 
"

"&




# D'
"77
 
" 
"
 #! 


  
> :

)?
 
"
 
+ 

# $

 
 # &

"

"  
"
+

#$
"

+
" 
"



$
&# 
+
4

  
# 
"

# 
 " & "
  
(
"


" 
"


B

##
"

&  
 

"

 

 &

 
 


%



& $
3



#

# 

"
& 
B

"
& (
 #  '

#
!$
"
 



!
3




:

-
"
!"

+

"
 
"   
"
"
 
+ 



"


"
 !
# 

"
  
> :

)?

+ "

"
# $
(  '
"

  

), )- -,).
> -?

& (

!

& '
"77
 &+ "
"

 ( 

(

>4

1?

" !

 
"


  
"
"
+
$


+  &

4
"



  

&# 
>4 )?

4

=
"
&
 
 
4" ! 
"



+ 

"


"
  

4
"
&# 
/ $'



 

4  
&&
"
 + 
$
 
+  &

" 
"
&# 
 
#
"

 
! & 

))


" 

3
&"'
#3 
& 

#
   


! &
"



"
 

!+
+ "

" #

( $ )-


;
"


#   '
B


 $
& $
 ( $'

"
  


'
+" "

! 

  

 
# $
(  

& 

 

#

#"


((# 

 $
!

 
5  

+



)1





  $'

"

# 

"

 '
"!$'

#

).

&
#  
   > ?'

 $'

 
 
 &$

 


  %&'%( )')* Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No