High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/29771/2024dismissed

Union Of India v. No 3983891h Ex Nk Dharam Pal

2024-12-17Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma8 pages

!"#$%%

!"!&"'

!"#%%

( ) )

*# +,* % ))

) -

+,* )% )) ) * !"#$%&'( !)*+)**,#%*,!'-%./,0$ 1!0*$2$0+0+3$!) !4+.$5,%6,7-%./,0$1!!$)23%$30 )

) -

.% *!#"*0*$+3)0,306!+02$0+0+3-0*$2$0+0+3$!)*$!$+3

3+313%+,-2!,')1!0*$)$00+3",)+%$10*$!%$!%,0$% 933$:#!$ ;- ,) 2,))$% &' 0*$ 7$,!3$% !<$% !/$) !+&#3,7 /3/$!3$%-6*$!$&')0*$/7,+<1!$)23%$30 1!0*$"!,301 )$!.+/$$7$<$3010*$%+),&+7+0'2$3)+31!0*$)$!.+/$!$3%$!$%&' *+<+3$1$3/$$/#!+0'!2)9;*,)&$$3,776$%-&'/3%3+3" 0*$)*!01,771 '$,!1!<0*$!$=#+)+0$>'$,!)1=#,7+1'+3")$!.+/$ 1!$,!3+3")$!.+/$2$3)+3+30*$

/'0&/1/'23 !&"

$)23%$30 6,)$3!77$%+30*$3%+,3!<'9*$ "!, $"+<$30; 3 ,3% 6,) %+)/*,!"$% 0*$!$1!< 3 $)23%$30 6,) "!,30$% !$0+!+3" 2$3)+3- ,) ,%<+))+&7$ 0 *+< ,) 2$! 0*$ $3)+3 $"#7,0+3) *$!$,10$!- !$)23%$30 6,)!$$3!77$%+30$1$3/$$/#!+0'!2)9 )$!.+/$; 3 //!%+3" 0 0*$ 2!$.,7$30 27+/'- #23

,00,+3+3"0*$,"$1)#2$!,33#,0+3-!$)23%$30 6,)%+)/*,!"$% 1!<)$!.+/$+30*$3 ,10$!!$3%$!+3",)$!.+/$1

'$,!)-6*+/*6,))*!0&' '$,!-),)0<,5$0*$)7%+$!$3,&7$%0 /<27$0$0*$=#,7+1'+3"0$!<1>'$,!)-1!0*$2#!2)$1"!,301 )$!.+/$2$3)+3-0*#)1!0*$)$/3%)$!.+/$!$3%$!$%&'*+<+30*$ $)23%$30 6,) %$3+$% )$!.+/$ 2$3)+3 &' 0*$ /<2$0$30,#0*!+0'1!*+)30/<27$0+3"0*$!$=#+)+0$=#,7+1'+3" 2$!+%1!$,!3+3")$!.+/$2$3)+3+30*$

$$7+3",""!+$.$%-!$)23%$30 1+7$%-&$1!$0*$ 7$,!3$% !<$% !/$) !+&#3,7 /3/$!3$%- 6*$!$&') *$ /,)0 , /*,77$3"$00*$,1!$),+%!$?$/0+3!%$!*$),+%-&$/,<$ ,776$%.+%$!%$!%,0$% *$2$!,0+.$2,!010*$),+% !%$!+)$:0!,/0$%*$!$+3,10$!( :::: ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

"# $

( &

+ > $$7+3",""!+$.$%1!<0*$,1!$),+%!%$!,)2,))$%#23 0*$9)#2!,;-&'0*$7$,!3$%!<$%!/$)!+&#3,7/3/$!3$%-0*$ 2$0+0+3$! 3+313%+,*,)1+7$%0*$!$,",+3)00*$+3)0,306!+02$0+0+3 &$1!$0*+)#!0

)&456

6!"

!708 1 '!&"

17!

08 9 0606!"

% @ *$7$,!3$%/#3)$71!0*$2$0+0+3$!))#&<+0)-0*,00*$ 7$,!3$%!+&#3,7*,)1,+7$%0/3)+%$!0*,0+30$!<)1$"#7,0+3

>10*$$3)+3$"#7,0+3)1!0*$!<'-@,3%$"#7,0+3

10*$$3)+3$"#7,0+3)1!0*$!<'- -0*#)37'0*$ <2$0$30#0*!+0'6,)$<26$!$%0/3%3$0*$%$1+/+$3/'+30*$ !$3%+0+31=#,7+1'+3")$!.+/$-0*#)&'0*$)7%+$!1!*+)&$/<+3" $30+07$%0)$$50*$$3%6<$3012$3)+30*+<*$),+%$"#7,0+3) ,!$$:0!,/0$%*$!$+3,10$! 9 A B-@;

" ,

& (#

(

- ".

& " &

(

& &

( (

+ 9 A B- ;

(

( "

(

& 2

& " &

( - +

!$.$!-0*$+3+)0!'1$1$3/$.+%$7+/'7$00$!

9 ;C CC9$3C7; %,0$% @ - +3)$!0$%/7,#)$9+.; +3 0*$

$"#7,0+3

10*$$3)+3$"#7,0+31!0*$!<'- *$ !$7$.,302,!06*$!$1-+)$:0!,/0$%*$!$+3,10$! 2$!#),710*$,1!$,<$3%<$306#7%<,5$+0/7$,!0*,0 !$7+$1 =#, /3%3,0+3 1 %$1+/+$3/' +3 !$3%+0+3 1 0*$ ,22)+0$ =#,7+1'+3")$!.+/$-+)0&$,//!%$%3<$!+0-),)0$3)#!$0*,0,3 ,!<'2$!)33$7+)$7+"+&7$1!,07$,)03$)$!.+/$2$3)+3! "

*$7$,!3$%/#3)$71!0*$2$0+0+3$!)1#!0*$!)#&<+0)-0*,0 0*$?#%"<$3010*$7$,!3$%!<$%!/$)!+&#3,7-!+3/+2,7D$3/*-

$6$7*+-!$3%$!$%+3/,)$0+07$%,) # $ %&

6,)30/!!$/0!,0*$!6,)/30!,!'07,6,3%1,/0)- 0*$!$1!$-3!$7+,3/$#"*00*,.$&$$327,/$%30*$),+%?#%"<$30 *$!$7$.,302,!,"!,2*)-,)//#!+30*$.$!%+/09)#2!,;,!$$:0!,/0$% *$!$+3,10$! /

( (3

") 1 # 5 ( & 678& '-

9%:6 "

)

;

; - (

9%:6

. < (# 7 & ( (

( <

# 8 (

(

( < # 6= 4

6& >$?%

@?A.

"" "B (3/

< # 8 3/

(9% :6#

& & <

)

(& ('

C 4 &

# % D A #

& #

& (6 7 8 &"

(8 8

( / (

8; (E F( 78

- && (

6 7 8( E F( E

86 ; =(GE

- & ( (

6& : / # !

‟ ( )

! " *

#8 ((

(# #

/ (

& +

& (7

# 3/ (

/ (

&&( "

)

; "7 7

;# (

+ "

,-. -/ " 0

/1-/ -/2

#% ;

# (

(8 8 ( / (

6& F% &#D A#

;

(& "7

!7086 !& 0% +3/$0*$$:2)0#7,0+3)<,%$+32,!,"!,2* 10*$ ?#%"<$30!$3%$!$%&'0*$ 3E&7$2$:#!0+3/,)$0+07$%,) "6!"!7 " 6//" "!08

( %)&

)6"38 5/ -!$2!0$%+3 -/32 ,-,- 2,!,"!,2* 6*$!$1 &$/<$) $:0!,/0$% *$!$+3,10$!-.$!/<$)0*$%+),&7+3"$11$/0)-+1,3'-1)#2!,$:/$20+3

9+.;-,)&$/,<$+3)$!0$%.+%$27+/'C7$00$!%,0$% @ -0*#)- +30$3%$%06!5,),3&)0,/7$!,0*$!,",+3)00*$)7%+$!/7,+<+3"!$7+$1 1/3%3,0+3+30*$!$=#+)+0$)*!01,771)$!.+/$ "% & &

& ( " % (

(

= E

8/ (

( (

( &

/ ( E&

& H "I)

(

// (

(

& *$!$1!$-0*$?#%+/+,7.$!%+/09)#2!,;-%$)!$3%$!3$",0$% 0*$)#2!,,!"#<$30!,+)$%&'0*$/#3)$71!0*$2$0+0+3$!)-0*,00*$ $<26$!<$300/3%3$0*$!$=#+)+0$)*!01,77-&$/<$))7+0,!+7' .$)0$%+30*$<2$0$30#0*!+0'-$)2$/+,77'6*$30*$*$!$+3,&.$ #3%$!7+3$%2,!,"!,2*)-,)//#!+30*$.$!%+/0<,%$+3)&

)6"38

5/ + '/

-,77#%$%0+30*$.$!%+/0<,%$+3*,<, ,#!E)/,)$-% +3.$)0?#!+)%+/0+3+30*$!+0#!0-00*!#"*?#%+/+,7+30$!.$30+30*#)<,5$0*$$)2#)$%/3%3,0+3 3)$=#$307'-0*$/#<#7,0+.$$11$/010*$,#0*!+0,0+.$ ?#%+/+,72!3#3/$<$30,)/,!!+$%+30*$,&.$$:0!,/0$%2,!,"!,2*- <,%$ +3 )

" 0*#) /<27$0$7'

/#30$!.,+7)&0*0*$)#2!,,!"#<$30)!,+)$%&$1!$0*+)#!0-&'0*$ /#3)$71!0*$2$0+0+3$!)-0*#)1!%$3'+3"00*$!$)23%$30-0*$ &$3$1+010*$)$!.+/$2$3)+31!*+))$!.+3"+30*$-<$!$7'30*$ "!#3%0*,0*$*,)30/<27$0$%0*$=#,7+1'+3"2$!+%1)$!.+/$- &$)+%$)30*$1#!0*$!17+<)'"!#3%-0*,037'0*$/<2$0$30,#0*!+0' +),#0*!+F$%0/3%3$0*$),+%)*!01,77

3$0*$7$))- +3 0$!<) 1 0*$ %$/7,!,0+3 <,%$ +3 0*$ *$!$+3,&.$ #3%$!7+3$% 2,!,- ,) /,!!+$% +3 0*$ .$!%+/0 9)#2!,;- 0*$ /7,+<)1%#,71,<+7'2$3)+3+3,%%+0+300*$1+!)01,<+7'2$3)+3-+1

!$=#+!$%-6#7%&$!$)0!+/0$%1!< -,)$3.+),"$%&'0*$ +3+)0!'1$1$3/$ $00$!%,0$%

6"/1

!7086 !& 0% 3,10$!<,0*-0*+)#!01+3%)3<$!+0+30*$6!+02$0+0+3 ,3%6+0*&)$!.,0+3),&.$-0*$),<$+)%+)<+))$% > *$+<2#"3$%!%$!-,)2,))$%&'0*$7$,!3$%!+&#3,7 /3/$!3$%-+)<,+30,+3$%,3%,11+!<$% @ +)2)$%1,73"6+0*,772$3%+3",227+/,0+39);-+1,3' :)

) -

;

:) ) *;

%% 3?,7 8

/26"3<

0/41