High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/51/2018disposed of

Sh. Jagmal Singh Since Deceased Through Lrs And ORS v. Magan Lal & ANR

2025-11-17Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja6 pages

+ @ + @ + @ + @ %" +7 %" +7 %" +7 %" +7 2

+785B C2 +785B C2 +785B C2 +785B C2 ,##+! ,##+! ,##+! ,##+!A A A A

858@

"#"#+!

/+!) !"

/+!) !" 2

!" $

&$%9#!)%0( )*+,%" 1

#$%!&'#()*+,%" %0+!;

1#"$ ;1#"$ -'!$%&%!./ "#"#+! #!6/ +!

'!#0$%)$%( )*+,%" 1#

%%'""()*+,%" %0+!;1#"$ #"$ $ %!#$+0%!&#. /+!) !"+

###2#!6/ +!

DDDD ( %02 ( %02 ( %02 ( %02 + 345 + 345 + 345 + 3456 +7858 +7858 +7858 +7858

% %9 :%) #!"$ %//0#,%"#+!# 7+#:/0 %)#!;"$ %//0#,%!"2 2% 0 ;%0$ #2+7 /+!) !"+ (1$+)# )+!8A 5 858

+ "$ %+! : !"#+! ) #! "$ %//0#,%"#+!( "$ %: # %00+1 1 )( '<- ,""+%00-'

" =, /"#+!%!)"$ %//0#,%!" 2%: !"#+! )#!/%%;%/$ + 4 +7"$ %//0#,%"#+ +!% +) )"+< #:/0 %) )% %0 ;%0$ #2+7 /+!) !"+ + 6 %;%!%0) , % )2#!+) "+/'' "$ / !",% :

: !) ): :++7/%"# #"%& ! +! ,+)

;

;#"9"+)+"$ ! )7'0 %#!,% %#!,% %#!,% %#!,% >?

9 1%9 +7 / !" *##+! / "#"#+ +!( ,$%00 !; $% < ! 0%#) "+ +) )%" ) @

85A/% ) <9 0 %! ) = ,'"#!; +'"('';%:( 1$ <9 "$ +<- ,"#+!/ "#"#+!/ 7 )%""$ #!"%!, +7/ "#"#+! 2.-');: !"6) <"+ 2 1%)#:# )( 7+00+1 )<9#'%!, +71%%!"

"+7/+ #+!%;%#!""$ :

>8?

# # 709 "%"#!;( % '#" 7+ / :% %! !" #!-'!,"#+! 1% 7#0 ) %" #!"%!, +7"$ /+!) !"%;%#!""$ / "#"#+!

! 1#"$ / ,""+"$ #) !

!"#%0 /0+"#"'%" )#!

$%%+ 4B( * !' "%" +7*#00%; '';%:

$ %#) '#" 1% )#:# ) <9 "$ 0 %! ) #%0 +'" *#) -');: !" %!) ) , )% %" ) 855 ;;

;# * )"$ +7("$ /+!) !" / 7 )%#*#0// %0< 7+ +'" +7 0 %!

) #"#," '); ( '';%:

'#!; / !) !,9 +7 "$ %// %0 0( % ""0 : !" ,%:

"+ < %#* ) %" < "1 ! "$ $ /%"# $ " : "$ +7 % ="%," )$ '!

!) 6 E

!"6+"$"$ /%"# $%* =/0%#! ) "$ /+, +7 : )#%"#+! %!) ,+!,#0#%"#+! "+ /%"

"# %// %#!;< 7+ : %0+!;1#"$ "$"$ #,+'! 0 '"$ : )#%"#+!

+!C ,+!

!,#0#%"#+!$%* =/0%#! )"$ /+, , +7: )#%"#+!C,+!,#0#%"#+!"+ + "$ /%"

"# ,+!)'," ) $ 7%," % <# 709 "%" ) <9 9 "$ /%"# % "$%" %// 00%!" 7#0 ) % ,#*# *#0%// %01$#,$#/ !)#!;#!"$ 7 %0,+'"

! : "#!;1%$ 0))'#!; "$ /+, +7: )#%"#+!

$ /% "# $%* * 11#"$"$ %#"%!, +7 )#%"

"+*+0'!"%#09%#* )%"%!%:#,% %<0 +0'

0'"#+! +0*#!;"$ #%<+* : !"#+!

! ))#/'" %!))#77 !, $ /%"# $ "+ ,+!7#: %!

!) ) ,0% "$%" "$ 9 $%* *+0'!"% %#09 "$"$ #+1!7 1#00C,+! !"1 1#"$+'"%!97+, (/ ' C,+ , ,#+! 7+:

: %!9 ,+! %#* ) %" %! %:# :#,%<0 ""0 : !" ; : !" #! / !, +7 )#%"+.+!,#0#%"+ $ /%"# $%* %; )"+ "

""0 "$ # !"# )#/'" C)#77 !

!, +!"

"$ 7+00+1#!;" :%!),+!)#"#+! 6 %!-%9$%&%!+!< $%07+7%0 00"$ +7%;:%0"%" )"$%""$ 9 9 % !+" " #!/+ #+!+7%!9/%"+7&$% %!+ 4B * !' "%" +7*#00 00%; '

';%+!%!)#7"$ 91 7+'!)#!'!

'!%'"$+# )/+ #+!+7%!90%!) )+7 &$% %%!+ 4B("$ 91#00 :+* "$ %:

!*# 1+7%<+* '!) "%&#!; %;%!%01#001#"$)%1"$ / !" %// / %0/ !)#!;#!"$ 7 %0,+'"

+"$"$ /%"# $%* !++<- , ,"#+!(7+: %' : !"+7&$%% !+ 4 4B<9 * !' %'"$+#"# %""$ #+1 1!,+"

7%!9 !,+%,$: !"#7+'!)< <9"$ * !' %'"$+#"# C"$ % %: #!

!+"*%,%" )<9 +7%;:%0#!;

!;$"$ !%;%!%01#00$%* #;$ $""+ 7#0 = ,'"#+!7+*%,%"#+!+7"$ !,+ +%,$ )0%!)C"+; "/+0#, %#)7+ "$ %#) )/'/+ 9 #;!#!; "$# %; : !" /% %"# "%" "$%" "$ 9 $%* !+ 7'"

"$ ,0%# #:C) :%!)%;%#!" %,$+"$ +7 +7%!9!%"' 1$%"+ * $ )#/'

'" C ) )#77 !, #! "$# ;%) $%* < ! %:#,%<09 ""0 ) 7+ * <9 "$ $ : "$+ +';$"$ /+, +7 )#%"#+!.+!

!,#0#%"#+!

$ /%"# '!) "%& "+%<#) <9"$ " :C,+!)#"#+! "+'

'"#! %; : !"( < 7+ "$ 7 %0 +'" %!) !+" "+ )#/'" "$ % %: $ #!%7" #!7'"'

F >4?

! "$ <%#+7"$ %7+ %#),+:/ /+:# ("$ #*#0// %0/ 7 ) %""$ #!"%!, + +7"$ /+!) !"1%)#:# ) )%1#"$)%1!%!)"$ /%"# 1 1 :%) "+ :%#!

! <+'!) <9 "$ " : +7 "$ %#) ,+:/+:# $ +) )% %" ) 4 5 858/% )<9"$ 0 %! )#"#,"');

(';%+!!+1'';%:2#!"

"$# ;%)# ="%,"

" )$ '!) 6

!" // 00%!"%;%!%0% %!)%!"+$ ':%#!/ +!

%$ $1%# /+!) !"!+ )*+,%" (0 %! ),+'! 07+"$

#0 , #* ) 7+: "$ $ )#%"#+! C +!,#0#%"#+! !

!" ( # "#,"+'"(';%+!(%0+!;1#"$ $ ""0 )%; : !"

+#!""%" : !

!"+7 %// 00%!" ,+) )"+"$ 77 ,""$ "$%""$ 9$%* ,+:/+:# )"$ :% %"" "$ /+!) !""$+';$ )#%"#+! !" (1$#,$#=%!)"$ 9 9 % <+'

'!)<9"$ %#),+:/+:# $ 9 91%!""+1#"$)%1"$ %// %0% / ,+:

:/+:# = !"$ +"$ $%!)( /+!) !" !+ $%:%) %"%" : !""$%"$ $% ,+:

:/+:# )"$ :%"" *#) ,+:/+ +:# = %!)"$ 9% <+'!) )<9 ,+:/+:# %) !*# 1+7"$#7%,"(%// / %0#)#:# )%1#"$)%1!

% "# % 0 7""+< %"$ #+1!,+" +"$ "$"$ /%"# 1+'0)< <+'!) <9 9 "$ ,+:

:/+:# = 1$#,$ 1+'0) < !7+, %<0 %" "$ #!"%!, +7 /% /%"9 %;% %#!""$ ) 7%'0"#!;/%"9

+1 +'" ,+) %0+!; 1# #"$ % ,+/9 +7 "$# +) < !" %!) %// / %07#0 < ,+!#;! )"+ ,+)++:

+:%7" )' ,+:/0#%!, !!+'!, )4 858 6)6 $%%"$'$%! %++!2( #"#,"'); (';%+!

F !!

'< < G' !"09("$ /+!) !"/ 7 7 )%!= ,'"#+! "#"#+!<% % ) +! "$ ) ,##+!

! !) ) <9 "$ // 00%" + +'" % "#!; "$%" "$ / "#"#+!

2 $%*#!; !,+%,$ $ )'/+!"$ /+"#+!+7 $%% %+ 4B#"'%" )#!"$ * !

!' "%" +7 '';%:( 1 G'# ) "

"+ :+* "$ # '!%'"$+# I ) 4) <'#0)#!;. !,+%, ,$: !"

'#!; "$ = ,'"#+!

! /+, )#!;( <% ) +! "$ ) :%,%"#+! ,% # ) +'" <9 "$ * !' +77#,# #%0 +! 8H 5B 85A( "$ +<- ,"# +! / 7 )%""$ #!"%!, +7"$ / "#"#+! 21 )#:# )7+00+1 )<9#'% !, +71%%!"+7/+ + #+!%;%#!""$ :

>@?

;;

;# * ) "$ +7( "$ / !" *##+! / "#"#+! ,%: "+ < 7#0 0 )( 1$ #! !+"#, +7 :+"#+! 1% #' ) +! @ 5 85B %!) #!" #: /+" ,"#+! 1 1% ;%!" ) #! 7%*+ +' +7 "$ / "#"#+! 2 % ;

%) "$ # )#/+ #+! 7+: /+/ "9#!G' "#+!

>3?

+) )%9( )'#!; "$ ,+' +7 $ %# #!;( #! "$ / !, +7 %'"$+# I ) / !"%"#* +7 "$ / ,"#* /%"# ( # #" $% < ! %; ) "$%" % 7 $ ) :%,%"#+! < ,%# ) +'" #! " : +7 "$ / +, )' !+"#7# ) <9 "$ #!%!, ,#%0 +::##+!

* !' C ))#"#+!%0 $# 7 , "%9 "+ +* !: !" %9% %!%(

* !' %!)# #%" %!%; : !" /%": !"

"*#) !+"#7#,%"#+!)%" )A 5H 58 1$#,$ %)%'

'!) 6 E

+"#7#,%"#+ +"#7#,%"#+ +"#7#,%"#+ +"#7#,%"#+ $ A"$ /" :< +!

+! :< (858 +

836 686858.3H35 6

%9%!%%!)

,+)%!'%0 ,+)%!'%0

,+)%!'%0 ,+)%!'%0 $% $% $% $% $%/" $%/" $%/" $%/" 6'* 9 '* 9 '* 9 '* 9 !"$ %9%!%%!) ,+) %!'%0('<6/%%2+7/%% H $% %00< '<"#"'" )%'!) 6 J$ 0#:#"%"#+!+7<+'!)%9 9%!)) :%,%"#+!,%!%0+< ,% # ) +'"1#"$"$ $ 0/+7J0 ,"+!

!#,+"%0"%"#+!J2:%,$#! %!) <9 '#!; '%0 G' !,9 0+<%0 %*#;%"#+! %" 00#" 9"

" : 2 , #* #! +"

+, #!; :+) + <9 %06 #:

#! :%"#, 2: "$+)'#!

!;+!"#!'+'09 / %"#!; !, 9" : 2 "1+&%!) +* %""$ ,+"+7//0#,% %!"J =/0%!%"#+! =/0%!%"#+! =/0%!%"#+! =/0%!%"#+! K$9 /0%, 1#"$ 60+<%0%*#;%"#+!%" 00#" 9"

" : 2 # % <+%) " : !,+ +:/%#!; )#77 !" "9/ +7 %" 00 00#" 6 <% ) /+#"#+!#!; 9" : ' ) ;0+<%009 0+<%0 +#"#+!

!#!; 9" :2#+! ',$"9/ +7

%06#: #! :%"#, 2# #% ,$!#G' "$%"' ,%# 6<% % ) %!;#!;%!)/+*#) )%!; % %!)"$ 7+ /+#"#+!2"$%"% +) ) +7:%;!#"') :+ / ,# "$% %!"$+ %*%#0%<0 "$+';$,+) 6<% % ) /+#"#+!#!;

>A?

#!%!,#%0 ))#"#+!%0$# 7 %9%!% * !'

/%": !"F ( +::##+! * !' C 7 , "%9"++* !: !" ' %!)#%" %!%; : !" $%7'"$ < !/+#!" )+'""$%"

""$ %7+ : !"#+! )/+, )' $% %0+< !!+"#7# )<9"$#+'"< #!;#!,+/+% %" )#!+0': ($%/" %"

"6 +7 '0 82 * *#) ,+ ,"#+! 0#/ + BH )%"

) 4 5@ 858 $ %: # % %0+ /+)', )$ '!) 6 E82 82> 0#:#"%"#+!+ :%,%"#+!' > 0#:#"%"#+!+ :%,%"#+!' > 0#:#"%"#+!+ :%,%"#+!' > 0#:#"%"#+!+ :%,%"#+!' #!;0 ,"+!#,+"%0"%"#+!%,$ #!;0 ,"+!#,+"%0"%"#+!%,$ #!;0 ,"+!#,+"%0"%"#+!%,$ #!;0 ,"+!#,+"%0"%"#+!%,$ $#! $#! $#! $#! ",

6$ ) 0#:#"%"#+!+7<+'!)%9%!

!)) :%,%"#+!,%!%0+< ,%# ) ) +'" "$ "$ $ 0/ +7 J0 ,"+!#, +"%0 "%"#+! 2 %,$#! %!) <9 ' #!;

'% '%0 G' !,9 0+<%0 %*#;%"#+! %" 00#" 9" : 2 , #* #! /+ "/+, #!;:+) +<9J %0# #: #! :%"#, 2J: "$+)' #!; +!

!"#!'+'09 / %"#!; 7 !, 9" : 2 "1+& %!)

+* * + <9 %!9 +"$ 0 ,"+!#, , : "$+) ,+;!#I ) <9 "$ "%" +* * !: !"<91%9+7!+"#7#,%"#+!.#!

!"',"#+!#' )7+:"#: "+"#:

? '

'0 82#! " )*#) + ,"#+!

'0 82#! " )*#) + ,"#+!0 0 0 0 0#/+ BH)%" )4 5@ 858M 0#/+ BH)%" )4 5@ 858M 0#/+ BH)%" )4 5@ 858M 0#/+ BH)%" )4 5@ 858MF >B?

"$ $%7'"$ < !%; )< "1 !

<+"$"$ /%"# "$%""$ 9$%00 !+" %%#0"$ 7 $) ) :%,%"#+! /+"/ /% )<9"

"$ * !' +77#,#%0#!" :+7 %7+ : !"#+! ) +"#7#,%"#+!%!)"$ ,+ ,"#+! 0#/%!)$%00 :%#!<+'!)<9#"

>H?

! * *# 1 +7 %7+ %#) ,+! !" ) "% %!) "%& ! <9 <+"$ "$ /%"# ( +) )%" )@ 85A/% )<9"$ 0 %! ) = ,'"#!;+'"# "%#) %!) 0 %! )+'"# G' " )"+) /'" +: !#+ + * !' +77#,#%07+:'';

%: + % "+ ,%9 +'" "$ 7 $ ) :%,%"#+! G'% "$ '<- ," /+/ "9( #! " : +7 %7+ : !"#+! ) +"#7#,%"#+! %!) "$ ,+ ,"#+ +! 0#/ $ 7 $ ) :%,%"#+! < ,%# ) +'" '!) "$ '/ *##+! +7 "$ #"# #," * !' 77#, ( '';%:

: % 1 00%#"%!

!"+::##+! +7 +0#, +7"$ $ % %,+!, ! ) ""$ ! ) )7'0 = ,# < ,%# # )+'"1#"$#!+! :+!"$7+:"

+)%9%7" /'""#!;<+"$"$ #) +! !+"#, L"$ %7"

<% )'/+!"$ %#)) :%,% %"#+! /+"("$ 0 %! )= ,'"

"#!; +'"$%00/+, , )#!%,,+)%!, 1#"$0%1 >5?

$ *##+! "#"#+!%0+!;1#"$/ / !)#!;%//0#,%"#+!2(#7%!9"% !) )#/+ )+7

2 +* :< +* :< +* :< +* :< A A A A(8 (8 (8 (8 "#& 858@ "$ / %&#!;. %+! ) .+ "$ /+"%<0 .+ K$ K$