Punjab Water Supply And Sewage Board, Through Its Executive Engineer, Patiala v. Jai Bhushan Malik, Contractor And Another

  
 

      
     


  !"#$ "%&'&#()*+* 

, -.  -, 

 / - 0
1/  .



1"2'3'

  - 

.4/

     




  




)  5 . *-
 --    


  

   

 
  
   --  /*

2 6    !
 
  

"

#
 
$$%

 &  # 

'



 
 


 
$()*$)$+
,# -.




"/


 

0#
 
1"/
   
 2

# "
3 
#/

1
4

"  

  5/

"

2#


"  


" )+)($)$+
#



 
6(


"  
 & 
 
((.
 



7 
 7  $ 8
# 



"


  
#"2  


 
 

 # 

1 



/2





 
"  
9
#"2 




 
1

1

 





 
#





"  


"   





#
':



"# 



 # /
 


"

"/

2
" 1

 



   

 


#
/2


 
#2


$)))))5- 1





"  
1
1

"
"
;#/
"/
" 
  



  -4
# # /




2#

 )))))5-



"  
"#


"  


2 



#
':



#


+)))))5-
1
1

" ;#/

"/
" 

 



1/

  

1

"# 1 

2#


%+))))5-
 #

  

/

 2#


)))))5-


2
" 1

  
9
# 

#"2 

1

1
1





  
 "

 
1

"/

  
#
 
6<



"
 
 

0#
 

1
1
 
 

1

#
 
6(


 
=
 
1

"/  
1



-



 
1

"/  $
1



"  

" 

 
1  # 
#
"/
1/


22

1


2#


,#
-.



 
 
1"/
"/
1
" 

   
  
1
 

  5/

"

2#

 "  


"
)+)($)$+
6 8
# 

#"2 


 



#


1

1







 



1 


 , 







#
':



1

/
!

#"

  

#2 



,#
-
1
1


7  2




"/

&
>,# 
?


  - 4
"/
1


"  
1

 $


 
  1
 


"/
2@



 
,#
-
  6)*$)$6

#"2 


 
#
1
2 

9

#"2 

 #



#
 







"   

2



 

" 1

 

"#



  ,#
-

 


"

2 


 

#
':



1#

/


 
 
9

#"2 

 

 


#2  

2# 

"

"

  < ?


 


# 


"
  
#"2 


  


 


#


  
 
9
#"2 

 #



 
1


1


 ,

2
" 1

 


2


 
1 
 
, 




"  


2
1


#
':







"




2



#
':



1 1


1
"
"
3




 #2 



 
 


#"2 




 # 


  
 


1

, 

/




2


  1
1

"/
" 

  
9
#"2 


/

1 
"
2
"/


# 


  


,#
- 1
1





"/

&
>,# 
?
 

  2


"  


1



 
,# -

#"2 


# 


 

1#
1


  
#  /
1
1

&
>,# 
?


,
/

' 1 
1



1

 





#
1

 1
 


, 




2
4
2  

9
#"2  
 /




#2


@

#2


  #  /

,
2


2
1#



"2
"
#  

1





1


 


2
 
  
=# 2


# 
$+
,


2 


" 


 
1
"

"/

"  

&   
((.
9
#"2 

 #

 
 


"  

"/

  

1 

 
  
"#

#

#  
#2 


#

/


2


  

!  
2



 

 @



@-A
!  
# 
$+ ,

#

#-
  



    

       

 

  !



 "

 

"

 #    



  



# 

    $% + 8
# 
# 
#"2 



1/


"

 
/
2
" 1

 

 

, 




  # 



 
1#
"


"/





#
':



 

 #/


1


 
# 
,

# "
9
#"2 


 
#
1

"

2 
 ,#
-
1
/
 



1
 
1
1


# "/

 
#  /

1
#



"
#
 

" 


 
 


, 



 "  
9


"

  



 

,
/


 
"  

2
#

"
 


2


   


 


" 1

  
1




2   


#
# 

1
 


2


 

    . 8
# 
# 
#"2 


/
 

    

 
2  


2 

1





 /






"  



1

"  
1 

 
  



,#
-6


"  

 




#


"





" 

 
 





, 

/"


"  


1

"






"  
1

"






#
,
 
 2

 


34






 


 6)

#

#-

$&   #



!#

 

  



    $  '    !  





   

"

 

()''&$% %
9
# 




,






"/ 

"  


1

1
/



 


"  
" 

 





, 
/"
 

"  
#





1
"/
1/




2 " 1

 
"


"  


1
 


 1
"



#
,

'
1

"




 
 2 

1
#


 
#  /




/
 


/"



"  

 


 1
1
2
"/

  




/2




1  
1
1 #
/
#  /

1


1



 
1 


 

"  

& 
 
((.



1

 


 
2#


+)))))5-
1

"

"/
" 
  

;#

!

 


 


# 
#-
  



#

# *$ $+* (( ,$  

"  " " "

 # *+  # #

"! 

 # "

$



     "     "

 # -* # $

"  

    "

 

  " 



  +$ $+*  

! "

 "



,

$  # #



      #

 

!#

 

   

     # 

# 

.

  '      !      



 

      

"

 

()''&$ (

 / 

0$-1 

23/()''& 

  



  

 

    

'

   $4!



!

  #

 

"





" 

# #



  



 

 

& $5  



"

   



#      



# #



  

    $





 "  "





 ! #  

!     

!   62

!   "

"

  

 $  &  

    #

$



 

 



  #

 

'

  57# 

$ #



 

'    

# #" $ $++ 89  

 :  

  $

 (  



 

$++9    



  

#$

"

  "

,

 



  

#!   



  $

 

#  +$+ $+-

$*+; *



$< 3 ($% * 8
# 
# 

#"2 


 



 
"

"/

  


2
1


"/ 
  

/
 
9
# 
#"2 



#"

;# 

6

 
$))$)$<
+ 

  ))<$)$<
. 

 
$))<$)$<

% 

  *)+$)$<

1
 /
"


"/


"  




"   
"#

2
1

"

 

"/

  9
# 

#"2 


/
 




#2/

1

"
1 



#
 




1
1



"/

 "  

2
#

"
  

"/

  



2 



"

 
#
 
6<



"#


 
 
 1

  


"

 
#
 
6<


 


# #
1
@
"/

  
"


 
 0#
'
1
/
1

" 
 

 $


   
 
#
 
6(


 

"/
1/

 2#

 
1


#


  

 

" 2#






1/

 /

  /

"
#

 2#
 ( '




# 


  

 ) !
  

 # 




1


"



 "  
'
1

 



# 


  


 1

"



,#
-
1

#

"
2  1





 
#2



$)))))5-
/


"



;#


"/
" 

  
1

1

 



# 
  



1

"




#
':


 "# 
,#
-




/
#
/2


" 
# 
2
" 1

  
'


# # 




2 " 1

 

1


# 

, 






 "  
!
/

1
1
2
"/


# 

   
1

,#
-

# 

,#
-
1#
1




1

"



"/

 

#  /


& >,# 
?
"/
1
 
$
1
 


 "  
!


2 

/

# #


 



 
91
1

 

1
1

#
   

#
1
 


1
 
8  

0#
1


 

"/
 



$
#
 
6(



"





#

  
1
 


  /


/

1
"# 

1
  
"/

 
#  /
>
 1 
 



 
1 
1

2

2
 

" 1
1
 


2



2

 
/
#

/2





"  
 
2

1/



#
':


 
91

 "



/
#

2


2
" 1

  
 

#
':



1#

'

 
  2 /

1

 


2


2 
!

+ 1
 



 2
 
1#


"


1# 




" 


 

1

1





 2

 


  

!

 
#2  
 

#
':



1
1/

 
2

"


# 

 


/


#

#
 



"  
'








"  

#
"


1

 
 

1
"




#
,

 2
 
! 

 1

/
"






 
$6$$)$6



#
"


 

1
"
%+))))5-


 /
  
 

1





 


 


1
"


 ': 

#

"

%+))))5-

! 
 /

 "  

"



#


/2


!
   2 /



/



#
/
 
>
 

#2/

  
1#




2
"  # /
 

  
#




2
"/
 "

 
#
 
6<



"#




# 

   


#
#
1
@
#


"

 
#
 
6<

   $ 4/
1/


2#



 
 0#

 



  

  5/

"

2#


 
"  

1

 




"  
1

2
  
6(


 
& 

 


#2  


&#




 
1


 
  



/
2 




2 
  

 6
& ;# /

 
  

 2



1 






$+)))5-

#
!1 /
=
!# 

1

"
  
"/
   



B/
2 
#

(%)))%+)6)%
C9- .
D!
&

D
9
&#
 /
9 
1 


 
2 
2
/



 

   



9 

   3 
@  E  3 
 "  E