High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/909/2018dismissed

United India Insurance Co. Ltd v. Bhinder Kaur And ORS.

2022-12-23Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan13 pages

!"#$ $$$!!%% & '( ) ( $$$*!

+%,-.(( $$$!!%% & / 0-.(( $$$*! +1+ 23$$ 2

$/!% %50 (!!%% !6$3

$+(-( 50 (!!%% !6$ $

$7 /!50 !6$8 !6$ $ $ '"( 5(%%!1:$$

1%;(%11!!%%< !" 1%;(%11!!%%<+%,-.(( 5:( ( (0 1( : $ $ '

1%"5(1 1( (3$3$5( %. -.(1 %.( " % (!: .

0%%. 1 0%%.-.(% .4( !; .

. 6$4'83=;23!$ $5:((( ( %% (1#> * %%5)( 5( 7; .

. 6$4'4 8 ( 1 1

( 11.

;. 0;" !6$/ 0-.( ( .%. (.( ! :( ; 0. 11 % :(;%:."( 7( :( !1

%. -.(= %%" %. -.(1%%:( 11 %!%, (;" %.(5 ( $=(:

0 0%?!%)( 5;7!.0:(

5(: 1

4/5 (. (5(:0 (( :" )( $ @(

: : ;" , -.($ 4 > (;":

0%?!%5 )( $3$$*6$3$3$5 - 5 354 : . :(4-)( . .(

$ $ @(%.% !

01 5 %"5- $'(

) <:1.;8" 5+%,-.(.; " / ,-.(.;8" < $ !) %

,) .; "

.( 5(;

.( %

3 ! - 1( &( % 5 ( 1

( ;1

% @ ;%5(. ( -(; ( 1 1

(@ ;% . !6$< / 0 -.( < 0 5 A.( ) < : $#$ 1(11. 7; . . 6$4'4 8$ 3$ ( % !5( % ( ( :.;8" : . " % (!

;10%%.-.(%=((:.. 0 1 "1 .: .*$35B1 %%

= (:; .(((%>! 0.(1 %"(; 1(;%"=( % (!*$585B( !

1;"51 %! .% $ $ 6 1( % !:.0 !5:( !!! $*!6$1%,:

5 :( !6$3(1%! :

$ 8$ (,:

1%;(%11 ! 6$5("(7!!

% ";, ( ! 6$11 0 ( "

(0( % C: :( !6$3< !"$ 5 ( ! 1( ( % !$ $ (! :

1%;" !6$3 !"5 (%%.( ;%"1( % ! .(( 7C(;:

.%"0%0( ,. !=(;;" % 0

:((!% 11 %14% -)( 1%*( ;. . ( ." !$ ( ;, ( ;7( 0 1(%%.11. 7:!. 0%511 0%.% 0.% ( 1%%.

(1 ::%%:((7:%.1 !6$$$:

1( 7!((! !6$ 0( 7 C(:. % .%. 5(:"5( 7:;. 0 0%1( 1( !% ".

%1 &( % 1 ( !6$: (0. 0% * 5 1 1 ! ( 1

$ @( . 1 ( ;. 8 " 5 ( 0 1 :

7. " % "1 .%%.%" .*$35B

% ;"( % : % (%%.$ $ %%(( !!

"1 %1( % !$ $ (!%.1(! 1%%:.: 1 2 $ D(( ( !6$ (1 %. -.(;"

0. 76$4'4 8 (.%. 3$3$234$ $( 1)( E44$ $ D(( ( % ! ;%E4* 3$ D(( 0 1(@ 76$4'4 8:(0.

0% 0.% ( 1

( 7( 0% . 1 ( E4*$ $ D(( ( % %1 !!

( !E44$

8 8$ *%1$ $ '((! %0 !!

1( ! 0

% $ + . ( 1 0 5 ( % 6$ - $'( ) (!! D5:( % 6$3/ , -.(.(

D$'(1( !!

(

1( % %!$ D3 ,-.(": 1(

( 1( % !

0.(" :

1 (

$ D ( -.(!%

1 !"1! !

1 F>$ 5 1 !"

1*F>$ 5 1 !"1 ( .(F>$ 35 1 !"1

(%% - 3

$4$ $F>$ 5 1 !"1

1/ 0-.(F>$ 85 1 !"1 0 " 1 7 F>$ 5!(.

!(1((!1 " % F>$ F>$ 35

.% !1!" 1;%%F>$ F>$ 8 .% ;%%F>$ $ ;%5 !6$ 0

. 1 1(11. 7F>$*5 !% " F>$*5 ! 1( 7F>$*350 1 1( 0.

% 1/ 0-.(F>$*5 0.% F>$*81

1 1 7F>$*1 (" 88$

%1 !6$3 0 1

!"1( !% "F>$* 5 .%0 1 !

1 ! . .(11.0( %F>$*5 .%0 1

1( 0.% 1 !6$F>$*1

1 1(11. 7F>$*$ $ 1 ( . . 5(@ ;% 6$ .( !10 1( % =6$: (%.( !6$(;;%!

0((: (0.0%11 0 0.% ( 1

= 6$3 : (%. ( %" % 6$ '( ) % !5:( % 6$5:(

(% 1( %$@( 1 0: 3$$ !1*$55B:: % 6$5 !";%;"%%( !,%"0 %%"5(:0 ! 6$3: 7!" 1 ! :(:

(1 (1!

1: 51%.:( ( % 6$:%;% 0 (: GH! (11%.1(!%% %$ $ @( % !"1%..

0;"( : ("(01%! !!%;1 ( 5:( ( ;.7!.( 1 (0. 1( : $ $ 6 1(!!%:( !5:(! !! ( .( %$ 3$ (0( % %1 (! ;..

( .((

$ $ @(1 1 . 0 ;"% % (!!%%< !":( 7; . . 6$4'4 8:0%0(

:!%%

( ;"( % 0 :((!% .

!$?1 ( ; (*6$3$3$5 :( (:%.(>"1(

(

. ; ( ! % 1(0( %:%% 1 ( 0 ,-.( ":1(

: ( (!( %0 :(%!! . D3 , -.((

> (((1 ;( %%.

:%%11.0( %(1 %" ; 1( $3$$$(>"1(

1( (.%.:(( (!% =(*: %.( 1+%,-.(5:(:> (

% $ 8$ D( 5% %1 ( % ( 0 ( 1% %1 (!!%% !"

.((

(1 ; ;" (.%. 0.1(11. 7;"/ 0-.( !6$

% (%11 %:%% "0 ;%(($ $ 1 ( . ( 0% 5 1 ( ( ; ;" %1 (!!%% !"% 1 0 $ $ %"5*%. . .(

. ; 1( 7( ! % :%%% 1( 0 %";7;!

( ! ! 1 . 1 ( * (

% ( " "! %.(*5:( "

"(0(

B 5 %";"%..1 ( ( ;.(11 , %(%1

(.%. 0.1! % 0( % !

1 %11 - 533 534 5 1

:( (!% ; . (*$ "; ( ( * "

%!1( ( %1( B

%.( 7!% =( 0( %:( ( (

=(! 5:(: 0. ( 0( % $ 10.$@(!% 1 %..(*

0.( 1(:(

: (! !;%1 .(

$@(.(!

!%..1(* ;%; %" . (( 0 .0(*; ;%0 .(%"51 0 .>!%1 (%".0$ $ ( 5(1 %" ; 1( (0 ;(7 I( .:;(1( (

$ C . % "

(7;%..1 :((!% $ ; >! ( %"% .;(1 (

(1 %" ; ( ! %.(": :%(0 ((!% 1 1%%%. !

( $@(%:

(;, 0 " % ( %1!

01 0 %" !!% ( !

. ;1 ( @ ;%$ $ - 1( &( % ! 1:%1

%.%$: ;"(4 % !

0 %1( ! 5:(11 , ( 0( %

:%% (%.% !

01(0 5:(1 %"%(

%0 ( (!$- %10 !

!!% ;%( $ $ @(@ ;% . ( !!";% >! !0 " . !

$%>;%"( C $- %"%..1(* "; %0 1

% ;!

. - 1(

&( % $- +%,-.(5:((%.(*( ( %1(

5(> : 7 " 11 ; 7 0 %" C ( 1 (

% $@( % (> ,-.(":1

:( +%,-.(( 01 (;1:( ((( . . *$ ,-.(!!

( 1( % %! .

%%".((

(; ;"

!6$/ 0-.(;"( (.%. 0.1( 11. 7$ ? :

> %.( ;(%1 1 (

!;( 7(. %;( "

%!$6 0:.. !

!;":( ( (: .((0 1 : !1%%"10 1(

% .( !$ $ %(.(

.% %1 (!!%%< !"5( % !(;1%;"( %

%%:((!% :%% 0 : 1(0( %;

( ;

1 (

$@(: 0 1 (0( %(1%,:

".(( 7 C ( "

$ @( : > ;" (

% ( ; !

> ( ;(%1$ F0 ( :51 (

1 ; :((: 0 1(11. 7: %%.:(( % $@( 1 (/ 0-.( !6$(!!(: ;>!((0 1( !6$( :

5 ( (: ( ( 0 ;" (

% 6$ ( . ; ; ( ! < !"% 7"11 .(

;"7.( !! (:;>1 (! !$ # @ ;%:(% .6$( (0 1%( 1

$C%";%( (/ 0-.(: (%%1 .(

$?:

( : ( .($@( 7C(;I ;"(!% $@( 1 511 0: ;7:( . 0 .0;"(@ ;%10 1( % .

!6$$ $ D( . (C 1 !51( ; , ;% %" ((.( $ @( @ ;%(7(.1( ;8" .

(. (! !

F>$ $%(.(

. ( % 5( :..(0 1".

% .1+4@@- .*$5B! (; :.

% 1*$5B1 (0 1 "1 .$@(

% (> %% 1((!-($( -.( D5:( ((( ((!( 5:( (:.( ;1". % .1+4@@-;(@ ;%1 (

;7: , ( " ( : ( 7%%%; 14,;/0 % 6$3 $$( (%" ; *$ BH :: 1 !

! 5:( B3 :

1(! %%0.>! ( 1 ( !: % %1 . %!% 1 . ! 0% (5 ( %

!::

7*$55B$@( ! :

71%"(.( ( !1

$ 3$ @( 1 5 ( 1% ;(%1 1 ( !";1%

.%"$ $ 6: . 1%;(%11!!%% +%, -.(5 / , -.( ! ) % , )

(% 1( 5:(: ( ( !1

( ( +%, -.( / , -.(5 :( 1 ((.1 , "(.( !)

G ,) (;

11$'(@ ;% % %"1%%

.$@(%.%!( . (; % 1;"( !> ,.

!"#$%&%:( :; 0(0

. 1 ( ;. %.%

0 (0 .( !!%" 1 ! 1

%($ 8$ 1

.( 1( 5 % "

.( .0;"( ! $@(" !

0.1 (7C1 C%" 10

5(:"5(" :1 %;11 (

! $D(((1( 1( 5 !) G ,) ( %" ; !

0 1 ( %0 11 ; ;0%" ( 11 ! "%%$-( 0;.

( ( !$ '()* +%, ) -( ) )

/ # 0(*1/ # 0( 2 3

3 4 -

'( 5

@( !.: 1 (!!%%+%,-.(5/ , -.( !) % ,) %1%. ( ( !:

1(1 %. -.( (

$@(@ ;%:,1.0.( ! % 6$'( ) $- ( 1 (( !: :%; !!

.%%( % 1%%:. $ 4 6$<'( )

88H $ 4 6$+%,-.( 8H 3$ 4 6$3/ ,-.( 8H $ 4 6$ !)

8H G ,)

3 $ % 1( ( !"(% "

( C!" ! 6$'( ) 5(( :%;%;%!"( (>1( .0(

!!%%1(:( (1 "5( !!%%+%,-.(5/ ,-.( !) % , ) :%;%1%> !!% ;1

% @ ;%5(. (-(;1 0 "1( ! 6$'( ) 5( :1 ( %% !5:%;%;%"1( !" !%":((

!(!!%$ 3$$ '

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#