State Of Haryana And ORS v. Satyapal @ Satpal
!"# #$%&'((
& )
( *(*(*+ )
( * *
!
"""" (*(*,%#-,.,/",0( 1,/ ! ! # $%&'$&() + $(22 $3 4*,56,7,/ 8 *,57,/ 9:( *5,5 $3 ,16,%, ,%# $5- 1:;* + , - ! - !./0 1/ 2 + ! !! + $)&3$&&4 5
6 7$8 , ! $'&9$&(95
6 738- :
!
! , ; <++
1 * +, !! ! - != , &$($$&(3 5
6 7%8 < </)'4$&&4
- , -! ! >:/%4(?(44) -
+ ,
* @% A- < ! 5 !- 8 , , ! *
7 B@%5(80 + , - + !+
,
- +
!+ !
+1!! 7 58
!-
+ - ! +
!! -
? + + !+ +
, +
! + -
5-8, - 5$8 0 + -7 5(8 + - 6 ! ,, A + -
!, , - - + !+
!+ - 5%8:
! + - !
!
, ! !
!+ + ! - , !
-7 5$8 -7 5%8 --A! !
, !
, ! +- !
!
! - -
, ! +-
@$ 5'8:
!
-7 5$8 - ! +
- 538:
!
-7 5%8 - ! +
- !
!+ !! ! -
!
+ !
+ ! - ! + - !
1
+-
+ C * # , ! , 1 , A < < ,%,< 1 7 1,5"$% "1!/ 0 ,=:-"% ,16,%, ">/" 9"51,% "<,?0,1%,@/,%#$5- 1:A:( ,5-@1,,::@75,0 ' *(((B
,:."%# 1C,@1A:( @%>,D*5,5 $. 1$17$1,5"$%"?"5 #,%# $5- 1:0 *(((
A 6 < ,"7@19"#6@59"51,%"<,?5#(,%#$5- 1:A:(,5-@ ,?0 *'
%"$%$3%#",A:(C(9(,%="1,?,%0 22*0 + ,, , 1-,1, + +
- , - * < - + D6+ : (3&3$&&4 5
6 7(8 , ,
+ + D6+ < - $9&4$&&$
D6+: (&(($&&) >:
-
+ - + ! - - # !! ! , - != 0 ! , - != &$($$&(3 5
6 7%8 # < </)'4$&&4 , , , , - -:,
! ! != , , - ! +
! ,
7
B: !
! ! * !!
#-
, ! + !+ E-
F (3&4(44) , ! < * + ,
! ! , , !, !
- ! * !, A (9&4(44) + :
(3&4(44) !!
#-
, , !
< - /
< -
< -
!+ ! !+
! + + + !
!! , -+ * ! ! + !+ E-
,
+ , > 5D + +8 D607$? , !
!! #-
,
< -
(94(44) : !
#-
,
(9&4(44) ! !! , ! !+
+, !
< -
(3&4(44) -!+ - :
, - < -
, !
!! #-
, ! !!+
+
!+ (3&4(44) * = + , / 6 +!
! 6 !+ + ! > !!
#-
, !+
+ + !! 1! , !!+ - !7!!
+1
, ,
-*
- ! +!
- , +
! ! ! * < ! - - ! -
- , - < = -
, * + A
- < -, * !! != !
+ +* --
-
!
C # 6< , , - E < "A"/77 ,/$('' $3 551" ,16,%, ">/" 9"51,% "<,? ,%# ,%$5- 1 9:( *-,:-" C@?,1; ! $9&4$&(% ,
6
- -!1, - A
7 BF - 7 ! -!+! , + , -
+ !+
, - +
!+ !
+1 !!
, !- + - ! + !! -
?
+ + !+ +
,
- : !+ ! + - 6 ,, A
, ! :
!
, !
- :
! - - :
!
! !+ , -
! * 6! ! !+6 !+ !
! + - !
+ -+
! !+
= +@%
, + + < D - A! +- + - != !
! ! - :
! , - ! * ! ! ! < ,A
:
-!1 , ! ! , + ! < , A !
!-!
- 6 D!
+, - -- < < * <
! !+ + ! - 0+ !
! ! ! ! , ! + +-1 , +, ! 6 ! , <
!(%9 <
, -!1, 0 - - , = , - ! !0+1! + - ! !
< !
+ , + - , - ! - + 2 !C ! , + # , ! , !
+$'&%$&&4 , - -
#
, - - / +- $&&4 !
+F + !
! - - : A !*-,:-"
C@?,1 :@71, -= A , - <
A 6< , - ! # 2 * 6 < ( ( ,#-,=1":-%,% 9:( *5,5 $3 C 1,/, ,%# $5- 1:0 B * 6+ ! , - !(434,
!
!
6 , * ! , , ! -!=
, -
-* !+ !- + , !!
, -+ - A
7 B$* ! -+ - !=
39 ! 7: ! - 0
! ! -+ 395(8
5$8 !(434 ,7 B395(80 ! , - + !+ ! ! , - !+
9& , , - +
,
!+ !
+1!! 7 58
!- ! - ! + ! ! + + !+ + !+ - 5-8, -
5!8 ! ! , ,!+
9&
-= ! -
+ 5$80 !+ ! , - +
!+ - 6 ! -A! -7 598-
, ! , , - - + !+
!
+ + !+ + !+ - , !
+ ! ! - ! -- ! + + +1
!
-+ -
+ ! - ! , ! -A! -7 5@8 - !
!
+ 5 - , 8 !
!+ + C % This is not a case where the appellant has been fully exonerated, meaning thereby an honourable acquittal. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that going by the judgment, the finding arrived at by the High Court in the criminal appeal regarding benefit of doubt is not correct. We are afraid, under the present proceedings, we cannot appreciate the above submission. The correctness or otherwise of the judgment in the Criminal Appeal is not the subject matter of this case. In these proceedings we can only look at the findings in the judgment. The acquittal is only on benefit of doubt. Thus, we find no merits in these appeals and the same are, accordingly, dismissed. 4.
Pending applications, if any, shall stand disposed of. There shall be no orders as to costs." < - !
, + , , - !+6
!- -- 0 , #
, - + , (9% A-!(4%':
!
! !+ ! !
+, - +!
! -, ,
! !
, - -
-, , 0 !+!
+ !, , , ! !! !=- - -,
, , , + , , , ! !,
6 + !+!
! A # -- 6 !! ,, 6 + ! , - +, , , - !!
! + ! - - # , !!
(*(*+
* '(( 1 ? H?/ 0 - H?/