← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5241/2024dismissed

Xxxxxxx v. Vishal Vohra

2024-11-07Mr. Justice Sudhir Singh,Mr. Justice Jasjit Singh Bedi13 pages

1- 

        

 



  !   "#$ % &&

 '$# '( '($ % )&            "$

 )(*+,+ $ $ -$.(#(+,+ $(&&

    "$ &&  ( /   0 ( 1#0-  $  

 & /  ( "$&  2#0+ -  .#$+ 3$ $ ($ 4- .#$5+ 6($/  ( & #$  7    ( *# $$0 + 8 $ ($ 9( 5   /  ( $&(#/6

6(-$$0/6 ( &$ 6  , /   $  ,$  ( 0$#$#  :( $ & ( /   /  ( $&(#/+    & 0 ($ ( ( -$$06(&&

66 -;

  &$ *# $+ /#  ( 6 /$ #  (  6  <6#$($& ((&&

66

2-     ($ -&$-   6  #  =#$$ 6(,$ 6(# $ <6#$($$ (((&&

6+($& (#/6-&

&#$(( #>#$ - & -  $ ,0 (   $#$  -  < 6 /#  ( &&

6 ( ( ( (  ( -($  ( $&(#/ 0 $$(6-&$,(&  3$

  :( &&

6 &$#$; ( $& (#/  , &$  $- ( &$  (  $ $0  #(   $ -- 

$?+ 3$  6   

@   < 6 #$($ 

0 ( 6( ( $&(#/ 6#  0  ( /($-0(+(&&

6#(( ( ($$-($-- -#(+ ( $&(#/ (   & # ( $-

( 6#  #$($  ( $&(#/   /(+ 06((+(6# $# &6((- ( #/#&($&(#/& -$ :( $&(#/ /$ ( $ /(,#$  ( &&

6 6( ( (& ( (0 6#  0 $- + /# 

  ,   

@+ ( ($  /$($  ( &&

6 $ ( (#  ( $&(#/ $/   # ($  ( -($ :(-$6$&$(& +6($(

3- &&

6  ($ -  --/$ & 0;  &$-  6$0 ( (  6#   $$  ( - -$($&(#/##$ <6 #$($ 

0 /  ( $&(#/ ( ( &&

6

6(-(,&(  $  6( ($   #  (  #  ( &&

6+ ( ( ,$ , ( (   < 6 #$($ $ ( $ $   6 + 6( ( ( / ( &(   $  6( ( &&

6+ ( ( &    (- ( ( 6 #0 &$# 6$0,0/$((  A$($ ( &&

6 (  #  6( ( $& (#/+#6((+(& 6

(- --/$  ( &&

6 ( & 0; $ (   /$ ( &    :($$+ ( &&

6 , ( $ --+ 6(  0  0 

( (#(  - 6(# ( &$-  ( $&(#/   B& + ( &&

6 $ &&$    ($ 6$ - -0 ( #-  -$$0 /6 ( &$  *6,$+  6 

0 ( ( $&(#/ 6  0 /$  0 6( ( &&

6   #(+ ( (-   6 (  :(

0

$-/ ( &&

6  ( $&(#/  ( -

4- --/$+ 6   < 6 #$($ 

0 ( ( &&

66 ,($-$- (-+/# (-($-$ #($&(#/ ( $ ($  , &$

 :( 

0  

0 ( $&(#/  /($- 6  <6#$($$(($((#+6($( &$6$ ,0&$ 6&/ (&$( &&

6  $&(#/  ( $ $(#(6 @

+ ,0/(( &&

6   $-(& 0(&$+($ #$ $-(

60#  D(($&$ $,$$- ($&(0$#$#  &$ $E ""

 D(($(&-/ &$$-E ") D(($(& / /-/0  $, #E")   )  F          < ,+ ( $&(#/ (-  &&$(6/>"D >-' '($  "D  *   $ #-$  , G> "   G> " 7   ( ($ (+ ( &&

6 >- ($   )D   >- ($ -($ - + -  2  "#$  )D+ / $0 ( #-$ ,G> ) G> )

5- ?

$($0(/((&$ $0(,/$#0($$+( $ -  .#$ 

6 ( & 0$0  $  ,$+/,          H$ #  $ ( &&

6 ( ,(- $0#((-&#01#0-$ &/ ( $- .#$/1#$ #$- <#$($$0#(( $- .#$ ( 6$0   # ( ( -   ( &&

6 #$ $- $   <  #$($ $0# (  6 ( &    ( &&

6 ( ($ -($ 6  -$  #

  ( $&(#/($(&&

 ,( -$-  (-   , &$   0 6( ($ (#/ <#$($$0#((&6# &$,$$+/#( $- .#$(

0$(- <#$($$0#((0(

$ -  .#$ $0$0 ( &&

6  &$-0 ( $&(#/  (, &(  $  6( ($+    #

 $$  <  #$($ $0# (   (   ( $&(#/ (- ((#/ (&(  $ 6(( &&

6 

  (  #(  6 -/ ($&(#/(- +-$/ ># $ ,$ # /0$#

6- ( ((&&

6($($& (#/ 6( $#   <  #$($ $0# ( (   >#  $#$ /6 ( &$$   -$  &$, ($/ $,(- $($/ &6$$/$ <    $0# (  ( $&(#/ (- $(&&

6/  ,0($-&  $- ( $ --+  6 (-+ 6( ( # $#    ( &&

6  (#+ ( -&#01#0-$ / ( @  D (, ($ ( $ #  $ ( &&

  (,   0 ($#0( ( -&#0 1#0-$&/ ( $- .#$      :( =#$$/$( #$ CD(($(-&#01#0-$& /  (

$ - .#$ $=#$   $$ EF

<6#/ ( $- .#$( "D''($+($>-+((

 I - #  $  )(  ( -  -$$0(&$ <6#$($&/ (-( ( &$ (  $?+ *#0 A$ .  + 3$ ($$+  + @+( ( $ + 3$   ( ( ( ,$ , ($ $ --   :( 6 #$($ & ( (

7- &&

6 6 ,$ $  , &$

 < 6 #$($ # ( ( &&

6+ 6(  &&$0  )D + -  ($ $>- ( ( /(,#$($(#/6(($6$

(#$($ &((

($(#/-$6( ($-($ 6$((($(#/(  ( -+ ( &&

6 6 ,0 &$    $ -- 6( ($ (#/  < 6 #$($ #(($6,$$1#  6( +   6#  0 &$ $- ( -($ 6(#   $  < 6  #$($ # (  >&  6$($60,/ (&&

6+ 6( (#$#(,># $#$6(( $&(#/  :( 

0  ( &&

6 $0$0-6$ 6$ #//  <6#$($#(6((&&

6-  ($ $>- ( ( /(,#$  ( $&(#/ 6$ ($ 6 $ + ( ($ 6  #/  ($ 

0 ( ( $& (#/($($ 

  <  6

   (  $$  #  $#  + ( &$  

00 ( - -# &$,  $$ ((/(,#$(&$ -& 0$( /  #( (  ( -  -&/  $ (  &$   ,  ( -&   ( &$  -& 

8- 0   :(   $#   -# / #(+ $- 6((  /$/  0

 #(($ /   $# /6 ( &$ #  (   :( $#    ($ / &(   $ -  $ /( :(#0(($-(- $-# ,(>   $#   

0 0+  (   $#- (,$ -#/>-( 0( (0$, (-  <      

 

 

  J*K/ &>.#$/$,#$

                       

          



    

   

       

      

    



     

       

           

                     

 !"

<    !"

   

 

# *K/ &>.#$/$,#$

"

 #     $

          

        #     

       %      &           '    (         

9-            

  )       

            $

 )    

      



)     



      *  (   

      # 

    ) &    $

)    

    

      +  )     

     

 ,-.,/./0  #!1  < 

  !"   #+   ..78+ (/( ($#  (/( (-/(/(,#$/ &# 6$ ( ($  :( $#    / &(   $ - + /##($#  -#/&$, <6( #$

,2 3 

 1   0   #  '       ,-.,/./   

      

            

              '  

  (            

         )     

             

       (                       

           

10-               

  (     .   4  .522*/6''7,,/ '          

 1         3     < !  $%  " &  $% +

  ..  +6( / (*5/  #&$-#$(# $-$/ 6$0$($#  +/# $   (#- /(,#$+ $ ,   0 6((9- $#  5+6$$-#  <6 ( / (*5/ &>.#$#$   8 

       

    

               

 1          3 9 ./ :    

              

       

 ./ :

 

                          

      ./  

        &

         

             

   ./             

      

11-

    

  ./ #         





  ./     

       

   

   

          ./       

      

   

                  ./           

 







    





  



      .3/     &      

  &     .3/                                                  3            

       3           .3/ (    

                             

    

12-    

  

 .3/ ;             

           

 .3/ ;                    

  .3/ )                          

  <             = 

      

       

(          <+ ( 0 $$ /  ( $ - .#$$>-( 0(( 6 6/ ( *5/  #&$-.#$($1#0-+6#  -#(((&&

6 0( $&(#/   >#  $#$+  $ -#- $#  

#$($+($,$  ( &&

66 ( ( (/ $/  ($ -($ 6  ( -$  # .

/  ($ (#/  , &$  $- (-  *6,$+  ($ - /$(.#$+((&(6(( -$  #  ($ (#/ -  $ 6( ($ -($ 6+ ( (  $  / ,0   $ --   L #$($+ ( &&

6 #   &$,  $$ ( ( ( / $ /  (

13- $&(#/  G,+ #$0 $0#- /$ ( .#$+ $# $(&&

# &#   ,  $$   ( ( 0 $$/ ( $- .#$#$$- & 

0  $&$,$     I($&(/#$0   :(#+$$# &$# (1#0-(

$- .#$+6(-# $$6((0$$/  ?

  < ,6  ( /,+ 6   -$  ( &$&& (-($/ -    

 &0 &&  +   + (

   & @   H/$ (6,$+0$(&&

6+  && 00$&$- - +  ,+ /$ ( $ -  .#$   <   #( &&   -,/  ( &&

6+ ( - (

/+$6( 6+&$$/ 6(& $>-( '  (   '(  



 1 "$($  )

  > 9 ? >8  ) 9 ? >8