High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/52620/2019dismissed

Kulwant Singh @ Sajan v. State Of Punjab

2022-03-11Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri35 pages

" !

!#$ %& !$'()(%* ++

,-./# 0(12 04

0##$

-45

+++++$)6%$# )

$$6 0(12

0##$

-45

7)2$$6 0(12

0##$

-45

* 8 9 +

0 0

! " ! #$$%&'&($&()* + " ! #$$),%)&$&()*

!!- . ! #$$&%*/$&(&) 0- !

1 02- !13 !" - !" - 4! #$$%&'&($&()*

0 0

+ ) 6! ! ! " "0 0 1 0

! " " ! # 7 00!! " 1"" .8 !"" " & 6!

0! " !

!""""0 00

" 0

! 0 # 9

# ! " 00 " 7 !

! 1 ! 0 ! !

" !0

! 0 # 9

# !

/ :&,(*&(&)#$$%&'&($&()*! # 0- !0 0

! # ! ! " !

!01 !! 0 0 "" !1 "- 4!!0

! ! 0 0

! # !0 !

; 4" " ! !" "00!!

0 "00

$ ,-./# 0(12 04 ;$<)-) 0##$ %&

-45

% 6! !" "0 ;/*"! #"# 10 " ! " 0 0! .8+(&/,(<(*&()* /,*$4 & /;"8 0#)<'( 0 1 2 0#11

1 ' ! 00 ! .8 ! ! 10 ! !1! 1 0! 0 ! 1 1 ! 1""0 " 6!

! " "! 1 0

! !1" ! !! 1 01 $% &/((9$" 1! "0 40 6! " ! 10 ""

01 1! 1 " !"!! 1" ! !! 00 !1"! -- !0 ! 1 0!" 1! " 1! 0 0 , 6! 0 ! "00

$ &/))&()* . 0 1

3 1 (/)&&()* 6! 00"07 !# )/)&&()* +"1

7 !#

0 )%()&(&( +

7 !# 1 0! "1 "

&(()&(&( 0" 1 0 ! (,(&&(&( - &;(/&(&( ! " !1 0 # (,(,&(&( "0 0 0 " 0

3 1 )((,&(&( 0

3 1 &/(<&(&) 7 !# " 1

0! 0 ! 0

!0 0# 6! " 00 " 1 ! 0

3 1 ! < 0"!" 0 ! ! ! "! 00 " ! # ! "0 ! 0 0 " ! 0 0

3 1 0! !! 0

" ! #

3 1 &,(<&(&)! # !! 1 !! !"0 0 00! ! 0!

- 4! !!

1(,(,&(&( 8! 00 1!

" !7 !# ! ! - 4! ! 1 ! "" 0 ! 0 0 0

! :!

#11

! 8

" ! ! ! !! 0 "! 0

3 !! " ! 7 !#

* 0"! )((,&(&(

!!!0 0

3 1 0! 0

! !"! 00

!0 0 ! ! 0 ! ! ! "! 00 " ! # 8 " ! " 1! !! 00!

! 0 0

3 1 1 6! 0 0 1

"" " ! ! !! ! 10 00 !

# "0 6! " ! # &,(*&(&)

! - 4! =0! "0 0 ! 1 !!"0! "" 0 ! 0 0 6! " ! !

0! - !"0! "" !!!

!!1! "! ! !!1

! ! 0 1"0 00"!

0 0!1! ! 00 !0 0 " 10 "! "10 11 !1" !0! ! 1 !0!1! !! ! "0 00! ! 0 0 # ! " "!

!1!!! "!! "" 1

!1! " !"" ! !

" 10 !0 6!" 0 00 " ! 0 !

"0 "" !! 00 0 $$6 0(12 ;$<)-) 0##$ %&

-45

)( 6! !! "0 ;/*"! #"# 10 " ! " 0 0! .8+));)'(,&()< ;(';&("80 #)<'( 01 )) !.8!00 ! ! 10 !! 1 !

010

! !!0 .8 !1! " !! 1! "10

!1 !! 10 !! " !1 ! 1! 10

! ! !1 0" :2" 1 "00 ! ! !! 0!0 2 1 001 !! ! ! 1 00 00 ! ! ! **((((9$ ,$< 0 " 0 1 " ! 6! );(*&()<! 0 00 0

0 1! 00 )& 6! 0 ! "00

$ ()(/&()* 400"0

! 1

38#1 ;/, '

# # );(/&()* "0 !" 1

3 0 )((;&()* 0"0 " 7 !#

/((;&()* &%(&&(&( 90

! # &<(;&(&( 400"0

! " 0 0

3 0 &*(;&(&( 40 !

3 0 (&(,&(&) &/(,&(&) + !0""!

" 7 !# &/(<&(&) 7 !# " 1

0! 0 ! 0

!0 0

3 06! " 00 " 1!0

3 0!

)/ 0"!" 0 ! ! ! "! 0 " ! # ! ! "0 00 " 0 0

3 0 0 00" ! " 1!0 0

3 0 !! ! !

!! 0 ! ! "! 00

" ! # " ! 0

0 0

3 0&*(;&(&(

! # &/(<&(&) ); 0"! 1 0 ! !! ! 0 " !0 0

3 !! " 1);(*&()< 1 1 ! "" ! ! 0 "0> ! " !7 !

# !10! - ! 00

! 0 ! " ! 1 1 7 ! 0 0" !! ! 0! !! 1 ! !1! !!

00 " ! # ? 0

3 0 0! 1 0 ! "

1 1 ! 7)2$$6

0(12 ;$<)-) 0##$ %&

-45 )% 6! !" 0"0 ;/*"

!#"# 10 " ! " 0 0! .8+)();()&(&( /,*$4;))"8 0#)<'( 0 -1 2 1 )' ! 00 ! .8 ! ! 10 1 ! !

"! 0 ! !

001 000 !1 ! " !!

! ! !"00 ! !! 1 0! @++:6A$* "0 6! );(*&(&( ), 6! 0 ! "00

$ &))&&(&( 40 0 1

3 1 )&()&(&) 0"07 !# &&()&(&) +"1

7 !#

0 (<('&(&) 40 0 "0

! " 0

3 1

))('&(&) 40

3 1 )%(*&(&) 6! # " 1

! 0 " ! ! ! 0

! 0 0

3 1 6! " ! # !0

3 1 !

" 11 " 1 ! 0 0

3 !! ! ! 0 !" ! "! )< 0"!" 0 ! !! ! "0 0 0 " ! 0 0

3 1 ! "! 0

!0 0

3 1 ! "! 0 2 B

3 1 ! 0 0

3 !! 0! 1!"""!

! "! "0!""!! 00"

! !7 !# !

! 0 ! " 0 1! 00 0" !!1 ))('&(&)! 0! 00 !! 00! ! " 1!7 !

# ! !"!0

3 ! ! ! "! 00 " !7 !# !0 0 !! 00!

! " 1!7 !# !0

3 !

00"! :&))(&(&)! !

0 "00"" " ! #

! 1 ! ! 00 ! 1! ! " 1! # 6! !0 !""! ! ! =0! ! 0 0 " ! # . ! 1 ! ! ! "! ! !! ! "0 0"

! 0"! )* ! ! " ! #$$%&'&($&()* + " ! #$$),%)&$&()* ! !- " ! #$$&%*/$&(&) !

1! " !"0 ! !"0 "! 00 " !

# ! "! 0 " ! # ! 1

6! !" ! 1!! !0! "0! 00 ! "! 00

" ! # ! 7 ! !

1!!0

# ! 0! ! 1 ! 1! !00

! ! 1 1 !

! ! 1 " !

1" &( 1 00 2 0 - ! 1! ! !"0 00

" !0

# ! "! 0

0 00 ! ! ! 1

! 7" ! 1! !00! ! ! 0

# ! !00

!! ! "0 &) 0- ! 0 0 !

! 0 1! 1

" 11C ! 1 " - 10 01 0- !0 ! 1!! 1 00! ! 1

! "" ! 0 0

! 0 0

3 ! "! 00 " ! #

00 ! ! " ! !0 = " !" !! !

1 0" " 1!0 0

3 " !01 !! ! "" !# !

0 00!!

! 0 0

3 !0 009007 " - 1" ! 1#

#$% 1! ! ! ! #

!" 1 0!# 0 ! 1 ! " ! ! # ! !0 "00 " 0 11 0

! !0! !0 0 ! 0 8 "

! !0 0 ! 1 0 0" && 7 0

! #

0 ! "" 7 1!0! !00!! "0 00

" !0 0

3 ! "! 0 0 " ! # ! 0 ! 1 !# ! 0 !0 "0! 00"1 ! 7 1!! ""

00" 0 ! 0

! ! # 800!! ! 00 !

! 0 0

3 ! 1

>0 ! # !! 00 0 " ! # 7 ! 11! 1

" 00" 0 " 019 "! 0 " ! " ! " "

00 9 "! 0

!0 0

3 0 1 1 ! " ! 1 7 1! 0 >

! ! " 7" ! 1!"0 !0 ! 0 ! 0

! !"0 "0 "" 1 ""0 !

"= 0 7

!0""0 "

!0 1

!0 7! 0- 1" 1# &

'( !)

& ,

' ! #* -

" 0

1% 2 ! 3

- +

! 1 &/ 8!! !0 0 " ! 00 !

&; 800! ! ! "0 0 0 0 " ! # ! "! !

"0 0 00 " 0 0

! 0 !"1" "! 00

= ! !"! "! 00

3 ! 00 " 1!! 0 0 " ! # ! ! 0! !! 1

! 00 ! ! 0

! 0 0

3 ! ! 1 10 ! !

! # ! !! "0 00!! 0

" 8! "0 !D-!00 ! ! " 1 0! ! 0 0 "0 " ! 0 0

3 0 !!"""! 0 !! !!

! 10 00

# "0 6!

" !"0""0 !! 00

! #

0 " ! # ""! 0 "0

!1 !

!! ! =0 ! ! "! 8! " !!00 ! ! !" 6!0 0

3 0! "1 1 ! ! " 00 0 0 0

3 8! " !!00

! ! "1 0! !0"0 !

00 " !0 0

3 ""

0 "0

! ! " !

! 0 0 " !7 !# !! !

! 0 !!1 " "0! ! 0 00 !! 00! ! " 1!7 !

# ! " !0 0

3 ! 0 0"! !1 0 1 7

!"0" ! 0" 0 !

1 " ! # 6! " ! ! 0 "00"" " ! #

1 ! !! 00 ! 1!0

! " 1! # &% "" >

# ! . 0 ! "0 "! !! 0 !

! 0

3 !0 009009 !

01"1 0"

" 00 " ! # ! !

! 1 0 ! " !0 ! !" " &' " !" 0 !

- 1 " 1# > " ! 8

!00 !!7 !# !0 ! 11 0 1 !

!! $!0 !

! ! !7 !#

1 !! 0" !"" 1

! 0 0 1 00

! 0 !"" 1 0!! ! "!001 0!7 !# 1# ! 0 &, 8 !

! 1# !! " "

# ! 00 1 ! " ! # 0 ! 1# ! !1 ! 0

!! "! ! 0 0 ! 0 ! 0 ! 0 " 0 !0 ! ! # "

0" ! > " "!

# 1" ! 0 0 " 1 ! 1 0

! "

1 ! 1 0 6! 0 "!" - 1 $

!" # $$$% &$$

$ '% &$$

(

)

, !

)

- . !

0 !

.) ,

* , !

.!1 !

2 !

3 !

4 4

.!) !

4 !

.!"

)

.! ) 5 ! !

! 2

4 34

-8 5!

5 9 # :; .

&$& 5 $$<= 5!

9+ :; .

&$$>5?

5 9

!( 5 :;

&$&@5<&

@& 4

, 4

+ # 5 !

: .$ B&@5$<$ -

) 4

, -

) !

4 +

4 !

5 !

* 4 C !

/ 3 0

* !

! ! $@? 4 !

* 4 !

4 "

@$ +

4 D

D 8 !

)

) !

* )

* * 4 !

) ,

4 4 5,67 6, ! 6 / 6 .

&< 8 &

'( ! )

! 1# !00# 1

- " ! 0 >

!! ! 0 "" " 1$0"1 " 1 1" "! 6! 0 "!- 1 $ $'

)

) !

4 ;

, ! , !

.//"

# &$?.$'5<

E +

E D ( !

D 8 *2 .

D -

F+ !

4 !

+ !

* !

! !

+ !

! ! + !

)

E !

! !

4 !

@ G

# #

< 3 * ,

6!" - 1 "

! 1 #

& ,

&* 8-

" *

! 1# ! 00 00 !00" 0 " ! ! 1 !1 0" " 1

1 !00! "" 1 10 ! ! 0 !!

- "00 0 8!0 !# 0 ! 0 "

! ! 1 ! 0 !- " 0 !

!# 8 " !

! 0 "0 0

"! " 0 !" ! !1 ! 0

0 !0 ! "0 1 ! 0 6! 0 "!" - 1 $

$@ "

+ !

4 !

* !

! !

+ !

) E "

+ *

+ +

)

!H + !

! +

H 8 !

, ( !

) !

! ! !

H ! *

)

! !

/( 82 ! 3

- +

* ! 1# ! "! 1 !

3 !! 0 0 0 1

! 0

3 8

!!"10 !"!3 !! ! 0 00 0 0!!1 !0 !

!16! 00 !"!"!0!

0 ! ! " " 1$ ! !! 0 0 7 ! 0

! 1# "

!" 1 "! 6! 0 "!- 1 $

$< )

+ 5 D ? , 5 D 3&< !

! D

E !

D !

)

# ;

) D

) !

E ! !

;

) I+7 5 < &%@<+#

5 <@B # "

/) 8 '!

8, ?

0 = A

! 1# ! -" 0 $ 0 0 !0 !00" 0 ! 0 !"" ! 0 !0 00 1!0 1 ! !! 1 ! 0 " 000 ! ! " 1

- !

" 0 ! 06! 0 "! " - 1 $ 3

J !

* . !

, !

D !

)

E !

/&89 !3

* ;0

! 1 #

! "" !

"1 0"

!"!"

1 0" 1"!0 ! !# 1 " = - 6! 0 "!- 1 $ E$$ +

, 4 "

& 6 5 !

66,5

57 5

6 ! !

6!, < 6

6 , (6 " + !* 4

( !

1! 0

// 8973)'(

&"97

;1 ! 1#

! " ;/* & " ! # " # 10 00" 06! 0 "!- 1

$B 9 LLL+++5 <@ .$

E 5

5 <@ .

LLL+++

. ! .

. ! .!

! !

.! * !

)

, !

!5 $?>.

* !

E !

, !

.7 5 ; !

5 ( $ B> GD$'>

@ )

4 !

M !

/; 8 & =>

: $;%

%! 1# =! 1 " !0" 0 0 ! 0&)"!# "8

!! 1 "10 ! 6! " 1 "

- 1 ! 1 " 0&) =0 & / 8,5 8=

& $;%#

* 8

6 ,* 3 * $%

$%* 3

9:' $;% 0;1* ? 6 &

9! * + ,

0% 3 &=&6

$$;

1 $"

/% F!0 !" !" "!

! 1 0 1 ! 0 > "0 " 1 "! 6!"00!! "0 ! 00 " ! 0 0

3 ! 0 ! "! 00 " ! # ! !0 8 ! 01 "! ! 0 ! 0 ! " ! 0 0

3 !

!"0

! ! 01 " 1 !1 "- ! 11!""" ! ! 00 " 1 "" A !!0

! ! " 1"" ! /' 0&) !! "!# 8

1 6! ! ! 01"0 0"0 0 1

01"

" # 0 ! 0 ! C "8 0 0 00! !! !"

0 ! ! 0 00 - " 0 " " 1! 16! " !> !! 0 !

! 0 0

3 !0 00900 !0 ""10 ! 0&)"!# "

88 1 ! 0 00!!

! 0 0

3 ! "

! 00 " ! # !!

!! 1 " ! # !! 0 ! !0 00900 ! "! 0 "00901" 0 6! 00 0 " 00"! 0 !

! 1# 1 "- 1 0! !

! " 00" 0 =!

0 01 "!0

0 10 10 " ! " 1 1 !

! "

00!"

"0 " 1- 11!1 0"

1 0 0! 10 !1 0" ! !"! /, #00" 0019 " 0

"" #00" 0 0"

1 "! 0 ! 1 "

901" 0

! ! # "" 1 0 0 !

"! "

08! ! 0 !

! 0

3 ! ! 0 " 00" 0 " " 0

! ! 6! " ! > ! 0 1

!! ! 0 !0 00

! # ! "

"1 0" ! "!

00 " ! # 00! 0!

! 1 !

!""! 0! 1

! ! ! 00 0 !

!# 6! " ! "

"1 0"! !! !0 " !0 0&)"! # "8 /< 8 9 ! 3

! 1 #

! 1 " ! =

G1 0"G!"""

"! 18

! 1 0 " 0 1 1 0 " ! "

1"! !0 0 00 ! " 0 !

!! ! 1 1 0" 0"! 0"8"!"

!!!

1 0" 1"!

! ! ! # 1 " =

- 8 ! 0! ! !

"1 0" " !0 0

!" 1 0" ! " 1"! ! " 0!

! 1 6! " !

" 1 0 " " $ 0 " " 0 0 " ! # 0

! !"0

! 0&)"!# "8 ! 0 1 /* 7 ! 1 1 ! # ! 1 ! "! ! " ! "- ! 0 0 !

;( 6!7G 0 1# !

! ! " ! # ! ! 1

!0 0

1 ""0 : ! 1 0 ;) 6! " !0 !"!" " 1

" ! ! ! # " ! ! "

00 90 9 !! 0

! 0 0

3 !"- 0 1

1 ! ;& 8 " 00!! !

! " )((((9$!

00!! 6! ! 1!# "0 #!"30 ! 1!

" 1 8! "! "! 1! 1 0 ! - ? 0 ! 8 ! 10 !

! # 1" ! #!"30 0

!1 !0 ! ! 0 "! " 1 "! 01! 0 009 ! " !"

""" 1!# ! !-" 10 ! 1 ;/ 6! ! " ! 1 !0 ! !" "0

" 6! # !

!! 0

F! ! 1 " 8" 1 6!0 "

10 "! 1 8 #$$&)%&'$&(&)

! # 0 ! !0 1 1 ! 0 " !# 0 !! ! 10 0 " 0 "! "# #! ! 1

" # 0 ! " " 1!! 1 !00 0 " $ 1

2 0 ! 0 9 " 00 !

" 1 " 1 ! 8 :"" ! ! "0 "

09 " #

" 0 . ! 1 " 0 9" ! " ! 9 0 " 0 !# 0 10 00 0 " 1!

1! # !0

&;(&&((*00! 2 B

3 !""!!1""0 " 0 0 " ! 6 0 # "" > "0 " 00"0

# ! 1 ! " ! 0 0 0

! :

! "10 !!" !1 ;; :! "! 1

!" 0 9

# " ! 0 >

!! "00

$ ) 8 !00

00!

3 "- 7 @6 #! !!! 0 0 0 9

1 !

2 ! !01 ! ! ! # !0 "

" 1!""0

"!- 7 7 !# #! !

!! 00>! 10 .8910 9 " !7 !# ! "! 1" & " "

!" 0! "0" ! 0"! # / 81 1 0 1 0"

0 0 9

!! ! 10 0" 0! ! 1 " @ ! # 8 ! 1 1! 0 1 ; 6!2 ""- 7 @ 6 #! ! !00 ! 0 "! !! !00 0

" 1 ! # "

0 00"! ! 1"" " " 1" 1! 8:90 ""0

% 6!

! # " 111 10 !10 ;% 4" ! ! - 1 ! #

0- ! !

#! ? 0 ! "! # " ! 0 0

"! 000!2 B

3 00 2 "!"- 7 @6 #! !! !! 0"! # ++

0 0

! F!! H 9+ F!! 0 H 9+